1936 Spanish general election

Last updated

1936 Spanish general election
Flag of Spain (1931-1939).svg
  1933 16 February 1936 (first round)
4 March 1936 (second round)
3 May 1936 (second round, partial re-run)
1967  

All 473 seats of the Congress of Deputies
237 seats needed for a majority
Turnout72.95%
 First partySecond partyThird party
  Indalecio Prieto, 1936 (cropped).jpg Jose Maria Gil-Robles (cropped).jpg Manuel Azana, 1933.jpg
Leader Indalecio Prieto José María Gil-Robles Manuel Azaña
Party PSOE CEDA IR
Leader since19354 March 19333 April 1934
Leader's seat Vizcaya-capital Salamanca Madrid-capital
Last election59 seats115 seats14 seats [nb 1]
Seats won998887
Seat changeIncrease2.svg40Decrease2.svg27Increase2.svg73

 Fourth partyFifth partySixth party
  Diego Martinez Barrio.jpg Lluis Companys i Jover.jpg Portela1935.jpg
Leader Diego Martínez Barrio Lluís Companys Manuel Portela
Party Republican Union Republican Left of Catalonia Party of the Democratic Centre
Leader since193419321936
Leader's seat Madrid-province Barcelona-capital Pontevedra
Last electionN/A17N/A
Seats won372117
Seat changeIncrease2.svg37Increase2.svg4Increase2.svg17

1936 Spanish general election - Results.svg
1936 Spanish general election - Detailed Results.svg

Prime Minister before election

Manuel Portela Valladares (acting)
PCD

Prime Minister after election

Manuel Azaña
IR

Legislative elections were held in Spain on 16 February 1936. At stake were all 473 seats in the unicameral Cortes Generales. The winners of the 1936 elections were the Popular Front, a left-wing coalition of the Spanish Socialist Workers' Party (PSOE), Republican Left (Spain) (IR), Esquerra Republicana de Catalunya (ERC), Republican Union (UR), Communist Party of Spain (PCE), Acció Catalana (AC), and other parties. Their coalition commanded a narrow lead over the divided opposition in terms of the popular vote, but a significant lead over the main opposition party, Spanish Confederation of the Autonomous Right (CEDA), in terms of seats. The election had been prompted by a collapse of a government led by Alejandro Lerroux, and his Radical Republican Party. Manuel Azaña would replace Manuel Portela Valladares, caretaker, as prime minister.

Contents

The electoral process and the accuracy of the results have been historically disputed. Some of the causes of this controversy include the formation of a new cabinet before the results were clear, a lack of reliable electoral data, and the overestimation of election fraud in the official narrative that justified the coup d'état. [1] [2] [3] [4] The topic has been addressed in seminal studies by renowned authors such as Javier Tusell and Stanley G. Payne. [5] [6] A series of recent works has shifted the focus from the legitimacy of the election and the government to an analysis of the extent of irregularities. [7] [8] Whilst one of them suggests that the impact of fraud was higher than previously estimated when including new election datasets, the other disputes their relevance in the election result. [7] [8]

The elections were the last of three legislative elections held during the Spanish Second Republic, coming three years after the 1933 general election which had brought the first of Lerroux's governments to power. The uncontested victory of the political left in the elections of 1936 triggered a wave of collectivisation, mainly in the south and west of the Iberian Peninsula, engaging up to three million people, [9] which has been identified as a key cause of the July coup. [10] The right-wing military coup initiated by Gens. Sanjurjo and Franco, the ensuing civil war, and the establishment of Franco's dictatorship ultimately brought about the end of parliamentary democracy in Spain until the 1977 general election.

Background

After the 1933 election, the Radical Republican Party (RRP) led a series of governments, with Alejandro Lerroux as a moderate Prime Minister. On 26 September 1934, the CEDA announced it would no longer support the RRP's minority government, which was replaced by a RRP cabinet, led by Lerroux once more, that included three members of the CEDA. [11] The concession of posts to CEDA prompted the Asturian miners' strike of 1934, which turned into an armed rebellion. [12] Some time later, Robles once again prompted a cabinet collapse, and five ministries of Lerroux's new government were conceded to CEDA, including Robles himself. [13] Since the 1933 elections, farm workers' wages had been halved, and the military purged of republican members and reformed; those loyal to Robles had been promoted. [14] However, since CEDA's entry into the government, no constitutional amendments were ever made; no budget was ever passed. [13]

In 1935, Manuel Azaña Díaz and Indalecio Prieto worked to unify the left and combat its extreme elements in what would become the Popular Front; this included staging of large, popular rallies,. [14] Lerroux's Radical government collapsed after two significant scandals, the Straperlo and the Nombela affairs. However, president Niceto Alcalá Zamora did not allow the CEDA to form a government, and called elections. [15] Zamora had become disenchanted with Robles's obvious desire to do away with the republic and establish a corporate state, and his air of pride. He was looking to strengthen a new center party in place of the Radicals, but the election system did not favour this. [16] Manuel Portela Valladares was thus chosen to form a caretaker government in the meantime. The Republic had, as its opponents pointed out, faced twenty-six separate government crises. [17] Portela failed to get the required support in the parliament to rule as a majority. [18] The government was dissolved on 4 January; the date for elections would be 16 February. [17]

