Time, Love, Memory

Last updated

Time, Love, Memory
Time, Love, Memory US 1st edition hardcover.png
First US hardcover edition (1999)
Author Jonathan Weiner
CountryUnited States
LanguageEnglish
Subject Seymour Benzer
Published1999
Publisher
ISBN 9780679763901 Penguin Random House edition

Time, Love, Memory: A Great Biologist and His Quest for the Origins of Behavior is a book by American non-fiction writer Jonathan Weiner, published in 1999. The book is a biography of California Institute of Technology biologist Seymour Benzer, who is recognized as one of the pioneers of genetics and molecular biology.

Contents

The book received mostly positive reviews, with critics noting its scientific accuracy and that it is about a "fascinating history". Reviews by the biologists, noted that Weiner "never really attempts a critical evaluation of what fruitflies have contributed to our understanding of behavior", and criticized the portrayal of Max Delbrück in the book; however, all the critics were very positive in their reviews.

Synopsis

Benzer started his career at Purdue University as a graduate student in solid state physics, studying semiconductors. His work in the early 1940s contributed to the subsequent development of the transistor. In 1946, he read Erwin Schrodinger's highly influential book What Is Life? , which described the nature of genes as known in the 1940s as "the great unsolved mystery of biology". Inspired by the book, Benzer enrolled in the summer course organized by Max Delbrück at Cold Spring Harbor Laboratory. After the course Benzer decided to change his career and became a biologist. For the next several years he worked with Delbrück and his phage group, and Andre Lwoff, Francois Jacob, and Jacques Monod at the Pasteur Institute. Later Benzer returned to Purdue. [1]

In classical genetics the gene was thought to be an indivisible entity; Benzer realized that if Watson and Crick's DNA model was correct, "then each gene is not a mathematical point but a linear segment, and that crossing-over should be able to occur within a gene." Benzer spent the next 10 years studying the rII region of phage mutants, as it was found to be very suitable and "an extraordinarily sensitive and simple assay" for detection of rare crossing-over events in a gene. When this field of study became more popular, Benzer abandoned it and started to work on a completely new area; that was very characteristic of Benzer throughout his career. [1]

Seymour Benzer in his office at Caltech in 1974 with a big model of Drosophila Seymour Benzer.gif
Seymour Benzer in his office at Caltech in 1974 with a big model of Drosophila

Benzer was interested by how different the personalities of his two daughters were. As the environment was the same, he reasoned that the cause should be in the genes. He chose Drosophila as his model organism. In his 1967 paper in Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA, "Behavioral mutant of Drosophila isolated by countercurrent distribution", he showed "that one can treat a fly as an 'atom of behavior' and profoundly change its behavior by introducing single-gene mutations". Benzer worked with flies from 1967 to 1980. [1]

The book is focused on three of the most specific types of mutants found during this period: "'Time' mutants that have an altered circadian clock, 'Love' mutants that are unable to perform the fly's intricate courtship behavior properly, and 'Memory' mutants that are unable to learn or remember." [1]

As summarized in The New York Times review:

Benzer [...] studied time, love and memory in fruit flies to see how genes govern behavior. Fruit flies wake up at dawn and go to sleep at night even when they are in a sealed room and never see the sun. Fruit flies also have elaborate courtship rituals and mating behavior: love. And surprisingly, experiments [...] have proved that flies can learn, for example, how to avoid electric shocks. That is, they have memory. [2]

Reception

Time, Love, Memory received several reviews in peer-reviewed journals. Charles Jennings in his 1999 review for Nature Neuroscience wrote that the science in the book is "for the most part, accurate and clearly explained" and noted that "it is remarkable how much intellectual history has been spanned in Benzer's career". But, in his opinion "it never really attempts a critical evaluation of what fruitflies have contributed to our understanding of behavior. Have Drosophila geneticists succeeded in isolating 'atoms of behavior', as Benzer once hoped? For Weiner's three core examples—time, love and memory—I would answer no, not yet, and a tentative yes." [3] Historian of biology Jane Maienschein in the review for the Journal of the History of Biology noted Weiner's "keen sense of history: of traditions, connectedness, and chains of influence" that resulted in a "beautifully crafted study". She observed "the scientist's empathy for the 'timeless', 'fruitless', and 'dunce' mutants that are deficient in time, love, and memory. We discover that fruit flies can learn, and we see scientists grappling with the questions of what free will might mean – and whether it matters." Additionally, she remarked on "the allusions to philosophy, literature, and popular culture" that "are much richer than in most history of science writing". [4]

Biologist Yuh-Nung Jan wrote in a review for Cell mostly positively, but criticized the portrayal of Max Delbrück in the book; "I don’t think Weiner quite captured the essence of Delbrück; his immense intellect, his unique personality, his moral integrity, and his almost magical influence on people who came into contact with him." [lower-alpha 1] One more flaw highlighted in the review is Weiner's treatment of the three titular mutations as "parallel and equal stories"; in Jan's view the work on Drosophila "points the way and provides the conceptual framework for the study of clocks in other organisms", but, in comparison, it contributed less into fields of learning and memory. Despite these points, Jan called Time, Love, and Memory "a terrific book that will appeal to a wide range of readers." [1]

