Stambovsky v. Ackley

Last updated

Stambovsky v. Ackley
New York Supreme Court, Appellate Division, First Department
Seal of New York.svg
Seal of New York
Decided July 18, 1991
Full case nameJeffrey M. Stambovsky v. Helen Ackley and Ellis Realty
Citations169 A.D.2d 254, 572 N.Y.S.2d 672, 60 USLW 2070
Prior historyNew York Supreme Court dismissed the action (April 9, 1990)
Main Holding
Seller who had undertaken to inform the public at large about the existence of poltergeists on the premises to be sold was estopped to deny existence of poltergeists on the premises, so the house was haunted as a matter of law and seller must inform the purchaser of the haunting.
Court membership
Presiding Justice Milonas
Associate Justices Ross, Kassal, Smith, Rubin
Case opinion
Decision byRubin
Joined byRoss, Kassal
Dissent bySmith, Milonas

Stambovsky v. Ackley, 169 A.D.2d 254 (N.Y. App. Div. 1991), commonly known as the Ghostbusters ruling, was a case in the New York Supreme Court, Appellate Division. The court held that a house, which the owner had previously advertised as haunted by ghosts, was legally haunted for the purpose of an action for rescission brought by a subsequent purchaser of the house. Because of its unique holding that "as a matter of law, the house is haunted", the case has been frequently printed in textbooks on contracts and property law and is widely taught in U.S. law school classes, as well as being cited by other courts.

Contents

Facts and prior history

During the course of her ownership of the property at issue, which was located in Nyack, New York, Helen Ackley and members of her family had reported the existence of numerous poltergeists in the house. [1] Ackley had reported the existence of ghosts in the house to both Reader's Digest [2] and a local newspaper on three occasions between 1977 and 1989, when the house was included on a five-home walking tour of the city. She recounted to the press several instances in which the poltergeists interacted directly with members of her family. She claimed that grandchildren received "gifts" of baby rings, all of which suddenly disappeared later. She also claimed that one ghost would wake her daughter, Cynthia, each morning by shaking her bed. [3] She claimed that when spring break arrived, Cynthia proclaimed loudly that she did not have to wake up early and she would like to sleep in; her bed did not shake the next morning.

Ackley's real estate broker, Ellis Realty, revealed the haunting to Jeffrey Stambovsky before he entered a contract to purchase the house in 1989 or 1990, because after Stambovsky signed the contract and made a $32,500 downpayment on the agreed price of $650,000, Ackley would not sign her end of the contract until after the haunting was disclosed to the buyers. The broker telephoned Stambovsky and advised him of Ackley's claim, and he laughed and said, "we'll have to call in the Ghostbusters", a popular movie at the time. The broker then advised Ackley that Stambovsky was advised and she signed her end of the contract of sale, and the house was heading to closing. Both the broker and the seller told the court this sequence of events, Stambovsky claimed he was never advised of this. [4] [ clarification needed ] Stambovsky was from New York City and was not aware of the folklore of Nyack, including the widely known haunting story.

About one week after the contracts of sale were fully signed, Stambovsky requested an in person meeting at the property with the seller directly to discuss the "ghosts". After the Stambovskys were told by Ackley passionately of the haunting story, he filed an action requesting rescission of the contract of sale and for damages for fraudulent misrepresentation by Ackley and Ellis Realty. Stambovsky did not attend the closing, which caused him to forfeit the downpayment (although he was then not obligated to buy the house). [4] A New York Supreme Court (trial court) dismissed the action, and Stambovsky appealed.

The case on appeal

Majority opinion

Near the beginning of the majority opinion (three out of five justices) appears its most well-known conclusion: "having reported [the ghosts'] presence in both a national publication... and the local press... defendant is estopped to deny their existence and, as a matter of law, the house is haunted." The court noted that regardless of whether the house was truly haunted or not, the fact that the house had been widely reported as being haunted greatly affected its value.

Notwithstanding these conclusions, the court affirmed the dismissal of the fraudulent misrepresentation action and stated that the realtor was under no duty to disclose the haunting to potential buyers. Thus, no damages were available to Stambovsky, because New York, at the time, adhered to property law doctrine of caveat emptor .

The appellate court reversed the trial court's decision regarding the rescission action, however, as it went on to note that "haunting" was not a condition that a buyer or potential buyer of real property can and should be able to ascertain upon reasonable inspection of the property. According to the court, though the doctrine of caveat emptor would normally operate to bar a rescission action, causing seller to have no duty to disclose information about the property to be sold (but also preventing the seller from affirmatively misrepresenting the condition of the property), the doctrine, in a merged law and equity system, can be modified to do justice to the parties. In this case, "the most meticulous inspection and the search would not reveal the presence of poltergeists at the premises or unearth the property's ghoulish reputation in the community;" thus equity would allow Stambovsky the remedy of contract rescission against the seller, Ackley. The court held:

Where, as here, the seller not only takes unfair advantage of the buyer's ignorance but has created and perpetuated a condition about which he is unlikely to even inquire, enforcement of the contract (in whole or in part) is offensive to the court's sense of equity. Application of the remedy of rescission, within the bounds of the narrow exception to the doctrine of caveat emptor set forth herein, is entirely appropriate to relieve the unwitting purchaser from the consequences of a most unnatural bargain.

