Thermodynamic pump testing

Last updated

Thermodynamic pump testing is a form of pump testing where only the temperature rise, power consumed, and differential pressure need to be measured to find the efficiency of a pump. These measurements are typically made with insertion temperature probes and pressure probes fitted to tapping points on the pump's inlet and outlet. [1] From these measurements, the flow produced by a pump can be derived. [2] The thermodynamic method was developed in the early 1960s, and since has been increasingly used. It is described in high precision hydraulic testing standards such as ISO 5198.

Contents

The thermodynamic method is used for performance testing of pumps, flow meter calibration, system curve tests, and other applications. It is capable of achieving results with uncertainties of less than 1% in pump efficiency and less than 1.5% in flow [3] while being able to test piping configurations where other conventional pump testing methods cannot provide accurate results. [4]

History

The thermodynamic method was developed concurrently in the 1960s at the University of Glasgow and University of Strathclyde in Scotland, and the National Engineering Laboratory in France (Electricite de France) and Austin Whillier (Chamber of Mines, Johannesburg, South Africa). Whillier published a paper titled "Pump efficiency determination from temperature measurements" in the October 1967 edition of The South African Mechanical Engineer describing the method. [5]

Since that time, the thermodynamic method has been rigorously verified in many instances by different companies, including: [4] [6]

The thermodynamic pump testing method is now included in pump testing standards such as the BS ISO 5198: Centrifugal, mixed flow and axial pumps - Code for hydraulic performance tests - Precision Class. [2]

Method and equipment

The inefficiency of pumps is transmitted through the medium of temperature. Thus, nearly all of the energy lost due to the inefficiency of a pump causes an increase in temperature of the fluid which is being pumped. The thermodynamic method takes advantage of this fact, and precisely measures the temperature difference across a pump to calculate the pump's efficiency. Pressure measurements are used to calculate the head of the pump, and a power meter is used to measure input power to the pump. Using the measurements of temperature, power, and pressure, flow can be back-calculated using the pump equation. [4]

The temperature measurement is critical, and consequently commercial distributors of thermodynamic pump testing equipment often quote an accuracy of greater than 0.001 °C. [8] [9] [10] Such accuracy is necessary as the temperature rise across a pump may be less than 0.05 °C. [11] Typically, temperature probes are inserted directly into the flow, and pressure measurements are taken from taps on both the suction and discharge sections of the pipe. Then, the head on the pump is varied by some sort of adjustment such as throttling a discharge valve, utilizing different pump combinations in parallel, or adjusting well levels. [4] This allows the pump's performance to be tested across its range of operation as its head, and hence flow, is varied.

Thermodynamic method vs. conventional method

Measured and calculated quantities

The conventional pump testing method is a method which relies on flow measurements rather than temperature measurements to obtain the performance curves of pumps. Hence, the thermodynamic method differs from the conventional pump testing method largely in what is measured, and how those values are calculated. [6] The table below shows which parameters are measured by the test equipment, and which are calculated.

MethodHeadFlowEfficiencyPower
Thermodynamic Methodmeasuredcalculatedmeasuredmeasured
Conventional Methodmeasuredmeasuredcalculatedmeasured

As seen in the table above, the main difference between the two methods is that the conventional method calculates efficiency and measures the other variables directly, while the thermodynamic method calculates flow and measures the other variables directly. Because of this, the accuracy of the calculated efficiency in the conventional method hinges upon the accuracy of the head, flow, and power measurements. Similarly, in the thermodynamic method, the accuracy of the calculated flow is dependent on the accuracy of the head, efficiency, and power measurements.

Testing requirements

Another key difference between the two methods is test setup requirements. The conventional method requires more stringent piping requirements, usually requiring greater than 5 diameters of straight pipe upstream of the flow meter in order to provide the quoted flow accuracy. [12] The thermodynamic method, however, typically requires only 1-2 diameters of straight pipe upstream of the equipment [10] in order to achieve quoted accuracies. Consequently, the thermodynamic method is often able to perform field tests which cannot be performed by a conventional test.

