Reindorf Review

Last updated

The Reindorf Review was a 2021 article published by the University of Essex and authored by barrister Akua Reindorf surrounding concerns of a suppression of academic freedom due to the de-platforming and blacklisting of academics Jo Phoenix and Rosa Freedman who had expressed "gender critical" views. [1]

Contents

The university issued a public apology to both academics and was subject to review their internal policy regarding inviting speakers in the future.

Background

On 5 December 2019, Jo Phoenix was invited to the University of Essex to hold a public seminar entitled "Trans rights, imprisonment and the criminal justice system" in which she was scheduled to discuss the possible tensions that would follow from the integration of transgender individuals into single sex prison systems. [2] Backlash followed as credible threats of violence from students and staff accused Phoenix of transphobia. A flyer of a person brandishing a weapon displayed the text "Shut the fuck up, TERF." was posted round the university campus. The initial cancellation of the event was seen to be justified due to security concerns due to the threats of violence. However, following the cancellation, the sociology department blacklisted Phoenix from future talks on concerns of transphobia. This was deemed to be an illegal exercise as it limited Phoenix's freedom of expression. Since the University of Essex is a public authority it has an duty to uphold the right to free expression and thus the blacklisting was not considered to be held on credible grounds. [3] The Reindorf Report states that "The later decision to exclude and blacklist Prof Phoenix was also unlawful. There was no reasonable basis for thinking that Prof Phoenix would engage in harassment or any kind of unlawful speech. The decision was unnecessary and disproportionate. Moreover the violent flyer was wholly unacceptable and should have been the subject of a timely disciplinary investigation." [4]

On 30 January 2020, a roundtable discussion entitled "The State of Antisemitism Today" Rosa Freedman was subject to disinvitation due to 'spurious' and 'non-evidenced' allegations of transphobia. [5] The allegation followed due to concerns over a 2018 open letter by Freedman and 54 other academics on the culture of fear surrounding the conducting of research into transgender issues. This was during a time where changes where being proposed to the Gender Recognition Act which were the topic of debate as it was considered to be a possible conflict towards academic freedom and scientific integrity. [6] Research into transgenderism has been considered to be important as the subject of "no-debate" limits perspectives necessary to provide support to transgender adolescents. The current lack of empirical evidence with which to draw effective support from is said to be dangerous to transgender people and women (who are more often the subject of a disproportionate number allegations of transphobia) as well as emboldening transphobic right-wing ideology as counterarguments are unable to be explored due to pressures to self-censor research proposals. [7] [8] Professor Freedman attended the event on 30 January following an internal investigation by the University of Essex who concluded that there were insufficient grounds to bar Freedman from attending the event. [9]

Aftermath

Debates on academic freedom have continued with the Reindorf Report being an example of how university institutions prevent research into politically sensitive issues and how this impacts science as a whole. [7] The Higher Education (Freedom of Speech) Bill 2021 and the Higher Education Authority (HEA) Bill 2022 are of particular contemporary interest, cited by supporters as a vital step to ensuring the credible enforcement of free speech on university campuses, [10] while others claim it represents government overreach. [11]

Stonewall, a charity named after the Stonewall riots of 1969, have begun to be questioned by academics and scholars due to their potentially undemocratic and self-defeating influence in universities due to their continued lobbying efforts which have direct impacts on internal policy within universities. [12] Stonewall has been critiqued for its effective use of 'policy capture' which sees it having disproportionate influence on the legal categories of sex and gender without proper democratic scrutiny. [13] [14]

The Free Speech Union has pledged to commit to legal disputes with universities who do not uphold their duties towards freedom of speech. [15]

See also

Related Research Articles

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Transphobia</span> Anti-transgender prejudice

Transphobia consists of negative attitudes, feelings, or actions towards transgender people or transness in general. Transphobia can include fear, aversion, hatred, violence or anger towards people who do not conform to social gender roles. Transphobia is a type of prejudice and discrimination, similar to racism, sexism, or ableism, and it is closely associated with homophobia. Transgender people of color can experience many different forms of discrimination simultaneously.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Stonewall (charity)</span> UK-based charity and advocacy group for LGBT rights

Stonewall Equality Limited, trading as Stonewall, is a lesbian, gay, bisexual and transgender (LGBT) rights charity in the United Kingdom. It is the largest LGBT rights organisation in Europe.

