Monarchism in Brazil

Coat of arms of the House of Orléans-Braganza, the Brazilian imperial family

The movement for the re-adoption of monarchy in Brazil has taken place as a series of uprisings and political acts, usually in a fragmented way and peripherally to larger causes. It has been important historically and remains a fast-growing active movement to this day. It advocates restoration of the constitutional monarchy under the House of Orléans-Braganza, a cadet branch of the House of Braganza, which ruled Brazil for 72 years as the kingdom and later Empire of Brazil until the monarchy was abolished in 1889 by a military coup d'état that gave rise to the First Brazilian Republic.

History

The flag of the Empire of Brazil is widely used by Brazilian monarchists

After the 1889 coup d'état that ended the imperial rule and established a republic in Brazil, the first monarchist nucleus began to form. Under the republican rule, they were a minority and initially even illegal. In 1890, the Brazilian Monarchical Directory was founded by Afonso Celso, the last Prime Minister of the Empire of Brazil in Rio de Janeiro. Its main objective was to organise the country's monarchists and to report directly with the exiled Brazilian Imperial Family.

Monarchist uprisings

The Navy revolt was a rebel movement promoted by units of the Brazilian Navy against the dictatorial government of Floriano Peixoto, supposedly supported by the monarchist opposition to the recent installation of the republic. ^[1] It was part of the Federalist Revolution, led by the monarchist Gaspar da Silveira Martins, one of the last ministers of the Empire of Brazil, who was disaffected by Deodoro da Fonseca.

The Canudos War was the confrontation between the Brazilian Army and the members of a popular movement of socio-religious background led by Antonio Conselheiro that lasted from 1896 to 1897, in the community of Canudos, Bahia. The great farmers of the region, joining the Church, formed a strong pressure group against the newly installed republic, asking that measures be taken against Antônio Conselheiro and his followers. Rumors were created that Canudos was armed to attack neighbouring towns and leave for the capital to depose the republican government and reinstall the monarchy. ^[2]

Another little known event was the Revolt of Ribeirãozinho, a conservative movement that occurred in the city of Ribeirãozinho (now Taquaritinga), in São Paulo. Its fundamental objective was the restoration of the monarchy and the coronation of Prince Luiz of Orléans-Braganza, son of Isabel, Princess Imperial of Brazil. Unhappy with the First Brazilian Republic, the São Paulo monarchists had planned an uprising that was supposed to take place on 23 August 1902, and which was to topple then President Campos Sales. In fact, the uprising had only been carried out in Ribeirãozinho and Espírito Santo do Pinhal, a neighbouring town. This attempt to restore the monarchy lasted one day. ^[3]

Parties and organizations

Pátria-Nova

Founded in 1928, the Brazilian Imperial Patrianovist Action, or simply Patrianovism, was a monarchist organisation present in several Brazilian states that expressed the nationalist and authoritarian ideas of the late 1920s and early 1930s. Idealised by Arlindo Veiga dos Santos, it aimed to establish a new monarchy in Brazil, based on a conservative political philosophy. The movement was linked to Prince Pedro Henrique of Orléans-Braganza, then Head of the Imperial House of Brazil and heir to the throne, as well as Plínio Salgado, leader and founder of the Brazilian Integralist Action.

Diretório Monárquico

Monarchist Institution founded in 1890 by the Viscount of Ouro Preto, the last President of the Council of Ministers in Brazil.

Famous monarchists

Eduardo Prado was a journalist and staunch monarchist who wrote, in 1893, A Ilusão Americana ("American Illusion"), criticising republicans and American imperialism. It was the first literary work to be censored by the newly established republic. Prado is the patron of the National Restorative Union (UNR), a counter-revolutionary and dissident monarchist movement in Brazil.

Many famous personalities in Brazil have declared themselves convicted monarchists.

Among the most famous names are Machado de Assis, Joaquim Nabuco, Baron of Rio Branco, André Rebouças, Viscount of Taunay, João Camilo de Oliveira Torres, Carlos de Laet and Count of Mota Maia.

Some monarchists, however, were victims of the republican regime. Among them is José da Costa Azevedo, the Baron of Ladario, who was shot by an unknown marksman for resisting an arrest warrant during 15 November, surviving only because a student, Carlos Vieira Ferreira, rescued him.