Applications

The thermodynamic method is used to test water, wastewater, and other pumps, but because of its ability to accurately test flow, it is also used for applications such as system curve testing, flow meter verification and calibration, and perpetual efficiency monitoring. [13] This method is useful particularly in situations which do not have the piping requirements of conventional testing methods. It can, like conventional pump testing, be used to gauge the performance of pumps for preventative maintenance and to inform replacement and refurbishment decisions. Additionally, the method can be extended to blower and turbine performance testing. [13]

Notable projects utilizing the thermodynamic method

A number of projects have utilized the thermodynamic method for large scale pump testing and performance review. A few projects are listed below.

Melbourne (UK) real time pump and turbine network optimisation

A project between the Riventa and the UK's Severn Trent Water (STW) at the water company's Melbourne Area Network, which has always suffered from large variations in energy use. Numerous historic investigations had not uncovered the reasons or best operating policies. The complex algorithms developed as part of the work enabled STW to accurately schedule operation over a set horizon, meeting the demand with very appreciable energy cost reductions - a process simply too difficult for operational staff to do by experience alone. Two key technologies were amalgamated to provide a network optimisation methodology: thermodynamic pump performance measurement for individual pump and station efficiency analysis, and live hydraulic modelling to assess network routes and their hydraulic profiles. [14] [15]

Ontario pump efficiency assessment and awareness pilot study (Canada)

This project was sponsored by the Ontario Power Authority to test over 150 water pumps in Ontario, Canada, across eight geographically diverse municipalities. The thermodynamic pump testing method was utilized, along with a number of conventional tests performed alongside the thermodynamic method to demonstrate the effectiveness of the thermodynamic method. The project tested a variety of pumps ranging from 30 to 4000 HP and was completed in May 2013. [4] [16] [17]

Pump efficiency monitoring and managementement at Melbourne Water (Australia)

In an effort to minimize energy costs and associated greenhouse gas emissions, Melbourne Water in Australia applied thermodynamic pump testing to monitor pumps at four major pumping stations. Over the course of 2003 and 2004, 23 water and wastewater pumps were tested as part of this project. [18]

See also

Related Research Articles

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Pump</span> Device that imparts energy to the fluids by mechanical action

A pump is a device that moves fluids, or sometimes slurries, by mechanical action, typically converted from electrical energy into hydraulic energy.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Turbine</span> Rotary mechanical device that extracts energy from a fluid flow

A turbine is a rotary mechanical device that extracts energy from a fluid flow and converts it into useful work. The work produced can be used for generating electrical power when combined with a generator. A turbine is a turbomachine with at least one moving part called a rotor assembly, which is a shaft or drum with blades attached. Moving fluid acts on the blades so that they move and impart rotational energy to the rotor. Early turbine examples are windmills and waterwheels.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Tesla turbine</span> Bladeless centripetal flow turbine

The Tesla turbine is a bladeless centripetal flow turbine patented by Nikola Tesla in 1913.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Turbopump</span> Pump driven by a gas turbine

A turbopump is a propellant pump with two main components: a rotodynamic pump and a driving gas turbine, usually both mounted on the same shaft, or sometimes geared together. They were initially developed in Germany in the early 1940s. The purpose of a turbopump is to produce a high-pressure fluid for feeding a combustion chamber or other use.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Water turbine</span> Type of turbine

A water turbine is a rotary machine that converts kinetic energy and potential energy of water into mechanical work.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Turbojet</span> Airbreathing jet engine which is typically used in aircraft

The turbojet is an airbreathing jet engine which is typically used in aircraft. It consists of a gas turbine with a propelling nozzle. The gas turbine has an air inlet which includes inlet guide vanes, a compressor, a combustion chamber, and a turbine. The compressed air from the compressor is heated by burning fuel in the combustion chamber and then allowed to expand through the turbine. The turbine exhaust is then expanded in the propelling nozzle where it is accelerated to high speed to provide thrust. Two engineers, Frank Whittle in the United Kingdom and Hans von Ohain in Germany, developed the concept independently into practical engines during the late 1930s.

