Tierney Darden v. City of Chicago

Last updated
Tierney Darden v. City of Chicago
Seal of Illinois.svg
Court Circuit Court of Cook County
Full case nameTierney Darden v. City of Chicago et al.
DecidedAugust 24, 2017;3 years ago (2017-08-24)
VerdictPlaintiff to be awarded $148,190,997
Court membership
Judge(s) sittingClare McWilliams

Tierney Darden v. City of Chicago was a civil court case in Cook County, Illinois. In August 2017, a jury awarded Tierney Darden $148 million for damages after a pedestrian shelter at Chicago's O'Hare International Airport collapsed, leaving Darden partially paralyzed. [1] The case resulted in the highest compensatory verdict awarded to an individual in the state of Illinois, and one of the top five in the United States, excluding punitive damages, wrongful death claims, and imprisoned defendants. [2] [3]

Contents

Background

In August 2015, Darden, then a 24-year-old Truman College student from Mundelein, Illinois, was standing with her mother and sister outside O'Hare's Terminal 2 waiting for transportation. A sudden storm enveloped the airport and the family sought shelter behind a pedestrian shelter. [4] High winds toppled the 750-pound glass and steel structure onto Darden, severing her spine and leaving her paralyzed from the waist down. Her mother, Trudy Darden, and sister, Tayah Minniefeld, were also injured. [5] Darden's injuries resulted in the permanent loss of leg use, chronic neuropathic pain, 24-hour care requirements, and 20 prescription medications. Her initial medical bills totaled $985,411. [6]

The lawsuit prompted an investigation by CBS Chicago, which determined excessive rust had weakened the shelter support posts and bolts were missing. The investigation also revealed other shelters at the airport had missing bolts, corroded parts, or broken brackets. [7]

Case

Darden, with her mother and sister, filed a negligence lawsuit in the Illinois Circuit Court for Cook County against the City of Chicago and the City of Chicago Aviation Department. The case went to trial on August 10, 2017, with Judge Clare McWilliams presiding. Darden was represented by attorneys Patrick A. Salvi, Jeffrey J. Kroll, Tara R Devine, Patrick Salvi II, and Eirene N. Salvi from Salvi, Schostok & Pritchard P.C.[ citation needed ] "The City of Chicago's wrongful conduct forever changed the course of Tierney's life. She will never walk or dance again," said Kroll during opening statements. [8] Chicago officials admitted wrongdoing prior to the trial, and their legal team, from the firms of Williams & Gundlach LLC and Dentons US LLP, offered $30 million in compensation. [9]

Darden's counsel team asked the jury to award $174,934,582. After four hours of deliberation on August 23, the jury returned a verdict awarding $148,190,997. [2] [3] [10] The city appealed, then settled for $115 million, still the highest personal injury payment in Illinois history.

Related Research Articles

Chicago City and county seat of Cook County, Illinois, United States

Chicago, officially the City of Chicago, is the most populous city in the U.S. state of Illinois, and the third most populous city in the United States. With an estimated population of 2,693,976 in 2019, it is also the most populous city in the Midwestern United States. Chicago is the county seat of Cook County, the second most populous county in the U.S., while a small portion of the city's O'Hare Airport also extends into DuPage County. Chicago is the principal city of the Chicago metropolitan area, defined as either the U.S. Census Bureau's Metropolitan Statistical Area or the larger Combined Statistical Area, often called Chicagoland. Both constitute the third most populous urban area in the United States after New York City and Los Angeles.

Rosemont, Illinois American village

Rosemont is a village in Cook County, Illinois, United States. Located immediately northwest of Chicago, as of the 2010 census it had a population of 4,202. The village was incorporated in 1956, though it had been settled long before that. While Rosemont's land area and population are relatively small among municipalities in the Chicago Metropolitan Area, the village is a major center for commercial activity in the region and is a key component of the Golden Corridor.

OHare International Airport Airport in Chicago, Illinois, United States

O'Hare International Airport, typically referred to as O'Hare Airport, Chicago O'Hare, or simply O'Hare, is an international airport located on the Northwest Side of Chicago, Illinois, 14 miles (23 km) northwest of the Loop business district. Operated by the Chicago Department of Aviation and covering 7,627 acres (3,087 ha), O'Hare has non-stop flights to 228 destinations in North America, South America, Europe, Africa, Asia and Oceania as of 2018.

Midway International Airport Airport in Chicago, Illinois, United States

Chicago Midway International Airport, typically referred to as Midway Airport, Chicago Midway, or simply Midway, is a major commercial airport on the south side of Chicago, Illinois, located eight miles (13 km) from the Loop. Established in 1927, Midway served as Chicago's primary airport until the opening of O'Hare International Airport in 1955. Today, Midway is the second-largest airport in Chicago metropolitan area and the state of Illinois, serving 20,844,860 passengers in 2019. Midway is a base for Southwest Airlines; Chicago is Southwest's largest operating base.

