Charles S. Roberts Award

Last updated

The Charles S. Roberts Awards (or CSR Awards) is an annual award for excellence in manual, tabletop games, with a focus on "conflict simulations", which includes simulations of non-military as well as military conflicts, as well as simulations of related historical topics. [1] From its founding in 1975 through 2021, the award was almost exclusively focused on historical wargaming, changing to a broader "conflict simulations" in award year 2022 (calendar year 2023). [2]

Contents

It is named in honor of Charles S. Roberts the "Father of Wargaming" who founded Avalon Hill. The award is informally called a "Charlie" and officially called a "Charles S. Roberts Award". The Wargamer magazine called it "very prestigious". [3] The Award is managed by the Charles S. Roberts Award Committee which has no commercial sponsorship, made up of designers, writers and hobbyists. It is a "people's award" with winners chosen through votes submitted by fans.

History

Created at the first Origins Game Convention in 1975, the awards were the brainchild of Canadian game store owner John Mansfield. [4] [5] Originally the awards were titled the "Origins Awards" but were informally known as the Charles Roberts Awards [6] and it was only in 1988 that Charles Roberts officially agreed to let his name be used. [7] The split from the Origins Awards occurred in 1987, after Fortress America by Milton Bradley Company won an award. Fortress America was not considered a traditional historical wargame by members of the wargaming community, with mechanics and a target audience more akin to Risk; and there was concern that because of the large print run of a Milton Bradley product, many of the voters came from outside the traditional wargaming hobby flooding out smaller run titles. [8]

Prior to 2000, the awards were given at the Origins Game Fair. From 2000–2012, the awards were presented at the World Boardgaming Championships (formerly "AvalonCon"). The awards were not given from 2013–2018.

Current award

In 2020, a group of gamers and industry figures restarted the award under auspices of Chairman Rodger B. MacGowan and directed and operated by Tim Tow. [8] Like the original, it is a non-profit and not associated with commercial interests. [9] There are an increased number of categories including art, print and play (called "amateur wargames"), and computer wargame categories.

The Awards also included the Charles Roberts Awards Hall of Fame which recognized game designers and producers that have made a significant and long lasting contribution to the contemporary board wargaming hobby.

Recent award winners

2003

Source: [10] [11]

2004

Source: [12] [11]

2005

Source: [13] [11]

2006

Source: [14] [11]

2007

Source: [15] [11]

2008

Source: [11]

2009

Source: [11]

2010

Source: [11]

2011

Source: [11]

2012

Source: [11]

2019

Source: [16] [17]

2020

Source: [19] [20]

2021

Source: [21]

2022

Source: [23]

Previous award winners

Source: [11]

1974 to 1975 – Best Professional Game

YearGameDesignerCompany
1974 Third Reich John Prados The Avalon Hill Game Company
1975 Kingmaker Andrew McNeilPhilMar Ltd.

1974 to 1975, 1978 – Best Amateur Game

YearGameDesignerCompany
1974 Manassas Tom EllerHistorical Simulations Ltd.
1975 La Bataille de la Moskowa Laurence GrovesMartial Enterprises
1978 Source of the Nile David Wesely & Ross MakerDiscovery Games

1976 to 1977 – Best Tactical Game

YearGameDesignerCompany
1976 Terrible Swift Sword Richard Berg Simulation Publications Incorporated
1977 Squad Leader John Hill The Avalon Hill Game Company

1976 to 1977 – Best Strategic Game

YearGameDesignerCompany
1976 The Russian Campaign John Edwards The Avalon Hill Game Company
1977 Victory in the Pacific Richard Hamblen The Avalon Hill Game Company

1978 to 1986 – Best Pre-20th century Game

YearGameDesignerCompany
1978 Source of the Nile David Wesely & Ross MakerDiscovery Games
1979 Napoleon at Leipzig Kevin Zucker Operational Studies Group
1980 Empires of the Middle Ages Jim Dunnigan Simulation Publications Incorporated
1981 A House Divided Frank Chadwick Game Designers' Workshop
1982 Civilization Francis Tresham The Avalon Hill Game Company
1983The Civil WarEric Lee Smith Victory Games
1984South Mountain Richard Berg West End Games
1985Pax Britannica Greg Costikyan Victory Games
1986ChickamaugaJon SouthardWest End Games

1978 to 1986 – Best 20th century Game

YearGameDesignerCompany
1978 To the Green Fields Beyond David Isby Simulation Publications Incorporated
1979 City Fight Joseph Balkoski Simulation Publications Incorporated
1980Cresendo of Doom (Squad Leader module) Don Greenwood The Avalon Hill Game Company
1981Wings Craig Taylor Yaquinto Publications
1982 Storm Over Arnhem Courtney Allen The Avalon Hill Game Company
1983 Ambush! Eric Lee Smith Victory Games
1984Vietnam 1965 – 1975Nick Karp Victory Games
1985 World in Flames Harry RowlandAustralian Design Group
1986 Fortress America Mike Gray Milton Bradley Company

