The Cave and the Light

Last updated
The Cave and the Light
The Cave and the Light.jpg
First edition
Author Arthur L. Herman
Cover artist The School of Athens by Raphael, 1509-11
CountryUnited States
LanguageEnglish
Genre Philosophy
Publisher Random House
Publication date
2013
Media typePrint (hardback and paperback) and ebook
Pages676
ISBN 9780553385663 (hardback)

The Cave and the Light: Plato Versus Aristotle and the Struggles for the Soul of Western Civilization is the seventh non-fiction book written by American historian Arthur L. Herman. [1] The book contrasts the philosophical approaches of Plato and Aristotle directly, then examines changes in political, religious, and philosophical views in western societies from the days of ancient Greece to the present in the context of their relationship to Platonic or Aristotelian viewpoints.

Contents

The book was published as a hardcover in October 2013 by Random House and as a trade paperback in June 2014.

Synopsis

Using Raphael's The School of Athens painting to introduce the various schools of philosophy, Herman refers back to figures in the painting and their positions in relation to others frequently throughout the book. The first several chapters of The Cave and the Light focus on Socrates and his pupil Plato, as well as earlier philosophers whose ideas they built on: Pythagoras, Heraclitus, Parmenides. Herman next introduces Aristotle, a pupil of Plato who went on to develop a philosophical model at odds with Plato's. The book provides a detailed comparison between Plato's Republic and Aristotle's Politics. In addition to Plato's Academy and Aristotle's Lyceum, the book covers the competing and successive Hellenistic schools of philosophy: Epicureans, Stoics, Cynics, and Skeptics.

Herman attributes political, religious, and philosophical changes throughout history to the influence of the philosophies of either Plato or Aristotle. The Cave and the Light uses the framework of the two philosophers to discuss Alexandria, ancient Rome, Constantinople, the spread of Christianity, Europe in the Middle Ages, the Age of Enlightenment, the French Revolution, the founding of the United States, the rise of communism in Russia, and Nazism.

In an interview, Herman summarizes his book: [2]

What gave Western civilisation its dynamism for so long was its creative tension and balance between the material and the spiritual, between what we aspire to be as spiritual beings and what we need to be as material beings and part of nature. That’s the overall theme of The Cave and the Light and how that creative tension reflects the twin intellectual legacies of Aristotle and Plato, the greatest philosophers the world has ever known.

Reception

In The Wall Street Journal , Roger Kimball describes the book as "a rollicking trip from classical Athens to 21st-century New York" and Herman as "an able storyteller". [3] Kirkus Reviews described the book as "Breezy and enthusiastic but resting on a sturdy rock of research." [4]

David Rieff, writing in The National Interest , criticizes Herman for both oversimplification and inconsistency, and takes issue with what he terms Herman's "dismissive treatment of the centrality of Judaism in the formation of Western culture and politics." [5] Choice: Current Reviews for Academic Libraries recommends the book as "an introduction to Western intellectual thought", but also notes oversimplification as an issue for advanced readers. [6]

Referring to the dialectic between Plato and Aristotle, Rod Dreher in The American Conservative notes, "Though Herman is pretty clearly on the side of Aristotle, he does a good job of showing how we need both insights" and says it is "a smart, fun book." [7]

In the National Review , Brian Anderson describes it as "bold" and "a wonderful introduction to the intellectual history of the West." [8] A review in The Buffalo News described the book as "a brilliant history of Western Civilization's essential polemic". [9] The reviewer for the Knoxville News Sentinel wrote "this is an important book for anyone interested in the history of tought". [10] In the Sun Herald , the review mentions Herman's "wildly interesting approach" to his theory of the battle between the teachings of Plato and Aristotle in the Western world. [11]

Related Research Articles

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Aristotle</span> Ancient Greek philosopher and polymath (384–322 BC)

Aristotle was an Ancient Greek philosopher and polymath. His writings cover a broad range of subjects including physics, biology, zoology, metaphysics, logic, ethics, aesthetics, poetry, drama, music, rhetoric, psychology, linguistics, economics, politics, meteorology, geology, and government. As the founder of the Peripatetic school of philosophy in the Lyceum in Athens, he began the wider Aristotelian tradition that followed, which set the groundwork for the development of modern science.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Heraclitus</span> Greek philosopher (c. late 6th century BC)

Heraclitus was an ancient Greek pre-Socratic philosopher from the city of Ephesus, which was then part of the Persian Empire.