As in the 1933 election, Spain was divided into multi-member constituencies; for example, Madrid was a single district electing 17 representatives. However, a voter could vote for fewer than that – in Madrid's case, 13. This favoured coalitions, as in Madrid in 1933 when the Socialists won 13 seats, and the right, with just 5,000 votes fewer, secured only the remaining four. [19]

Election

electoral districts in proportion to number of mandates available, from Barcelona city (20) to Ceuta and Melilla (1 each) Spain, electoral districts 1933-1936.jpg
electoral districts in proportion to number of mandates available, from Barcelona city (20) to Ceuta and Melilla (1 each)

Vatican Fascism offered you work and brought hunger; it offered you peace and brought five thousands tombs; it offered you order and raised a gallows. The Popular Front offers no more and no less than it will bring: Bread, Peace and Liberty!

One election poster. [20]

There was significant violence during the election campaign, most of which initiated by the political left, though a substantial minority was by the political right.[ citation needed ] In total, some thirty-seven people were killed in various incidents throughout the campaign, ten of which occurred on the election day itself. [21] [22] Certain press restrictions were lifted. The political right repeatedly warned of the risk of a 'red flag' – communism – over Spain; the Radical Republican Party, led by Lerroux, concentrated on besmirching the Centre Party. [20] CEDA, which continued to be the main party of the political right, struggled to gain the support of the monarchists, but managed to. Posters, however, had a distinctly fascist appeal, showing leader Gil-Robles alongside various autocratic slogans and he allowed his followers to acclaim him with cries of "Jefe!" (Spanish for "Chief!") in an imitation of "Duce!" or "Führer!". [23] [24] Whilst few campaign promises were made, a return to autocratic government was implied. [23] Funded by considerable donations from large landowners, industrialists and the Catholic Church – which had suffered under the previous Socialist administration – the Right printed millions of leaflets, promising a 'great Spain'. [25] In terms of manifesto, the Popular Front proposed going back to the sort of reforms its previous administration had advocated, including important agrarian reforms, and reforms relating to strikes. [20] It would also release political prisoners, including those from the Asturian rebellion (though this provoked the right), [24] helping to secure the votes of the CNT and FAI, although as organisations they remained outside the growing Popular Front; [26] the Popular Front had the support of votes from anarchists. [27] The Communist Party campaigned under a series of revolutionary slogans; however, they were strongly supportive of the Popular Front government. "Vote Communist to save Spain from Marxism" was a Socialist joke at the time. [28] Devoid of strong areas of working class support, already taken by syndicalism and anarchism, they concentrated on their position within the Popular Front. [28] The election campaign was heated; the possibility of compromise had been destroyed by the left's Asturian rebellion and its cruel repression by the security forces. Both sides used apocalyptic language, declaring that if the other side won, civil war would follow. [24]

34,000 members of the Civil Guards and 17,000 Assault Guards enforced security on election day, many freed from their regular posts by the carabineros. [20] The balloting on 16 February ended with a draw between the left and right, with the center effectively obliterated. In six provinces left-wing groups apparently interfered with registrations or ballots, augmenting leftist results or invalidating rightist pluralities or majorities. [29] In Galicia, in north-west Spain, and orchestrated by the incumbent government; there also, in A Coruña, by the political left. The voting in Granada was forcibly (and unfairly) dominated by the government. [30] In some villages, the police stopped anyone not wearing a collar from voting. Wherever the Socialists were poorly organised, farm workers continued to vote how they were told by their bosses or caciques . Similarly, some right-wing voters were put off from voting in strongly socialist areas. [31] However, such instances were comparatively rare. [32] By the evening, it looked like the Popular Front might win and as a result in some cases crowds broke into prisons to free revolutionaries detained there. [27] [29]

Outcome

first round. RED: Popular Front at least 5% more votes than counter-revolutionary bloc, BLUE: the opposite, GREY: less than 5% difference or another list coming first Spanish general election map, 1936.png
first round. RED: Popular Front at least 5% more votes than counter-revolutionary bloc, BLUE: the opposite, GREY: less than 5% difference or another list coming first

Just under 10 million people voted, [27] with an abstention rate of 27-29 per cent, a level of apathy higher than might be suggested by the ongoing political violence. [33] [nb 2] A small number of coerced voters and anarchists formed part of the abstainers. [33] The elections of 1936 were narrowly won by the Popular Front, with vastly smaller resources than the political right, who followed Nazi propaganda techniques. [15] The exact numbers of votes differ among historians; Brenan assigns the Popular Front 4,700,000 votes, the Right around 4,000,000 and the centre 450,000, [34] while Antony Beevor argues the Left won by just 150,000 votes. [24] Stanley Payne reports that, of the 9,864,763 votes cast, the Popular Front and its allies won 4,654,116 votes (47.2%), while the right and its allies won 4,503,505 votes (45.7%), however this was heavily divided between the right and the centre-right. The remaining 526,615 votes (5.4%) were won by the centre and Basque nationalists. [35] It was a comparatively narrow victory in terms of votes, but Paul Preston describes it as a 'triumph of power in the Cortes' [36] – the Popular Front won 267 deputies and the Right only 132, and the imbalance caused by the nature of Spain's electoral system since the 1932 election law came into force. The same system had benefited the political right in 1933. [34] However, Stanley Payne argues that the leftist victory may not have been legitimate; Payne says that in the evening of the day of the elections leftist mobs started to interfere in the balloting and in the registration of votes distorting the results; Payne also argues that President Zamora appointed Manuel Azaña Díaz as head of the new government following the Popular Front's early victory even though the election process was incomplete. As a result, the Popular Front was able to register its own victory at the polls and Payne alleges it manipulated its victory to gain extra seats it should not have won. According to Payne, this augmented the Popular Front's victory into one that gave them control of over two-thirds of the seats, allowing it to amend the constitution as it desired. Payne thus argues that the democratic process had ceased to exist. [37] Roberto García and Manuel Tardío also argue that the Popular Front manipulated the results, [38] though this has been contested by Eduardo Calleja and Francisco Pérez, who question the charges of electoral irregularity and argue that the Popular Front would still have won a slight electoral majority even if all of the charges were true. [39]