Air Wisconsin Airlines is a regional airline based at Appleton International Airport in the town of Greenville, Wisconsin, United States, near Appleton. Air Wisconsin originally operated as one of the original United Express partners in 1986, and operated then as US Airways Express on behalf of US Airways prior to becoming an American Eagle regional air carrier. Since March 2018, Air Wisconsin operates exclusively as a United Express regional air carrier once again with primary hubs located at Chicago O'Hare International Airport (ORD) and Washington Dulles International Airport (IAD).

Chicago "L" Rapid transit system in Chicago, Illinois, operated by the CTA

The Chicago "L" is the rapid transit system serving the city of Chicago and some of its surrounding suburbs in the U.S. state of Illinois. Operated by the Chicago Transit Authority (CTA), it is the fourth-largest rapid transit system in the United States in terms of total route length, at 102.8 miles (165.4 km) long as of 2014, and the third-busiest rail mass transit system in the United States, after the New York City Subway and the Washington Metro. In 2016, the "L" had 1,492 rail cars, eight different routes, and 145 train stations; average weekday ridership was 759,866.

TransUnion is an American consumer credit reporting agency. TransUnion collects and aggregates information on over one billion individual consumers in over thirty countries including "200 million files profiling nearly every credit-active consumer in the United States". Its customers include over 65,000 businesses. Based in Chicago, Illinois, TransUnion's 2014 revenue was US$1.3 billion. It is the smallest of the three largest credit agencies, along with Experian and Equifax.

OHare, Chicago Community area in Chicago

O'Hare, located on the far north side of Chicago, is one of the city's 77 semi-official community areas. O'Hare International Airport is located within the boundaries of this community area. This community area is the only one that extends outside Cook County; the western edge is in DuPage County.

Chicago Rockford International Airport Airport in Winnebago County, IL, USA

Chicago Rockford International Airport, is in Winnebago County, Illinois, four miles (6 km) south of Rockford and 85 miles northwest of Chicago.

The O. J. Simpson murder case was a criminal trial held in Los Angeles County Superior Court. Former National Football League (NFL) player, broadcaster and actor O. J. Simpson was tried and acquitted on two counts of murder for the June 12, 1994, slashing deaths of his ex-wife, Nicole Brown Simpson, and her friend Ron Goldman. At 12:10 a.m. on June 13, 1994, Brown and Goldman were found stabbed to death outside her condominium in the Brentwood neighborhood of Los Angeles. Simpson became a person of interest after police found a bloody glove behind his house and was formally charged with the murders on June 17. When he did not turn himself in at the agreed time, he became the object of a low-speed pursuit in a white 1993 Ford Bronco SUV owned and driven by his friend Al Cowlings. TV stations interrupted coverage of the 1994 NBA Finals to broadcast the incident. The pursuit was watched live by an estimated 95 million people. The pursuit, arrest, and trial were among the most widely publicized events in American history. The trial—often characterized as the trial of the century because of its international publicity—spanned eleven months, from the jury's swearing-in on November 9, 1994. Opening statements were made on January 24, 1995, and the verdict was announced on October 3, 1995 when Simpson was acquitted on two counts of murder. According to USA Today, the case has been described as the "most publicized" criminal trial in history.

Robert A. Clifford is a Chicago trial lawyer and principal partner at Clifford Law Offices. Clifford's firm specializes in "personal injury, medical malpractice, mass torts, consumer and health care fraud, product liability, and aviation and transportation disasters." He attended DePaul University for both his undergraduate work and Juris Doctorate, finishing in 1976. The firm was founded in 1984 to represent plaintiffs in personal injury and wrongful death cases.

Milwaukee Airport Railroad Station

The Milwaukee Airport Railroad Station is an Amtrak railway station which opened for service on January 18, 2005. It is located at 5601 South 6th Street, just south of Wisconsin Highway 119, near the western edge of Milwaukee Mitchell International Airport in Milwaukee, Wisconsin, United States. The facility accommodates travelers who use the Hiawatha Service between Chicago and the Milwaukee Intermodal Station, and sees fourteen daily arrivals, seven each from Milwaukee Intermodal Station and Chicago. There is a shuttle from the station to the airport terminal.

Cumberland station (CTA) Chicago "L" station

Cumberland is a station on the Chicago Transit Authority's 'L' system. Situated on the Blue Line between Rosemont and Harlem, the station is located in the median of the Kennedy Expressway at Cumberland Avenue in the O'Hare neighborhood on Chicago's Northwest Side. It is also in close proximity to both the Norwood Park neighborhood and the city of Park Ridge. The area surrounding the station consists of mixed commercial and residential development.

The proposed Chicago south suburban airport is a proposed airport that would be located in Peotone, Illinois, approximately 40 miles south of Chicago. Serving in addition to the two international commercial airports serving Chicago, the site would serve the south suburbs of the Chicago metropolitan area. The two existing airports currently serving Chicago are located within and operated by the City of Chicago, with the Northern Illinois region also served by two other international airports in Illinois and Wisconsin.