In philosophy, rationalism is the epistemological view that "regards reason as the chief source and test of knowledge" or "any view appealing to reason as a source of knowledge or justification". More formally, rationalism is defined as a methodology or a theory "in which the criterion of truth is not sensory but intellectual and deductive".

Allan David Bloom was an American philosopher, classicist, and academician. He studied under David Grene, Leo Strauss, Richard McKeon, and Alexandre Kojève. He subsequently taught at Cornell University, the University of Toronto, Tel Aviv University, Yale University, the École normale supérieure, and the University of Chicago.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Allegory of the cave</span> Allegory by Plato

The Allegory of the Cave, or Plato's Cave, is an allegory presented by the Greek philosopher Plato in his work Republic (514a–520a) to compare "the effect of education and the lack of it on our nature". It is written as a dialogue between Plato's brother Glaucon and his mentor Socrates, narrated by the latter. The allegory is presented after the analogy of the sun (508b–509c) and the analogy of the divided line (509d–511e).

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Ancient Greek philosophy</span> Philosophical origins and foundation of Western civilization

Ancient Greek philosophy arose in the 6th century BC, marking the end of the Greek Dark Ages. Greek philosophy continued throughout the Hellenistic period and the period in which Greece and most Greek-inhabited lands were part of the Roman Empire. Philosophy was used to make sense of the world using reason. It dealt with a wide variety of subjects, including astronomy, epistemology, mathematics, political philosophy, ethics, metaphysics, ontology, logic, biology, rhetoric and aesthetics.

Pseudophilosophy is a term applied to a philosophical idea or system which does not meet an expected set of philosophical standards. There is no universally accepted set of standards, but there are similarities and some common ground.

"Form of the Good", or more literally "the idea of the good" is a concept in the philosophy of Plato. The definition of the Good is a perfect, eternal, and changeless Form, existing outside space and time. It is a Platonic ideal.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Natural philosophy</span> Philosophical study of nature

Natural philosophy or philosophy of nature is the philosophical study of physics, that is, nature and the physical universe. It was dominant before the development of modern science.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Renaissance philosophy</span> Period of European thought (1355–1650)

The designation "Renaissance philosophy" is used by scholars of intellectual history to refer to the thought of the period running in Europe roughly between 1400 and 1600. It therefore overlaps both with late medieval philosophy, which in the fourteenth and fifteenth centuries was influenced by notable figures such as Albert the Great, Thomas Aquinas, William of Ockham, and Marsilius of Padua, and early modern philosophy, which conventionally starts with René Descartes and his publication of the Discourse on Method in 1637.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Obscurantism</span> Practice of obscuring information

In the fields of philosophy, the terms obscurantism and obscurationism identify and describe the anti-intellectual practices of deliberately presenting information in an abstruse and imprecise manner that limits further inquiry and understanding of a subject. The two historical and intellectual denotations of obscurantism are: (1) the deliberate restriction of knowledge — opposition to the dissemination of knowledge; and (2) deliberate obscurity — a recondite style of writing characterized by deliberate vagueness.

<i>Republic</i> (Plato) Philosophical work written by Plato around 375 BC

The Republic is a Socratic dialogue, authored by Plato around 375 BCE, concerning justice, the order and character of the just city-state, and the just man. It is Plato's best-known work, and one of the world's most influential works of philosophy and political theory, both intellectually and historically.

Arthur L. Herman is an American popular historian. He currently serves as a senior fellow at Hudson Institute.