The political centre did badly. Lerroux's Radicals, incumbent until his government's collapse, were electorally devastated; many of their supporters had been pushed to the right by the increasing instability in Spain. Portela Valladares had formed the Centre Party, but had not had time to build it up. [34] Worried about the problems of a minority party losing out due to the electoral system, he made a pact with the right, but this was not enough to ensure success. Leaders of the centre, Lerroux, Cambó and Melquíades Álvarez, failed to win seats. [34] The Falangist party, under José Antonio Primo de Rivera received only 46,000 votes, a very small fraction of the total cast. This seemed to show little appetite for a takeover of that sort. [40] The allocation of seats between coalition members was a matter of agreement between them. [41] The official results (Spanish : escrutinio) were recorded on 20 February. [27] The Basque Party, who had not at the time of the election been part of the Popular Front, would go on to join it. [32] In 20 seats, no alliance or party had secured 40% of the vote; 17 were decided by a second vote on 3 March. [42] In these runoffs, the Popular Front won 8, the Basques 5, the Right 5 and the Centre 2. [43] In May, elections were reheld in two areas of Granada where the new government alleged there had been fraud; both seats were taken from the national Right victory in February by the Left. [43]

Because, unusually, the first round produced an outright majority of deputies elected on a single list of campaign pledges, the results were treated as granting an unprecedented mandate to the winning coalition: some socialists took to the streets to free political prisoners, without waiting for the government to do so officially; similarly, the caretaker government quickly resigned on the grounds that waiting a month for the parliamentary resumption was now unnecessary. [44] In the thirty-six hours following the election, sixteen people were killed (mostly by police officers attempting to maintain order or intervene in violent clashes) and thirty-nine were seriously injured, while fifty churches and seventy conservative political centres were attacked or set ablaze. [45] Almost immediately after the results were known, a group of monarchists asked Robles to lead a coup but he refused. He did, however, ask prime minister Manuel Portela Valladares to declare a state of war before the revolutionary masses rushed into the streets. Franco also approached Valladares to propose the declaration of martial law and calling out of the army. It has been claimed that this was not a coup attempt but more of a "police action" akin to Asturias, [46] [24] [31] Valladares resigned, even before a new government could be formed. However, the Popular Front, which had proved an effective election tool, did not translate into a Popular Front government. [47] Largo Caballero and other elements of the political left were not prepared to work with the republicans, although they did agree to support much of the proposed reforms. Manuel Azaña Díaz was called upon to form a government, but would shortly replace Zamora as president. [47] The right reacted as if radical communists had taken control, despite the new cabinet's moderate composition, abandoned the parliamentary option and began to conspire as to how to best overthrow the republic, rather than taking control of it. [36] [24] The military coup in Spain was triggered by the so-called ‘Spanish Revolution’, a spontaneous popular wave of collectivisation and cooperativism, engaging up to three million people, which was ignited by the victory of the left in the general election of 1936, a wave described by historian James Woodcock as “the last and largest of the world's major anarchist movements”. [48]

First-round results

The below table summarises results of the first round, i.e. of the voting which took place on February 16. It does not take into account elections of the second round, which took place in 5 electoral districts (Álava, Castellón, Guipúzcoa, Soria, Vizcaya provincia) on March 1. It includes results in electoral districts (Cuenca, Granada), where results would be declared invalid, elections annulled and repeated in May.

The numbers given are votes, not voters. Each voter was entitled to vote for a number of candidates; the maximum number of selections allowed differed across the electoral districs, from 16 in Barcelona (city) to 1 in Álava, Ceuta and Melilla. All the selections made for individual candidates (there were 993 contestants running) are summarised. Example: Partido Republicano Federal fielded 3 candidates: Luis Cordero Bel on Frente Popular list in Huelva got 79.667 votes, Bernardino Valle Gracia on Frente Popular list in Las Palmas got 32.900 votes and José Bernal Segado running as independent in Murcia (city) got 1.329 votes, which produced sub-totals of 112.567 votes on Frente Popular lists and 1.329 votes for independents, which totals in 113.896 votes.

