Deborah Lawrie

Last updated

Deborah Jane Lawrie

AM
Born1953 (age 6970) [1]
Sydney
Alma materUniversity of Melbourne
Occupation Airline pilot
Known forCommercial Pilot

Deborah Jane Lawrie AM (born 1953), known as Deborah Wardley while married, was the first woman to become a pilot with a major Australian airline [2] after winning a landmark sex discrimination case against Ansett Airlines.

Contents

Early life and education

Deborah Lawrie was born in Sydney in 1953; her family later moved to Melbourne. [1] Lawrie, from the age of 14, wanted to fly. Deborah, 16 years old, learned to fly at Moorabbin Airport. [3] She graduated with a degree in science from the University of Melbourne in 1974 and in education from Rusden State College in 1975. She taught high school mathematics and science from 1975 to 1977.

She obtained a private pilot licence in 1971 (aged 18) [4] and a commercial pilot licence in 1973. She logged 2600 flying hours and became a general aviation flying instructor and charter pilot in 1976.

Case against Ansett

Lawrie encouraged by her husband Peter Wardley, an Air Traffic Controller, first applied to Ansett Airlines in 1976 and kept sending applications for two years. During that time, 10 fellow male flying instructors were accepted into the Ansett pilot training program. She was finally interviewed in 1978 but was rejected. She took the case to the then new Victorian Equal Opportunity Board under the equivalent direct discrimination provisions of the Victorian Equal Opportunity Act 1977, and challenged Ansett's rejection under recently enacted equal opportunity legislation.

She and Peter Wardley having married days before the case began, she chose to use her married name in the case. The case of Wardley v Ansett Transport Industries (Operations) Pty Ltd, [5] [6] was the first sex discrimination in employment case [7] contested before the Equal Opportunity Board. [8]

Reg Ansett denied the allegation of discrimination but admitted that it was his strong personal view that women were not suited to be airline pilots. [9] This led to public demonstration marches in August 1979, [10] and a successful 'girl-cot': businesses were encouraged by women to transfer their travel accounts from Ansett to Trans Australia Airlines and, in the first six months, Ansett lost more than 50 per cent of its business travel and a lot never returned. [11] In a letter to the secretary of the Women's Electoral Lobby, the general manager of Ansett wrote:

"Ansett has adopted a policy of only employing men as pilots. This does not mean that women cannot be good pilots, but we are concerned with the provision of the safest and most efficient air service possible. In this regard, we feel that an all-male pilot crew is safer than one in which the sexes are mixed." [12]

Ansett raised a number of objections to the employment of women as pilots, including: [13]

The Victorian Equal Opportunity Board ruled that Ansett's refusal to employ Lawrie was illegal. It awarded damages of $14,500 and ordered Ansett to include her in its next pilot training program. Ansett delayed its training intake and appealed to the Supreme Court of Victoria but the appeal was dismissed. Ansett appealed the Supreme Court decision to the High Court of Australia in October 1979, but employed Lawrie from 5 November pending the outcome of the case. [14]

During classroom training, Ansett attempted to sack her by claiming she had been at fault in a near-miss incident at Moorabbin Airport despite an inquiry exonerating her and identifying the other pilot as at fault. Ansett backed down after unions stepped in. [15]

When classroom training was completed in December 1979, she was not assigned to training aircraft despite the male trainees progressing to flight training. Ansett Airlines had been taken over by Peter Abeles and Rupert Murdoch in late 1979. Lawrie had previously trained Murdoch's brother in law, John Calvert-Jones, to fly. She telephoned Calvert-Jones in early January 1980 informing him of the situation. Two days later Rupert Murdoch issued a memo directing that she was to be treated the same as the male pilot candidates. [15] She commenced flight training immediately and made her first commercial flight co-piloting a Fokker F27 from Alice Springs to Darwin on 22 January 1980.