Another little known case is the murder of Colonel Gentil de Castro during the Canudos War. Owner of the monarchist newspapers Gazeta da Tarde and Gazeta da Liberdade, he was shot by unknown attackers in Rio de Janeiro. ^[4]

A list of some notable monarchists by date of birth:

Name	Political party	Occupation	Birth	Death
José Bonifácio de Andrada	None	Statesman	1763	1838
Maria Quitéria	None	Lieutenant	1792	1853
José Paranhos, Viscount of Rio Branco	Conservative Party	Politician	1819	1880
João Lustosa da Cunha Paranaguá, Marquis of Paranaguá	Liberal Party	Politician	1821	1912
Deodoro da Fonseca	None	Politician; marshal	1827	1892
José de Alencar	Conservative Party	Novelist; politician	1829	1877
Antônio Conselheiro	None	Religious leader	1830	1897
Antônio Carlos Gomes	None	Composer	1836	1896
Afonso Celso, Viscount of Ouro Preto	Liberal Party	Politician	1836	1912
André Rebouças	None	Engineer	1838	1898
Machado de Assis	None	Novelist	1839	1908
Joaquim Nabuco	None	Diplomat; politician	1839	1910
José Paranhos, Baron of Rio Branco	Conservative Party	Diplomat; politician	1845	1912
José do Patrocínio	None	Writer; politician	1854	1905
Alberto Santos-Dumont	None	Aeronaut; inventor	1873	1932
José Osvaldo de Meira Penna	None	Diplomat; writer	1917	2017
Ariano Suassuna	None	Playwright; writer	1927	2014
Prince Luiz Gastão of Orléans-Braganza	None	Activist	1938	2022
Prince Bertrand of Orléans-Braganza	None	Activist	born 1941
Olavo de Carvalho	None	Philosopher; Activist	1947	2022
Ayrton Senna	None	Racing driver	1960	1994
Prince Luiz Philippe of Orléans-Braganza	Liberal Party (PL)	Politician; businessman	born 1969
Carla Zambelli	Liberal Party (PL)	Politician	born 1980
Arlindo Veiga dos Santos	AIPB	Writer, politician, poet	1902	1978

Present day

According to the Los Angeles Times , the level of support for a return of monarchy has remained fairly steady with 10.3% in the 1993 referendum and 10.7% in a 2017 survey by pollster Paraná Pesquisas. ^[5]

Luiz Philippe of Orléans-Braganza, nephew of the current Head of the Vasourian pretenders to the Imperial House of Brazil, is known in the Brazilian academical environment.^{[ citation needed ]} He is an active member of liberal movements in the country. ^[6] On 28 February, he announced his pre-candidacy to federal deputy for the state of São Paulo by the New Party. ^[7]

Politically, the movement is still small. In 2016, journalist Paulo Eduardo Martins, known for his monarchist positions, was elected federal deputy. ^[8] The movement now hopes to raise public awareness of the issue and discuss the possibility of a new plebiscite similar to the one of 1993. In early 2017, a legislative idea was launched on the website of the Federal Senate to hold a referendum on the restoration of the monarchy in Brazil. Needing 20,000 votes in favour, it reached the mark of 32,000 votes and was converted into a legislative suggestion, already sent to the Commission of Human Rights of the Brazilian Federal Senate for debate, awaiting a rapporteur. On 10 August 2017, a state deputy from Minas Gerais sent a motion of support to the legislative suggestion to the President of the Senate through the Legislative Assembly of Minas Gerais, although this motion was not subject to a vote by the full membership of the assembly. ^[9] On 14 November 2017, the state of Rondônia did the same by sending a motion to support the referendum proposal for the restoration of the monarchy to the federal senate through its legislative assembly. ^[10]

National "Bandeiraço" of the Independence

In 2015, some Brazilian monarchists started appearing with Brazil's imperial flag in military parades and similar events during Independence Day, an act known as the National "Bandeiraço" of Independence (bandeiraço may be translated as "great flag demonstration"). In 2016, the act was carried out nationally, in 16 cities. In 2017, 34 cities participated. ^[11]

National "Bandeiraço" of the Independence in Anápolis, Goiás, in 7 September 2017.

