United States and America steamboat disaster

Last updated
Harpers Weekly litho.jpg

The United States and America steamboat disaster was a collision between two US Mail Line Company ships on the Ohio River in 1868. [1] Both ships were sunk and about seventy-four people died. The death toll makes this accident one of the worst Ohio River maritime disasters of all time.

Contents

On the night of 4 December 1868, sister ships owned by the US Mail Line Company collided on the Ohio River near Warsaw, Kentucky. Confusion among the pilots with the passing signals was the primary cause. The sidewheeler United States was struck by the sidewheeler America forcing barrels of flammable liquids into United States fireboxes. Both vessels became engulfed in flames and burned to the waterline and sank.

Collision

United States [2] and America [2] were recently built steamships employed in daily passenger, freight and mail delivery between Louisville, Kentucky and Cincinnati, Ohio. Both were of classic double cabin side wheeler design and over 300 feet in length. They were reported to be the fastest packets on the river at the time. Both boats were owned by the US Mail Line Company and would routinely pass one another along the stretch of river near Warsaw Kentucky where a great bend in the river exists. The pilots had a routine of passing with the Cincinnati (upriver) boat would take the Kentucky side for the passage and the down bound boat would pass on the opposite Indiana side.

On the night of the deadly collision, [3] the routine pilot on America had disembarked at Ghent, Kentucky for a family visit. A relief pilot unfamiliar with the routine passing agreement was at the helm. Lookouts on each boat spotted the other at a range of about 1 mile. The closing speed of the two vessels was about one mile every two minutes (30 miles per hour). America's relief pilot, a man named Captain Napoleon Jenkins, decided to signal for a two-whistle pass, meaning that they vessels would pass on the right. This is the opposite of the routine practice for these two vessels. The pilot on United States, unaware of relief pilot on the sister ship and impatient for a signal, preemptively signaled for a one-whistle pass (i.e. to pass on the left, as routine). Apparently, this steam whistle blast drowned out Jenkin’s first whistle from America. The second blast was taken on United States as acknowledgment on the one-whistle (port side) pass. As a result, both boats turned for the Indiana side of the river.

The upbound boat, America, rammed the down bound sidewheeler United States just forward of midships. Approximately 75 people were on board each vessel, many who were in their cabins in their night clothes. The impact started a fire on United States when some flammable liquids were spilled and reached the firebox. The fire quickly spread on United States as the two vessels made for the nearby Indiana bank. America came to the aid of United States pulling along aside to provide escape for passengers and crew. The fire then spread to America.

Passengers and crew rushed to abandon the burning vessels and many acts of valor were documented. In the end, about seventy people perished on the United States along with four from America . Survivors were tended to by local farmers and citizens of Kentucky who made their way across on small craft. Both United States and America burned to the water line and sank. United States sank at the Indiana bank near a place called Rayl’s landing. The burning America broke loose from shore and drifted downriver a few hundred yards and sank neat the mouth of Bryant's Creek, which enters the Ohio River in Switzerland County Indiana.

The entire event transpired over about 45 minutes from about 11:30 pm to shortly after midnight.

Aftermath

Survivors were cared for by Switzerland County farm families and Gallatin County, Kentucky residents who had witnessed the fires. The U. S. Mail Line Company sent the steamer C. T. DuMont [2] to the scene to return survivors to Cincinnati. The chief clerk sketched a map of the accident area that was published in the Cincinnati Daily. [3] The death toll is uncertain due to the loss of the passenger manifest from United States, but the best estimate is 74 souls. Bodies were recovered for some time and along a great length of the Ohio - as far downriver as Madison Indiana. United States was determined to be salvageable and was raised by the salvage vessel Underwriter [2] [3] in early 1869. It's hull was rebuilt with the rebuilt vessel retaining the name United States. This vessel served the U. S. Mail Line Company for many more years. America was not salvaged and it's hull remains somewhere near the mouth of Bryant's creek. A 1967 barge accident [4] caused the Markland Dam to lower the Ohio river level dramatically and the hull was visible. [5] Markland Dam was built in 1959 and has raised the river level some 37 feet since the time of the accident.

Burnt hulk of United States after salvage and tow to Cincinnati United States burnt out hull.jpg
Burnt hulk of United States after salvage and tow to Cincinnati

An inquest was initiated by the Board of Steamboat Inspectors at Cincinnati to investigate the accident. Both pilots were found to be at fault. The board sanctioned Mr. Jacob Remlein, pilot on United States, for signaling before hearing the full signal from the upbound America, and Mr. Napoleon Jenkins, pilot on America, for not stopping at 800 yards distance when the passing signals made were in conflict. [6] Lawsuits against U. S. Mail Line Company were filed in Indiana court, but none were ever fully adjudicated or settled due to confusion over jurisdiction on the Kentucky - Indiana state line. An insurance claim was paid to the company but came far short of the loss of the company's two finest steamers..

The death toll makes this accident one of the worst Ohio River maritime disaster of all time, along with Lucy Walker (1844) and Missouri [7] (1866).