Flow measurement is the quantification of bulk fluid movement. Flow can be measured using devices called flowmeters in various ways. The common types of flowmeters with industrial applications are listed below:

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Air compressor</span> Machine to pressurize air

An air compressor is a machine that takes ambient air from the surroundings and discharges it at a higher pressure. It is an application of a gas compressor, and a pneumatic device that converts mechanical power into potential energy stored in compressed air, which has many uses. A common application is to compress air into a storage tank, for immediate or later use. When the delivery pressure reaches its set upper limit, the compressor is shut off, or the excess air is released through an overpressure valve. The compressed air is stored in the tank until it is needed. The pressure energy provided by the compressed air can be used for a variety of applications such as pneumatic tools as it is released. When tank pressure reaches its lower limit, the air compressor turns on again and re-pressurizes the tank. A compressor is different from a pump because it works on a gas, while pumps work on a liquid.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Centrifugal compressor</span> Sub-class of dynamic axisymmetric work-absorbing turbomachinery

Centrifugal compressors, sometimes called impeller compressors or radial compressors, are a sub-class of dynamic axisymmetric work-absorbing turbomachinery.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Fluid power</span> Use of fluids under pressure to generate, control, and transmit power

Fluid power is the use of fluids under pressure to generate, control, and transmit power. Fluid power is conventionally subdivided into hydraulics and pneumatics. Although steam is also a fluid, steam power is usually classified separately from fluid power. Compressed-air and water-pressure systems were once used to transmit power from a central source to industrial users over extended geographic areas; fluid power systems today are usually within a single building or mobile machine.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Chiller</span> Machine that removes heat from a liquid coolant via vapor compression

A chiller is a machine that removes heat from a liquid coolant via a vapor-compression, adsorption refrigeration, or absorption refrigeration cycles. This liquid can then be circulated through a heat exchanger to cool equipment, or another process stream. As a necessary by-product, refrigeration creates waste heat that must be exhausted to ambience, or for greater efficiency, recovered for heating purposes. Vapor compression chillers may use any of a number of different types of compressors. Most common today are the hermetic scroll, semi-hermetic screw, or centrifugal compressors. The condensing side of the chiller can be either air or water cooled. Even when liquid cooled, the chiller is often cooled by an induced or forced draft cooling tower. Absorption and adsorption chillers require a heat source to function.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Hydraulic head</span> Specific measurement of liquid pressure above a vertical datum

Hydraulic head or piezometric head is a specific measurement of liquid pressure above a vertical datum.

Condition monitoring is the process of monitoring a parameter of condition in machinery, in order to identify a significant change which is indicative of a developing fault. It is a major component of predictive maintenance. The use of condition monitoring allows maintenance to be scheduled, or other actions to be taken to prevent consequential damages and avoid its consequences. Condition monitoring has a unique benefit in that conditions that would shorten normal lifespan can be addressed before they develop into a major failure. Condition monitoring techniques are normally used on rotating equipment, auxiliary systems and other machinery like belt-driven equipment,, while periodic inspection using non-destructive testing (NDT) techniques and fit for service (FFS) evaluation are used for static plant equipment such as steam boilers, piping and heat exchangers.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Air flow bench</span> Device for testing internal aerodynamics of engine parts

An air flow bench is a device used for testing the internal aerodynamic qualities of an engine component and is related to the more familiar wind tunnel.

Specific speedNs, is used to characterize turbomachinery speed. Common commercial and industrial practices use dimensioned versions which are of equal utility. Specific speed is most commonly used in pump applications to define the suction specific speed —a quasi non-dimensional number that categorizes pump impellers as to their type and proportions. In Imperial units it is defined as the speed in revolutions per minute at which a geometrically similar impeller would operate if it were of such a size as to deliver one gallon per minute against one foot of hydraulic head. In metric units flow may be in l/s or m³/s and head in m, and care must be taken to state the units used.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Custody transfer</span> Oil and gas industry term for transfer of physical substance from one operator to another

Custody Transfer in the oil and gas industry refers to the transactions involving transporting physical substance from one operator to another. This includes the transferring of raw and refined petroleum between tanks and railway tank cars; onto ships, and other transactions. Custody transfer in fluid measurement is defined as a metering point (location) where the fluid is being measured for sale from one party to another. During custody transfer, accuracy is of great importance to both the company delivering the material and the eventual recipient, when transferring a material.