John Herman Randall Jr. was an American philosopher, New Thought author, and educator.

The theory of Forms or theory of Ideas is a philosophical theory attributed to Plato, that the physical world is not as real or true as timeless, absolute, unchangeable ideas. According to this theory, ideas in this sense, often capitalized and translated as "Ideas" or "Forms", are the non-physical essences of all things, of which objects and matter in the physical world are merely imitations. Plato speaks of these entities only through the characters of his dialogues who sometimes suggests that these Forms are the only objects of study that can provide knowledge. The theory itself is contested from within Plato's dialogues, and it is a general point of controversy in philosophy. Nonetheless, the theory is considered to be a classical solution to the problem of universals.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Philosophy of happiness</span> Philosophical theory

The philosophy of happiness is the philosophical concern with the existence, nature, and attainment of happiness. Some philosophers believe happiness can be understood as the moral goal of life or as an aspect of chance; indeed, in most European languages the term happiness is synonymous with luck. Thus, philosophers usually explicate on happiness as either a state of mind, or a life that goes well for the person leading it. Given the pragmatic concern for the attainment of happiness, research in psychology has guided many modern day philosophers in developing their theories.

Ancient Egyptian philosophy refers to the philosophical works and beliefs of Ancient Egypt. There is some debate regarding its true scope and nature.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Victorino Tejera</span>

Victorino Tejera was a writer, scholar, and professor of philosophy with specializations in ancient Greek thought, Metaphysics, Aesthetics, and American philosophy. He was born in Caracas, Venezuela. He is known especially for his writing on Plato's Dialogues. Many scholars believe Tejera's work in this area is his most valuable contribution to philosophy. He was editor and contributor with Thelma Lavine on History and Anti-History in Philosophy whose FromSocrates to Sartre (1984) was the basis for the PBS series of the same name.

The Dream of Reason: A History of Philosophy from the Greeks to the Renaissance is a 2000 nonfiction book by Anthony Gottlieb, the first in a series of three volumes that introduce Western philosophy to a wide audience. The second volume is The Dream of Enlightenment. The third volume in the trilogy—which will continue chronologically from Immanuel Kant—will complete the survey, that has been compared to Bertrand Russell's A History of Western Philosophy published in 1945.

References

  1. Herman, Arthur (2013). The Cave and the Light. Random House. ISBN   978-0553807301.
  2. "The Declinist Imagination: Arthur Herman". Hudson Institute. Retrieved 15 May 2019.
  3. Kimball, Roger (17 November 2013). "Book Review: 'The Cave and the Light,' by Arthur Herman; In the pantheon of Dead White European Males, are there any specimens more deeply interred than Plato and Aristotle?". Wall Street Journal. Retrieved 15 May 2019.
  4. "The Cave and the Light". Kirkus. Retrieved 15 May 2019.
  5. Rieff, David (January 2014). "Western Civ's Life Coach". The National Interest. No. 129 (129): 79–86. JSTOR   44151048.
  6. Ingoglia, R. T. (Feb 2014). "Herman, Arthur. The cave and the light: Plato versus Aristotle, and the struggle for the soul of Western civilization". CHOICE: Current Reviews for Academic Libraries. 51 (6): 1066. Retrieved 15 May 2019.
  7. Dreher, Rod (24 November 2013). "Puddleglum & The Savage". The American Conservative. Retrieved 15 May 2019.
  8. Anderson, Brian (25 November 2013). "The West's Dynamic Tension". National Review. Retrieved 15 May 2019.
  9. Simon, Jeff (January 5, 2014). "Editor's choice". The Buffalo News. p. 33.
  10. Hughs, Ina (August 10, 2014). "Plato and Aristotle do battle". The Knoxville News-Sentinel. p. 54.
  11. Fraisier, Jim (July 30, 2017). "Philosophers offer answers to 'How should we live?'". Sun Herald. p. 2D, 7D.