Williams v. Vidmar

Last updated
Williams v. Vidmar
US DC NorCal.svg
Court United States District Court for the Northern District of California
Full case nameStephen J. Williams v. Patricia Vidmar, et al.
DecidedApril 28, 2005
Docket nos. 5:04-cv-04946
Citation(s)367 F. Supp. 2d 1265
Court membership
Judge(s) sitting James Ware

Williams v. Vidmar, 367 F. Supp. 2d 1265 (N.D. Cal. 2005), was a lawsuit filed in federal court on November 22, 2004. It alleged that Patricia Vidmar, the then Principal of Stevens Creek Elementary School in Cupertino, California, was interfering with the first amendment rights of Stephen Williams, a fifth-grade teacher at Stevens Creek Elementary School. The lawsuit also named the board members of the Cupertino Union School District as defendants.

In the weeks before the lawsuit, parents of students at the school had been complaining to Vidmar about Williams, who described himself as an "Orthodox Christian," handing out religiously-themed pamphlets in his classes. Vidmar, herself a Christian Republican, began to screen Williams's handouts.

The lawsuit was handled for Williams by the Alliance Defense Fund (ADF), an Arizona-based legal group whose mission was to defend "the right to hear and speak the Truth through strategy, training, funding and litigation" in response to "challenges to people of faith to live and proclaim the Gospel." In 2003, the ADF received $16,474,818 from donors, more than covering their $2,003,654 in General and Administrative expenses. Since 2001, the ADF has been targeting public schools with lawsuits. As Mike Johnson of the ADF told the Baptist Press News (12/20/04), "The school ground is the battleground now in the culture war when it comes to religious expression. Teachers are in the crosshairs." [1]

The ADF issued a press release titled "Declaration of Independence Banned from Classroom," a title that caused considerable controversy and some outrage among listeners to various news outlets. This press release was especially publicized by various Fox News Network shows, [2] and resulted in over a thousand hostile messages being sent to the school, some containing threats. The effects on the community were chronicled by an article in the New Yorker. [3]

On April 28, 2005, Judge James Ware dismissed all but one of the charges in the lawsuit. [4]

On August 11, 2005, the lawsuit was settled. Under the settlement, filed in federal court in San Jose, no money would exchange hands, and no school policies would be altered. The parties agreed not to file future claims based on the complaint.[ citation needed ]

Williams resigned from the school at the end of the 2004-2005 school year. [5]

Related Research Articles

Edwards v. Aguillard, 482 U.S. 578 (1987), was a United States Supreme Court case concerning the constitutionality of teaching creationism. The Court considered a Louisiana law requiring that where evolutionary science was taught in public schools, creation science must also be taught. The constitutionality of the law was successfully challenged in District Court, Aguillard v. Treen, 634 F. Supp. 426, and the United States Court of Appeals for the Fifth Circuit affirmed, Aguillard v. Edwards, 765 F.2d 1251. The United States Supreme Court ruled that this law violated the Establishment Clause of the First Amendment because the law was specifically intended to advance a particular religion. In its decision, the court opined that "teaching a variety of scientific theories about the origins of humankind to school children might be validly done with the clear secular intent of enhancing the effectiveness of science instruction."

Cupertino, California City in California, United States

Cupertino is a city in Santa Clara County, California, United States, directly west of San Jose on the western edge of the Santa Clara Valley with portions extending into the foothills of the Santa Cruz Mountains. The population was 57,820 as of the 2020 census. It is known for being the home of Apple Inc., headquartered at Apple Park.

Alliance Defending Freedom is an American conservative Christian legal advocacy group. ADF is headquartered in Scottsdale, Arizona. It also has branch offices in Folsom, California; Washington, D.C.; Lawrenceville, Georgia; and New York. Its global arm, Alliance Defending Freedom International, is headquartered in Vienna, Austria.

The Cupertino Union School District is a school district in Santa Clara County, California. CUSD's jurisdiction covers the communities of Cupertino, San Jose, Sunnyvale, Santa Clara, Saratoga, and Los Altos. CUSD operates nineteen elementary schools (K-5) and five middle schools (6-8), and one (K-8) school. It is a feeder for the Fremont Union High School District.

Thomas More Law Center Christian, conservative, nonprofit, public interest law firm in Ann Arbor, Michigan, US

The Thomas More Law Center is a Christian, conservative, nonprofit, public interest law firm based in Ann Arbor, Michigan, and active throughout the United States. According to its website, its goals are to "preserve America's Judeo-Christian heritage, defend the religious freedom of Christians, restore time-honored moral and family values, protect the sanctity of human life, and promote a strong national defense and a free and sovereign United States of America."

School District 36 Surrey operates schools in Surrey, White Rock, and Barnston Island, British Columbia. It is the largest school district in British Columbia with 71,838 students during the 2016/2017 school year. District 36 includes 101 elementary schools, 26 secondary schools, and 5 learning centres. The first school in Surrey opened in 1882. The district is Surrey’s largest employer with 10,989 employees including 6,063 teachers.

The Spiritual Counterfeits Project is a Christian evangelical parachurch organization located in Berkeley, California. Since its inception in the early 1970s, it has been involved in the fields of Christian apologetics and the Christian countercult movement. Its current president is Dr. Mark J Harris. In its role as a think tank, SCP has sought to publish evangelically based analyses of new religious movements, New Age movements, and alternative spiritualities in light of broad cultural trends. SCP has also been at the center of two controversial US lawsuits, one involving church-state issues and the other being a religious defamation case.

