Who Shall Live and Who Shall Die

Last updated
Who Shall Live and Who Shall Die
Who shall live.jpg
Directed byLaurence Jarvik
Release date
  • 1982 (1982)
Running time
90 minutes
CountryUnited States
LanguageEnglish

Who Shall Live and Who Shall Die is a 1982 documentary film that asks whether the United States could have stopped the Holocaust. The film combines previously classified information, rare newsreel footage, and interviews with the politicians who were in office at the time, to tell a behind-the-scenes story of secret motives and inane priorities that allowed for the death of millions. The film title refers to the prayer Unetanneh Tokef that has been a part of the Rosh Hashanah and Yom Kippur liturgy in rabbinical Judaism for centuries and is also remembered in Leonard Cohen's song Who by Fire.

Contents

Summary

At the height of the war, dying Hungarian Jews managed to smuggle a letter to the Allies. It read, "And you, our brothers in all free countries: and you, governments of all free lands, where are you? What are you doing to hinder the carnage that is now going on?"

Through archival footage and soundbites, the documentary simultaneously reconstructs and criticizes America's isolationist attitude during the war. Full of righteous anger, the film scrutinizes Jewish-Americans inactivity and the government's apathetic response to the European Jews' cry for help.

Full of biting anger, Peter Bergson of the Emergency Committee to Save the Jewish People of Europe believes that American Jews silenced their outcries against the Holocaust because they were afraid they wouldn't get into their local Country Clubs. Bergson argues that if American Jewish leadership had taken a more vocal and active stance against the Nazism, lives could have been saved.

But while Bergson blames Jewish leadership, other politicians are more critical of the Franklin D. Roosevelt administration, which seems to have been ill-advised, consumed by other issues and dependent upon the nation's approval. One politician quips that the truth is President Roosevelt didn't want to be remembered for passing the "Jew Deal."

Regardless of Roosevelt's motives, the Commander-in-Chief missed opportunities both at war and at home to save Jewish lives. One of the most devastating decisions was the nation's refusal to change its immigration policies. The tangles of bureaucracy, deep-rooted anti-Semitism, and a fear of the economic effects seem to have caused the inflexibility. One politician recognizes that "it should have been a crisis, but there wasn't enough passion in America to let them in." He's still haunted by a story of a boat full of Jewish refugees who managed to escape from Hamburg, Germany, and traveled to America, only to be refused asylum. They ventured down to Cuba, where they were again refused entrance. Left with no other option—the Jews "returned to Hamburg to burn."

The documentary points to the fact that while the Jews were being slaughtered, America refused to fully recognize the horror, but, as soon as the war was over, the nation was ready to address the inhumanity. Who Shall Live and Who Shall Die shows clips from a disturbing American propaganda film, Death Mills , which was intended to educate the German people about the crimes of the Nazi regime. Black-and-white footage shows Nazi concentration camps after their liberation. Emaciated bodies, still alive but with no chance of survival, lie motionless on the open fields. When the crematorium door is opened, showing the skulls inside, the narrator demands, "Don't turn away! Look!" Once the evil had been committed and nothing could be done to change the awful reality, the public was ready to be shocked and horrified.

About the director

Laurence A. Jarvik received his Ph.D. and Master of Fine Arts in Film and Television from UCLA's School of Film and TV and taught at UCLA and California State University, Los Angeles. [1]

Since then, he's been involved in PBS. He wrote two books about the station, Masterpiece Theatre and the Politics of Quality (Scarecrow Press, 1999) and PBS: Behind the Screen (Prima, 1997), and testified before the United States Congress about PBS and cultural policy. He has appeared on C-SPAN's Washington Journal , CNN's Crossfire , ABC's Nightline , and the CBS Evening News , among other programs. His articles have appeared in scholarly and popular publications including The New York Times, The Boston Globe , The Los Angeles Times, American Film , Montage , and American Cinematographer . [1]

James Kurth, Claude Smith Professor of Political Science at Swarthmore College, co-produced this film.

In 2017 he was interviewed in Agustin Blazquez's documentary film THE TRUMP EFFECT: Deprogramming the American Mind [2]

Reception

Who Shall Live and Who Shall Die was the first documentary to examine America's roles during the Holocaust. The documentary received positive reviews from major publications. The Los Angeles Times called it, "a devastating political story," [3] and the New York Times said the, "unadorned" film tells a story not to be proud of. [4]

See also

Other documentaries about the Holocaust:

Notes

  1. 1 2 "Who Shall Live and Who Shall Die". Geocities. Archived from the original on October 20, 2009. Retrieved August 23, 2007.{{cite web}}: CS1 maint: unfit URL (link)
  2. "https://www.imdb.com/title/tt7277556/
  3. "Who Shall Live and Who Shall Die". Kino International. Retrieved August 23, 2007.
  4. Canby, Vincent (April 19, 1982). "American Roles During the Holocaust". New York Times. Retrieved August 23, 2007.