The High Court dismissed Ansett's appeal in March 1980. [16] [17] The case is still used as a precedent. However, simply removing the most formal of exclusionary practices did not dissolve barriers, [18] and so continuing prejudices and obstacles mean that female commercial airline pilots are still rare in Australia. [19] [20]

"The board had ordered that Ansett pay me $40 a day until they employed me, so I was getting a pay cheque every second Wednesday," — Lawrie [21]

Lawrie was awarded $14,500, which went toward legal fees. [22]

Later career

Lawrie progressed to jet aircraft, going on to fly the McDonnell Douglas DC-9, Boeing 727 and Boeing 737 with Ansett Airlines. She was one of 1,640 pilots who resigned en masse following the 1989 Australian pilots' dispute. [23] She briefly returned to teaching and had her first child, Thomas, in January 1991. A biography of Lawrie was published by Allen & Unwin in 1992.

In 1993 she moved to the Netherlands and joined KLM as a Fokker 50 pilot. In 1994 she became a Fokker 50 instructor. In 1998 she became Flight Safety Manager and Chief Flight Safety Investigator for KLM Cityhopper. [3] Until 2007 she was also a senior Airbus A330 captain with KLM.

Now divorced, she has resumed using the name Deborah Lawrie. [15]

After reaching the mandatory retirement age for airline pilots in Europe, Lawrie returned to Australia in 2008. [3] She joined Jetstar Airways as Safety Investigations Manager and occasional pilot to maintain her Airbus A320 type rating. In July 2012 she joined Tigerair Australia and was an Airbus A320 Captain and instructor, later retraining on the Boeing 737-800. When the Tigerair brand was retired by Virgin Australia Holdings in 2020 she transferred to Virgin Australia.

Lawrie was made a Member of the Order of Australia (AM) in the 2019 Queen's Birthday Honours in recognition of her "significant service to aviation as a commercial pilot, and to women in the profession". [24] In June 2020 she was inducted into the Australian Aviation Hall of Fame. [25] [26]

As of November 2023, Lawrie is the world's oldest female commercial pilot. [27]

Legacy

In November 2023, a flyover of the Sydney Gateway leading into the Sydney Airport domestic terminal buildings was named the Deborah Lawrie Flyover. [27] Lawrie, who was present at the flyover's name unveiling, said she was "honoured to be recognised as a trailblazer for women in aviation".

Related Research Articles

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Trans Australia Airlines</span> Defunct Australian airline

Trans Australia Airlines (TAA), renamed Australian Airlines in 1986, was one of the two major Australian domestic airlines between its inception in 1946 and its merger with Qantas in September 1992. As a result of the "COBRA" project, the entire airline was rebranded Qantas about a year later with tickets stating in small print "Australian Airlines Limited trading as Qantas Airways Limited" until the adoption of a single Air Operator Certificate a few years later. At that point, the entire airline was officially renamed "Qantas Airways Limited" continuing the name and livery of the parent company with the only change being the change of by-line from "The Spirit of Australia" to "The Australian Airline" under the window line with the existing "Qantas" title appearing above.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Ansett Australia</span> Defunct domestic airline of Australia (1936–2002)

Ansett Australia was a major Australian airline group, based in Melbourne, Victoria. The airline flew domestically within Australia and from the 1990s to destinations in Asia. After operating for 65 years, the airline was placed into administration in 2001 following a financial collapse and subsequent organised liquidation in 2002, subject to deed of company arrangement. The last flight touched down on 5 March 2002.

Société Aircalin, also known as Air Calédonie International, is the flag carrier of the French collectivity of New Caledonia, with its headquarters in Nouméa. It operates scheduled services from its main base at La Tontouta International Airport to destinations across Oceania and Asia, such as Japan and Singapore, and additionally operates domestic services in Wallis and Futuna. The airline is 99% owned by the Government of New Caledonia, with the remaining 1% held by minority owners, including the airline's employees.

