Plot
At the Hilltop Colony, Rick re-reads his letter from his deceased son, Carl, urging Rick to end the war with Negan, start over and help to rebuild a peaceful society.
Inside the Sanctuary, Gregory tries to make amends with Simon, who has taken over the Saviors after claiming that Negan is dead. Gregory insists he can help resecure the other communities, but Simon puts him to work instead.
In the woods, outside the Oceanside community, Cyndie and the other residents shun Aaron's attempts to protect their community, despite him starving and dehydrating himself. After barely surviving a walker attack, Cyndie and the others find an exhausted Aaron begging them to join the fight against the Saviors as they would otherwise continue to be fearful of the outside world.
Meanwhile, Eugene oversees the workers making ammunition for the Saviors and is forced to dismiss an ill Gabriel, who has purposely tampered with the bullets to make them ineffectual. As Eugene heads out with guards, the guards are quickly dispatched by Daryl and Rosita. They take Eugene captive, planning to keep him locked up to be able to use his intellect. While Daryl dispatches approaching walkers, Eugene is able to induce himself to vomit over Rosita; Eugene escapes.
Outside the Sanctuary, Dwight, still hiding his alliance with the Militia, is surprised to see Negan, who had returned the night before. Dwight begins to explain what happened, but Negan is unconcerned and only reminds him about his loyalty to the Saviors. Later, Negan gathers his lieutenants for a meeting where Simon apologizes for the Hilltop disaster; Negan then reminds Simon that he also orchestrated the killing of all the men and boys from Oceanside, something that made Negan keep an eye on Simon from then on. Simon is forced to get on his knees, but then Negan declares Simon forgiven and instructs his lieutenants to set up sniper nests all around the Hilltop to contain the residents in order to win a war of attrition. Shortly after the meeting, Negan again commends Dwight for staying true to the goal of the Saviors. In his apartment, Dwight marks up a map for Rick and writes a message describing Negan's attack plan. Simon, anxious from the meeting, stops by and urges Dwight to help him overthrow Negan; Dwight agrees to meet with Simon to plan the coup sometime later.
In the courtyard, Dwight meets with Simon, who also brings Gregory and several other Saviors who would like to see Negan eliminated. Simon explains his plan for Negan's downfall and offers Dwight the opportunity to kill Negan first hand, but Dwight unexpectedly whistles. Negan—having been tipped off by Dwight—whistles in response and emerges from his hiding place. All of the conspirators—except Simon and Gregory—are suddenly shot and executed by a group of hidden, loyal Saviors. Negan then angrily reprimands Simon for the massacre of the Scavengers and going against his orders. Despite this and his backstabbing, Negan offers Simon a chance of leadership of the Saviors by fighting to the death. In the Sanctuary, with all the Saviors and workers gathered, Negan and Simon engage in a furious and brutal fist fight. Simon initially gets the upper hand before Negan eventually overpowers him, beating Simon to the floor. Dwight uses the opportunity to pull Gregory aside, hand him the map to deliver to Rick, and direct him to a vehicle he previously prepared for a quick escape; Gregory runs off. Negan, hovering over Simon, strangles his right-hand man to death, all the while furiously berating Simon for ruining what chance they had left of making peace with the communities and asserting that he'll now have to kill them all. He then gives one final squeeze that crushes Simon's windpipe, killing him. Afterwards, Gregory returns to Hilltop with the plans, but is thrown back in prison by Maggie, who then gives Dwight's map to Rick.
Walking Dwight back to his room, Negan offers Dwight to be his new right-hand man; Dwight accepts. However, inside Dwight's room, Negan reveals who he picked up on his way back to the Sanctuary—Laura, a high-ranking Savior that witnessed Dwight's treachery during the night of the attack on Alexandria. Having learned of Dwight's betrayal, Negan deduces that Dwight was responsible for many of Rick's attacks on the Savior outposts and explains that the map Dwight secretly conveyed to Rick will lead the Militia right into the Saviors' line of fire, saying the plan was fake. He then tells Dwight that he won't kill him, but rather has plans for him. Later, Eugene returns to the ammunition factory, more resolved to make sure to meet Negan's requirements for bullets.
After having a freshly turned Simon chained to the Sanctuary fence, Negan is contacted by Michonne over walkie-talkie; she reads Carl's letter to him, again reiterating his same request to end the war peacefully and start over. However, Negan refuses and states that Rick pushed him too far and that forgiveness is out of the question, vowing to kill her, Rick and the entire Militia. He finishes by saying "no more talk" before crushing the walkie-talkie with his foot.