1987 to 2008 – Best Pre–World War Two Game

YearGameDesignerCompany
1987Shot & ShellRoger NordWorld Wide Wargames
1988 Lee vs. Grant Joseph Balkoski Victory Games
1989 A House Divided (2nd ed.) Frank Chadwick Game Designers' Workshop
1990KadeshGary DickensXTR Corporation
1991AlexandrosMike MarkowitzXTR Corporation
1992 SPQR Richard Berg & Mark Herman GMT Games LLC
1993When Eagles Fight Ted Raicer XTR Corporation
1994Battles of Waterloo Richard Berg GMT Games LLC
1995Great War in EuropeTed RaicerXTR Corporation
1996Fields of Glory Richard Berg Moments in History
1997All Quiet on the Western FrontTed RaicerMoments in History
1998For the PeopleMark Herman The Avalon Hill Game Company
1999 Paths of Glory Ted Raicer GMT Games LLC
2000Drive on ParisAl Wambold The Gamers Incorporated
2001Wilderness WarVolko Runkhe GMT Games LLC
2002Napoleonic WarsMark McLaughlin GMT Games LLC
2003Age of NapoleonRenaud VerlaquePhalanx Games
2004Sword of RomeWray Ferrell GMT Games LLC
2005 Bonaparte at Marengo Bowen SimmonsSimmons Games
2006Here I StandEd Beach GMT Games LLC
20071914: Twilight in the EastMichael Resch GMT Games LLC
2008Warriors of GodMakoto Nakajima Multi-Man Publishing

2009 to 2012 – Best Ancient to Napoleonic Era Board Wargame

YearGameDesignerCompany
2009A Most Dangerous Time: Japan in Chaos, 1570–1584Tetsuya Nakamura Multi-Man Publishing
2010Washington's WarMark Herman GMT Games
2011Sekigahara Matthew Calkins GMT Games
2012The Battle of FontenoyMathew Hinkle Clash of Arms

2009 to 2012 – Best Post-Napoleonic to Pre–World War II Era Board Wargame

YearGameDesignerCompany
2009Battle Above the CloudsEd Beach & Mike Belles Multi-Man Publishing
2010The Spanish Civil War 1936–1939Javier Romero GMT Games
2011None But HeroesDean Essig Multi-Man Publishing
2012Bloody AprilTerry Simo GMT Games

1987 to 2012 – Best World War Two Game

YearGameDesignerCompany
1987Raid on St. Nazaire Rob Markham The Avalon Hill Game Company
1988 Tokyo Express Jon Southard Victory Games
1989Hitler's Last GambleDanny ParkerWorld Wide Wargames
1990Operation ShoestringGene Billingsley GMT Games LLC
1991 East Front Craig Besinque Columbia Games
1992Stalingrad PocketMasahiro Yamazaki The Gamers Incorporated
1993AfrikaDean Essig The Gamers Incorporated
1994Enemy at the GatesDean Essig The Gamers Incorporated
1995TunisiaDean Essig The Gamers Incorporated
1996Wave of TerrorJohn DeschXTR Corporation
1997DAKDean Essig The Gamers Incorporated
1998Invasion: SicilyVance von Borries GMT Games LLC
1999BurmaDave Friedrichs The Gamers Incorporated
2000 (tie)SicilyDean Essig The Gamers Incorporated
2000 (tie)Ukraine '43Mark Simonitch GMT Games LLC
2001Barbarossa – Army Group NorthVance von Borries GMT Games LLC
2002Barbarossa to BerlinTed Raicer GMT Games LLC
2003Europe EngulfedRick Young & Jesse Evans GMT Games LLC
2004 Advanced Squad Leader Starter Kit #1 Ken Dunn Multi-Man Publishing
2005Empire of the SunMark Herman GMT Games LLC
2006A Victory LostTetsuya Nakamura Multi-Man Publishing
2007Case BlueDean Essig Multi-Man Publishing
2008Conflict of HeroesUwe EckertAcademy Games
2009D-Day at Omaha BeachJohn Butterfield Decision Games
2010Normandy '44Mark Simonitch GMT Games
2011No Retreat: The Russian Front Deluxe EditionCarl Paradis GMT Games
2012Red WinterMark Mokszycki GMT Games