Air Niugini Limited is the national airline of Papua New Guinea, based in Air Niugini House on the property of Port Moresby International Airport, Port Moresby. It operates a domestic network from Port Moresby to 12 major airports while its subsidiary company, Link PNG, operates routes to minor airports. It also operates international services in Asia, Oceania, and Australia on a weekly basis. Its main base is Port Moresby International Airport, which is located in 7 Mile, Port Moresby, Papua New Guinea. Niugini is the Tok Pisin word for New Guinea.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Reg Ansett</span> Australian businessman and aviator

Sir Reginald Myles Ansett KBE was an Australian businessman and aviator. He was best known for founding Ansett Transport Industries, which owned one of Australia's two leading domestic airlines between 1957 and 2001. He also established a number of other business enterprises including Ansett Pioneer coachlines, Ansett Freight Express, Ansair coachbuilders, Gateway Hotels, Diners Club Australia, Biro Bic Australia and the ATV-0 television station in Melbourne and TVQ-0 in Brisbane which later became part of Network Ten. ATI also bought out Avis Rent a Car and had a 49% interest in Associated Securities Limited (ASL). In late 1979, mainly due to the collapse of ASL, Ansett lost control of the company to Peter Abeles of TNT and Rupert Murdoch of News Corporation who became joint managing directors.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Hamilton Airport (New Zealand)</span> Airport in the Waikato Region of New Zealand

Hamilton Airport is an airport located 14 kilometres south of the city of Hamilton in the Waikato region, in New Zealand. It is sited at Rukuhia, which was the name of the Royal New Zealand Air Force base on that site during World War II.

InterGlobe Aviation Limited, doing business as IndiGo, is an Indian low-cost airline headquartered in Gurgaon, Haryana, India. It is the largest airline in India by passengers carried and fleet size, with a 63.4% domestic market share as of July 2023. It is also the largest individual Asian low-cost carrier in terms of jet fleet size and passengers carried, and the largest carrier in Asia. It carried over 300+ million passengers as of November 2022. It operates 2,000 daily flights, as of December 2023, to 118 destinations – 85 domestic and 33 international. It has its primary hub at Indira Gandhi International Airport, Delhi.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Air France Flight 296Q</span> Aviation accident at Habsheim Air Show

Air France Flight 296Q was a chartered flight of a new Airbus A320-111 operated by Air France for Air Charter International. On 26 June 1988, the plane crashed while making a low pass over Mulhouse–Habsheim Airfield as part of the Habsheim Air Show. Most of the crash sequence, which occurred in front of several thousand spectators, was caught on video.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Armavia Flight 967</span> 2006 plane crash in the Black Sea off Sochi, Russia

Armavia Flight 967 was a scheduled international passenger flight operated by Armavia from Zvartnots International Airport, Zvarnots in Armenia to Sochi, a Black Sea coastal resort city in Russia. On 3 May 2006, the aircraft operating the route, an Airbus A320-200, crashed into the sea while attempting a go-around following its first approach to Sochi airport; all 113 aboard were killed. The accident was the first major commercial airline crash in 2006. It was Armavia's first and only fatal crash.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Châteauroux-Centre "Marcel Dassault" Airport</span> Airport in Indre, France

Châteauroux-Centre "Marcel Dassault" Airport, formerly known as Châteauroux-Déols "Marcel Dassault" Airport, is an airport serving the French city of Châteauroux. The airport is located 5.5 km (3.0 NM) north-northeast of Châteauroux in Déols, a commune of the Indre department in the Centre-Val de Loire region in France. The airport is named after Marcel Dassault and is located on the site of the former Châteauroux-Déols Air Base. It is dedicated to air freight, aeronautical maintenance, pilot training and training of airport firefighters.

Geraldton Airport is an airport located 6 nautical miles east of Geraldton, Western Australia, in Moonyoonooka along the Geraldton – Mount Magnet Road.