All tables purporting to present number of voters, which supported specific parties or blocs, are based on various statistical methodologies, constructed ex post by historians and intended to translate the number of votes into the number of voters; this applies also to tables presented in the section below. Their accuracy might be and is disputed. The below table is not based on any such data manipulations and summarises number of votes received by individual candidates as recorded by electoral authorities. [49]

partyFrente
Popular
35.514.447
CEDA-led alliances
32.977.932
Portela-led alliances
2.582.542
independents & own lists
1.772.687
TOTAL
SPAIN
72.847.608
Confederación Española de Derechas Autónomas155245586006715584625
Partido Socialista Obrero Español118278551518711843042
Izquierda Republicana935329118681564579546563
Unión Republicana415049187116192314256838
non-party candidates114239623109552025872562573912195
Esquerra Republicana de Catalunya37019393701939
Partido del Centro Democrático207243413855733458007
Lliga Regionalista27051522705152
Renovación Española2599381526892652070
Partido Republicano Radical20406149974799872521598
Partido Comunista de España22603672260367
Comunión Tradicionalista2120091628332182924
Partido Agrario Español19414314934301711261858699
Partido Republicano Progresista8684971376301006127
Partido Republicano Liberal-Demócrata90524476480191891000913
Acció Catalana Republicana896275896275
Unió Socialista de Catalunya718274718274
Partido Nacionalista Vasco431970431970
Partido Galleguista4266244991431615
Partido Republicano Conservador272674108170380844
Partido de Unión Republicana Autonomista311201311201
Partit Nacionalista Republicà d'Esquerra278111278111
Partit Català Proletari256880256880
Partido Obrero de Unificación Marxista256723256723
Partido Republicano Federal1125671329113896
Partido Sindicalista9766797667
Falange Española8293982939
Partido Nacionalista Español6490264902
Acción Nacionalista Vasca3498734987
Acción Católica Obrera265265

Final results

Detailed results by region. 1936 Spanish general election - Detailed Results.svg
Detailed results by region.
Summary of the popular vote in the 16 February and 4 March 1936 Congress of Deputies election results [50]
PartyAbbr.Voters%
Popular Front (Frente Popular)FP3,750,90039.63
Left Front (Front d’Esquerres) [nb 3] FE700,4007.40
Total Popular Front:4,451,30047.03
Spanish Confederation of Autonomous Right-wing Groups and right [nb 4] CEDA-RE1,709,20018.06
Spanish Confederation of Autonomous Right-wing Groups and Radical Republican Party [nb 5] CEDA-PRR943,4009.97
Spanish Confederation of Autonomous Right-wing Groups and centre [nb 6] CEDA-PCNR584,3006.17
Front Català d'Ordre - Lliga Catalana LR483,7005.11
Spanish Confederation of Autonomous Right-wing Groups and Progressive Republican Party [nb 7] CEDA-PRP307,5003.25
Spanish Confederation of Autonomous Right-wing Groups and Conservative Republican Party [nb 8] CEDA-PRC189,1002.00
Spanish Confederation of Autonomous Right-wing Groups and Liberal Democrat Republican Party [nb 9] CEDA-PRLD150,9001.59
Spanish Agrarian Party (Partido Agrario Español) [nb 10] PAE30,9000.33
Total National Bloc:4,375,80046.48
Party of the Democratic Centre (Partido del Centro Democrático)PCD333,2003.51
Basque Nationalist Party (Euzko Alderdi Jeltzalea-Partido Nacionalista Vasco)EAJ-PNV150,1001.59
Radical Republican Party (Partido Republicano Radical) [nb 11] PRR124,7001.32
Conservative Republican Party (Partido Republicano Conservador) [nb 12] PRC23,0000.24
Progressive Republican Party (Partido Republicano Progresista) [nb 13] PRP10,5000.11
Falange Española de las J.O.N.S. [nb 14] 6,8000.07
Total9,465,600100