1987 to 2012 – Best Post–World War Two or Modern Game

YearGameDesignerCompany
1987 (tie)Central AmericaJames McQuaid Victory Games
1987 (tie)7th Fleet Joseph Balkoski Victory Games
1988 Tac Air Gary Morgan The Avalon Hill Game Company
1989Modern Naval Battles Dan Verssen World Wide Wargames
1990Silver BayonetGene Billingsley GMT Games LLC
1991 (tie)InchonJim WerbanethXTR Corporation
1991 (tie)Hornet LeaderDan Verssen GMT Games LLC
1992Tet '68 Joe Miranda XTR Corporation
1993Crisis: Korea 1995Gene Billingsley GMT Games LLC
1994no award--
1995Yom KippurAl Sandrick The Gamers Incorporated
1996no award--
1997Semper FiLee Forester The Gamers Incorporated
1998no award--
1999no award--
2000no award--
2001When Dragons FightTy BombaXTR Corporation
2002 (tie)Khe Sahn 1968John PradosAgainst the Odds Magazine
2002 (tie)First Indochina WarJoe Miranda Decision Games
2003Lock 'n LoadMark WalkerShrapnel Games
2004DowntownLee Brimmicombe-Wood GMT Games LLC
2005 Twilight Struggle Ananda Gupta & Jason Matthews GMT Games LLC
2006Winged Horse: Campaigns in Vietnam, 1965–66Joe Miranda Decision Games
2007World at War: Eisenbach GapMark H. Walker Lock 'n Load Publishing
2008Red Dragon Rising: The Coming War with ChinaBruce Costello Decision Games
2009Elusive VictoryTerry Simo GMT Games LLC
2010Labyrinth: The War on TerrorVolko Ruhnke GMT Games
2011Lock 'n Load: Heroes of the GapPete Abrams, Mark H. Walker Lock 'n Load Publishing
2012Andean AbyssVolko Ruhnke GMT Games

1999 to 2012 – Best DTP Game (or Print and Play, from 2009)

YearGameDesignerCompany
1999 (tie)Bloody Beach: OmahaBill RamseyBill Ramsey
1999 (tie)ChantillyHampton NewsomeIvy Street Games
2000Solomon SeaMarkus StumptnerSimulations Workshop Incorporated
2001Longbow Richard Berg BSO Games
2002 (tie)A Mere Matter of MarchingBruce MacFarlaneMicrogame Design Group
2002 (tie)Togoland 1914Dennis BishopKhyber Pass Games
2003 Thunder on South Mountain Scot HolmgrenBlue Guidon Games
2004Louisiana Tigers Richard Berg BSO Games
2005Death in the TrenchesBen Madison and Wes ErniSchutze Games
2006Battle of the Little BighornMicheal TaylorKhyber Pass Games
2007Rosebud: Prelude to Little BighornMicheal TaylorKhyber Pass Games
2008June '44Danny HolteDHH Games
2009Zulus on the Ramparts!Joe MirandaVictory Point Games
2010We Must Tell the Emperor!Steve CareyVictory Point Games
2011La Bataille d' Halle – 1806Dennis A. Spors, James Soto, Monte Mattson, Michael NeylanMarshal Enterprises
2012City of Confusion: The Battle for Hue, Tet 1968Paul RohrbaughHigh Flying Dice Games

1999 to 2012 – Best Magazine Game

YearGameDesignerCompany
1999Borodino & FriedlandKevin Zucker Decision Games (Strategy & Tactics)
2000XenophonJoe Miranda Decision Games (Strategy & Tactics)
2001War of 1812Tom Dalgliesh Decision Games (Strategy & Tactics)
2002First Indochina WarJoe Miranda Decision Games (Strategy & Tactics)
2003Ignorant ArmiesPhil Sharp Decision Games (Strategy & Tactics)
2004Fortress BerlinJohn PradosAgainst the Odds Magazine
2005Chennault's First FightPaul RohrbaughAgainst the Odds Magazine
2006Kulikovo 1380: the Golden Horde Richard Berg Against the Odds Magazine
2007Not War But MurderMichael RinellaAgainst the Odds Magazine
2008Iwo Jima: Rage Against the MarinesTakaharu HorieOperations Magazine
2009Deathride: Mars-la-Tour 1870Charles VaseyAgainst the Odds Magazine
2010A Week in HellLaurent GuenetteBattles Magazine
2011Into the Bastards! – First tank battleNicolas RidentBattles Magazine
2012Beyond WaterlooJohn PradosAgainst the Odds Magazine

2009 to 2012 – Best Expansion or Supplement for an Existing Game

YearGameDesignerCompany
2009Panzerblitz Hill of Death mini-module CarentanDarren Emge Multi-Man Publishing
2010Combat Commander: Battle Pack #3 – NormandyJohn Foley GMT Games
2011 Advanced Squad Leader: Starter Kit Expansion Pack #1Ken Dunn Multi-Man Publishing
2012 Advanced Squad Leader: Festung BudapestBill Cirillo Multi-Man Publishing