Second officer is a civil aviation rank, also known as junior first officer. It is used for pilots at an early stage of their career.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Julie Clark</span> Aerobatic pilot

Julie E. Clark is a retired American aerobatic air show aviator and commercial airline pilot. She started her commercial flying career with Golden West Airlines as a first officer and ended it in 2003 as a Northwest Airlines Airbus A320 Captain. She was one of the first female pilots to work for a major airline, and has been voted as "Performer of the Year" several times for her air show performances.

Strategic Airlines Pty Ltd, trading as Air Australia Airways was an Australian airline flying domestic and international scheduled passenger flights. Strategic Aviation, a sister company, flew air charter flights using the Air Australia fleet or other leased aircraft. Both companies had their head office in Hendra, a suburb of Brisbane.

Airlines of New South Wales callsign "NEWSOUTH" was an Australian domestic regional airline that operated from 1959 until its merger into Ansett in 1993. It was formed by Reg Ansett's takeover of Butler Air Transport. Airlines of New South Wales operated air passenger services in New South Wales, and later in other Australian states. In 1964–65 the airline fought a High Court case, Airlines of New South Wales Pty Ltd v New South Wales, that was significant in adjudicating the spheres of constitutional power of the national and state governments in respect of air navigation.

Virgin Australia Regional Airlines is an Australian regional airline based in Perth, servicing key towns in the state of Western Australia. The airline also flies interstate to destinations such as Adelaide, Darwin, Melbourne and Alice Springs. Formerly known as Skywest, in April 2013 the airline was purchased by Virgin Australia Holdings as its new regional offshoot. On 21 April 2020, Virgin Australia Regional Airlines' parent company, Virgin Australia Holdings went into voluntary administration due to the COVID-19 pandemic.

Maria Ziadie-Haddad is an airline pilot from Jamaica. She was the first woman commercial pilot hired by Air Jamaica and upon obtaining her qualifications as a captain became Air Jamaica's first woman captain. When the government divested its holding in the firm, Ziadie Haddad began flying commercial freight in the United States.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">BAA Training</span> Flying school in Lithuania

BAA Training is an aviation training center, and a subsidiary of Avia Solutions Group. Headquartered in Vilnius, Lithuania, it operates globally. Certified as an Approved Training Organization (ATO), BAA Training offers a wide range of programs, including Ab Initio, Type Rating, Cabin Crew, Ground Handling, and Flight Dispatcher training. Additionally, BAA Training provides the flexibility to complete theory remotely through online courses.

Rosemary Anne Balmford was an Australian judge, barrister, solicitor and legal academic. She was the first female judge of the Supreme Court of Victoria, and the first female lecturer in the law faculty of the University of Melbourne.

Robyn Clay-Williams is an Australian academic and one of the first two women to serve as pilots in the Royal Australian Air Force (RAAF). She joined the RAAF in 1979 and initially served in maintenance roles as women were not permitted to be pilots. After this restriction was lifted she completed pilot training in June 1988 and became a test pilot in 1993. Clay-Williams reached the rank of Wing Commander and led No. 85 Wing. After leaving the RAAF in 2003, she completed a doctorate. As of 2021, Clay-Williams was an Associate Professor at Macquarie University.