The following outline is provided as an overview of and topical guide to transgender topics.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Violence against transgender people</span> Violence or victimization against transgender people

Violence against transgender people includes emotional, physical, sexual, or verbal violence targeted towards transgender people. The term has also been applied to hate speech directed at transgender people and at depictions of transgender people in the media that reinforce negative stereotypes about them. Trans and non-binary gender adolescents can experience bashing in the form of bullying and harassment. When compared to their cisgender peers, trans and non-binary gender youth are at increased risk for victimisation, which has been shown to increase their risk of substance abuse.

The Sylvia Rivera Law Project (SRLP) is a legal aid organization based in New York City at the Miss Major-Jay Toole Building for Social Justice that serves low-income or people of color who are transgender, intersex and/or gender non-conforming. The organization was formed in August 2002 by attorney and transgender civil rights activist, Dean Spade. The project was named for Sylvia Rivera, a transgender activist and veteran of the 1969 Stonewall Riots, who died the same year that SRLP was formed.

The Equality and Human Rights Commission (EHRC) is a non-departmental public body in Great Britain, established by the Equality Act 2006 with effect from 1 October 2007. The Commission has responsibility for the promotion and enforcement of equality and non-discrimination laws in England, Scotland and Wales. It took over the responsibilities of the Commission for Racial Equality, the Equal Opportunities Commission and the Disability Rights Commission. The EHRC also has responsibility for other aspects of equality law: age, sexual orientation and religion or belief. A national human rights institution, it seeks to promote and protect human rights throughout Great Britain.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Transgender Europe</span>

Transgender Europe (TGEU) is a network of different organisations working to combat discrimination against trans people and support trans people rights. It was founded in 2005 in Vienna during the 1st European Transgender Council as "European Transgender Network" and it is currently a registered NGO as "Transgender Europe".

Feminist views on transgender topics vary widely.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Outline of LGBT topics</span> Overview of and topical guide to LGBT topics

The following outline offers an overview and guide to LGBT topics.

Selina Todd is an English historian and writer. From 2015, she has been Professor of Modern History at the University of Oxford. Todd's research focuses on the history of the working-class, women and feminism in modern Britain. Since 2017, Todd has also been president of the Socialist Educational Association.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Transgender rights in the United Kingdom</span>

Transgender rights in the United Kingdom have varied significantly over time, with transgender Britons facing many issues not experienced by non-trans individuals. These include various laws and public attitudes in regards to identity documents, as well as anti-discrimination measures used by or pertaining to transgender people, in the areas of employment, education, housing and social services, amongst others.

Rosa Anne Freedman, who has written as Rosa Davis, is a British professor of law, conflict, and global development at the University of Reading. Her principal area of research is the activities of the United Nations as they relate to human rights. She has given evidence before the Foreign Affairs Select Committee of the House of Commons of the United Kingdom about the human rights work of the Foreign and Commonwealth Office, and to the Scottish Government relating to gender questions on the national census.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Kathleen Stock</span> British analytical philosopher and writer

Kathleen Mary Linn Stock is a British philosopher and writer. She was a professor of philosophy at the University of Sussex until 2021. She has published academic work on aesthetics, fiction, imagination, sexual objectification, and sexual orientation.

The LGB Alliance is a British nonprofit advocacy group founded in 2019, in opposition to the policies of LGBT rights charity Stonewall on transgender issues. Its founders are Bev Jackson, Kate Harris, Allison Bailey, Malcolm Clark and Ann Sinnott. The organisation has said that lesbians are facing "extinction" because of the "disproportionate" focus on transgender identities in schools.

Allison Elaine Bailey is a retired barrister who specialised in criminal defence law and worked in London, England. Bailey initiated an employment tribunal claim against her legal chambers and Stonewall in 2020. The case has attracted public and media attention, particularly in relation to the Diversity Champions programme. She announced her retirement from the Bar and resignation from her chambers on her website effective 31 March 2023.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Debbie Hayton</span> Transgender British teacher and political activist

Debbie Hayton is a British secondary school science teacher and political activist.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Transgender Trend</span> British pressure group

Transgender Trend is an anti-trans British pressure group, which describes itself as a group of parents, professionals and academics who are concerned about the number of children diagnosed with gender dysphoria. It was founded in 2015 by Stephanie Davies-Arai.

Joanna Phoenix is an academic author and professor of criminology in the United Kingdom. Phoenix writes about the policies and laws which surround various sexual activities and the social conditions which underpin them.