1974 to 2012 – Best Professional Wargaming Magazine

YearMagazinePublisher
1974 Strategy & Tactics Simulation Publications Incorporated
1975 Strategy & Tactics Simulation Publications Incorporated
1976 Strategy & Tactics Simulation Publications Incorporated
1977 Strategy & Tactics Simulation Publications Incorporated
1978 Fire & Movement Rodger MacGowan & Baron Publishing
1979 Fire & Movement Rodger MacGowan & Baron Publishing
1980 Fire & Movement Rodger MacGowan & Baron Publishing
1981 Fire & Movement Rodger MacGowan & Baron Publishing
1982 Fire & Movement Friedrich Helfferich & Steve Jackson Games
1983 Fire & Movement Friedrich Helfferich & Steve Jackson Games
1984 The Wargamer World Wide Wargames
1985 The Wargamer World Wide Wargames
1986 The Wargamer World Wide Wargames
1987 Strategy & Tactics World Wide Wargames
1988 Strategy & Tactics World Wide Wargames
1989 Strategy & Tactics World Wide Wargames
1990CommandXTR Corporation
1991CommandXTR Corporation
1992CommandXTR Corporation
1993CommandXTR Corporation
1994CommandXTR Corporation
1995CommandXTR Corporation
1996CommandXTR Corporation
1997CommandXTR Corporation
1998 Strategy & Tactics Decision Games
1999 Strategy & Tactics Decision Games
2000 Strategy & Tactics Decision Games
2001 Strategy & Tactics Decision Games
2002 Strategy & Tactics Decision Games
2003Against the OddsAgainst the Odds Magazine
2004 (tie)Against the OddsAgainst the Odds Magazine
2004 (tie) Strategy & Tactics Decision Games
2005Against the OddsAgainst the Odds Magazine
2006Against the OddsAgainst the Odds Magazine
2007Against the OddsAgainst the Odds Magazine
2008C3iRBM Publishing
2009BattlesOlivier Revenu
2010BattlesOlivier Revenu
2011BattlesOlivier Revenu
2012C3iRBM Publishing

1974 to 2012 – Best Amateur Wargaming Magazine

YearMagazinePublisher
1974 Albion Don Turnbull
1975 Jagdpanther Jagdpanther Publications
1976Battlefield/JagdpantherJagdpanther Publications
1977 The Space Gamer Steve Jackson Games
1978 Perfidious Albion Charles Vasey
1979Perfidious AlbionCharles Vasey
1980HMS Review*Herb Barents
1981 Journal of World War Two Wargaming Nick Schuessler
1982Journal of 20th Century WargamingNick Schuessler
1983Journal of 20th Century WargamingNick Schuessler
1984 Alarums and Excursions Lee Gold
1985The V.I.P of GamingAlan Emrich
1986 The Midwest Wargamers' Association Newsletter Hal Thinglum
1987Volunteers – Civil War Gaming NewsletterBill Koff
1988Volunteers – Civil War Gaming NewsletterBill Koff
1989 The Canadian Wargaming Journal Canadian Wargaming Group
1990 The Canadian Wargaming Journal Canadian Wargaming Group
1991 The Canadian Wargaming Journal Canadian Wargaming Group
1992 The Canadian Wargaming Journal Canadian Wargaming Group
1993 Paper Wars Hexessential Publications
1994 Paper Wars Hexessential Publications
1995 Berg's Review of Games (BROG) Richard Berg
1996 Berg's Review of Games (BROG) Richard Berg
1997 Berg's Review of Games (BROG) Richard Berg
1998 Berg's Review of Games (BROG) Richard Berg
1999The BoardgamerBruce Monnin
2000The BoardgamerBruce Monnin
2001The BoardgamerBruce Monnin
2002The BoardgamerBruce Monnin
2003PanzerschreckMinden Games
2004PanzerschreckMinden Games
2005PanzerschreckMinden Games
2006Line of DepartureJim Werbaneth
2007Line of DepartureJim Werbaneth
2008Line of DepartureJim Werbaneth
2009 Panzer Digest Minden Games
2010Line of DepartureJim Werbaneth
2011Line of DepartureJim Werbaneth
20121914 DispatchesOregon Consim Gamers

1987 to 2012 – Best Historical or Scenario Magazine Article

YearArticleWriterMagazine
1987Aesthetics, Function and History in Wargame GraphicsRodger MacGowan The Wargamer Vol. 2, #3
1988Forrest at Bay Richard Berg Strategy & Tactics #119
1989Rush for GloryRichard Hitchman Strategy & Tactics #127
1990 (tie)BorodinoGary Morgan Strategy & Tactics #136
1990 (tie)Enter RommelFrank WatsonEuropa Magazine #15
1991Desert StormBo EldridgeCommand #13
1992Russo-Japanese WarRon BellCommand #19
1993When Eagles Fight: First World War in the EastTed RaicerCommand #25
1994No Award--
1995Bunker HillWilliam MarshCommand #32
1996No Award--
1997End of Empire, Parts I and IIWilliam MarshCommand #46
1998The Meuse-Argonne: America's Last Offensive of the Great WarJohn DeschCommand #51
1999Equus: Cavalry Battles of the Second Punic WarDan FournieC3i #10
2000French Foreign LegionTimothy Kutta Strategy & Tactics #200
2001The Boer War, 1899–1902Joseph Miranda Strategy & Tactics #205
2002Overshadowed by a Phrase: PyrrhusDavid W. TschanzC3i #14
2003Napoleon at the Berezina Rob Markham Against the Odds #4
2004The Sedan Campaign of 1870: An AnalysisTy Bomba Strategy & Tactics #224
2005No Winner Declared*--
2006No Award--
2007Not War But Murder: The Cold Harbor Campaign – 1864Michael RinellaAgainst the Odds #19
2008 (tie)Combat Commander: Variant RulesChad Jensen and John FoleyC3i #21
2008 (tie)Flying Colors: Trafalgar CampaignMark BarkerC3i #20
2009For the People – 10th Anniversary Variant RulesMark HermanC3i #23
2010History of the Peloponnesian WarJoel ToppenC3i #24
2011To Script or Not to Script, that is the question?Mark HermanC3i #25
20121914 – A postwar Solution for Austria-Hungary's MobilizationMichael ReschC3i #26

