Numidian language

Last updated

Numidian
Old Libyan
Numidjanska stela3.jpg
Numidian stela with Libyc text in the Bardo National Museum
Native toancient Numidia
RegionMainly modern day Algeria, parts of Tunisia and parts of west Libya (as result of Numidian expansion but with Libyan Berber languages)
Ethnicity Numidians
Extinct Developed into, or replaced with various modern Berber languages in the 3rd century AD [1]
Afro-Asiatic
Early form
Dialects
  • East-Numidian †
  • West-Numidian †
  • ? Mauretanian
  • ? Gaetulian
Libyco-Berber alphabet (Proto-Tifinagh)
Language codes
ISO 639-3 nxm
nxm
Glottolog numi1241

Numidian[ needs IPA ] was a language spoken in ancient Numidia. The script in which it was written, the Libyco-Berber alphabet (from which Tifinagh descended), has been almost fully deciphered and most characters (apart from a few exceptions restricted to specific areas) have known values. Despite this, the language has barely been deciphered and only a few words are known. Libyco-Berber inscriptions are attested from the 3rd century BC to the 3rd century AD. The language is scarcely attested and can be confidently identified only as belonging to the Afroasiatic family, although it was most likely part of the Berber languages, spoken at the start of the breakup of the Proto-Berber language. [2] [3] [4]

Contents

Dialects and relation to other ancient languages

Dialects and foreign influences

It is known that there was an orthographical difference between the western and eastern Numidian language. Starting at Kabylia, which was a kind of mixed region, the regions to the east all the way to what is east of modern day Tunisia and western parts of Libya used the east Libyan writing system, while the regions to the west all the way to approximately the Moulouya river spoke the western Numidian dialect and used the larger and still undecoded west Libyan writing system. [5] The East-Numidian dialect was much more influenced by the Punic language than the West-Numidian, and West-Numidian is thought to be more ancient than East-Numidian. [6] Numidian was influenced mostly by Punic and then Latin, although Numidian and even some modern Berber vocabulary seem to have been also slightly influenced by the Paleohispanic languages and possibly by other Pre-Indo-European languages. [7] [8]

Other ancient Berber or Berber-like languages

Not much is known about the variations of the old Libyc language(s) as none of them have been fully deciphered, and outside of some east-Numidian steles none of the various Old Libyc writings have been interpreted. It may be possible that the language of the neighbouring Mauri people of modern-day Morocco may have been a dialect of the larger Numidian, although there are little to no sources or researches into the language. [9] If Numidian was a Berber language then it is known that by that stage the breakup of Proto-Berber into various Berber languages was still not fully complete, and thus the ancient Berber languages of the time were very similar to each other, even more so than the modern ones. [10] In circa 500 B.C various nomadic Berber groups penetrated the Sahara from the north, corresponding the area of the later Gaetulians. [11] Although the area where these nomads lived yielded no writing and thus is incomparable to Numidian, it is known that Pliny the Elder described the Saharan Gaetulian language as very similar or the same as the Numidian one, implying that the Gaetulian language may have been a dialect of Numidian. [12]

Not much is known of the Numidian language, and even less of Berber or Proto-Berber languages and dialects at this time, although it is known that for example the language of the native Berbers of Cyrenaica contained many Greek loanwords according to Herodotus. [13] It is also unknown whether the language of the neighbouring Kingdom of Mauretania in what is approximately modern day Morocco formed a part of the Numidian language, or was a separate language from it, as there has been as of yet no major efforts into decoding it, and there are no known sources describing it. [9]

Categorization and reconstruction

As the Massylii, who spoke the language, were ethnically Berber, [14] [15] it is supposed that Numidian was therefore a Berber language. [16] The Berber branch of Afro-Asiatic is sometimes called Libyco-Berber since it is not certain whether Numidian would fall within the modern Berber languages or form a sister branch to them. Some theorize that it constituted a group of its own, as there is no trace of the noun-case system shared by the modern Berber languages. [17] However, Proto-Berber is theorized to have no grammatical case either, which would also imply a later addition of the system. The Lybico-Berber tifinagh and the Phoenician alphabet being abjads without vowels complicates the matter even more. [18]