Related Research Articles

<i>Shoah</i> (film) 1985 French documentary film about the Holocaust

Shoah is a 1985 French documentary film about the Holocaust, directed by Claude Lanzmann. Over nine hours long and 11 years in the making, the film presents Lanzmann's interviews with survivors, witnesses and perpetrators during visits to German Holocaust sites across Poland, including extermination camps.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Jan Karski</span> Polish World War II resistance movement fighter

Jan Karski was a Polish soldier, resistance-fighter, and diplomat during World War II. He is known for having acted as a courier in 1940–1943 to the Polish government-in-exile and to Poland's Western Allies about the situation in German-occupied Poland. He reported about the state of Poland, its many competing resistance factions, and also about Germany's destruction of the Warsaw Ghetto and its operation of extermination camps on Polish soil that were murdering Jews, Poles, and others.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Stephen Samuel Wise</span> Hungarian-American Reform rabbi (1874–1949)

Stephen Samuel Wise was an early 20th-century American Reform rabbi and Zionist leader in the Progressive Era. Born in Budapest, he was an infant when his family immigrated to New York. He followed his father and grandfather in becoming a rabbi, serving in New York and in Portland, Oregon. Wise was also a founding member of the NAACP.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Bibliography of the Holocaust</span>

This is a selected bibliography and other resources for The Holocaust, including prominent primary sources, historical studies, notable survivor accounts and autobiographies, as well as other documentation and further hypotheses.

<i>The Eternal Jew</i> (film) 1940 antisemitic Nazi propaganda film

The Eternal Jew is a 1940 antisemitic Nazi propaganda film, presented as a documentary. The film's initial German title was Der ewige Jude, the German term for the character of the "Wandering Jew" in medieval folklore. The film was directed by Fritz Hippler at the insistence of Nazi Germany's Minister of Propaganda, Joseph Goebbels.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Yonassan Gershom</span> American rabbi and author

Yonassan Gershom is a Rabbi and writer who was ordained in the Jewish Renewal movement during the 1980s, and is now a follower of Breslov Hasidism. He was associated with the early days of the B'nai Or movement, a forerunner of Jewish Renewal, in which he was ordained by Rabbi Zalman Schachter-Shalomi in 1986, although he is not in agreement with the direction that the movement has taken in more recent years.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Hillel Kook</span> Revisionist Zionist activist and Israeli politician

Hillel Kook, also known as Peter Bergson, was a Revisionist Zionist activist and politician.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Priest's Grotto</span>

Priest's Grotto is a cave in western Ukraine near the village of Strilkivtsi, located within Chortkiv Raion (District) of Ternopil Oblast (Province).

<span class="mw-page-title-main">International response to the Holocaust</span> Aftermath and reaction to the Holocaust by national governments and international bodies

In the decades since the Holocaust, some national governments, international bodies and world leaders have been criticized for their failure to take appropriate action to save the millions of European Jews, Roma, and other victims of the Holocaust. Critics say that such intervention, particularly by the Allied governments, might have saved substantial numbers of people and could have been accomplished without the diversion of significant resources from the war effort.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Steven Pressman</span>

Steven Pressman is an American documentary filmmaker, journalist, author of two books, and director/producer of the documentary film 50 Children: The Rescue Mission of Mr. and Mrs. Kraus.

The Abandonment of the Jews: America and the Holocaust 1941–1945 is a 1984 nonfiction book by David S. Wyman, former Josiah DuBois professor of history at the University of Massachusetts Amherst. Wyman was the chairman of the David S. Wyman Institute for Holocaust Studies. The Abandonment of the Jews has been well received by most historians, and has won numerous prizes and widespread recognition, including a National Jewish Book Award, the Anisfield-Wolf Award, the Present Tense Literary Award, the Stuart Bernath Prize from the Society for Historians of American Foreign Relations, and the Theodore Saloutos Award of the Immigration History Society, and was nominated for the National Book Critics Circle Award."

The War Refugee Board, established by President Franklin D. Roosevelt in January 1944, was a U.S. executive agency to aid civilian victims of the Axis powers. The Board was, in the words of historian Rebecca Erbelding, "the only time in American history that the US government founded a non-military government agency to save the lives of civilians being murdered by a wartime enemy."

The Story of Chaim Rumkowski and the Jews of Łódź is a 1982 documentary film that uses archival film footage and photographs to narrate the story of one of the Holocaust's most controversial figures, Chaim Rumkowski, a Jew put in charge of the Łódź ghetto by the German occupation authorities during World War II.

<i>From Swastika to Jim Crow</i> 2000 American film

From Swastika to Jim Crow is a 2000 documentary that explores the similarities between Nazism in Germany and racism in the American south. In 1939, the Nazi government expelled Jewish scholars from German universities. Many of them found teaching positions in Southern universities, where they sympathized with the plight of their African-American colleagues and students.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Rafael Medoff</span> American scholar and academic

Rafael Medoff (born c. 1959) is an American professor of Jewish history and the founding director of The David Wyman Institute for Holocaust Studies, which is based in Washington, D.C. and focuses on issues related to America's response to the Holocaust.

<i>Imaginary Witness</i> 2004 American film

Imaginary Witness: Hollywood and the Holocaust is a 2004 documentary film directed by Daniel Anker and narrated by Gene Hackman that examines the treatment of the Holocaust in Hollywood films over a period of sixty years and the impact of the films on public perception and thinking, and vice versa. The film was originally produced for the American cable network, American Movie Classics.

Pierre Sauvage is a French-American documentary filmmaker and lecturer, who was a child survivor of the Holocaust as well as a child of Holocaust survivors. Described by Tablet Magazine as "a filmmaker of rare moral perception,"

German Concentration Camps Factual Survey is the official British documentary film on the Nazi concentration camps, based on footage shot by the Allied forces in 1945.

Moriah Films is the Jack and Pearl Resnick Film Division of the Simon Wiesenthal Center.

<i>The U.S. and the Holocaust</i> American documentary television series

The U.S. and the Holocaust is a 2022 three-part documentary miniseries about the United States' response to the Holocaust. The series was directed by Ken Burns, Lynn Novick, and Sarah Botstein, and was written by frequent Burns collaborator Geoffrey C. Ward.

References

The Auschwitz Tattoo in Visual Memory at https://film-history.org/node/1169