1987 to 2012 – Best Game Review or Game Analysis

YearArticleWriterMagazine
1987Central AmericaTom Slizewsk Fire & Movement #56
1988Lee vs. Grant Keith Poulter The Wargamer Vol. 2, #5
1989World War II Anthology, Part IVance Von Borries Fire & Movement #60
1990D-Elim Ulrich & Dirk Blennemann Command #2
1991The Evolution of Simulation DesignJohn SchettlerMOVES #65
1992August Storm: Franco-Prussian WarUlrich & Dirk BlennemannMOVES #72
1993–95No Award--
1996A Fleet SquanderedTom DworschakCommand #40
1997Panzergruppe GuderianTed KimSPI Revival eZine #1
1998Home Before the Leaves FallRick Lechowich Fire & Movement #116
1999La Bataille de LutzenJuan Rosario Paper Wars #32
2000 Clash of Arms' Summer StormGreg Ullrich Paper Wars #33
2001Hube's Pocket AnalysisTony ZbaraschukOperations #41
2002Enjoying a Slice of SicilianAdam Starkweather Paper Wars #48
2003Drive on StalingradAdam Starkweather Paper Wars #50
2004No Award--
2005Empire of the Sun Strategy ConceptsMark HermanC3i #17
2006No Award--
2007The Evolution of Cards and WargameJohn PradosAgainst the Odds #19
2008 (tie)Top 20 Games – A Look BackSteve CareyC3i #20
2008 (tie)Empire of the Sun: Opening StrategyMark HermanC3i #21
2009Liberty Roads reviewFrançois Xavier EuzetBattles #2
2010Washington's War, Art of Asymmetrical StrategyMark HermanC3i #24
2011LabyrinthDavid HughesBattles #6
2012For the People – Defending the UnionDave Dockter, Mark HermanC3i #25

1976 to 2012 – Best Wargame Graphics

YearGameArtistPublisher
1976 Avalanche: The Salerno Landings Rich Banner Game Designers' Workshop
1977no award--
1978Cross of Iron (Squad Leader module)Scott Moores The Avalon Hill Game Company
1979no award--
1980no award--
1981no award--
1982no award--
1983no award--
1984Vietnam 1965 – 1975Ted Koller Victory Games
1985Pax BritannicaTed Koller (Jim Talbot – map) Victory Games
1986Korean WarTed Koller Victory Games
1987Raid on St. NazaireCharles Kibler The Avalon Hill Game Company
1988 (tie)Lee vs. GrantTed Koller Victory Games
1988 (tie) The Campaigns of Robert E. Lee Rick Barber (map) Clash of Arms Games
1989Hitler's Last GambleDean Essig World Wide Wargames
1990KadeshLarry Hoffman (counters) & (Mark Simonitch – map)XTR Corporation
1991Hornet LeaderRodger MacGowan GMT Games LLC
1992SPQRRodger MacGowan (Mark Simonitch – map) GMT Games LLC
1993Lion of the NorthRodger MacGowan (Mark Simonitch – map) GMT Games LLC
1994Battles of WaterlooRodger MacGowan (Mark Simonitch – map) GMT Games LLC
1995Yom KippurDean Essig The Gamers Incorporated
1996GD '41Dean Essig The Gamers Incorporated
1997DAKDean Essig The Gamers Incorporated
1998Saratoga 1777Rodger MacGowan (Joe Youst – map) GMT Games LLC
1999River of DeathRodger MacGowan (Joe Youst – map) GMT Games LLC
2000Brandywine CreekRodger MacGowan (Joe Youst – map) GMT Games LLC
2001Wilderness WarRodger MacGowan (Mark Simonitch – map) GMT Games LLC
2002Streets of Stalingrad (3rd ed.)Joe Youst (map) L2 Design Group
2003Ardennes '44Rodger MacGowan (Mark Simonitch – map) GMT Games LLC
2004DowntownRodger MacGowan (Lee Brimmicombe-Wood – map) GMT Games LLC
2005 (tie)Empire of the SunRodger MacGowan (Mark Simonitch – map) GMT Games LLC
2005 (tie)Fire in the SkyNicolas Eskubi Multi-Man Publishing
2006A Victory LostNicolas Eskubi Multi-Man Publishing
2007 (tie)1914: Twilight in the EastMarkus Brown, Michael Resch, (Mark Simonitch – map) GMT Games LLC
2007 (tie)OverlordMark HinkleNew England Simulations
2008Conflict of HeroesSteve PaschalAcademy Games
2009Battle Above the CloudsCharles Kibler & Nicolas Eskubi Multi-Man Publishing
2010Normandy '44Mark Simonitch GMT Games
2011Where Eagles DareNicolas Eskubi Multi-Man Publishing
2012The Battle of FontenoyCharles Kibler Clash of Arms