People for Legal and Non-Sectarian Schools (PLANS) is an organization based in California in the United States which campaigns against the public funding of Waldorf methods charter schools alleging they violate the United States Constitution's separation of church and state. The group claims independent Waldorf schools and public Waldorf methods charter schools teach anthroposophical content, that this content is religious in nature, and that the schools disguise the anthroposophical content from the public. PLANS filed federal suit in 1998 against two California public school districts, Sacramento City Unified School District and Twin Ridges Elementary School District, to halt the Waldorf methods educational programs implemented in two of their schools. The case was ultimately dismissed on its merits in 2012.

The National Council on Bible Curriculum in Public Schools (NCBCPS) is a conservative nonprofit organization that promotes the use of its 300-page Bible curriculum, The Bible in History and Literature, in public schools throughout the United States.

Association of Christian Schools International v. Stearns, 678 F. Supp. 2d 980, was filed in spring 2006 by Association of Christian Schools International against the University of California claiming religious discrimination over the rejection of five courses as college preparatory instruction. On August 8, 2008, Judge S. James Otero entered summary judgment against plaintiff ACSI, upholding the University of California's standards.

Bossier Parish School Board is a school district headquartered in Benton, Louisiana, United States. The Superintendent of Bossier Schools is, as of 2009, D.C. Machen. The district serves Bossier Parish.

Excel Christian School Private Christian school in Sparks, Nevada, United States

Excel Christian School is an accredited private Pre-K through grade 12 Christian school in Sparks, Nevada, founded in 2003 as a non-profit organization. The school mascot is the Warriors, and the school colors are red and black.

In the United States, the Day of Dialogue is the Christian fundamentalist group Focus on the Family's annual event to oppose LGBTQ rights. It was previously known as the Day of Truth and was founded by the Alliance Defense Fund in 2005 in opposition to the Gay, Lesbian & Straight Education Network's Day of Silence which protests the harassment and bullying of LGBTQ students. Since 2018 the event is no longer marked on a single date, or organized nationally.

Pacific Justice Institute

The Pacific Justice Institute (PJI) is an anti-LGBT conservative legal defense organization and based in California, United States, founded by attorney Brad Dacus. The organization describes itself as focusing on representation relating to "...religious freedom, parental rights, and other civil liberties." It was declared an anti-LGBT hate group in 2014 by the Southern Poverty Law Center due to the group's long history of anti-LGBT rhetoric through its founder.

Robert J. Muise is an American attorney who specializes in constitutional law litigation. Along with attorney David Yerushalmi, he is co-founder and Senior Counsel of the American Freedom Law Center (AFLC), a national nonprofit law firm whose stated mission is "to fight for faith and freedom by advancing and defending America's Judeo-Christian heritage and moral foundation through litigation, education, and public policy programs." Before launching AFLC, Muise was Senior Trial Counsel at the Ann Arbor-based Thomas More Law Center, a conservative Christian law firm founded by Domino's Pizza founder Tom Monaghan.

Karen Pence Former Second Lady of the United States and former First Lady of Indiana

Karen Sue Pence is an American schoolteacher, painter, and was the second lady of the United States from 2017 to 2021. She is married to the 48th vice president of the United States, Mike Pence. She was the first lady of Indiana from January 14, 2013, to January 9, 2017.

Our Lady of Guadalupe School v. Morrissey-Berru, 591 U.S. ___ (2020), was a United States Supreme Court case involving the ministerial exception of federal employment discrimination laws. The case extends from the Supreme Court's prior decision in Hosanna-Tabor Evangelical Lutheran Church & School v. Equal Employment Opportunity Commission which created the ministerial exception based on the Establishment and Free Exercise Clauses of the United States Constitution, asserting that federal discrimination laws cannot be applied to leaders of religious organizations. The case, along with the consolidated St. James School v. Biel, both arose from rulings in the United States Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit that found that federal discrimination laws do apply to others within a religious organization that serve an important religious function but lack the title or training to be considered a religious leader under Hosanna-Tabor. The religious organization challenged that ruling on the basis of Hosanna-Tabor. The Supreme Court ruled in a 7–2 decision on July 8, 2020 that reversed the Ninth Circuit's ruling, affirming that the principles of Hosanna-Tabor, that a person can be serving an important religious function even if not holding the title or training of a religious leader, satisfied the ministerial exception in employment discrimination.

Uzuegbunam v. Preczewski, 592 U.S. ___ (2021), is a decision by the Supreme Court of the United States, dealing with nominal damages to be awarded to individuals whose right to freedom of speech has been suppressed by an entity but subsequently rendered moot due to intervening circumstances. In an 8–1 decision, the Court held that such nominal damages satisfy the Article Three requirement of redressability, when awarded for a past violation of a legal rights.

Havasupai Elementary School Bureau of Indian Education (BIE) school in Supai, Arizona

Havasupai Elementary School is a Bureau of Indian Education (BIE)-operated K–6 school in Supai, Arizona. It serves the Havasupai Indian Reservation.

References

  1. "AASA | American Association of School Administrators".
  2. "FOX peddles false report that California school "banned Declaration of Independence because it mentions God"".
  3. Peter J. Boyer, "Jesus in the classroom: parents loved Cupertino's schools, then a teacher said he was being discriminated against as a Christian", The New Yorker, March 21, 2005, p. 62.
  4. Williams v. Vidmar, 367F. Supp. 2d1265 ( N.D. Cal. 2005).
  5. Herel, Suzanne (17 August 2005). "Teacher resigns after settling dispute over religious material". SF Gate. Retrieved 13 November 2015.