Robert Roche (activist)

Last updated
Robert Roche
Born (1947-05-03) May 3, 1947 (age 75) [1] [2]
Nationality American
Occupation Civil rights organizer
Years active1973present
OrganizationThe American Indian Education Center
People, Not Mascots
Autonomous American Indian Movement (AAIM)
Known forChairman and Executive Director of the American Indian Education Center of Cleveland (now run by Jeffrey Pierce)
Opposition to Chief Wahoo and other Native American mascots

Robert Roche, also known as Bob Roche and Rob Roche, is an activist for Native American civil rights. He is perhaps best known for being one of several prominent American Indians to spearhead the movement against the use of Native American imagery as sports mascots.

Contents

Early life

Robert Roche was born Robert Joseph Roche on 3 May 1947 at Saint Ann's Hospital located in Cleveland, Ohio. [2] He would end up meeting Russell Means, a well-known actor, civil rights activist and founder of the Cleveland branch of the American Indian Movement. He would profoundly influence a young Roche, and the two would go on to collaborate on many projects.

Career

From 1974 to 1984, Roche worked in the City of Cleveland Juvenile Court Division as an Acting Probation Officer. During this time, he worked with indigenous youth who had come in contact with and were already in the juvenile justice system. [3] [4] In 1995, Robert Roche founded the American Indian Education Center, a non-profit organization that offered a variety of re-entry services for the American Indian population in the greater Greater Cleveland area, including HIV testing, tutoring, smoking cessation classes, cultural programming and resume writing instruction. [5] in Cleveland, Ohio. [6] Roche opened the American Indian Education Center to provide a more comprehensive variety of services after the two decades of controversy its "predecessor," the Cleveland American Indian Center, founded by Russell Means, had been embroiled in. [5] in Cleveland, Ohio. [7]
Robert currently serves as the executive director of the American Indian Education Center [5] in Cleveland, Ohio. [8] Some of the work he carried out was documented in a book written by attorney Joseph Patrick Meissner as part of a compendium of accounts focusing on people who work to improve their community. [9] Robert Roche has also taught a course in Oberlin College's Experimental College Department about the history of the Native American civil rights organization, the American Indian Movement. [10]

Activism

Roche was an active member of the Cleveland branch of the Autonomous American Indian Movement (AAIM) until January 2020, [8] [11] [12] [13] a separate division of the American Indian Movement.

Robert Roche has been a highly visible figure on the Cleveland scene for many decades, periodically using his role as a leader in the community to act as a character witness. [14] He provided testimony in the clemency hearing for Billy Slagle, who was convicted of aggravated murder with death penalty specifications after, in 1987, he stabbed babysitter Mari Anne Pope to death while the children she was babysitting watched. [15] In the appeal, Roche explained that Slagle, whose mother was Native American, visited the American Indian Education Center with his family as a child. Roche recalled alcohol abuse and violence were prominent fixtures in Slagle's home and believed Slagle would have been incapable of murder if it were not his addictions. [16]

Roche worked to raise awareness for Cleveland kidnapping victim Amanda Berry, who is part Native American, by writing letters to the city police department and holding candlelight vigils for her. [17]

Roche engaged in annual protests against Cleveland Indians mascot Chief Wahoo since 1973. [18] [19] He also founded the group "People, Not Mascots", a cohort which is dedicated to raise awareness against the use of a race of people as mascots and end the current use of offensive Native American imagery. [20] As he explained, "We are not mascots. I'm nobody's mascot. My children are not mascots. "It mocks us as a race of people. It mocks our religion." [21] Roche's protest at the Indians' 2014 home opener went viral when local blogger Peter Pattakos, who had hoped to film an argument for an anti-Chief Wahoo documentary, instead staged a confrontation by goading Pedro Rodriguez, a Latino fan wearing red face paint and a fake feather headdress, into approaching Roche on camera. [22] [23] [24] [25] [26] [27] [28] [29]