1979 to 1981 – Best Initial Release Wargame

YearRecipientGameCompany
1979 Ironclads John FuselerYaquinto Publications
1980 Streets of Stalingrad Dana Lombardy Phoenix Games
1981 Ironbottom Sound Jack GreeneQuarterdeck Games

1977 to 1986 and 2010 to 2012 – Best Fantasy or Science Fiction Wargame

YearGameRecipientCompany
1977 War of the Rings Richard Berg Simulation Publications Incorporated
1978 Mayday Marc Miller Game Designers' Workshop
1979 The Creature That Ate Sheboygan Greg Costikyan Simulation Publications Incorporated
1980 Azhanti High Lightning Frank Chadwick Game Designers' Workshop
1981: Sci-Fi Car Wars Chad Irby & Steve Jackson Steve Jackson Games
1981: Fantasy Barbarian Prince Arnold HendrickDwarfstar Games
1982: Sci-Fi Illuminati Steve Jackson Steve Jackson Games
1982: Fantasy Sherlock Holmes Consulting Detective Gary Grady, Raymond Edwards & Suzanne GoldbergSleuth Publications
1983: Sci-Fi Nuclear Escalation Douglas MalewickiFlying Buffalo
1983: Fantasy Lost Worlds Alfred LeonardiNova Game Designs
1984: Sci-FiWeb & Starship Greg Costikyan West End Games
1984: Fantasy Lonely Mountain Coleman Charlton Iron Crown Enterprises
1985 Wabbit Wampage Mark Acres Pacesetter Games
1986 Kings & Things Tom Wham & Robert J. Kuntz West End Games
2010War of the Ring Collector's EditionRoberto di Meglio, Marco Maggi, Francesco NepitelloFantasy Flight Games
2011Space Empires 4XJim Krohn GMT Games
2012Star Wars: X-Wing Miniatures GameJeffrey KniffenFantasy Flight Games

1989 to 2012 – James F. Dunnigan Award for Playability and Design

To a Game Designer, Developer, Graphic Artist or Game for outstanding achievement in that year

YearRecipientGameCompany
1989Dan Verssen & Rodger MacGowanModern Naval Battles** World Wide Wargames
1990 Don Greenwood Republic of Rome The Avalon Hill Game Company
1991 (tie)Mark SimonitchThe Legend BeginsRhino Games
1991 (tie) Craig Besinque East Front**Columbia Games
1992Ben KnightVictory at MidwayXTR Corporation
1993Dean EssigAfrika The Gamers Incorporated
1994Dean EssigEnemy at the Gates The Gamers Incorporated
1995Ted RaicerGreat War in EuropeXTR Corporation
1996Ty BombaCommand magazineXTR Corporation
1997Dean EssigDAK The Gamers Incorporated
1998Mark HermanFor the People The Avalon Hill Game Company
1999Ted Raicer Paths of Glory GMT Games LLC
2000Mark SimonitchUkraine '43 GMT Games LLC
2001Volko RuhnkeWilderness War GMT Games LLC
2002Ben HullThis Accursed Civil War GMT Games LLC
2003Rick Young & Jesse EvansEurope Engulfed GMT Games LLC
2004Lee Brimmicombe-WoodDowntown GMT Games LLC
2005Ananda Gupta & Jason Matthews Twilight Struggle GMT Games LLC
2006Tetsuya NakamuraA Victory Lost Multi-Man Publishing
2007Dean EssigCase Blue and the OCS series Multi-Man Publishing
2008Uwe EickertConflict of Heroes Academy Games
2009John ButterfieldD-Day at Omaha Beach Decision Games
2010Volko RuhnkeLabyrinth: The War on Terror GMT Games
2011Adam StarkweatherThe Devil's Cauldron & Where Eagles Dare Multi-Man Publishing
2012Dean EssigIt Never Snows and the SCS series Multi-Man Publishing

Leading CSR award winners for wargames (1974 to 2011)

These totals include awards for games, magazine games, game graphics and (for designers) the James F. Dunnigan award. Not included are awards for magazines, computer media and articles.