References

  1. 1 2 Johnston, Marjorie (1989). Jobs for the Girls. Richmond, Vic.: William Heinemann Australia. ISBN   978-0-8556-1152-1.[ page needed ]
  2. "World's oldest female commercial pilot Deborah Lawrie enjoys 50 years of flying". ABC News. 8 March 2020.
  3. 1 2 3 "Captain Deborah Lawrie AM". Platinum Speakers & Entertainers. Retrieved 15 March 2023.
  4. "Women in aviation: Landmark cases". Skies Mag. Retrieved 15 March 2023.
  5. Ansett Transport Industries (Operations) Pty Ltd v Wardley (1984) EOC 92003.
  6. Dahn, S. (1987). Wardley v. Ansett: an examination and analysis of a leading and influential equal opportunity case. Masters Research thesis, Economics & Commerce, The University of Melbourne
  7. L.R. Edwards, 'Employment of Women Airline Pilots in Australia' (1980) 5 Air and Space Law, Issue 3, pp. 171–173
  8. Sisely, Dianne (2000–2001). "Annual Report: Chief Executive's Report" (PDF). Equal Opportunity Commission Victoria. p. 14. Retrieved 8 June 2007.
  9. Maloney, Shane and Grosz, Chris. Reg Ansett and Deborah Wardley [online]. Monthly, The, Sept 2012: 66. Availability: ISSN   1832-3421. [cited 05 Jul 15].
  10. Robson, P. (1984). The Accord and Social Welfare: Current Results and Outlook. Australian Left Review, 1(88), 4-11.
  11. Magarey, S. (2010). 4.'To Demand Equality is to Lack Ambition': Sex discrimination Legislation—Contexts and Contradictions1. Sex Discrimination in Uncertain Times, 93. Chicago
  12. "Equal opportunity getting a fair go: The Raw Deal". Archived from the original on 30 August 2007. Retrieved 8 June 2007.
  13. Smith, Fiona (September 2004). "Bridging the Gap Between Expectation and Reality" (PDF). Equal Opportunity Commission Victoria. Archived from the original (PDF) on 28 September 2007. Retrieved 8 June 2007.
  14. "The Law Report, 6 July 2004". Australian Broadcasting Corporation . Retrieved 8 June 2007.
  15. 1 2 3 Porter, Liz (27 June 2004). "25 years on, pilot fighter lands softly". The Age. Retrieved 8 June 2007.
  16. Ansett Transport Industries (Operations) Pty Ltd v Wardley [1980] HCA 8 , (1980) 142 CLR 237(4 March 1980), High Court.
  17. Scutt, J. A. (2003). Without Precedent-Sex/Gender Discrimination in the High Court. Alternative LJ, 28, 74. Chicago
  18. Smith, Belinda (2008). "From Wardley to Purvis - How Far has Australian Anti-Discrimination Law Come in 30 Years?". Australian Journal of Labour Law. 21: 3 ff. doi:10.2139/ssrn.1005528. SSRN   1005528 . Sydney Law School Research Paper No. 07/55.
  19. Gaze, B. The Sex Discrimination Act at 25: Reflections on the Past, Present and Future. In Thornton, Margaret (editor) (2010) Sex Discrimination in Uncertain Times, ANU E Press, The Australian National University Canberra. p.110
  20. "To celebrate the 25th anniversary of Deborah’s win, the [Equal Opportunity] Commission [invited] Ms Lawrie...to Australia to celebrate 25 years since her historic win. Speaking at the official celebration she said she was surprised at how little had changed since her case attracted international headlines. She said Australia lagged behind European countries in addressing sex discrimination, maternity leave entitlements, sexual harassment and sexist attitudes towards women." Equal Opportunity Commission Annual Report 2003/4 p.15
  21. "25 years on, pilot fighter lands softly". The Age . 27 June 2004. Retrieved 15 March 2023.
  22. Money, Lawrence (25 September 2014). "Pioneer female pilot Deborah Lawrie says mission accomplished in the airline cockpit". The Age . Retrieved 15 March 2023.
  23. "Deborah Lawrie". Her Place Women's Museum. Retrieved 15 March 2023.
  24. "Deborah Jane Lawrie". honours.pmc.gov.au. Retrieved 10 June 2019.
  25. "Women's rights pioneer Deborah Lawrie enters Hall of Fame". Australian Aviation. 18 June 2020.
  26. "'Reg Ansett did not want women on his flight decks': how a trailblazing pilot fought prejudice all the way to the high court". the Guardian. 22 October 2022. Retrieved 22 October 2022.
  27. 1 2 "Australia's first female commercial airline pilot Captain Deborah Lawrie opens Sydney Airport bridge named in her honour". ABC News. 6 November 2023.

Further reading