Goldberg Weisman Cairo

Goldberg Weisman Cairo is a Chicago, Illinois law firm established in 1978 by founding partners Michael B. Goldberg and Larry E. Weisman. Two years later, Louis C. Cairo joined the firm and would become its third name partner. Since then, Goldberg Weisman Cairo has grown to thirty-three attorneys. The firm concentrates its practice in personal injury, workers' compensation, wrongful death, and medical malpractice law and has achieved record amounts in verdicts and settlements for its clients, totaling over one billion dollars.

Fashion Outlets of Chicago Shopping mall in Rosemont, Illinois

Fashion Outlets of Chicago is an enclosed outlet mall located at Balmoral Avenue and I-294, one-half mile east of O'Hare International Airport, in Rosemont, Illinois. It opened on August 1, 2013 taking approximately $250 million to develop. The outlet mall contains more than 150 stores that range from luxury to causal. Due to the mall's proximity to O'Hare International Airport, it is frequented by travelers. To service travelers, visitors are able to shop at the mall and visit an area in the facility to print tickets and check their luggage directly to O’Hare Airport.

Horwitz, Horwitz & Associates

Horwitz, Horwitz & Associates is a Chicago, Illinois law firm that focuses its practices in personal injury, workers' compensation, nursing home abuse and neglect, and wrongful death law. Horwitz, Horwitz & Associates has won numerous verdicts and settlements throughout Illinois, totaling over $1 billion. Horwitz, Horwitz & Associates won what was the largest non-death compensatory personal injury verdict in Illinois history as noted by the Illinois Jury Verdict Reporter.

Patrick A. Salvi

Patrick A. Salvi is an American trial lawyer and sports entrepreneur who lives and works in the Chicago area. He is the managing equity partner at Salvi, Schostok & Pritchard, a personal injury law firm with offices in Chicago and Waukegan, Illinois and founder of Salvi Sports Enterprises, a Chicago-based, multi-faceted sports consulting group that provides strategic planning and consulting within the minor league sports world.

Kenneka Jenkins, aged 19, was found dead inside a latched freezer of the Crowne Plaza Chicago O'Hare hotel in Rosemont, Illinois, after attending a party there on September 10, 2017.

Reaction to the verdict in the O. J. Simpson criminal trial

On Tuesday, October 3, 1995, the verdict in the O. J. Simpson murder case was announced and Simpson was acquitted on both counts of murder. The public reaction to the verdict remains a popular subject because initial polling showed that most blacks (70%) agreed with the verdict while most whites (75%) did not. The media called this the "racial gap" In 2016, FiveThirtyEight reported that the gap has narrowed with most African Americans now believing Simpson committed the murders. The narrowing racial gap is primarily attributed to several factors: Daniel Petrocelli disproving all of the blood planting claims at the civil trial, defense witness Dr. Henry Lee publishing a study that effectively disproved the contamination claim presented at trial, and the fading of Simpson's celebrity status since the trial.

References

  1. Hope, Leah (2017-08-24). "Paralyzed dancer is "very thankful" for $148M award". ABC7 Chicago . Retrieved 2017-12-21.
  2. 1 2 staff, Chicago Daily Law Bulletin (August 24, 2017). "$148M verdict for airport shelter collapse". Chicago Daily Law Bulletin. Retrieved 2017-12-21.
  3. 1 2 "Illinois Jury Awards Record $ 148 Million To College Student Paralyzed When Airport Pedestrian Shelter Collapsed". LexisNexis . August 31, 2017. Retrieved 2017-12-21.
  4. "Jury awards $148M to Chicago woman paralyzed after airport accident". CBS News . August 23, 2017. Retrieved 2017-12-21.
  5. "$148 million awarded to woman paralyzed in shelter collapse". Associated Press . August 24, 2017. Archived from the original on 2018-01-14. Retrieved 2017-12-21.
  6. Cherone, Heather (August 24, 2017). "$148M Award 'Gives Me Hope,' Says Dancer Paralyzed By Fallen Bus Shelter". DNAinfo . Archived from the original on 2018-01-14. Retrieved 2017-12-21.
  7. "Jury Awards Record $148M To Woman Paralyzed At O'Hare". CBS Chicago . 2017-08-23. Retrieved 2017-12-21.
  8. "Dancer left paralyzed by windblown pedestrian shelter at O'Hare awarded $148M verdict". The Cook County Record. August 25, 2017. Retrieved 2017-12-21.
  9. Harmon, Dwayne (August 25, 2017). "Woman awarded over $100 million after suing Chicago for freak storm accident". Newburgh Gazette. Retrieved 2017-12-21.
  10. Daniels, Melissa (August 23, 2017). "Jury Awards $148M To Woman Paralyzed At O'Hare Airport". Law360 . Retrieved 2017-12-21.