The opinion makes reference to a number of popular books and films featuring ghosts, including Shakespeare's Hamlet and the 1984 movie Ghostbusters and uses supernatural idioms throughout (e.g., "plaintiff hasn't a ghost of a chance", "I am moved by the spirit of equity", and "the notion [...] is a hobgoblin which should be exorcised from the body of legal precedent"). [5]

Dissenting opinion

The dissenting opinion argued that the doctrine of caveat emptor should be strictly applied and would affirm the trial court's dismissal of all of the actions. Displeased by the majority's basis for its holding, the dissent said, "Finally, if the doctrine of caveat emptor is to be discarded, it should be for a reason more substantive than a poltergeist. The existence of a poltergeist is no more binding upon the defendants than it is upon this court."

Epilogue

The case generated considerable publicity, and area real estate agents had between 25 and 50 potential buyers calling within a week of the court's decision. [4] Among the prospective buyers to the house at 1 LaVeta Place on the Hudson River was Kreskin. Kreskin was a renowned mentalist interested in purchasing a haunted home in which to curate his collection of paranormal paraphernalia. [4] Ackley sold the house to another buyer and moved to Florida in 1991. Helen Ackley died in 2003, and her son-in-law "lays odds" that her spirit has taken up residence back at 1 Ackley Place. [3] There have not been public reports of hauntings in recent years. Owners of the home in subsequent years include the singer-songwriter Ingrid Michaelson and the musician Matisyahu and filmmaker Adam Brooks. [6] The home went up for sale in 2020 for $1.9 million and last sold in 2021 for $1,795,000. [7]

Ghost stories

The house had been vacant and was in disrepair when the Ackleys moved into the waterfront home in the 1960s. [8] Local children purportedly warned them that the house was haunted, though no prior paranormal incidents appear to have been published. [8] Helen Ackley claimed there were at least three ghosts in the residence. She described two as a married couple who had lived in the 18th century and the other as a Navy Lieutenant in the American Revolution. [4] In 1993, she was contacted by paranormal researcher Bill Merrill and medium Glenn Johnson, who claimed to have already made contact with two of the spirits at 1 LaVeta Place. The pair met with Helen and disclosed that the couple were likely the poltergeists of Sir George and Lady Margaret, who lived in the region in the 18th century.

While the couple's identity has never been historically verified,what was claimed about this ghostly couple by Merrill and Johnson is that :

In 1995, Merrill and Johnson published a book about their findings entitled Sir George, The Ghost of Nyack (Deer Publishing, Beaverton, Oregon). [3] [10]

sitting in midair, watching me paint the ceiling in the living room, rocking back and forth... I was on an 8-foot stepladder. I asked if he approved of what we were doing to the house, if the colors were to his liking. He smiled and he nodded his head. [4]

Cyn had already fallen asleep and I was drifting. Then I heard the bedroom door creak, and the floor boards squeak. My back was to the edge of the bed. Suddenly the edge of the bed by my mid-section depressed down, and I felt something lean against me. I went literally stone stiff! I was speechless and could hardly move. I was able to twist my neck around enough to see a womanly figure in a soft dress through the moonlight from the bay windows. I felt like she was looking straight at me. After about minute, the presence got up and walked back out of the room. I finally relaxed enough to shake my wife out of sound sleep acting like a toddler who just had a nightmare. [8]

All but Kavanagh's accounts were written by Helen and submitted to Reader's Digest magazine and published in its May 1977 issue.

Despite these somewhat unnerving tales, the Ackleys said they had a peaceful coexistence with the poltergeists, and the only account of any terrorizing events is Kavanagh's tale reproduced above. [11] Kavanagh later reflected on the incidents that he experienced and came to the conclusion that the ghosts were evaluating him to make sure he was a good suitor for Cynthia. [8]

Since the Ackleys moved from the home in the beginning of the 1990s, there have not been any more accounts of paranormal activity reported by any of the subsequent owners, of which there have been three. [11] However, Merrill and Johnson reported that Sir George and Lady Margaret expressed that the spirits were not as fond of the new owners and were thinking of moving on. [12] It is also reported that after the judgment against Helen in the lawsuit, she claimed that she was moving and taking the ghosts with her. [11]