A review by The New York Times noted that the book is about a "fascinating history", but stated that "in the second half of the book we almost lose sight of Benzer [...] and we sometimes lose Weiner's narrative thread as well". [2] Kirkus Reviews wrote that Weiner is good in "explaining the science with you-are-there descriptions of lab life and personalities" and "telling anecdotes that reveal the humor, quirks, frustration, anger, and rewards of being a scientist". [6] The Journal of Young Investigators noted that while Benzer's work is highly influential in genetics "Benzer is little more than a footnote in most textbooks. Due to the highly private life he led, his unusual dusk to dawn working hours, and his tendency to keep to the fringes of scientific research, Benzer's story has long gone unheralded." The review praised the book for unfolding the story of Benzer's life and work. [7]

The book won the American National Book Critics Circle Award for General Nonfiction in 1999. [8]

Biologist and the Brain Prize winner Ed Boyden said in several interviews that the book is one of his favourites and influenced him a lot; "I love it because it shows science in action ― not like a textbook [...] ― it shows people struggling with ambiguity and wrestling with all sorts of difficulty, and it’s very entertaining. For a while I would read that every year, once a year." [9]

See also

Notes

  1. Delbrück was Jan's PhD adviser. [5]

Related Research Articles

<i>Drosophila</i> Genus of flies

Drosophila is a genus of flies, belonging to the family Drosophilidae, whose members are often called "small fruit flies" or pomace flies, vinegar flies, or wine flies, a reference to the characteristic of many species to linger around overripe or rotting fruit. They should not be confused with the Tephritidae, a related family, which are also called fruit flies ; tephritids feed primarily on unripe or ripe fruit, with many species being regarded as destructive agricultural pests, especially the Mediterranean fruit fly.

Thomas Hunt Morgan American evolutionary biologist, geneticist, embryologist, and author (1866–1945)

Thomas Hunt Morgan was an American evolutionary biologist, geneticist, embryologist, and science author who won the Nobel Prize in Physiology or Medicine in 1933 for discoveries elucidating the role that the chromosome plays in heredity.

Max Delbrück Biophysicist

Max Ludwig Henning Delbrück was a German–American biophysicist who participated in launching the molecular biology research program in the late 1930s. He stimulated physical scientists' interest into biology, especially as to basic research to physically explain genes, mysterious at the time. Formed in 1945 and led by Delbrück along with Salvador Luria and Alfred Hershey, the Phage Group made substantial headway unraveling important aspects of genetics. The three shared the 1969 Nobel Prize in Physiology or Medicine "for their discoveries concerning the replication mechanism and the genetic structure of viruses". He was the first physicist to predict what is now called Delbrück scattering.

<i>Drosophila melanogaster</i> Species of fruit fly

Drosophila melanogaster is a species of fly in the family Drosophilidae. The species is often referred to as the fruit fly or lesser fruit fly, or less commonly the "vinegar fly" or "pomace fly". Starting with Charles W. Woodworth's proposal of the use of this species as a model organism, D. melanogaster continues to be widely used for biological research in genetics, physiology, microbial pathogenesis, and life history evolution. As of 2017, five Nobel Prizes have been awarded to drosophilists for their work using the animal.

Seymour Benzer

Seymour Benzer was an American physicist, molecular biologist and behavioral geneticist. His career began during the molecular biology revolution of the 1950s, and he eventually rose to prominence in the fields of molecular and behavioral genetics. He led a productive genetics research lab both at Purdue University and as the James G. Boswell Professor of Neuroscience, Emeritus, at the California Institute of Technology.

Eric F. Wieschaus

Eric Francis Wieschaus is an American evolutionary developmental biologist and 1995 Nobel Prize-winner.

The fruitless gene (fru) is a Drosophila melanogaster gene that encodes several variants of a putative transcription factor protein. Normal fruitless function is required for proper development of several anatomical structures necessary for courtship, including motor neurons which innervate muscles needed for fly sexual behaviors. The gene does not have an obvious mammalian homolog, but appears to function in sex determination in species as distant as the mosquito Anopheles gambiae.

The phage group was an informal network of biologists centered on Max Delbrück that contributed heavily to bacterial genetics and the origins of molecular biology in the mid-20th century. The phage group takes its name from bacteriophages, the bacteria-infecting viruses that the group used as experimental model organisms. In addition to Delbrück, important scientists associated with the phage group include: Salvador Luria, Alfred Hershey, Seymour Benzer, Charles Steinberg, Gunther Stent, James D. Watson, Frank Stahl, and Renato Dulbecco.

