Walnut Hall

Last updated
Walnut Hall
WalnutHall.jpg
Walnut Hall in 1934
Walnut Hall
Former namesO'Donohoe Row
General information
TypeResidential
Architectural style Georgian
LocationShuter Street, Toronto, Ontario, Canada
Completed1856
DemolishedMay 19, 2007
OwnerTrisan Realty Corp (at demolition)
Technical details
Floor count3.5
Design and construction
Architect(s)John Tully
Designated1997
Delisted2007

Walnut Hall was a row of four Georgian-style terraced homes in Toronto, Ontario, Canada. Constructed in 1856, it was recognized by both the Government of Canada [1] and the City of Toronto [2] as being of historic significance, but portions of it collapsed and it had to be demolished in 2007 due to neglect. At the time of its demolition, it was Toronto's last remaining complete row of 19th century Georgian townhomes. [3]

Contents

O'Donohoe Row

John O'Donohoe, a local politician, auctioneer and land speculator, purchased a lot on Shuter Street in Toronto in 1853. A four-unit terrace, known as O'Donohoe Row, was designed by architect John Tully and completed on the lot in 1856. At three and half storeys, the building featured buff brick with decorative brickwork and stone detailing, a symmetrical façade, a gabled roof and dormer windows. [2]

At the time, Shuter Street was located in a prestigious residential neighbourhood. Given its location and the quality of its construction, O'Donohoe Row was intended to cater to the affluent middle class, and was representative of the Georgian-style brick row houses which flourished in Toronto in the 1850s. [2]

The character of the neighbourhood changed, and the building was renamed Walnut Hall Apartment House in 1903. [2] In 1949, the interior was converted to a rooming house, and a number of changes were made to the exterior, including the conversion of the southeast corner to a storefront. [1]

The Royal Canadian Mounted Police purchased the building in the 1970s, as part of a land assembly for a new Ontario Division headquarters building. [4] In 1983, the Government of Canada designated it as a Recognized Federal Heritage Building. It was also during the 1980s that Walnut Hall was vacated, left unheated and boarded up. [1] [4] The building was sold to a private developer in 1996. Once it was privately owned, the City designated Walnut Hall under the Ontario Heritage Act in 1997. [2]

Demolition

Walnut Hall in 2006 Walnut Hall 2006.jpg
Walnut Hall in 2006

Walnut Hall was the subject of a number of demolition proposals and redevelopment schemes from the 1970s onwards, ranging from a proposed parking lot to residential developments that would have incorporated the heritage building. None of the proposals was achieved, however, and Walnut Hall remained vacant and unheated. In 1999, the City of Toronto issued an order to the landowner to correct a number of growing structural deficiencies in the building. [1]

In 2004, Walnut Hall appeared in the film Cinderella Man when the derelict building was used to portray a 1930s New York City-streetscape. [5] [6]

In March 2007, Trisan Realty Corp. purchased the property with the intention of restoring Walnut Hall. [7] On May 19, 2007, however, police and fire officials were called to the site when pedestrians noticed bricks falling from the second and third storeys. By the end of the afternoon, parts of the rear walls had begun to cave in. That evening, a city building inspector recommended that Walnut Hall be demolished for safety reasons, and the demolition was undertaken that night. [3]

In 2008, Heritage Canada included Walnut Hall in its annual list of "Worst Losses", referring to the building's neglect and demolition as "a case of architectural euthanasia". [8] Michael McClelland, a heritage architect and a founding member of the Canadian Association of Professional Heritage Consultants, described the loss of Walnut Hall as being emblematic of a "broken" heritage preservation system in Toronto. [9]

Related Research Articles

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Terraced house</span> Form of medium-density housing

A terrace, terraced house (UK), or townhouse (US) is a type of medium-density housing which first started in 16th century Europe with a row of joined houses sharing side walls. In the United States and Canada these are sometimes known as row houses or row homes.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Exhibition Place</span> Publicly owned mixed-use development in Toronto

Exhibition Place is a publicly owned mixed-use district in Toronto, Ontario, Canada, located by the shoreline of Lake Ontario, just west of downtown. The 197-acre (80 ha) site includes exhibit, trade, and banquet centres, theatre and music buildings, monuments, parkland, sports facilities, and a number of civic, provincial, and national historic sites. The district's facilities are used year-round for exhibitions, trade shows, public and private functions, and sporting events.

The year 1856 in architecture involved some significant architectural events and new buildings.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Toronto City Hall</span> Canadian city hall, opened 1965

The Toronto City Hall, or New City Hall, is the seat of the municipal government of Toronto, Ontario, Canada, and one of the city's most distinctive landmarks. Designed by Viljo Revell and engineered by Hannskarl Bandel, the building opened in 1965. The building is located adjacent to Nathan Phillips Square, a public square at the northwest intersection of Bay Street and Queen Street, that was designed and officially opened alongside Toronto City Hall.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Campbell House (Toronto)</span> Heritage house and museum in Ontario, Canada

Campbell House is an 1822 heritage house and museum in downtown Toronto, Ontario, Canada. It was built for Upper Canada Chief Justice Sir William Campbell and his wife Hannah. The home was designed for entertaining and comfort, and constructed at a time when the Campbells were socially and economically established and their children had grown to adulthood. The house is one of the few remaining examples of Georgian architecture left in Toronto and is constructed in a style in vogue during the late Georgian era known as Palladian architecture.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Government House (Ontario)</span> Official residences in Toronto, Canada

Government House was the official residence of the lieutenant governor of Upper Canada and Ontario, Canada. Four buildings were used for this purpose, none of which exist today, making Ontario one of four provinces not to have an official vice-regal residence.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Garden District, Toronto</span> Neighbourhood in Toronto, Ontario, Canada

The Garden District is a neighbourhood in downtown Toronto, Ontario, Canada. The name was selected by the Toronto East Downtown Residents Association (TEDRA) in recognition of Allan Gardens, an indoor botanical garden located nearby at the intersection of Carlton and Jarvis Streets. The Garden District was officially designated by the Mayor and Toronto City Council in 2001, while TEDRA has since been renamed the Garden District Residents Association. Part of the neighbourhood is within official City of Toronto neighbourhood of Moss Park.