Seats

Congreso de los Diputados de Espana 1936 (por coaliciones).svg Congreso de los Diputados de Espana 1936 (por partidos).svg
AffiliationPartyName in Spanish (* indicates Catalan, ** indicates Galician)Abbr.Seats (May)Seats (Feb)
UnknownPayne [33]
Popular Front
Spanish Socialist Workers' Party Partido Socialista Obrero EspañolPSOE
99 / 473
8988
Republican Left Izquierda RepublicanaIR
87 / 473
8079
Republican Union Unión RepublicanaUR
37 / 473
3634
Republican Left of Catalonia Esquerra Republicana de Catalunya*ERC
21 / 473
2122
Communist Party of Spain Partido Comunista de EspañaPCE
17 / 473
1514
Catalan Action ECAcció Catalana Republicana*ACR
5 / 473
55
Socialist Union of Catalonia ECUnió Socialista de Catalunya*USC
4 / 473
43
Galicianist Party IRPartido Galeguista**PG
3 / 473
33
Federal Democratic Republican Party Partido Republicano Democrático FederalPRD Fed.
2 / 473
22
Union of Rabassaires ECUnió de Rabassaires*UdR
2 / 473
22
National Left Republican Party ECPartit Nacionalista Republicà d'Esquerra*PNRE
2 / 473
21
Valencian Left ECEsquerra Valenciana*EV
1 / 473
11
Syndicalist Party Partido Sindicalista 
1 / 473
12
Independent Syndicalist PartyPartido Sindicalista IndependientePSI
1 / 473
1
Workers' Party of Marxist Unification Partido Obrero de Unificación MarxistaPOUM
1 / 473
11
Proletarian Catalan Party Partit Català Proletari*PCP
1 / 473
11
Independent Republicans (Leftist)Republicanos Independientes (de Izquierdas)
3 / 473
2
Socialist Independents (Payne: "Leftist independents")Socialista Independiente 
0 / 473
14
Total Popular Front:
286 / 473
[51]
267 [51] 263 [nb 15]
Centre & PNV Centre Republicans
Party of the Democratic Centre Partido del Centro DemocráticoPCD
17 / 473
2021
Progressive Republican Party R [n 1] Partido Republicano ProgresistaPRC
6 / 473
66
Radical Republican Party [n 2] Partido Republicano RadicalPRR
5 / 473
89
Conservative Republican Party RPartido Republicano ConservadorPRC
3 / 473
32
Liberal Democrat Republican Party BN [n 3] Partido Republicano Liberal DemócrataPRLD
2 / 473
11
Republican Independents [n 4] Republicanos Independientes 
4 / 473
3
PNV Group Basque Nationalist Party Partido Nacionalista VascoPNV
9 / 473
95
Basque Social-ChristianSocialcristiano Vasco
1 / 473
1
Total Centre & PNV Group:
46 / 473
6054
Right
Spanish Confederation of the Autonomous Right Confederación Española de Derechas AutónomasCEDA
88 / 473
97101
National Bloc Bloque Nacional (Renovación Española )RE
12 / 473
1313
Catalan League [n 5] Lliga Catalana*LC
12 / 473
1212
Spanish Agrarian Party Partido Agrario EspañolPAE
10 / 473
1111
Traditionalist Communion Comunión TradicionalistaCT
9 / 473
1215
Independent monarchistsMonárquicos Independientes 
2 / 473
2
Spanish Nationalist Party BNPartido Nacionalista EspañolPNE
2 / 473
11
Partido MesócrataMesocratic Party 
1 / 473
1
Mallorcan Regionalist PartyPartido Regionalista de MallorcaPRM
1 / 473
1
CatholicCatólico
1 / 473
11
Rightist IndependentsIndependientes de Derecha 
4 / 473
810
Total Right:
141 / 473
146156
Total: 473
Notes

R Joined the Republican parliamentary group together with the PCNR.
EC Joined the Esquerra Catalana parliamentary group together with ERC.
IR Joined the Izquierda Republicana parliamentary group with IR.
BN Joined the Bloque Nacional parliamentary group with RE.

  1. All 6 in Andalusia, where the party is running with the Right
  2. Four of them in constituencies in which they run with the Right
  3. The 2 of them in Oviedo, where they present with the Right.
  4. 3 elected on centre-right lists and 1 on his own. Includes former prime minister Chapaprieta, minister Villalobos, former radical deputy Pascual and Galician rep Cornide.
  5. Heads the Front Català d'Ordre

Related Research Articles

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Manuel Azaña</span> Spanish Republican; Prime Minister & President (1880–1940)

Manuel Azaña Díaz was a Spanish politician who served as Prime Minister of the Second Spanish Republic, organizer of the Popular Front in 1935 and the last President of the Republic (1936–1939). He was the most prominent leader of the Republican cause during the Spanish Civil War of 1936–1939.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Popular Front (Spain)</span> Left-wing political party in the Second Spanish Republic from 1936 to 1939

The Popular Front was an electoral alliance and pact formed in January 1936 to contest that year's general election by various left-wing political organizations during the Second Spanish Republic. The alliance was led by Manuel Azaña. In Catalonia and the modern-day Valencian Community, the coalition was known as the Front of the Lefts.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Falange Española de las JONS</span> Former political party in Spain

The Falange Española de las Juntas de Ofensiva Nacional Sindicalista was a fascist political party founded in Spain in 1934 as merger of the Falange Española and the Juntas de Ofensiva Nacional-Sindicalista. FE de las JONS, which became the main fascist group during the Second Spanish Republic, ceased to exist as such when, during the Civil War, General Francisco Franco merged it with the Traditionalist Communion in April 1937 to form the similarly named Falange Española Tradicionalista y de las JONS.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">CEDA</span> 1933–1937 political party in Spain

The Confederación Española de Derechas Autónomas was a Spanish political party in the Second Spanish Republic. A Catholic conservative force, it was the political heir to Ángel Herrera Oria's Acción Popular and defined itself in terms of the 'affirmation and defence of the principles of Christian civilization,' translating this theoretical stand into a political demand for the revision of the anti-Catholic passages of the republican constitution. CEDA saw itself as a defensive organisation, formed to protect religious toleration, family, and private property rights. José María Gil-Robles declared his intention to "give Spain a true unity, a new spirit, a totalitarian polity..." and went on to say "Democracy is not an end but a mean to achieve the conquest of the new state. When the time comes, either parliament submits or we will eliminate it." The CEDA held Fascist-style rallies, called Gil-Robles "Jefe", the Castillian Spanish equivalent to Duce, and sometimes debated whether CEDA might lead a "March on Madrid" to forcefully seize power.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Alejandro Lerroux</span> Spanish pro-Republican politician

Alejandro Lerroux García was a Spanish politician who was the leader of the Radical Republican Party. He served as Prime Minister three times from 1933 to 1935 and held several cabinet posts as well. A highly charismatic politician, he was distinguished by his demagogical and populist political style.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Labor Party (Mexico)</span> Mexican political party

