Ray Carsillo Jonathan Cahill Kenna Roubicek Jamal Henderson David Pinion David Kocher Barry Papick Veronica Warner Caitlin Morris Bill Kates Ilya Salkind Mark Jones
Cinematography
Scott Crawley
Edited by
Jacob Harlow
Production company
Two Ram Productions
Release date
November 12th 2024
Running time
183 minutes
Country
United States
Language
English
Superman Reborn (also known as Superman V and Superman: The New Movie) is a recorded 2024 live script reading performance of the never before seen first draft of the unmade 5th Christopher Reeve Superman movie. [1]There was a third draft of the story that leaked on the Internet many years ago however that was not the draft that was used. What was used was a never before seen first draft that was signed off and intended by producer Ilya Salkind and writers Mark Jones and Cary Bates before getting revision notes from Warner Bros/DC at the time. There are some major differences between the drafts. The film was intended to revive and continue the franchise after Superman IV: The Quest for Peace.
The performance was immediately followed by a live Q&A with producer Ilya Salkind and writer Mark Jones to talk about the project and how the film never came into full fruition. [2]The event also partnered up with the Christopher and Dana Reeve Foundation to raise awareness and encourage donations toward the foundation for spinal cord injury research.[3]
Plot
Brainiac is introduced as an intimidating robot, he dominates space with his hi-tech ark, destroying planets and imprisoning the few survivors. His alien assistant Kosmo secretly loathes Brainiac, and arranges for him to discover Earth in the hopes that Superman can end the villain's reign of terror.[4]
From there, the traditional supporting cast is introduced. There's some attempt to indicate this is a modern version of the Daily Planet updated for the '90s, but aside a reference to its hi-tech newsroom, it feels similar to the previous Salkind films.
Lois, who still doesn't know Clark's secret, is sick of Superman always leaving for emergencies, their relationship never evolving. She's a human, but is accepting now that he isn't. She's leaving Metropolis for a job writing for the Los Angeles Times.
Brainiac invades Earth and targets Metropolis. As the invasion occurs, Kosmo beams down a cemetery to find a body to clone for Brainiac to take human form. During the cloning process there is a mishap and Brainiac's skin turns green and he is bald.
Superman confronts Brainiac in the Metropolis streets, and seemingly falls dead after a powerful blast from Brainiac. Brainiac then attempts to woo Lois aboard his ark, amused at the thought of stealing Superman's love. After buying some time, she befriends Kosmo and schemes against Brainiac. Lois discovers Brainiac shrinks his chosen cities and traps them within crystalline eggs. Metropolis has joined them.
Drawing inspiration from Silver Age comics, one of Brainiac's cities is Kandor, collected by the alien intelligence before Krypton's destruction. Superman's body, we learn, is in the City of Kandor's - their doctors beamed him out of the fight.
Superman awakes with no powers in a strange white outfit (similar to Marlon Brando's costume from the first movie) He walks out into the crystalline, futuristic City of Kandor, under a red sun. He's romanced by Lyla Lerrol, an obscure figure from the comics who has connections to Kandor's elites.
After connecting with Max-Dur, Superman eventually gets his powers back and confronts Brainiac twice, once in his human form and another in machine form after defeating his human form. After saving Metropolis, Superman and Lois get married and the story ends with Lois being pregnant with twins, one boy and one girl.
Key Differences Between The First Draft and Third Draft
The story is primarily the same between the drafts but here are some of the key differences.
Martha Kent and Jor-El are in the first draft while they are not in the third draft.
Brainiac has comic book accurate green skin in his human form in the first draft while he does not in the third draft. This change was made because according to Cary Bates, it would've been harder to sell a movie star on the role if was difficult to see their face through make up and prosthetics.[5]
At the end of the first draft, Superman and Lois Lane get married and Lois is pregnant with twins while in the end of the third draft, Clark Kent reveals to Lois that he is Superman and proposes to her and they then fly off into the night.
The cast of Superman Reborn performing at the Broadwater Theater in Hollywood, CA. Superman flying with Lois.
Alexander and Ilya Salkind sold the Superman movie rights to Menahem Golan and Yoram Globus of The Cannon Group in June 1985 for $5 million.[6] The sale took place during negotiations at the 38th Cannes Film Festiva l. After the release of Superman IV under Cannon Films, the Salkinds bought the rights back and Ilya Salkind commissioned a fifth Superman script before Warner Bros. acquired the rights entirely in 1993.
After being on set of Superman III in 1982 as a liaison from Warner Bros. and DC Comics, Cary Bates wrote a treatment for Superman IV that involved Brainiac but shelved it when the Salkinds sold the rights in 1985 but was able to revisit it when Bates had shown his treatment to Ilya Salkind in 1988 while working on Superboy.