Work on deciphering the language has not been decisive, although especially recently some tried to reconstruct words by comparing Numidian script to proto and modern Berber languages. Most remaining scripts are funerary, and follow the formula of "X w-Y" (X son of Y). BNS is also an often returning words in this script, which probably meant "tomb of". Many words had an H at the end of them, the function of which is unclear. A few gravestones show a different word between the two personal names, plausibly interpreted as a kinship term based on Berber comparisons: wlt "daughter (of)" (modern Berber wəlt), and, more rarely, mt "mother (of)" (modern Tuareg ma). Similar to the modern berber languages, the ta-...-t circumfix signified feminine version of the word with a silent h added to the end. [19] In the Dougga inscriptions some political positions are mentioned, such as "gld" (lord) which based on this technique, can be translated into the modern berber word "agellid" [20] which originates from the proto-berber word "*a-gəllid". A few verbs have been unambiguously identified in the various inscriptions. Comparison with modern Berber suggests that ṣkn, probably read as "eṣ(ə)k-n based on modern berber comparison which means"built" is to be analysed as ṣk "build" plus -n, marking 3pl subject agreement (-ən). [21] [22]

An example of translation using this method can be demonstrated on a part of a Numidian inscription which is read as "Msnsn. gldt. w-gjj." [23] "Msnsn" is the name of king Massinissa while "gldt" is the word for king. Finally, "w-gjj" means "son of Gaia". Thus by attempting to translate the Numidian text through modern and proto-Berber the inscription would read "Massinissa the king, son of Gaia". [24] [22]

Numidian also featured and shared most or all of its prepositions "n" (of) and "d" (and) with modern Berber, along with various prefixes, such as "ta...-t", "m-" etc. with modern Berber. [25]

These facts would strongly suggest that Numidian is a now extinct branch of the Berber languages, although some linguists believe that Numidian is not an ancestor but an extinct sister branch to the modern surviving Berber languages. [17]

If the translations of "SBS" (asebbas) in the Thugga inscription as "year" is correct then that would mean the Proto-Berber form "ww" which evolved into "gg" or "gʷ" in most modern Berber languages was "bb" or "bʷ" in Numidian. This is only found in the Zenaga language of Mauritania and a few instances of Kabyle in modern times [26] . As Zenaga was one of the first Berber languages to split off from the Proto-Berber group and thus still possesses many ancient characteristics, along with the Numidian usage of this form, could suggest that in the evolution of Berber languages "ww" turned into "bʷ" and then into "gʷ".

Naming conventions

Numidian names generally often followed a complicated, but well documented naming convention of Berber antiquity and medieval times. While this wasn't always the case, this was especially true for nobles or higher leaders. The way it worked was simple: Verb in the 3rd person + personal pronouns as an affix (direct or indirect) in 3rd person plural form (he/she-X-they/of them). [27]

For example, the actual name of Jughurta most likely sounded as "y-uger-ten" (he who surpasses them), while the name of king Massinissa (MSNSN in Libyco-Berber) [28] was "mas-nsen" (their seignor). Much of the onomastic work on the Numidian language was done by Salem Chaker, who through his work also help in decoding a few words in the language through dissecting known names. [29]

Known words

Here is a comparison of the few known Numidian words to modern Northern Berber languages and the Tamashek language. Normalized words with vowels added are written in the brackets. Underlined words are based on etymologic or onomastic reconstructions from Numidian names.