The house - history and today

The imposing Victorian waterfront home was built in 1890 with 5 bedrooms, 3 ½ baths, and approximately 4,628 square feet. George and Helen Ackley purchased the home in the early 1960s and shared the home with their four children, Cynthia, George, Cara, and William. [13] George died at an area hospital after heart surgery in 1978 at the age of 53, less than one year after the first accounts of paranormal activity appeared in Reader's Digest. [14] Though his death was not in the home, there was a death in the home later when a relatively young and otherwise healthy dinner guest died of a brain aneurysm. [11] [14] By 1990, the residents included Helen's grandchildren, daughter-in-law and future son-in-law, Mark Kavanagh. [1] [12] The home sold on Jan 8, 2016, for more than $600,000 above comparable homes in Nyack according to Trulia, fetching $1,770,000. [15]

The exterior of the home was red for some time, though it has now been painted light blue.

See also

Related Research Articles

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Poltergeist</span> Ghost that causes physical disturbance

In German folklore and ghostlore, a poltergeist is a type of ghost or spirit that is responsible for physical disturbances, such as loud noises and objects being moved or destroyed. Most claims or fictional descriptions of poltergeists show them as being capable of pinching, biting, hitting, and tripping people. They are also depicted as capable of the movement or levitation of objects such as furniture and cutlery, or noises such as knocking on doors. Foul smells are also associated with poltergeist occurrences, as well as spontaneous fires and different electrical issues such as flickering lights.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Nyack, New York</span> Village in New York, United States

Nyack is a village located primarily in the town of Orangetown in Rockland County, New York, United States. Incorporated in 1872, it retains a very small western section in Clarkstown. The village had a population of 7,265 as of the 2020 census. It is a suburb of New York City lying approximately 15 miles (24 km) north of the Manhattan boundary near the west bank of the Hudson River, situated north of South Nyack, east of Central Nyack, south of Upper Nyack, and southeast of Valley Cottage.

Caveat emptor is Latin for "Let the buyer beware". It has become a proverb in English. Generally, caveat emptor is the contract law principle that controls the sale of real property after the date of closing, but may also apply to sales of other goods. The phrase caveat emptor and its use as a disclaimer of warranties arises from the fact that buyers typically have less information than the seller about the good or service they are purchasing. This quality of the situation is known as 'information asymmetry'. Defects in the good or service may be hidden from the buyer, and only known to the seller.

A haunted house, spook house or ghost house in ghostlore is a house or other building often perceived as being inhabited by disembodied spirits of the deceased who may have been former residents or were otherwise connected with the property. Parapsychologists often attribute haunting to the spirits of the dead who have suffered from violent or tragic events in the building's past such as murder, accidental death, or suicide.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Borley Rectory</span> Building in Borley, Essex, England

Borley Rectory was a house located in Borley, Essex, famous for being described as "the most haunted house in England" by psychic researcher Harry Price. Built in 1862 to house the rector of the parish of Borley and his family, the house was badly damaged by fire in 1939 and demolished in 1944.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Enfield poltergeist</span> Claim of supernatural activity

The Enfield poltergeist was a claim of supernatural activity at 284 Green Street, a council house in Brimsdown, Enfield, London, England, between 1977 and 1979. The alleged poltergeist activity centred on sisters Janet, aged 11, and Margaret Hodgson, aged 13.

In the law of the sale of property a latent defect is a fault in the property that could not have been discovered by a reasonably thorough inspection before the sale. In relation to a construction contract, a latent defect is a fault in the property or its underlying site which comes to light after construction has been completed.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Stigmatized property</span> Real estate devalued due to social taboo

In real estate, stigmatized property is property that buyers or tenants may shun for reasons that are unrelated to its physical condition or features. These can include death of an occupant, murder, suicide, previous illicit activities, and even the belief that a house is haunted.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Ed and Lorraine Warren</span> American paranormal investigators

Edward Warren Miney and Lorraine Rita Warren were American paranormal investigators and authors associated with prominent cases of alleged hauntings. Edward was a self-taught and self-professed demonologist, author, and lecturer. Lorraine professed to be clairvoyant and a light trance medium who worked closely with her husband.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Ghost hunting</span> Investigating reportedly haunted locations for ghosts

Ghost hunting is the process of investigating locations that are purportedly haunted by ghosts. The practice has been heavily criticized for its dismissal of the scientific method. No scientific study has ever been able to confirm the existence of ghosts. Ghost hunting is considered a pseudoscience by the vast majority of educators, academics, science writers and skeptics. Science historian Brian Regal described ghost hunting as "an unorganized exercise in futility".

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Lincoln's ghost</span> Ghost of U.S. president Abraham Lincoln

The ghost of U.S. president Abraham Lincoln, also known as the White House Ghost, is said to have haunted the White House since Lincoln's assassination in 1865. Lincoln's ghost has also been said to haunt many of his former residences in Springfield, Illinois, including his former law office.