A rotodynamic pump is a kinetic machine in which energy is continuously imparted to the pumped fluid by means of a rotating impeller, propeller, or rotor, in contrast to a positive displacement pump in which a fluid is moved by trapping a fixed amount of fluid and forcing the trapped volume into the pump's discharge. Examples of rotodynamic pumps include adding kinetic energy to a fluid such as by using a centrifugal pump to increase fluid velocity or pressure.

A hydraulic compressor is a type of compressor that is designed to convert hydraulic power to pneumatic power. It is used across various industries to improve the efficiency of certain types of machinery. Hydraulic compressors have a hydraulic pump to push air through a pipe, which forces a motor to spin. The motor powers the internal air compressor, releasing air in a chamber as a result. Compressors became more popularized in 1799 when Englishman George Medhurst invented a motorized air compressor as a means for propulsion. They have technologically advanced to the point where they can achieve greater force and precision than humans.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Instrumentation in petrochemical industries</span>

Instrumentation is used to monitor and control the process plant in the oil, gas and petrochemical industries. Instrumentation ensures that the plant operates within defined parameters to produce materials of consistent quality and within the required specifications. It also ensures that the plant is operated safely and acts to correct out of tolerance operation and to automatically shut down the plant to prevent hazardous conditions from occurring. Instrumentation comprises sensor elements, signal transmitters, controllers, indicators and alarms, actuated valves, logic circuits and operator interfaces.

The Glossary of Geothermal Heating and Cooling provides definitions of many terms used within the Geothermal heat pump industry. The terms in this glossary may be used by industry professionals, for education materials, and by the general public.

References

  1. ↑ Advanced Thermodynamic Performance Measurements for pumps and pump systems, Malcolm Robertson, IMechE Seminar on Site Testing, London, June 2013.
  2. 1 2 BS ISO 5198:1999 Centrifugal, mixed flow and axial pumps - Code for Hydraulic performance tests - Precision Class.
  3. ↑ Thermodynamic performance testing and monitoring pumpindustry magazine, April 2013.
  4. 1 2 3 4 5 Toward Municipal Sector Conservation: A Pump Efficiency and Awareness Pilot Study Hydratek & Associates Inc, May 2013.
  5. ↑ ftp://140.98.193.80/uploads/pes/PowerAfrica2007/PowerAfrica-32-cattaeae.pdf.pdf
  6. 1 2 Pump Efficiency Testing By Thermodynamic Method.
  7. ↑ ATAP
  8. ↑ Wireless Thermodynamic Pump Monitoring
  9. ↑ Freeflow Portable Pump Testing System
  10. 1 2 P22 Pump Efficiency and Flow Meter
  11. ↑ Pump efficiency testing by the thermodynamic method - an independent view
  12. ↑ Flow Meter Piping Requirements
  13. 1 2 AEMS Testing and Monitoring Services
  14. ↑ Clifford, Tom. "Pump Centre Conference 2016 - Keynote Paper" (PDF).
  15. ↑ "Pioneering technology project scoops Pump Centre award 2016". www.riventa.com. Retrieved 2016-09-29.
  16. ↑ Thermodynamic method used for pump performance and efficiency testing program
  17. ↑ The reality of pump energy efficiency and performance: Canada sets example in characterizing actual energy efficiency of water pumps with province-wide testing program.
  18. ↑ Pump efficiency monitoring and management at Melbourne Water
This page is based on this Wikipedia article
Text is available under the CC BY-SA 4.0 license; additional terms may apply.
Images, videos and audio are available under their respective licenses.