Numidian Northern Berber languages Tuareg languages English
Political positions and jobs
GLD (a-gəllid)agellid or a-žellidamănokalchief or king
TGLT(H) (Ta-gəllit)Tagellidt or Tagellittamănokaltqueen
MNKD(H) (amenkad)amenkademperor
MSWH (amsiweɣ?)aserdasəssărdasiPossibly soldier or guard based on linguistic reconstruction
GLDMṢK (a-gellid ameṣka)agellid imeskaamănokal ălbănnaUnknown, corresponds with Punic "chief of fifty", may be reconstructed as "chief of the builders/masons"
NBBN (inababen?)imahalen, yixeddamenimǝsɡuyyaworkers
MWSN(H) (amawsan)amussnawamûssensage or wise man
GẒB (agẓab)Unknown, possibly "inspector of construction"
MṢṢKW (amṣeṣkaw)amasgad, ameṣkadpossibly architect
MS (mass)massmăsshonorary title for men. May be translated as "sir" or "seignor",
MSTN (amastan)amastanamastandefender/protector
Verbs
RN (rna or erna)ernu, erna, or erniernuachieve victory, inflict defeat upon someone
ṢK (eṣk)eṣk or bnukann or dăybuild
YS (yusa)yusa or as-dǝqqălcome or came
DR (idir)idirto live
BDD (bded)bdedto stand
FL (afel?)zgerto cross
Materials
ZLH (uzzal)uzzaltăzoliiron [7]
Š?RH (a-šɣarh?)a-sɣaresăɣerwood
Affixes and prepositions
NS (-ennes)-nnes, -is or -es-ənnesits
N (n)nnof (pertaining to something)
D (d)ddand
-TN (-ten)-ten-santhem
-NSN (-nsen)-nsen-nesǝntheir
y-y-y-he (third person masculine singular verb subject affix)
t-t-t-she (third person feminine singular verb subject affix)
WR (war)urwǝrnot
Kinship terms
W (u- or w-)u-ăw-son of
WLT (wəlt-)wəltwălătdaughter of
MT (mat?)yimma, yemmamamother of
Others
SBS (asəbbas)assewas, assegwas or asseggasawăṭayPossibly year, although Numidian translation is unsure
ẒK (aẓekka)aẓekkaaẓəkkatomb
ugər or agəruger or agaragǝrto surpass
yif or ifif or afufto be superior
MSKR or MSKRH (ameskar or miskiri)Unsure, either cognate to Kabyle and Tuareg word ameskar, [Note 1] or denoting the Misciri tribe

This comparison suggests that Numidian may be closest to the modern Northern Berber languages such as the Zenati languages, Shilha language, and the Kabyle language although the modern northern Berber languages have gone through grammatical changes, and they have also taken loanwords from Arabic, Latin, and French. Kabyle may be the closest to Numidian, but has absorbed loanwords and phrases from the other languages mentioned. [30]

According to many linguists the H at the end of many numidian words were either silent or disappeared by modern times, [31] or that in many cases such as MSWH or MWSNH was possibly used as a replacement for, or possibly was the ancestor of the modern berber ɣ sound. [25]

Thugga inscription

The Thugga inscription is the longest known Numidian inscription as of yet, and has served with the most clues regarding the language.

Numidian script

ṢKN•TBGG•BNYFŠ•MSNSN•GLDṮ•WGYY•GLDṮ•WZLLSN•ŠFṬ

SBSNDH•GLDṮ•SYSH•GLD•MKWSN

ŠFṬ•GLDṮ•WFŠN•MWSNG•ŠNK•WBNY•WŠNK•DŠFṬ•WM

WTNKW•MṢṢKW•MGN•WYRŠTB•WSDYLN•GẒB•MGN•WŠFṬ•MW

WŠMN•GLDṮ•GLDGMYL•ZMR•WMSNF•WŠMN•GLDMṢK•M

WŠYN•GLDṮ•WMGN•GLDṮ•ṬNYN•ŠYN•WNKKN•WFṬŠ•DR

ŠFṬ•WŠNK•

[31]

Normalization and adding of known or possible vowels

əṣk(ə)-n Tubgag BNYFŠ[?] Masnsen a-gəllidṯ u-Gayya a-gəllidṯ u-Zelalsen šufeṭ

Asəbbas NDH a-gəllidṯ(?) s-yusa a-gəllid Mikiwsan [31]

Translation from Punic

The people of Thugga built this temple for Masinissa the King son of Gaia the King son of Zilalsan the Judge, in the tenth year since Micipsa ruled, in the year of Shufet the King son of Afshan the King, The Centurion: Shanok son of Banay and Shufet son of Magon son of Tanaku. The ms s kwy Magon son of Yirashtan son of Sadyalan, and gzby: Magon son of Shufet the Centurion son of Abdeshmun the King. Erectors of this property: Ashyan son of Ankikan son of Patash and Arash son of Shufet son of Shanok.