According to Ilya Salkind, Christopher Reeve was ready to come back to play Superman for this installment and had read the first draft. During the live Q&A, Mark Jones and Ilya Salkind revealed that George P. Cosmatos was originally attached to direct before he and Salkind clashed. In a 2024 interview with Seth Everett on the Hall of Justice podcast, Salkind revealed that he and Margot Kidder buried the hatchet and Kidder was expected to reprise her role as Lois Lane. In the first draft there is mention of Gotham City. When asked if there was ever a conversation to have Christopher Reeve's Superman meet Michael Keaton's Batman on the big screen, Salkind revealed that in having the rights, he could have used any character from DC Comics on film like Wonder Woman so as long as it featured Superman but was sad that it didn't happen.[7] Salkind also revealed to David Kocher that Phyllis Thaxter was not expected to reprise her role as Martha Kent.
The date of the first draft was September 13th 1990. An ideal theatrical release date for was for 1992. The first draft was titled Superman: The New Movie but overtime during rewrites it was later called Superman Reborn. This would have been the first Christopher Reeve Superman sequel that did not have a roman numeral attached to the title. This was an attempt to distance and rebrand the franchise from the negative connotation of Superman III and Superman IV. The date of the third draft was August 23rd 1992. Salkind stated that the MPAA rating aim was PG-13.
Throughout the years there were rumors of this film being a reboot that would have introduced Gerard Christopher as the Man of Steel coming off from Superboy. Mark Jones was asked about this by David Kocher and had mentioned that it came up once but the plan was always for Christopher Reeve to be in this film. According to Jones, Ilya Salkind believed that there was a difference between TV and film and wanted to keep the two worlds separate. Salkind revealed on the All Star Superfan podcast that he did consider Gerard Christopher to be Superman in a movie related to Superboy after Superman Reborn. [8]
With the Batman films ruling the box office at this time, Warner Bros. made the decision to self-produce their superhero properties, with Superman as their next objective. Exercising their right of script refusal, Warners ended the Superboy series and rejected Superman Reborn, cutting out the Salkinds and moving on with ABC's Lois and Clark: The New Adventures of Superman. Christopher Reeve would never portray Superman onscreen again, but fans now have an idea of how his journey as the hero could've ended.
Ray Carsillo with Mark Jones and Ilya Salkind.
Planned sequels
During the live Q&A, Ilya Salkind and Mark Jones had mentioned that they had plans for a Superman 6 & 7 if Reborn was a success. It would have explored Superman being a father of twins with Lois while still carrying on duties of saving the world. Jones had stated that one of the twins would have super powers while the other would not.
Inspiration for the Death of Superman
Since there was a death of Superman scene in this story, Mark Jones noted how DC Comics likely took inspiration of the idea for the Death of Superman comic book storyline in 1993.
Event development
Ilya Salkind with Mark Jones and David Kocher.
David Kocher originally planned to produce a live script reading performance of the third draft that leaked on the internet.[9] Through mutual friends, Kocher met Mark Jones at a cigar lounge in Woodland Hills, CA. Jones had mentioned to Kocher that he still possessed a copy of the first draft which had previously never been seen to the public. Jones had still kept in touch with Ilya Salkind and it was arranged that Jones and Salkind would do a live Q&A following the performance. Cary Bates was invited but was unable to attend. Kocher then reconnected with Ray Carsillo to help produce and direct the show. Kocher first connected with Carsillo from seeing his work on DC Daily. Carsillo being a member of Deadline Junkies, which specializes in cold reads and stage reads of various scripts, casted actors of his choice from there. Custom Superman shirts that replicated the Christopher Reeve 'S' emblem were made by Charlie Rose for Jonathan Cahill to wear during his performance as Superman. Rose also designed the teaser poster while the official poster was designed by Julian Adderley.
Release
The performance took place and was recorded at the Broadwater Theater in Hollywood, CA on November 12th 2024. The recording posted January 13th 2025 on David Kocher's YouTube Channel.[10]
After the premiere on YouTube, a 3 part audio only of the performance was made available on the Hall of Justice podcast with Seth Everett.[11]
Reception
Critical Response
Overall the performances of the actors was received very positively from the audience and general public.[12] It's been notated that Jonathan Cahill really captured the essence of Christopher Reeve in his performance as both Clark Kent and Superman. Some of the criticisms that were made were that of the script in the continuity issues that were inconsistent with the franchise such as Martha Kent being alive when it was established that she was deceased in Superman III and Superman IV. [13] It's a move that would have been similar to what Superman Returns did in ignoring Superman III and Superman IV and continuing forward from Superman II, though it's likely a reason why Martha Kent was not in the third draft. Other criticisms were that it was too edgy in the sense that there was a sex scene between Braniac and an Android Lois. Mark Jones had noted that upon recently rereading the first draft, there are more or less a few things that he would modify but overall he would keep it the same. Cary Bates shared that while quite a few details of the first draft are different than the last version he worked on, he was happy to see the main story beats for the most part in tact.
Campaign for an animated movie
Mark Jones mentioned that he would like to see this script be made into an animated movie. In a 2025 interview with Superman Homepage, David Kocher also mentioned that he would like to see an animated movie of Superman Reborn be made for DC Studios that would be set in the year 1992 and be made with the likeness of Christopher Reeve as Superman and Margot Kidder as Lois Lane. [14]
This page is based on this Wikipedia article Text is available under the CC BY-SA 4.0 license; additional terms may apply. Images, videos and audio are available under their respective licenses.