On 25 June 2014, major news media outlets began reporting that Robert Roche would file a lawsuit against the Cleveland Indians organization in July. [30] Roche would be suing the team in excess of $9 billion. [31] According to Roche, compensation would be sought based on the length of time and exploitation which has occurred from the use of the mascot. [32] "We're going to be asking for $9 billion and we're basing it on a hundred years of disparity, racism, exploitation and profiteering," Roche said. "It's been offensive since day one. We are not mascots. My children are not mascots. We are people." [33]

Criticism

Robert Roche has been the subject of criticism from some members within the Cleveland Native American community. Philip Joseph Yenyo, who has claimed at various time to be Cherokee Indian or Aztec Indian, [34] protester, and member of the American Indian Movement of Ohio, [35] claimed that Roche had constructed a false identity, claiming to have a birth certificate which reveals that Robert Roche was really Jose Roche. [2] However, when asked to validate the nature of the injurious claims, Yenyo was unable to substantiate his accusations with material evidence. [2] Roche has also been accused by members of the Native American community of using the Center as a platform for himself while failing to provide a consistent regimen of services. [6] Roche was also asked by one of the founders of the original American Indian Movement to stop identifying himself as a member of the organization. According to Vernon Bellecourt, Robert Roche had never been an AIM representative in Ohio. "We have known for some time that he was invoking the name of AIM," Bellcourt said. "We feel if people are doing good work in our name, it's OK. But that is not the case with Roche. We received complaints about him from leaders of the Indian community, and that was enough to cause us to issue the letter." Despite identifying himself as a representative of the Autonomous America Indian Movement, Roche would also state that he was representative or executive director of Cleveland AIM, even doing so in a resume where he describes himself as an "appointed American Indian Movement executive director - Cleveland Ohio, 1994-present." [11]

There have also questions raised about the use of grant funds allocated to the American Indian Education Center Roche operates. The Ohio Attorney General's Office launched an investigation into the use of the Center's finances following a 2013 anonymous complaint that alleged the American Indian Education Center mishandled the grant money it had been appropriated, and the fact Roche paid $153,00.00 in salary and benefits to himself that year, according to the tax filing. [6] Closer examination to the available financial records, however, showed that Roche paid himself in relative proportion of grant funding allocated to the organization. In 2012, the American Indian Education Center received $650,000.00 in grant funding, an elevated increase in comparison from previous years. This was due largely to a Department of Education grant aimed at improving education for impoverished and underprivileged kids. In 2011, when the center was allocated $235,000.00 in grant funding, Roche paid himself only $37,000.00. Prior to that year, in 2010, when the Center was allocated $42,000.00 in grants, Roche, who served as the executive director, and the sole full-time employee on staff (who also worked seven days a week), paid himself only $12,000.00. During that same year, he also wrote a $16,000.00 loan for the center. On the tax filing, under "purpose," it read: "Keep Center Open." [36]

New details into the mismanagement of money allocated to the American Indian Education Center have slowly emerged. It was revealed that the inspector general for the U.S. Department of Health and Human Services also launched an independent investigation into the American Indian Education Center. According to the Substance Abuse and Mental Health Services Administration (SAMHSA) starting in 2011. The Substance Abuse and Mental Health Services Administration, which is a branch of the U.S. Department of Health, had provided thousands of dollars to the American Indian Education Center from 2011 onwards. However, due to the placement of a "high risk restriction" on the Center, access to the SAMHSA grant money was on a limited basis. The investigation also cites the lack of proper financial management to administer the federal grant. The probe has also identified certain irregularities into the expenditure of funds provided by the SAMHSA. These irregularities included the $136,000.00 salary Roche paid himself in 2012, which did not appear to be concordant with wages supplied in grant documentation provided by the American Indian Education Center, the flat fees paid to the center's grant writer, McGuire & Associates, are inconsistent with standard practice, and the Center's bylaws giving Roche governing authority and control over his board of directors, are not in keeping with federal guidelines, which state that the board should operate independently of its director. There are also matters of personnel costs, related taxes and fringe benefit payments that The Substance Abuse and Mental Health Services Administration is looking into. [37]