Example texts

These texts are examples of bilingual inscriptions with known meanings, most of which are funerary texts

The first published sketch of the Ateban inscription The first published sketch of the Bilingual inscription of Dougga (Jean Emile Humbert).jpg
The first published sketch of the Ateban inscription

Bilingual texts

Cenotaph inscription

Punic

[mn]ṣbt š'ṭbn bn ypmṭt bn plw

hbnm š'bnm ʕb'rš bn ʕbdštrt

zmr bn 'ṭbn bn ypmṭt bn plw

mngy bn wrsbn

wb'zrt šl' **t* zzy wṭmn wwrskn

hḥršm šyr msdl bn nnpsn w'nkn b[n] 'šy

hnskm šbrzl špṭ bll wppy bn bby

Punic to English translation

The monument of 'ṭbn son of Ypmṭt son of Plw. 

Builders of the stones: ʕb'rš son of ʕbdštrt;

Zmr son of 'ṭbn son of Ypmṭt son of Plw;

Mngy son of Wrsbn. 

And for its ???, Zzy son of Ṭmn and Wrskn. 

Workers of the wood: Msdl son of Nnpsn and 'nkn son of 'šy.

Casters of the iron: Šfṭ son of Bll and Ppy son of Bby.

Numidian

****N WYFMṬT W*******DRŠ WWDŠTR

*****BN WYFMṬṮ WFLW

MNGY WWRSKN

KSLNS ŻŻY WṬMN WRSKN

NBBN NŠ[Q]RH MSDL WNNFSN NKN WŠY

NB*N NZLH ŠFṬ WBLL FFY WBBY

Normalization and adding of known or possible vowels

Aṭeban w-Yefmaṭat w-Falu****D'rš w-Wadaštar

Zamir w-Aṭeban w-Yefmaṭat w-Falu

Mangy w-Wareskan

KSLNS Żaży w-Ṭaman w-Raskn

inababen n a-šɣarh Masdil w-Nanafsen Naken w-šy

inababen (?) n uzzal Šufeṭ w-Balil Fafy W-Beby [32]

Kef Beni Fredj inscriptions

Latin

SACTUT•IHIMIR F•VIXIT•ANORVM•LXX H[SE]

Latin to English

Sactut son of Ihimir lived 70 years. [He is buried here.]

Numidian

ZKTT WYMR MTYBLH MSWH MNKDH

Normalization and adding of known or possible vowels

Zaktut w-Iymir MTYBLH amsiweɣ amenkad

Possible Numidian to English translation

Zaktut son of Iyimir MTYBLH soldier of the emperor. [25]

See also

Notes

^ Meaning either "the good one" or the "resting one".

Related Research Articles

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Berber languages</span> Family of languages and dialects indigenous to North Africa

The Berber languages, also known as the Amazigh languages or Tamazight, are a branch of the Afroasiatic language family. They comprise a group of closely related but mostly mutually unintelligible languages spoken by Berber communities, who are indigenous to North Africa. The languages are primarily spoken and not typically written. Historically, they have been written with the ancient Libyco-Berber script, which now exists in the form of Tifinagh. Today, they may also be written in the Berber Latin alphabet or the Arabic script, with Latin being the most pervasive.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Tifinagh</span> Abjad of the Tuareg languages

Tifinagh is a script used to write the Berber languages. Tifinagh is descended from the ancient Libyco-Berber alphabet. The traditional Tifinagh, sometimes called Tuareg Tifinagh, is still favored by the Tuareg Berbers of the Sahara desert in southern Algeria, northeastern Mali, northern Niger, and northern Burkina Faso for writing the Tuareg Berber language. Neo-Tifinagh is an alphabet developed by Berber Academy to adopt Tuareg Tifinagh for use with Kabyle; it has been since modified for use across North Africa.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Numidia</span> Berber kingdom in North Africa (202 BC - 46 AD)