Related Research Articles

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Steamboat</span> Smaller than a steamship; boat in which the primary method of marine propulsion is steam power

A steamboat is a boat that is propelled primarily by steam power, typically driving propellers or paddlewheels. Steamboats sometimes use the prefix designation SS, S.S. or S/S or PS ; however, these designations are most often used for steamships.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Pusher (boat)</span>

A pusher, pusher craft, pusher boat, pusher tug, or towboat, is a boat designed for pushing barges or car floats. In the United States, the industries that use these vessels refer to them as towboats. These vessels are characterized by a square bow, a shallow draft, and typically have knees, which are large plates mounted to the bow for pushing barges of various heights. These boats usually operate on rivers and inland waterways. Multiple barges lashed together, or a boat and any barges lashed to it, are referred to as a "tow" and can have dozens of barges. Many of these vessels, especially the long distances, or long haul boats, include living quarters for the crew.

<i>Sultana</i> (steamboat) 19th-century American steamboat that sank on the Mississippi River in 1865

Sultana was a commercial side-wheel steamboat which exploded and sank on the Mississippi River on April 27, 1865, killing 1,167 people in what remains the worst maritime disaster in United States history.

<i>Belle of Louisville</i> Steamboat owned and operated by the city of Louisville, Kentucky

Belle of Louisville is a steamboat owned and operated by the city of Louisville, Kentucky, and moored at its downtown wharf next to the Riverfront Plaza/Belvedere during its annual operational period. The steamboat claims itself the "most widely traveled river steamboat in American history." Belle of Louisville's offices are aboard Mayor Andrew Broaddus, and also appears on the list of National Historic Landmarks.

<i>Delta Queen</i> Historic American steamboat

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Jeffboat</span>

Jeffboat was a shipyard in Jeffersonville, Indiana founded by James Howard in 1834, a builder of steamboats. The company was owned by the Howard family until it was sold leading up to World War II. Following the war, it became known as the Jeffersonville Boat and Machine Company and later changed its name to Jeffboat, the more commonly used short form of its name. The company was the largest inland shipbuilder in the United States and the second-largest builder of barges before it closed in 2018.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Great Steamboat Race</span> Annual steamboat race in the Ohio River as part of the Kentucky Derby Festival

The Great Steamboat Race is an annual steamboat race, taking place the Wednesday before the first Saturday of May, three days before the Kentucky Derby, as part of the Kentucky Derby Festival. The race was first run in 1963 and it takes place on the Ohio River in the span that runs between Louisville, Kentucky and Jeffersonville, Indiana. Until 2009, the race was traditionally between the Belle of Louisville and the Delta Queen, although other steamboats have participated. Since 2009, the Delta Queen has not participated due to ownership and legal issues, and the Belle of Cincinnati has taken its place in the competition. In 2012, the Belle of Louisville and Belle of Cincinnati were joined in the race by the American Queen.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Puget Sound mosquito fleet</span> Private transportation companies in Puget Sound

The Puget Sound mosquito fleet was a multitude of private transportation companies running smaller passenger and freight boats on Puget Sound and nearby waterways and rivers. This large group of steamers and sternwheelers plied the waters of Puget Sound, stopping at every waterfront dock. The historical period defining the beginning and end of the mosquito fleet is ambiguous, but the peak of activity occurred between the First and Second World Wars.

<i>Natchez</i> (boat)

Natchez has been the name of several steamboats, and four naval vessels, each named after the city of Natchez, Mississippi or the Natchez people. The current one has been in operation since 1975. The previous Natchez were all operated in the nineteenth century, most by Captain Thomas P. Leathers. Each of the steamboats since Leathers' first had as its ensign a cotton bale between its stacks.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Shipwrecks of the inland Columbia River</span>

Steamboats on the Columbia River system were wrecked for many reasons, including striking rocks or logs ("snags"), fire, boiler explosion, or puncture or crushing by ice. Sometimes boats could be salvaged, and sometimes not.

<i>Wilson G. Hunt</i> (sidewheeler)

Wilson G. Hunt was a steamboat that ran in the early days of steam navigation on Puget Sound and Sacramento, Fraser, and Columbia Rivers. She was generally known as the Hunt during her years of operation. She had a long career on the west coast of the United States and Canada, and played an important transportation role in the California Gold Rush; it also transported the Governor and the state legislature as the state capital of California moved from Benicia to Sacramento in 1854.

<i>Idaho</i> (sidewheeler)

The sidewheeler Idaho was a steamboat that ran on the Columbia River and Puget Sound from 1860 to 1898. There is some confusion as to the origins of the name; many historians have proposed it is the inspiration for the name of the State of Idaho. Considerable doubt has been cast on this due to the fact that it is unclear if the boat was named before or after the idea of 'Idaho' as a territory name was proposed. John Ruckel also allegedly stated he had named the boat after a Native American term meaning 'Gem of the Mountains' he got from a mining friend from what is now Colorado territory. This steamer should not be confused with the many other vessels of the same name, including the sternwheeler Idaho built in 1903 for service on Lake Coeur d'Alene and the steamship Idaho of the Pacific Coast Steamship Line which sank near Port Townsend, Washington.