<i>Ontario Heritage Act</i> Canadian act

The Ontario Heritage Act, first enacted on March 5, 1975, allows municipalities and the provincial government to designate individual properties and districts in the Canadian Province of Ontario, as being of cultural heritage value or interest.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">George Brown House (Toronto)</span> Canadian politician

George Brown House is a historic building in the Grange Park neighbourhood of Toronto, Ontario, Canada. It was home to Father of Confederation, Reform Party politician and publisher George Brown. Its current address is 186 Beverley Street.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Architecture of Philadelphia</span>

The architecture of Philadelphia is a mix of historic and modern styles that reflect the city's history. The first European settlements appeared within the present day borders of Philadelphia, Pennsylvania in the 17th century with most structures being built from logs. By the 18th century, brick structures had become common. Georgian and later Federal style buildings dominated much of the cityscape. In the first half of the 19th century, Greek revival appeared and flourished with architects such as William Strickland, John Haviland, and Thomas U. Walter. In the second half of the 19th century, Victorian architecture became popular with the city's most notable Victorian architect being Frank Furness.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">John O'Donohoe</span> Canadian politician

John O'Donohoe was a Canadian politician.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Enoch Turner School</span> Ontario Heritage Trust historic site and museum in Ontario, Canada

Enoch Turner Schoolhouse is a historic site and museum in Toronto, Ontario, Canada. It is a former school owned by the Ontario Heritage Trust. The school was built in 1848 when it was known as the Ward School. The building is located at 106 Trinity Street between King Street East and Eastern Avenue. It is the oldest school standing in the city.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Moses Chamberlain Edey</span> Canadian architect

Moses Chamberlain Edey (1845–1919) was an Ottawa architect who designed the Aberdeen Pavilion at Lansdowne Park, a National Historic Site and the Daly Building (1905–1992), which was Ottawa's first department store.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Second Empire architecture in the United States and Canada</span> 19th-century North American architectural style

Second Empire architecture in the United States and Canada is an architectural style that was popular in both nations in the late 19th century between 1865 and 1900. Second Empire architecture was influenced by the redevelopment in the mid-19th century of ancient Paris, the capital city of France, under former President of the French Republic (1848-1852), and later Emperor Napoleon III's Second French Empire (1852-1870), and was influenced partly by the architectural styles of the earlier French Renaissance.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Stratford City Hall</span> City hall in Ontario, Canada

Stratford City Hall is the city hall of Stratford, Ontario, and a National Historic Site of Canada. It sits amidst the city's business district, on a triangular town square.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Paul Kane House</span> House in Ontario, Canada

The Paul Kane House is a heritage structure in Toronto, Ontario, Canada. Paul Kane, an important early Canadian artist, purchased the property in 1853 and built a cottage on the site.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Michael McClelland</span> Canadian architect

Michael McClelland is a Canadian architect with a history of experience in heritage conservation. He is a founding principal of the Toronto-based firm ERA Architects Inc., as well as an author of several books.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">TOBuilt</span>

TOBuilt is a digital, crowd-sourced database of buildings, structures, heritage sites, and human-made landscapes in Toronto, Ontario, Canada maintained by the Toronto branch of the Architectural Conservancy of Ontario. The database's initial catalogue was created by Robert Krawczyk in 2006. In 2015, ACO Toronto assumed the operation of TOBuilt and relaunched it on a new platform. As of December 2023, TOBuilt maintains entries for over 15,000 sites located across the city of Toronto.

References

  1. 1 2 3 4 Report to Toronto East York Community Council from Joe Halstead, Commissioner Economic Development, Culture and Tourism, re. 102 – 110 Shuter Street – Walnut Hall – Authority to Enter into an Heritage Easement Agreement (HEA). June 5, 2002. Retrieved 2008-04-29.
  2. 1 2 3 4 5 A by-law to designate the property at 102-108 Shuter Street as being of architectural value or interest. City of Toronto By-law No. 1997-0219. Enacted May 12, 1997.
  3. 1 2 Kyonka, Nick. Historic building dies of neglect. Toronto Star. May 20, 2007.
  4. 1 2 Goddard, John. Historic Building in Ruins. Toronto Star. May 21, 2007.
  5. Fleischer, David (2008-07-01). "Reel Toronto: Cinderella Man". Torontoist . Retrieved October 24, 2010.
  6. Toronto Film and Television Office. "Productions shot in Toronto representing New York". City of Toronto. Retrieved October 24, 2010.
  7. Goddard, John. Heritage block buyer `shocked' site demolished. Toronto Star. May 23, 2007.
  8. "Worst Losses By Province - Ontario". Worst Losses Archives. Heritage Canada . Retrieved 28 February 2012.
  9. De Franco, Luca. "HEADSPACE: Architect Michael McClelland discusses Heritage Preservation". Spacing Toronto. Spacing . Retrieved 23 July 2013.

43°39′20″N79°22′23″W / 43.655691°N 79.373099°W / 43.655691; -79.373099