Numidia was the ancient kingdom of the Numidians in northwest Africa, initially comprising the territory that now makes up Algeria, but later expanding across what is today known as Tunisia and Libya. The polity was originally divided between the Massylii in the east and the Masaesyli in the west. During the Second Punic War, Masinissa, king of the Massylii, defeated Syphax of the Masaesyli to unify Numidia into the first Berber state in present-day Algeria. The kingdom began as a sovereign state and later alternated between being a Roman province and a Roman client state.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Tuareg languages</span> Group of closely related Berber languages and dialects

The Tuareg languages constitute a group of closely related Berber languages and dialects. They are spoken by the Tuareg Berbers in large parts of Mali, Niger, Algeria, Libya and Burkina Faso, with a few speakers, the Kinnin, in Chad.

Phoenician is an extinct Canaanite Semitic language originally spoken in the region surrounding the cities of Tyre and Sidon. Extensive Tyro-Sidonian trade and commercial dominance led to Phoenician becoming a lingua franca of the maritime Mediterranean during the Iron Age. The Phoenician alphabet spread to Greece during this period, where it became the source of all modern European scripts.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Punic language</span> Extinct ancient Phoenician language

The Punic language, also called Phoenicio-Punic or Carthaginian, is an extinct variety of the Phoenician language, a Canaanite language of the Northwest Semitic branch of the Semitic languages. An offshoot of the Phoenician language of coastal West Asia, it was principally spoken on the Mediterranean coast of Northwest Africa, the Iberian peninsula and several Mediterranean islands, such as Malta, Sicily, and Sardinia by the Punic people, or western Phoenicians, throughout classical antiquity, from the 8th century BC to the 6th century AD.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Kabyle language</span> Berber language of northern Algeria

Kabyle or Kabylian is a Berber language (tamazight) spoken by the Kabyle people in the north and northeast of Algeria. It is spoken primarily in Kabylia, east of the capital Algiers and in Algiers itself, but also by various groups near Blida, such as the Beni Salah and Beni Bou Yaqob.

The Zenati languages are a branch of the Northern Berber language family of North Africa. They were named after the medieval Zenata Berber tribal confederation. They were first proposed in the works of French linguist Edmond Destaing (1915) (1920–23). Zenata dialects are distributed across the central Berber world (Maghreb), from northeastern Morocco to just west of Algiers, and the northern Sahara, from southwestern Algeria around Bechar to Zuwara in Libya. The most widely spoken Zenati languages are Tmazight of the Rif in northern Morocco and Tashawit Berber in northeastern Algeria, each of which have over 3 million speakers.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Numidians</span> Berber people in ancient Northern Africa

The Numidians were the Berber population of Numidia. The Numidians were originally a semi-nomadic people, they migrated frequently as nomads usually do but during certain seasons of the year, they would return to the same camp. The Numidians soon became more than pastoralists and started to engage in more urban professions. The Numidians were one of the earliest Berber tribes to trade with Carthaginian settlers. As Carthage grew, the relationship with the Numidians blossomed. Carthage's military used the Numidian cavalry as mercenaries. Numidia provided some of the highest quality cavalry of the Second Punic War, and the Numidian cavalry played a key role in several battles, both early on in support of Hannibal and later in the war after switching allegiance to the Roman Republic. Numidian culture flourished between the end of the Second Punic War and around the Roman conquest, with Massinissa as the first king of a unified Numidia.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Roger Blench</span> British linguist, ethnomusicologist and anthropologist

Roger Marsh Blench is a British linguist, ethnomusicologist and development anthropologist. He has an M.A. and a Ph.D. from the University of Cambridge and is based in Cambridge, England. He researches, publishes, and works as a consultant.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Ancient Libya</span> Region west of the Nile Valley

During the Iron Age and classical antiquity, Libya referred to modern-day Africa west of the Nile river. Greek and Roman geographers placed the dividing line between Libya/Africa and Asia at the Nile.