<i>New Orleans</i> (steamboat) Mississippi and Ohio River steamboat (1811–1814)

New Orleans was the first steamboat on the western waters of the United States. Owned by Robert Fulton and Robert R. Livingston, and built by Nicholas Roosevelt, its 1811–1812 voyage from Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania, to New Orleans, Louisiana, on the Ohio and Mississippi rivers ushered in the era of commercial steamboat navigation on the western and mid-western continental rivers.

SS <i>Superior City</i> Freighter in the Great Lakes service that sank in Lake Superior

The SS Superior City was considered a pioneer vessel at her launching in 1898. She was the largest vessel ever built on freshwater at that time. She sailed the Great Lakes for twenty-two years until she sank after a collision in 1920 with the steamer Willis L. King in Whitefish Bay of Lake Superior that resulted in the loss of 29 lives. Controversy was immediate over the collision. It was subsequently ruled that the captains of both ships failed to follow the “rules-of-the-road”. Controversy started again in 1988 when the Great Lakes Shipwreck Historical Society produced a video called "Graveyard of the Great Lakes" that included extensive footage of the skeletons of the Superior City crew. The controversy continued as late as 1996 over artifacts removed from her wreck. She is now a protected shipwreck in the Whitefish Point Underwater Preserve.

SS <i>John B. Cowle</i> (1902) Early Great Lakes bulk freighter sunk in Lake Superior

SS John B. Cowle was one of the early Great Lakes bulk freighters known as "tin pans". She was the first of two ships named for prominent Cleveland, Ohio citizen and shipbuilder John Beswick Cowle. In 1909 on her maiden voyage SS Isaac M. Scott rammed John B. Cowle in heavy fog off Whitefish Point. John B. Cowle sank in three minutes, taking 14 of her 24-man crew with her. Artifacts from her wreck were illegally removed in the 1980s. Her artifacts are now the property of the State of Michigan and are on display as a loan to the Great Lakes Shipwreck Museum. The wreck of John B. Cowle is protected as part of an underwater museum in the Whitefish Point Underwater Preserve.

<i>Lucy Walker</i> steamboat disaster

The Lucy Walker steamboat disaster was an 1844 steamboat accident caused by the explosion of the boilers of the steamboat Lucy Walker near New Albany, Indiana, on the Ohio River. The explosion occurred on the afternoon of Wednesday, October 23, 1844, when the steamer's three boilers exploded, set the vessel on fire, and sank it. It was one of a number of similar accidents of early 19th-century riverine transportation that led to important federal legislation and safety regulations. The vessel's owner was a Native American; her crew were African-American slaves, and her passengers represented a cross-section of frontier travelers.

Gordon C. Greene was a paddle steamer, launched in 1923, that operated under several names before sinking in St. Louis in 1967.

<i>Island Queen</i>

The Island Queen was a series of two American sidewheeler steamboats built in 1896 and 1925 respectively. Both vessels were passenger carriers cruising along the Mississippi and Ohio rivers as both an excursion boat and tramp steamer. The first Island Queen burned in 1922 in a fire which destroyed several other vessels. The second Island Queen was destroyed in 1947 when her chief engineer, using a welding torch, accidentally cut into her fuel tank. Island Queen was reduced to her steel frame, and was scrapped by a local company.

<i>Jennie Clark</i> American steamboat

Jennie Clark, also seen spelled Jenny Clark, was the first sternwheel-driven steamboat to operate on the rivers of the Pacific Northwest, including British Columbia. This vessel was commonly known as the Jennie when it was in service. The design of the Jennie Clark set a pattern for all future sternwheel steamboats built in the Pacific Northwest and in British Columbia.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Guards (steamboat)</span>

Guards on a steamboat were extensions of the main deck out from the boat’s main hull. Guards were originally adopted for side-wheel steamboats to protect the paddle wheels and to provide a mounting point for the outer ends of the paddle wheel shafts. The main deck planking extended out over the guards, and when a steamboat was fully loaded, and sunk deeply in the water, it often appeared that the edges of the guards marked the line of the hull.

References

  1. "Collision Between the Mail Boats United States and America". The Courier-Journal. 6 December 1868. p. 1.
  2. 1 2 3 4 Way, Frederick (1994). Way's Packet Directory, 1848-1994 (Paperback ed.). Athens Ohio: Ohio University Press. pp. 19–20, 66–67, 463, 464. ISBN   0-8214-1106-3.
  3. 1 2 3 Bogardus, Carl (1991). Collison of the United States and America Rendezvous with Destiny. Warsaw Kentucky USA: The Gallatin County Historical Society. pp. 2–30.
  4. "River Going Down and Down". The Cincinnati Enquirer. 28 May 1967. p. 1.
  5. Pedigo, Martin (1 December 1968). "Flames of Hell on the Darkened River". The Courier-Journal & Times Magazine. pp. 24–29.
  6. "River Unintelligence". The Republican. Nashville, Tennessee. February 18, 1869. p. 3 via Newspapers.com.
  7. Schmitt, Stan (12 January 2016). "Tragedy on the Ohio". Evansville Living. Retrieved 9 November 2022.

Further reading