Pretenders

The most recognised pretender to the Brazilian throne is Prince Bertrand of Orléans-Braganza. He is the head of the called Vassouras branch of the Imperial Family, since it was divided after the resignation of his great-uncle Pedro de Alcântara, Prince of Grão-Pará in 1908. The descendants of Prince Pedro de Alcântara did not accept his resignation and maintained an active claim to the throne until the death of his elder son, Prince Pedro Gastão of Orléans-Braganza in 2007, whose claim passed to his son, Prince Pedro Carlos of Orléans-Braganza, head of the Petrópolis branch. ^[12]

Public opinion

There is no official research on public opinion regarding which form of government is preferred in Brazil. However, the emergence and growth of monarchist activity and organisations throughout the country is visible, especially in anti-government protests. ^[13] Currently, according to an online poll conducted on the Brazilian Senate's website, 93% of the participants expressed support for a referendum on the restoration of the monarchy as a constitutional monarchy. This legislative suggestion has been terminally rejected by the legislative committee responsible for appraising it. ^[14]

Date	Polling organisation	Question	Yes	No	No answer	Ref
4 June 2018	"O Tempo" (Newspaper from Minas Gerais)	"Do you support the restoration of the monarchy in Brazil?"	78%	22%	—	[15]
23 June 2017	Paraná Research Institute	"Would you be for or against the return of the Monarchy in Brazil, or rather, going back to having a King/Queen or an Emperor/Empress?"	10.7%	84.5%	4.7%	[16]
22 June 2017	"Senado Federal" (Official Brazilian senate website)	"Do you support the legislative suggestion to restore constitutional monarchy?"	92.8%	7.2%	—	[17]
21 April 2013	"Portal Terra" (Newspaper)	"From the same ticket used in 1993, you can vote for this virtual plebiscite. Which system of government do you choose?"	82%	18%	—	[18]
21 April 1993	"Federal Government of Brazil" (Federal Law n° 8.624)	"Constitutional Referendum about the Government regime and system"	10.2%	66%	23.7%	[19]

References

1. Smallman; Shall C. Fear & Memory in the Brazilian Army & Society, 1889–1954 The University of North Carolina Press 2002 ISBN   0807853593 Page 20 2nd paragraph
2. Levine, R.M. Vale of Tears: Revisiting the Canudos Massacre in Northeastern Brazil, 1893–1897. University of California Press, 1995
3. "The Revolt of Ribeirãozinho and the return of the monarchy". Taquaritinga On-line. 21 June 2008. Archived from the original on 5 March 2014. Retrieved 24 April 2017.
4. "The Murder of Colonel Gentil de Castro - A Martyr of the Monarchist Cause in Brazil". Instituto Histórico de Petrópolis. 5 August 2005. Retrieved 24 April 2017.
5. Schipani, Andres (6 January 2020). "Royalists pine for days of empire in Bolsonaro's Brazil". Los Angeles Times .
6. "Descendent of the Imperial Family is leader of anti-Dilma group". Folha de S. Paulo. 15 August 2015. Retrieved 24 April 2017.
7. "Sobrinho do Imperador de jure do Brasil é pré-candidato pelo NOVO em SP". Boletim da Liberdade (in Brazilian Portuguese). 28 February 2018. Retrieved 10 March 2018.
8. "The monarchist deputy". Câmara dos Deputados do Brasil. Retrieved 24 April 2017.
9. "Senado Federal - Programa e-Cidadania - Consulta Pública".
10. "Rondônia aprova moção de apoio a proposta de referendo pela restauração da monarquia". Diga Sim a Monaquia. 18 November 2017. Retrieved 18 November 2017.
11. "Bandeiraço de 07 de setembro". Império News (in Brazilian Portuguese). 23 October 2017. Retrieved 10 March 2018.
12. "Imperial Family divided in dispute to the right to the Brazilian throne". Folha de S. Paulo. 6 March 2008. Retrieved 24 April 2017.
13. In the midst of the political crisis, monarchists want emperor in Brazil
14. 92 percent of votes for a legislative suggestion that would restore the Brazilian monarchy
15. Amidst political chaos, monarchists want to reign in Brazil
16. Instituto Paraná Pesquisas
17. 92 percent of Brazilians shows support for the legislative suggestion for the restoration of monarchy
18. 20 years of the plebiscite TV3
19. (in Portuguese) Results at the Brazilian Institute for Monarchy Studies of Rio Grande do Sul Archived 10 December 2010 at the Wayback Machine . Source: Superior Electoral Court.