The traditional Berber religion is the ancient and native set of beliefs and deities adhered to by the Berbers. Many ancient Berber beliefs were developed locally, whereas others were influenced over time through contact with others like ancient Egyptian religion, or borrowed during antiquity from the Punic religion, Judaism, Iberian mythology, and the Hellenistic religion. Some of the ancient Berber beliefs still exist today subtly within the Berber popular culture and tradition. Syncretic influences from the traditional Berber religion can also be found in certain other faiths.

The Berber Latin alphabet is the version of the Latin alphabet used to write the Berber languages. It was adopted in the 19th century, using varieties of letters.

The Massylii or Maesulians were a Berber federation in eastern Numidia, which was formed by an amalgamation of smaller tribes during the 4th century BC. They were ruled by a king. On their loosely defined western frontier were the powerful Masaesyli. To their east lay the territory of the rich and powerful Carthaginian Republic. Their relationship to Carthage resembled that of a protectorate. Carthage maintained its dominance over the Massylii by skillful diplomatic manoeuvering, playing off local tribal and kingdom rivalries. The principal towns of the Massylii were Cirta, Tébessa and Thugga in modern-day Algeria and Tunisia.

Proto-Berber or Proto-Libyan is the reconstructed proto-language from which the modern Berber languages descend. Proto-Berber was an Afroasiatic language, and thus its descendant Berber languages are cousins to the Egyptian language, Cushitic languages, Semitic languages, Chadic languages, and the Omotic languages.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Jerba Berber</span> Berber language of Tunisia

Tamazight of Djerba, Shilha of Djerba, Djerbi or Djerbian is a Berber language of the Eastern Maghreb, spoken on the island of Djerba, in Tunisia. It is a component of what is regularly denominated Tunisian "Shilha" or "Chelha" in the south of the country.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Berber orthography</span> Writing systems for the Berber languages

Berber orthography is the writing system(s) used to transcribe the Berber languages.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Punic-Libyan bilinguals</span> Two important ancient inscriptions from Dougga, Tunisia

The Punic-Libyan bilingual inscriptions are two important ancient bilingual inscriptions dated to the 2nd century BC.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Mastanabal</span> King of Numidia

Mastanabal was one of three legitimate sons of Masinissa, the King of Numidia, a Berber kingdom in, present day Algeria, North Africa. The three brothers were appointed by Scipio Aemilianus Africanus to rule Numidia after Masinissa's death.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Libyco-Berber alphabet</span> Abjad writing system

The Libyco-Berber alphabet or the Libyc alphabet is an abjad writing system that was used during the first millennium BC by various Berber peoples of North Africa and the Canary Islands, to write ancient varieties of the Berber language like the Numidian language in ancient North Africa.