by game company

47 – GMT Games LLC
16 – Multi-Man Publishing
13 – The Gamers Incorporated
12 – The Avalon Hill Game Company
12 – Victory Games
10 – Decision Games
9 – XTR Corporation
6 – Simulation Publications Incorporated
6 – Against the Odds Magazine
5 – Game Designers' Workshop
4 – World Wide Wargames
4 – West End Games
3 – Clash of Arms
3 – Khyber Pass Games

by game designer or graphic artist

16 – Dean Essig
13 – Rodger MacGowan
9 – Richard Berg
8 – Ted Raicer
6 – Joe Miranda
6 – Mark Herman
5 – Volko Ruhnke
5 – Mark Simonitch
4 – John Prados
4 – Ted Koller
4 – Nicolas Eskubi
3 – Frank Chadwick
3 – Joseph Balkoski
3 – Greg Costikyan
3 – Dan Verssen
3 – Charles Kibler

See also

Related Research Articles

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Wargame</span> Strategy game that realistically simulates war

A wargame is a strategy game in which two or more players command opposing armed forces in a simulation of an armed conflict. Wargaming may be played for recreation, to train military officers in the art of strategic thinking, or to study the nature of potential conflicts. Many wargames re-create specific historic battles, and can cover either whole wars, or any campaigns, battles, or lower-level engagements within them. Many simulate land combat, but there are wargames for naval and air combat, as well.

Simulations Publications, Inc. (SPI) was an American publisher of board wargames and related magazines, particularly its flagship Strategy & Tactics, in the 1970s and early 1980s. It produced an enormous number of games and introduced innovative practices, changing the course of the wargaming hobby in its bid to take control of the hobby away from then-dominant Avalon Hill. SPI ran out of cash in early 1982 when TSR called in a loan secured by SPI's assets. TSR began selling SPI's inventory in 1982, but later acquired the company's trademarks and copyrights in 1983 and continued a form of the operation until 1987.

Clash of Arms Games is a wargaming company best known for a high level of graphics quality and moderately to highly complex games, often focusing on the Napoleonic era, but with offerings in most eras of military history. Besides boardgames, such as the La Bataille series, it has published miniature wargaming rulesets, such as Flint & Steel and The Dawn of the Rising Sun.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Game Designers' Workshop</span> Wargame and roleplaying game publisher

Game Designers' Workshop (GDW) was a wargame and role-playing game publisher from 1973 to 1996. Many of their games are now carried by other publishers.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">GMT Games</span> American board game publisher

GMT Games is a California-based wargaming publisher founded in 1990. The company has become well known for graphically attractive games that range from "monster games", of many maps and counters, to quite simple games suitable for introducing new players to wargaming. They also produce card games and family games. The current management and creative team includes Tony Curtis, Rodger MacGowan, Mark Simonitch, and Andy Lewis.

SPQR is a board wargame designed by Richard Berg and Mark Herman, and released in 1992 by GMT Games, as part of the Great Battles of History (GBoH) series of games on ancient warfare. SPQR deals with battles fought by the Roman Republic, and is designed to showcase the strengths and weaknesses of the Roman manipular legion.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Tactical wargame</span> Type of wargame that models military conflict at a tactical level

Tactical wargames are a type of wargame that models military conflict at a tactical level, i.e. units range from individual vehicles and squads to platoons or companies. These units are rated based on types and ranges of individual weaponry. The first tactical wargames were played as miniatures, extended to board games, and they are now also enjoyed as video games.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Richard Berg</span> American wargame designer (1943–2019)

Richard Harvey Berg was a prolific American wargame designer. He was inducted into the Charles Roberts Awards Hall of Fame in 1987.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">John Hill (game designer)</span> American designer of military wargames

John Evans Hill was an American designer of military board wargames, as well as rules for miniature wargaming. He is best known as the designer of the Avalon Hill board game Squad Leader and the American Civil War miniatures game Johnny Reb. He was inducted into the Charles Roberts Awards Hall of Fame.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Don Greenwood (game designer)</span>

Don Greenwood is a board game designer and was a pioneer editor among commercial board-wargaming magazines. He began his own fanzine, Panzerfaust Magazine, which he oversaw from 1967 until 1972. He then joined The Avalon Hill Game Company in 1972, and took over editorship of that company's "house organ", The General Magazine, which office he held until 1982. He left Avalon Hill and continued to work in the wargame industry, notably for GMT Games. He is the founder of the Origins, Avaloncon, and WBC gaming conventions and remains the WBC convention manager. Greenwood was also president of the Boardgame Players Association. He was inducted into the Origins Award hall of fame in 1991 and the Charles Roberts Awards Hall of Fame in 1994. He was honored as a "famous game designer" by being featured as the king of spades in Flying Buffalo's 2011 Famous Game Designers Playing Card Deck.