Gender-critical feminism, also known as trans-exclusionary radical feminism or TERFism, is an ideology or movement that opposes what it refers to as "gender ideology": the concept of gender identity and transgender rights, especially gender self-identification. Gender-critical feminists believe that sex is biological and immutable, while believing gender, including both gender identity and gender roles, to be inherently oppressive. They reject the concept of transgender identities. These views have been described as transphobic by feminist and scholarly critics, and are opposed by many feminist and LGBT rights organizations.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">FiLiA</span> British gender-critical feminist charity

FiLiA is a British gender-critical feminist charity founded in 2015 that describes itself as part of the women's liberation movement. FiLiA organizes a conference, held first in 2008 as Feminism in London, in different cities, which it now describes as the "largest annual grassroots feminist conference in Europe". FiLiA is gender-critical, and states that it supports "sex-based rights" and opposes what they refer to as "gender ideology." It has lobbied against gender recognition reform and considers gender self-identification a threat to "women's protected rights." Critics describe it as anti-transgender and transphobic. FiLiA is critical of the sex industry and as a result, it considers pornography harmful. It has campaigned on behalf of women internationally, and as a result, it has held its campaigns in countries such as Iran, Cyprus, and Kenya. It has been described as one of "the most important 'gender critical' groups" alongside Women's Declaration International. FiLiA has faced protests and attempted cancellations, notably in 2023 when the venue Platform attempted to cancel the conference due to alleged transphobia.

References

  1. ↑ "The Reindorf Review: a wake up call for universities". SexMatters. 23 June 2021. Retrieved 25 September 2022.
  2. ↑ Reindorf, Akua (2021). Review of the circumstances resulting in and arising from the cancellation of the Centre for Criminology seminar on Trans Rights, Imprisonment and the Criminal Justice System, scheduled to take place on 5 December 2019, and the arrangements for speaker invitations to the Holocaust Memorial Week event on the State of Antisemitism Today, scheduled for 30 January 2020 (Report). p. 3.
  3. ↑ Reindorf, Akua (2021). Review of the circumstances resulting in and arising from the cancellation of the Centre for Criminology seminar on Trans Rights, Imprisonment and the Criminal Justice System, scheduled to take place on 5 December 2019, and the arrangements for speaker invitations to the Holocaust Memorial Week event on the State of Antisemitism Today, scheduled for 30 January 2020 (Report). p. 40.
  4. ↑ Reindorf, Akua (2021). Review of the circumstances resulting in and arising from the cancellation of the Centre for Criminology seminar on Trans Rights, Imprisonment and the Criminal Justice System, scheduled to take place on 5 December 2019, and the arrangements for speaker invitations to the Holocaust Memorial Week event on the State of Antisemitism Today, scheduled for 30 January 2020 (Report). p. 1.
  5. ↑ Griffiths, Sian (26 January 2020). "Lawyer demands inquiry into trans 'gag' by university". The Sunday Times.
  6. ↑ Kathleen Stock; et al. (16 October 2018). "Academics are being harassed over their research into transgender issues". The Guardian.
  7. 1 2 Suissa, Judith; Sullivan, Alice. "How can universities promote academic freedom? Insights from the front line of the gender wars". Impact: Philosophical Perspectives on Education Policy (27): 12–17, 25–33.
  8. ↑ Fazackerley, Anna (30 October 2018). "UK universities struggle to deal with 'toxic' trans rights row". The Guardian.
  9. ↑ Reindorf, Akua (2021). Review of the circumstances resulting in and arising from the cancellation of the Centre for Criminology seminar on Trans Rights, Imprisonment and the Criminal Justice System, scheduled to take place on 5 December 2019, and the arrangements for speaker invitations to the Holocaust Memorial Week event on the State of Antisemitism Today, scheduled for 30 January 2020 (Report). p. 39.
  10. ↑ Clarence-Smith, Louisa (2 December 2022). "University free speech at risk if education Bill weakened, warns professor". The Telegraph.
  11. ↑ Casey, Jess (19 September 2022). "Higher Education Bill 'essentially a Government takeover of academia', researchers warn". Irish Examiner.
  12. ↑ Doyle, Andrew (30 July 2022). "How Stonewall turned against gay rights". Sp!ked.
  13. ↑ Biggs, M (2020). "The transition from sex to gender in English prisons: human rights and queer theory". SocArXiv Papers.
  14. ↑ Murray, K; Blackburn, L.H.; MacKenzie, L (2020). "Reform under the radar? Lessons for Scotland from the development of gender self-declaration laws in Europe" (PDF). Edinburgh Law Review. 24 (2): 281–289. doi:10.3366/elr.2020.0634. S2CID   219426805.
  15. ↑ Morgan, John (7 June 2022). "Free Speech Union legal pressure forces Essex harassment changes". Times Higher Education.
This page is based on this Wikipedia article
Text is available under the CC BY-SA 4.0 license; additional terms may apply.
Images, videos and audio are available under their respective licenses.