The Labor Party is a political party in Mexico. It was founded on 8 December 1990. The party is currently led by Alberto Anaya.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Niceto Alcalá-Zamora</span> Spanish lawyer and politician (1877–1949)

Niceto Alcalá-Zamora y Torres was a Spanish lawyer and politician who served, briefly, as the first prime minister of the Second Spanish Republic, and then—from 1931 to 1936—as its president.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">José María Gil-Robles y Quiñones</span> Spanish fascist

José María Gil-Robles y Quiñones de León was a Spanish politician, leader of the CEDA and a prominent figure in the period leading up to the Spanish Civil War. He served as Minister of War from May to December 1935. In the 1936 elections the CEDA was defeated, and support for Gil-Robles and his party evaporated. Gil-Robles was unwilling to struggle with Francisco Franco for power and in April 1937 he announced the dissolution of CEDA, and went into exile. Abroad, he negotiated with Spanish monarchists to try to arrive at a common strategy for taking power in Spain. In 1968 he was named a professor of the University of Oviedo and published his book No fue posible la paz . He was a member of the International Tribunal at the Hague. After the death of Franco and the end of his regime, Gil-Robles became one of the leaders of the "Spanish Christian Democracy" party, which however failed to win support in the Spanish general elections in 1977.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Second Spanish Republic</span> Government of Spain, 1931–1939

The Spanish Republic, commonly known as the Second Spanish Republic, was the form of government in Spain from 1931 to 1939. The Republic was proclaimed on 14 April 1931 after the deposition of King Alfonso XIII. It was dissolved on 1 April 1939 after surrendering in the Spanish Civil War to the Nationalists led by General Francisco Franco.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Radical Republican Party</span> Political party in Spain

The Radical Republican Party, sometimes shortened to the Radical Party, was a Spanish Radical party in existence between 1908 and 1936. Beginning as a splinter from earlier Radical parties, it initially played a minor role in Spanish parliamentary life, before it came to prominence as one of the leading political forces of the Spanish Republic.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">1933 Spanish general election</span>

Elections to Spain's legislature, the Cortes Generales, were held on 19 November 1933 for all 473 seats in the unicameral Cortes of the Second Spanish Republic. Since the previous elections of 1931, a new constitution had been ratified, and the franchise extended to more than six million women. The governing Republican-Socialist coalition had fallen apart, with the Radical Republican Party beginning to support a newly united political right.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">1931 Spanish general election</span>

The 1931 Spanish general election for the Constituent Cortes was the first such election held in the Second Republic. It took place in several rounds.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Asturian miners' strike of 1934</span> October 1934 insurrection in Spain

The Asturian miners' strike of 1934 was a major strike action undertaken by miners in Asturias against the new CEDA-led government, from October 4-19. The strike and subsequent demonstrations eventually developed into a violent revolutionary uprising in an attempt to overthrow the conservative regime. The revolutionaries took over Asturias by force, killing many of the province's police and religious leaders. Armed with dynamite, rifles, and machine guns, they destroyed religious buildings, such as churches and convents. The rebels officially declared a Proletarian Revolution and instituted a local government in the territory. The rebellion was crushed by the Spanish Navy and the Spanish Republican Army, the latter using mainly colonial troops from Spanish Morocco.

The background of the Spanish Civil War dates back to the end of the 19th century, when the owners of large estates, called latifundios, held most of the power in a land-based oligarchy. The landowners' power was unsuccessfully challenged by the industrial and merchant sectors. In 1868 popular uprisings led to the overthrow of Queen Isabella II of the House of Bourbon. In 1873 Isabella's replacement, King Amadeo I of the House of Savoy, abdicated due to increasing political pressure, and the short-lived First Spanish Republic was proclaimed. After the restoration of the Bourbons in December 1874, Carlists and anarchists emerged in opposition to the monarchy. Alejandro Lerroux helped bring republicanism to the fore in Catalonia, where poverty was particularly acute. Growing resentment of conscription and of the military culminated in the Tragic Week in Barcelona in 1909. After the First World War, the working class, the industrial class, and the military united in hopes of removing the corrupt central government, but were unsuccessful. Fears of communism grew. A military coup brought Miguel Primo de Rivera to power in 1923, and he ran Spain as a military dictatorship. Support for his regime gradually faded, and he resigned in January 1930. There was little support for the monarchy in the major cities, and King Alfonso XIII abdicated; the Second Spanish Republic was formed, whose power would remain until the culmination of the Spanish Civil War. Monarchists would continue to oppose the Republic.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Catholicism in the Second Spanish Republic</span>

Catholicism in the Second Spanish Republic was an important area of dispute, and tensions between the Catholic hierarchy and the Republic were apparent from the beginning, eventually leading to the Catholic Church acting against the Republic and in collaboration with the dictatorship of Francisco Franco.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Events of 6 October</span> 1934 general strike, armed insurgency, and declaration of a Catalan state

The events of 6 October were a general strike, armed insurgency and declaration of a Catalan State by Catalonia's autonomous government on 6 October 1934, in reaction to the inclusion of conservatives in the republican regime of Spain. They took place as part of a nationwide strike and armed action known as the Revolution of 1934. Catalan President Lluís Companys declared the Catalan State at 8 p.m. Martial law was declared, and military forces attacked the Palau de la Generalitat de Catalunya and other buildings. Companys surrendered on the morning of 7 October.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Revolution of 1934</span> October 1934 series of revolutionary strikes in Spain