References

  1. "Berbère". Archived from the original on 24 January 2015. Retrieved 1 May 2024. c. 200 BC.
  2. Daniels, Peter T.; Bright, William (1996). The World's Writing Systems. Oxford University Press. ISBN   978-0-19-507993-7.
  3. Güldemann, Tom (10 September 2018). The Languages and Linguistics of Africa. Walter de Gruyter GmbH & Co KG. ISBN   978-3-11-042175-0.
  4. Woodard, Roger D. (10 April 2008). The Ancient Languages of Syria-Palestine and Arabia. Cambridge University Press. ISBN   978-1-139-46934-0.
  5. Chaker, S. (1 January 2008). "Libyque : écriture et langue". Encyclopédie berbère (in French) (28–29): 4395–4409. doi: 10.4000/encyclopedieberbere.344 . ISSN   1015-7344. S2CID   161729616.
  6. Chaker, Salem (2002). "Variétés des usages libyques : variations chronologiques, géographiques et sociales". Antiquités africaines. 38 (1): 267–273. doi:10.3406/antaf.2002.1360.
  7. 1 2 Kossmann, Maarten (2013). The Arabic Influence on Northern Berber. BRILL. ISBN   978-90-04-25309-4.
  8. Iglesias, Hector (2011). "La parenté de la langue berbère et du basque: nouvelle approche". Archive ouverte HAL (in French). Retrieved 15 November 2023.
  9. 1 2 Rask, Rasmus (15 April 2013). Investigation of the Origin of the Old Norse or Icelandic Language: New edition of the 1993 English translation by Niels Ege. John Benjamins Publishing. ISBN   978-90-272-7198-3.
  10. Blench, Roger. "Reconciling archaeological and linguistic evidence for Berber prehistory". Academia.edu. Archived from the original on 7 May 2023.
  11. Gatto, M. C.; Mattingly, D. J.; Ray, N.; Sterry, M. (14 February 2019). Burials, Migration and Identity in the Ancient Sahara and Beyond. Cambridge University Press. ISBN   978-1-108-47408-5.
  12. "Pliny the Elder, The Natural History, BOOK I.1, DEDICATION. 1 Lemaire informs us, in his title-page, that the two first books of the Natural History are edited by M. Alexandre, in his edition". www.perseus.tufts.edu. Retrieved 2 May 2022.
  13. "Hérodote : livre IV : Melpomène (bilingue)". remacle.org. Retrieved 11 April 2022.
  14. Jamil M. Abun-Nasr (20 August 1987). A History of the Maghrib in the Islamic Period. Cambridge University Press. p. 15. ISBN   978-1-316-58334-0.
  15. Phillip C. Naylor (7 May 2015). Historical Dictionary of Algeria. Rowman & Littlefield Publishers. p. 132. ISBN   978-0-8108-7919-5.
  16. Steven Roger Fischer (4 April 2004). History of Writing. Reaktion Books. p. 104. ISBN   978-1-86189-588-2.
  17. 1 2 Robert Martin Kerr, 2010
  18. Pereltsvaig, Asya (3 September 2020). Languages of the World. Cambridge University Press. ISBN   978-1-108-47932-5.
  19. Nehmé, Laïla; Al-Jallad, Ahmad (20 November 2017). To the Madbar and Back Again: Studies in the languages, archaeology, and cultures of Arabia dedicated to Michael C.A. Macdonald. BRILL. ISBN   978-90-04-35761-7.
  20. Maddy-Weitzman, Bruce (1 May 2011). The Berber Identity Movement and the Challenge to North African States. University of Texas Press. ISBN   978-0-292-74505-6.
  21. "Libyco-Berber". mnamon.sns.it. Retrieved 12 February 2022.
  22. 1 2 Daniels, Peter T.; Bright, William (1996). The World's Writing Systems. Oxford University Press. ISBN   978-0-19-507993-7.
  23. Jensen, Hans (1969). Sign, Symbol, and Script: An Account of Man's Efforts to Write. Putnam.
  24. "Libyan' Inscriptions in Numidia and Mauretania". World History Encyclopedia. Retrieved 12 February 2022.
  25. 1 2 3 Chaker, Salem (1995). Linguistique berbère: études de syntaxe et de diachronie (in French). Peeters Publishers. ISBN   978-2-87723-152-7.
  26. "porta". Diccionari Amazic-Català (in Catalan). Retrieved 25 May 2024.
  27. Camps, G.; Chaker, S. (1 May 2004). "Jugurtha". Encyclopédie berbère (in French) (26): 3975–3979. doi: 10.4000/encyclopedieberbere.1377 . ISSN   1015-7344.
  28. Jongeling, Karel (1984). Names in Neo-Punic Inscriptions. Rijksuniversiteit te Groningen.
  29. Chaker, Salem (1 June 2013). "Onomastique libyco-berbère (Anthroponymie)". Encyclopédie berbère (in French) (35): 5760–5779. doi: 10.4000/encyclopedieberbere.2816 . ISSN   1015-7344.
  30. Cust, Robert Needham (15 October 2013). A Sketch of the Modern Languages of Africa: Volume I. Routledge. ISBN   978-1-136-37237-7.
  31. 1 2 3 Souag, Lameen (2011). Re-examining Libyco-Berber: how much do we know, and how does it fit into the family's subclassification?. Lameen Souag.
  32. "Libyco-Berber - Examples of writing". mnamon.sns.it. Retrieved 14 March 2022.