<i>Twilight Struggle</i> Board game

Twilight Struggle: The Cold War, 1945–1989 is a board game for two players, published by GMT Games in 2005. Players are the United States and Soviet Union contesting each other's influence on the world map by using cards that correspond to historical events. The first game designed by Ananda Gupta and Jason Matthews, they intended it to be a quick-playing alternative to more complex card-driven wargames.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Board wargame</span> Wargame played on a printed surface or board

A board wargame is a wargame with a set playing surface or board, as opposed to being played on a computer or in a more free-form playing area as in miniatures games. The modern, commercial wargaming hobby developed in 1954 following the publication and commercial success of Tactics. The board wargaming hobby continues to enjoy a sizeable following, with a number of game publishers and gaming conventions dedicated to the hobby both in the English-speaking world and further afield.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Mark Simonitch</span>

Mark Simonitch is an American wargame designer and graphic artist. His game designs include Hannibal: Rome vs. Carthage and Ardennes '44, and he has made maps for Wilderness War and Empire of the Sun among others. He has worked at Avalon Hill and GMT Games. He was inducted into the Charles Roberts Awards Hall of Fame in 2002.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Ted Raicer</span>

Ted S. Raicer is a game designer who has worked on board games. He became a board wargamer at the age of 12 years and has published more than 10 games based on World War I. Raicer has won many awards in his gaming career.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Ty Bomba</span>

Tyrone S. Bomba is a prolific American board wargame designer, credited as the designer of over 125 board wargames and game items. Bomba is the recipient of the James F. Dunnigan Award, has been inducted into the Charles Roberts Awards Hall of Fame for his contributions to the wargaming industry, and several of his games have won Charles S. Roberts Awards.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Kevin Zucker (game designer)</span>

Kevin S. Zucker is an American wargame designer, historian, author, and musician.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">John Prados</span> American author and historian (1951–2022)

John Frederick Prados was an American author, historian, and wargame designer who specialized in the history of World War II, the Vietnam War, and current international relations.

<i>Labyrinth: The War on Terror, 2001 – ?</i> 2010 wargame board game

Labyrinth: The War on Terror, 2001–? is a board game for one or two players, published by GMT Games in 2010.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Rodger B. MacGowan</span> American artist

Rodger B. MacGowan is an artist, game developer, art director and magazine publisher who has been active in the board wargame industry since the 1970s. MacGowan is a prolific artist of cover art for wargames, and the wargaming magazine he founded, Fire & Movement, won the Charles S. Roberts Award several times while under his editorial control.

References

  1. "Awards Year 2023 Charter". Charles S. Roberts Award.
  2. "CSR Awards Announce New Charter". Charles S. Roberts Award. 2023.
  3. Scott Parrino (15 April 2010). "Industry News: Voting for the Charles S Roberts Award Now Open". The Wargamer . Archived from the original on 18 January 2014. Retrieved 17 January 2014. ..the very prestigious Charles S Roberts Awards has started.
  4. John Prados (June 1979). "The Evolution of Origins: The National Convention af Five". Moves (45): 5.
  5. John Mansfield, resident of Winnipeg, Manitoba and long time gamer, is manager of Pendragon Games & Hobbies as of 2014.
  6. John Prados (June 1979). "The Evolution of Origins: The National Convention af Five". Moves (45): 10.
  7. Charles S. Roberts (31 May 1988). "CSR Awards Authorization". CSR website. Archived from the original on 6 May 2009.
  8. 1 2 Pancaldi, Dan Duce (17 May 2020). "Interview with Tim Tow". No Enemies Here via YouTube.
  9. "CSR Awards Charter" . Retrieved 28 July 2023.
  10. "2003 CSR Award Winners". ConsimWorld. 8 August 2004. Archived from the original on 19 April 2006. Retrieved 11 August 2008.
  11. 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 "CSR Award winners by year". CSR website. Archived from the original on 7 May 2016. Retrieved 24 November 2018.
  12. "2004 CSR Award Winners". ConsimWorld. 8 August 2005. Archived from the original on 12 August 2005. Retrieved 11 August 2008.
  13. "2005 CSR Award Winners". ConsimWorld. 8 August 2006. Archived from the original on 2 March 2009. Retrieved 11 August 2008.
  14. "2006 CSR Award Winners". ConsimWorld. 6 August 2007. Archived from the original on 2 March 2009. Retrieved 11 August 2008.
  15. "2007 CSR Award Winners". ConsimWorld. 11 August 2008. Archived from the original on 12 December 2009. Retrieved 11 August 2008.
  16. "2019 Charles S. Roberts Winners". charlieawards.wordpress.com. 26 October 2020.
  17. Capaldi, Dan. "The Charles S Roberts Awards Oct 25 2020". No Enemies Here. Archived from the original on 12 December 2021. Retrieved 27 October 2020.
  18. "2019 Charles S. Roberts Nominees and Awards – Charles S. Roberts Awards". 8 August 2020.
  19. "2020 Charles S. Roberts Results". BGG. 10 November 2021.
  20. "2020 Charles S. Roberts Awards and Nominees – Charles S. Roberts Awards". 17 November 2021.
  21. "2021 Charles S. Roberts Winners". charlessrobertsawards.com. 28 December 2022.
  22. "Let's Play! Devil Boats: PT Boats in the Solomons (Overview & Review)". YouTube .
  23. "2022 Charles Roberts Awards Winners". Charles S. Roberts Award.