The Revolution of 1934, also known as the Revolution of October 1934 or the Revolutionary General Strike of 1934, was a revolutionary strike movement that took place between 5 and 19 October 1934, during the black biennium of the Second Spanish Republic. The revolts were triggered by the entry of the conservative Spanish Confederation of the Autonomous Right (CEDA) into the Spanish government. Most of the events occurred in Catalonia and Asturias and were supported by many Spanish Socialist Workers' Party (PSOE) and General Union of Workers (UGT) members, notably Largo Caballero, as well as members of the Confederación Nacional del Trabajo (CNT). Historians have argued that the incident sharpened antagonism between the political Right and Left in Spain and was part of the reason for the later Spanish Civil War. Around 2,000 people were killed during the uprising, which was repressed by Spanish government forces.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Artemio Precioso (writer)</span>

Artemio Precioso García was a Spanish writer, publisher and civil servant. He is known as the author of some 30 novels, published mostly in the 1920s and intended for popular audience. He contributed to numerous press titles and managed some usually ephemeral periodicals himself. Politically he was related to moderate left-wing republicanism; in 1934 he served as civil governor of the province of Toledo, and in 1934-1936 at the same post in Lugo.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Catalan State (1934)</span>

The Catalan State was a short-lived state proclaimed during the events of 6 October 1934 by Lluís Companys as the "Catalan State within the Spanish Federal Republic".

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Electoral Carlism (Second Republic)</span>

In terms of electoral success Carlism of the Second Spanish Republic remained a medium-small political grouping, by far outperformed by large parties like PSOE and CEDA though trailing behind also medium-large contenders like Izquierda Republicana. During three electoral campaigns to the Cortes combined the Carlists seized less than 50 seats, which is below 3% of all seats available. Disorganized during the 1931 elections, the Carlist candidates were a first-choice political option for some 50,000 voters; following re-organization in successive campaigns the number grew to 420,000 (1933) and 365,000 (1936), respectively 4.9% and 3.8% of active electors. In the mid-1930s as a second-choice option the Carlists were acceptable candidates for some 1.8m voters (18%). The movement enjoyed support mostly in the Northern belt of Spain; the party stronghold was Navarre, the only region where Carlism remained a dominating force; it was a minority group still to be reckoned with in Vascongadas, Old Castile and Aragón, with rather testimonial presence in some other regions. The best known Carlist Cortes personality was Tomás Domínguez de Arévalo, who held the mandate during all three Republican terms.

References

Notes

  1. compared to the results of the Republican Action (5 seats), the Galician Republican Party (6 seats) and the Independent Radical Socialist Republican Party (3 seats) in 1933, who merged to form IR in 1934
  2. exact figures as to the number of voters, the number of electors and the turnout differ. The number of voters is quoted as 9.864.783 (Stanley G. Payne, Spain’s First Democracy, Madison 1993, ISBN 9780299136703, p. 274), 9.729.454 (Albert Carreras, Xavier Tafunell (eds.), Estadísticas históricas de España, vol. I, Bilbao 2005, ISBN 849651501X, p. 1098), 9.687.108 (Manuel Álvarez Tardío, Roberto Villa García, 1936, fraude y violencia en las elecciones del Frente Popular, Barcelona 2017, ISBN 9788467049466, p. 412) or 9.572.908 (Juan J. Linz, Jesús de Miguel, Hacia un análisis regional de las elecciones de 1936 en España, [in:] Revista Española de la Opinion Pública 48 (1977), p. 34. Internet sources might provide even different figures, e.g. 9.792.700 (HistoriaElectoral website). The number of electors, e.g. Spaniards entitled to vote, is given as 13.578.056 (Álvarez Tardío, Villa García 2017, p. 412), 13.553.710 (Payne 1993, p. 274) or 13.338.262 (Carreras, Tafunell 2005, p. 1098). Accordingly, the turnout rate which emerges from these figures might be calculated as 72,97% (Carreras, Tafunell 2005, p. 1098), 72,78 (Payne 1993, p. 274) or 71,34% (Álvarez Tardío, Villa García 2017, p. 412).
  3. Running only in Catalonia
  4. Coalition of right-wing parties including CEDA in 30 constituencies
  5. Coalition of right-wing parties and the Radicals in 10 constituencies
  6. Coalition of right-wing parties and the centre in 6 constituencies
  7. Coalition of right-wing parties and the PRP in 4 constituencies in Andalusia
  8. Coalition of right-wing parties and the PRC in Lugo and A Coruña
  9. Running only in Oviedo
  10. Independent, separate Agrarian lists only in Burgos and Huelva
  11. Independent, separate Radical lists in Cáceres, Castellón, Ceuta, Málaga (prov.), Ourense, Santander, Tenerife, Las Palmas and Córdoba
  12. Running only in Soria
  13. Running only in Ciudad Real
  14. Running only in Oviedo, Sevilla, Toledo and Valladolid
  15. Payne (2006) gives a total of 262.