Sandra Ramdhanie was an Irish psychic and qualified psychologist.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Mordecai House</span> Historic house in North Carolina, United States

The Mordecai House, built in 1785, is a registered historical landmark and museum in Raleigh, North Carolina that is the centerpiece of Mordecai Historic Park, adjacent to the Historic Oakwood neighborhood. It is the oldest residence in Raleigh on its original foundation. In addition to the house, the Park includes the birthplace and childhood home of President Andrew Johnson, the Ellen Mordecai Garden, the Badger-Iredell Law Office, Allen Kitchen and St. Mark's Chapel, a popular site for weddings. It is located in the Mordecai Place Historic District.

<i>Chandelor v Lopus</i>

Chandelor v Lopus (1603) 79 ER 3 is a famous case in the common law of England. It stands for the distinction between warranties and mere affirmations and announced the rule of caveat emptor.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Old Rectory, Epworth</span> Queen Anne-style building in Lincolnshire, now a museum

The Old Rectory in Epworth, Lincolnshire is a Queen Anne-style building, rebuilt in 1709, which has been restored and is now the property of the Methodist Church of Great Britain, who maintain it as a museum. The rectory was home to the rector of Epworth from 1697 to 1735, the Reverend Samuel Wesley, his wife Susanna and their 19 children, one of whom, John Wesley, grew up to become a founder of Methodism. On 9 February 1709, while the Wesleys were resident, a fire burnt down the wooden rectory and it was rebuilt in brick. The Old Rectory is a Grade I listed building.

The following are reportedly haunted locations in Pennsylvania:

<i>When the Lights Went Out</i> 2012 film directed by Pat Holden

When the Lights Went Out is a 2012 British supernatural horror film directed by Pat Holden and starring Kate Ashfield, Tasha Connor, Steven Waddington, Craig Parkinson, Martin Compston, and Jo Hartley. It was released in the UK on 13 September 2012. The film premiered at the Rotterdam International Film Festival.

A haunted doll is a handmade or manufactured doll or stuffed toy that is claimed to be cursed or possessed in some way.

The Doris Bither case, also known as the Entity haunting, was a 1974 investigation into alleged paranormal phenomena in Culver City, California, experienced by a woman named Doris Bither. The case inspired Frank De Felitta's 1978 book The Entity which was made into a 1982 film of the same name starring Barbara Hershey.

References

  1. 1 2 3 4 5 Xavier (September 3, 2015). "The Haunted House On The Hudson". Ghost Theory. Retrieved September 21, 2016.
  2. ↑ Helen Herdman Ackley (May 1977). "Our Haunted House on the Hudson". Reader's Digest. p. 217.
  3. 1 2 3 "Ghost of Nyack: Update". ktransit.com. Retrieved September 21, 2016.
  4. 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 Barron, James (March 20, 1990). "Phones Ringing (Eerily?) For Nyack Spook Home". The New York Times. ISSN   0362-4331 . Retrieved September 21, 2016.
  5. ↑ "Stambovsky v. Ackley". casetext.com. 1991. Retrieved December 20, 2021.
  6. ↑ Curley, Melissa. "Singer/rapper Matisyahu selling Nyack home; former occupants include Ingrid Michaelson and maybe, a ghost". lohud.com. Retrieved February 10, 2023.
  7. ↑ Sherman, Tiffani (June 3, 2020). "Don't Be Scared! Home at Center of Haunted House Legal Case Available for $1.9M". Realtor.com. Retrieved February 10, 2023.
  8. 1 2 3 4 5 "Ghost of Nyack: Background". ktransit.com. Retrieved September 21, 2016.
  9. 1 2 Zimmermann, Linda (2002). Ghost Investigator: Hauntings of the Hudson Valley. Eagle Press. p. 25. ISBN   978-0-9712326-0-0.
  10. ↑ Merrill, Bill; Johnson, Glenn (January 1, 1995). Sir George The Ghost of Nyack. Beaverton, Or.: Deer Publishing Co. ISBN   9781883832056.
  11. 1 2 3 4 5 "Nyack Sketch Log: A Legally Haunted House". Nyack News and Views. October 21, 2014. Retrieved September 21, 2016.
  12. 1 2 Strom-Mackey, Robin M. (August 2, 2015). "Helen Ackley's Haunted House on the Hudson". The Shore. Retrieved September 21, 2016.
  13. ↑ "Kavanagh Website -> Family Page". ktransit.com. Retrieved September 21, 2016.
  14. 1 2 "Clark County, OH, Posted Obituaries for". Ancestry.com. Retrieved September 21, 2016.
  15. ↑ "1 Laveta Place, Nyack, NY". Trulia Real Estate Search. Retrieved September 21, 2016.
This page is based on this Wikipedia article
Text is available under the CC BY-SA 4.0 license; additional terms may apply.
Images, videos and audio are available under their respective licenses.