The T4 rII system is an experimental system developed in the 1950s by Seymour Benzer for studying the substructure of the gene. The experimental system is based on genetic crosses of different mutant strains of bacteriophage T4, a virus that infects the bacteria E. coli.

Ronald J. Konopka (1947-2015) was an American geneticist who studied chronobiology. He made his most notable contribution to the field while working with Drosophila in the lab of Seymour Benzer at the California Institute of Technology. During this work, Konopka discovered the period (per) gene, which controls the period of circadian rhythms.

Jean-Jacques Weigle was a Swiss molecular biologist at Caltech and formerly a physicist at the University of Geneva from 1931 to 1948. He is known for his major contributions on field of bacteriophage λ research, focused on the interactions between those viruses and their E. coli hosts.

<i>Endless Forms Most Beautiful</i> (book) 2005 evo-devo book by Sean B. Carroll

Endless Forms Most Beautiful: The New Science of Evo Devo and the Making of the Animal Kingdom is a 2005 book by the molecular biologist Sean B. Carroll. It presents a summary of the emerging field of evolutionary developmental biology and the role of toolkit genes. It has won numerous awards for science communication.

A behaviour mutation is a genetic mutation that alters genes that control the way in which an organism behaves, causing their behavioural patterns to change.

Jeffrey C. Hall

Jeffrey Connor Hall is an American geneticist and chronobiologist. Hall is Professor Emeritus of Biology at Brandeis University and currently resides in Cambridge, Maine.

Michael W. Young

Michael Warren Young is an American biologist and geneticist. He has dedicated over three decades to research studying genetically controlled patterns of sleep and wakefulness within Drosophila melanogaster.

Amita Sehgal is a molecular biologist and chronobiologist in the Department of Neuroscience at the Perelman School of Medicine at the University of Pennsylvania. Sehgal was involved in the discovery of Drosophila TIM and many other important components of the Drosophila clock mechanism. Sehgal also played a pivotal role in the development of Drosophila as a model for the study of sleep. Her research continues to be focused on understanding the genetic basis of sleep and also how circadian systems relate to other aspects of physiology.

Yuh Nung Jan is a Chinese-American neuroscientist. He is the Jack and DeLoris Lange Professor of Molecular Physiology at the University of California, San Francisco, where he works together with his wife Lily Jan as co-PIs of the Jan Lab.

Lily Yeh Jan is a Chinese-American neuroscientist. She is the Jack and DeLoris Lange Professor of Physiology and Biophysics at the University of California, San Francisco, where she collaborates with her husband Yuh Nung Jan as co-PIs of the Jan Lab.

<i>Drosophila</i> circadian rhythm

Drosophila circadian rhythm is a daily 24-hour cycle of rest and activity in the fruit flies of the genus Drosophila. The biological process was discovered and is best understood in the species Drosophila melanogaster. Other than normal sleep-wake activity, D. melanogaster has two unique daily behaviours, namely regular vibration during the process of hatching from the pupa, and during mating. Locomotor activity is maximum at dawn and dusk, while eclosion is at dawn.

Ravi Allada is an Indian-American chronobiologist studying the circadian and homeostatic regulation of sleep primarily in the fruit fly Drosophila. He is the Edward C. Stuntz Distinguished Professor of Neuroscience and Chair of the Department of Neurobiology at Northwestern University. Working with Michael Rosbash, he positionally cloned the Drosophila Clock gene. In his laboratory at Northwestern, he discovered a conserved mechanism for circadian control of sleep-wake cycle, as well as circuit mechanisms that manage levels of sleep.

References

  1. 1 2 3 4 5 Jan, Yuh-Nung (April 2000). "Curious Seymour" (PDF). Cell. 101 (2): 123–125. doi:10.1016/S0092-8674(00)80807-7 . Retrieved 9 November 2021.
  2. 1 2 "Books of The Times: 'Time, Love, Memory': Lessons of Fruit Flies, From the Finch's Friend". archive.nytimes.com. The New York Times. Retrieved 9 November 2021.
  3. Jennings, Charles (July 1999). "Flies by night". Nature Neuroscience. 2 (7): 591–591. doi:10.1038/10141.
  4. Maienschein, Jane (1999). "Time, Love, Memory Book Review". Journal of the History of Biology. 32 (3): 557–582. doi:10.1023/A:1017291029970.
  5. "Jans' Autobiography and Lab History". Jan Lab. UCSF. Retrieved 15 November 2021.
  6. "TIME, LOVE, MEMORY". kirkusreviews.com. Kirkus Reviews . Retrieved 9 November 2021.
  7. "MEDIA REVIEW – Time, Love, Memory: A Great Biologist and His Quest for the Origins of Behavior by Jonathan Weiner". Journal of Young Investigators. Retrieved 9 November 2021.
  8. "1999 Winners & Finalists". The National Book Critics Circle Award. Retrieved 9 November 2021.
  9. "How To Think, According To This Winner Of The Brain Prize". HuffPost . 13 September 2016. Retrieved 9 November 2021.