Citations

  1. "Revista de Libros: «Las elecciones generales de febrero de 1936: una reconsideración historiográfica» de Enrique Moradiellos". www.revistadelibros.com (in Spanish). 11 September 2017. Retrieved 2021-07-05.
  2. Arrarás Iribarren, Joaquín (1964). Historia de la Segunda República Española. Madrid: Editora Nacional.
  3. Gobernación, Espana Ministerio de la (1939). Dictamen de la Comisión sobre ilegitimidad de poderes actuantes en 18 de Julio de 1936 (Report). Editora Nacional.
  4. Bécarud, Jean (1967). La Segunda República Española. Madrid: Taurus.
  5. Tusell, Javier (1971). Las elecciones del Frente Popular. Madrid: Edicusa.
  6. Payne, Stanley G. (2019). La revolución española (1936-1939) : un estudio sobre la singularidad de la Guerra Civil. Barcelona. ISBN   978-84-670-5533-7. OCLC   1100348435.{{cite book}}: CS1 maint: location missing publisher (link)
  7. 1 2 Álvarez Tardío, Manuel (2017). 1936, fraude y violencia en las elecciones del Frente Popular. Roberto Villa García. Barcelona. ISBN   978-84-670-4946-6. OCLC   976020486.{{cite book}}: CS1 maint: location missing publisher (link)
  8. 1 2 González Calleja, Eduardo; Sánchez Pérez, Francisco (2018-10-01). "Revisando el revisionismo. A propósito del libro 1936. Fraude y violencia en las elecciones del Frente Popular". Historia Contemporánea. 3 (58): 851–881. doi: 10.1387/hc.19831 . hdl: 10810/38374 . ISSN   2340-0277. S2CID   240078416.
  9. Gaston Leval, Social Reconstruction in Spain, London, 1938. Discussed in Woodcock, p. 373.
  10. see James Woodcock, Anarchism (1960), London: Penguin, 1970, pp. 365–375.
  11. Thomas (1961). p. 78.
  12. Thomas (1961). p. 80.
  13. 1 2 Thomas (1961). p. 88.
  14. 1 2 Preston (2006). p. 81.
  15. 1 2 Preston (2006). pp. 82–83.
  16. Brenan (1950). p. 294.
  17. 1 2 Thomas (1961). p. 89.
  18. Brenan (1950). pp. 294–295.
  19. Brenan (1950). p. 266.
  20. 1 2 3 4 Thomas (1961). p. 92.
  21. Payne, S.G. and Palacios, J., 2014. Franco: A personal and political biography. University of Wisconsin Pres. p. 101
  22. Tardío, Manuel Álvarez. "The Impact of Political Violence During the Spanish General Election of 1936." Journal of Contemporary History 48, no. 3 (2013): 463–485.
  23. 1 2 Brenan (1950). p. 289.
  24. 1 2 3 4 5 6 Beevor, Antony. The Battle for Spain: The Spanish Civil War 1936–1939. Hachette UK, 2012.
  25. Beevor (2006). pp. 34–35.
  26. Thomas (1961). pp. 91–2.
  27. 1 2 3 4 Payne (2006). p. 175.
  28. 1 2 Brenan (1950). p. 307.
  29. 1 2 Payne, S.G. and Palacios, J., 2014. Franco: A personal and political biography. University of Wisconsin Pres. p. 102
  30. Payne (2006). pp. 174–5.
  31. 1 2 Brenan (1950). p. 300.
  32. 1 2 Thomas (1961). p. 93.
  33. 1 2 3 Payne (2006). p. 177.
  34. 1 2 3 4 Brenan (1950). p. 298.
  35. Payne, Stanley G. Spain's first democracy: the Second Republic, 1931–1936. Univ of Wisconsin Press, 1993, p.274
  36. 1 2 Preston (2006). p. 83.
  37. Payne, S.G. and Palacios, J., 2014. Franco: A personal and political biography. University of Wisconsin Pres. p. 105
  38. García, Roberto Villa, and Manuel Álvarez Tardío. 1936. Fraude y violencia en las elecciones del Frente Popular. Espasa, 2017.
  39. Calleja, Eduardo González, and Francisco Sánchez Pérez. "Revisando el revisionismo. A propósito del libro 1936. Fraude y violencia en las elecciones del Frente Popular." Historia Contemporánea 3, no. 58 (2018).
  40. Beevor (2006). pp. 38–39
  41. Brenan (1950). p. 299.
  42. Thomas (1961). pp. 93–94.
  43. 1 2 Thomas (1961). p. 100.
  44. Beevor (2006). p. 38
  45. Alvarez Tardio, Manuel. "Mobilization and political violence following the Spanish general elections of 1936." REVISTA DE ESTUDIOS POLITICOS 177 (2017): 147–179.
  46. Jensen, Geoffrey. Franco. Potomac Books, Inc., 2005, p.66
  47. 1 2 Brenan (1950). p. 301.
  48. James Woodcock, Anarchism (1962), London: Penguin, 1970, 374)
  49. based on data as reproduced in Manuel Alvarez Tardio, Roberto Villa Garcia, 1936. Fraude y violencia en las elecciones del Frente Popular, Barcelona 2017, ISBN 9788467054736, pp. 580-599
  50. "Votos por candidatura 1936".
  51. 1 2 Lozano, Elecciones de 1936.

Further reading