One grant received by the American Indian Education Center received in 2012 carried over into 2013. However, the grant was terminated by the grantor, the Ohio Department of Education, which decided that the program being funded by the grant was ineffective. Roche also made an attempt to open a second education center for American Indian people in the city of Columbus, Ohio in spite of financial difficulties faced during 2012. Although he cited poor health and financial difficulties, Roche registered a 1989 Jaguar in the "unfinished" Columbus Center's name in December 2012. According to Roche, he donated the car to the center, where he plans to raffle the vehicle in the name of American Indian services. [37]

Embezzlement

Prior to his August 2018 indictment, Roche had been under investigation from the Department of Health and Human Services for several years. Investigators found Roche to have conspired with consultant Craig McGuire, whose company wrote grant applications, to steal the Circle of Care grant money. In April 2017, McGuire had pled guilty to conspiracy and theft of government funds. [38]

Investigators said Roche worked with consultant Craig McGuire to steal Circle of Care grant money. According to Roche's indictment, the two secured grants meant to support the mental health and wellness programs for American Indian and Alaskan families and children. McGuire, whose company wrote grant applications, pleaded guilty in April 2017 to conspiracy and theft of government funds. [39]

Roche and consultant Craig McGuire conspired to divert money from the American Indian Education Center. Investigators say McGuire submitted false applications to the federal Substance Abuse and Mental Health Services Administration (SAMHSA). According to prosecutors, McGuire falsely claimed that the center offered an afterschool program for 500 children and had a "wellness department." [40]

On 16 May 2018, Cleveland.com reported that Roche pled guilty to two counts of theft of government funds for stealing $77,000 in federal grant money meant from the Substance Abuse and Mental Health Services Administration grant money to improve the well-being of American Indians and Alaskan Natives living in Northeast Ohio. [39] Roche was sentenced with four months in prison followed by four months of home confinement. Roche was also ordered by the judge to pay $77,000 in restitution, the amount he was accused of stealing. [38]

Roche claimed he was in the early stages of dementia. [39]

See also

Related Research Articles

Cleveland Guardians Major League Baseball franchise in Cleveland, Ohio

The Cleveland Guardians are an American professional baseball team based in Cleveland. The Guardians compete in Major League Baseball (MLB) as a member club of the American League (AL) Central division. Since 1994, they have played at Progressive Field. Since their establishment as a Major League franchise in 1901, the team has won 10 Central division titles, six American League pennants, and two World Series championships,. The team's World Series championship drought since 1948 is the longest active among all 30 current Major League teams. The team's name references the Guardians of Traffic, eight monolithic 1932 Art Deco sculptures by Henry Hering on the city's Hope Memorial Bridge, which is adjacent to Progressive Field. The team's mascot is named "Slider." The team's spring training facility is at Goodyear Ballpark in Goodyear, Arizona.

American Indian Movement United States civil rights organization

The American Indian Movement (AIM) is a Native American grassroots movement founded in July 1968 in Minneapolis, Minnesota, initially centered in urban areas to address systemic issues of poverty, discrimination, and police brutality against Native Americans. AIM soon widened its focus from urban issues to include many Indigenous Tribal issues that Native American groups have faced due to settler colonialism of the Americas. These have included treaty rights, high rates of unemployment, Native American education, cultural continuity, and preservation of Indigenous cultures.

Chief Illiniwek Former mascot of the University of Illinois Urbana-Champaign

Chief Illiniwek was the mascot of the University of Illinois Urbana–Champaign (UIUC), associated with the University's intercollegiate athletic programs, from October 30, 1926 to February 21, 2007. Chief Illiniwek was portrayed by a student to represent the Illiniwek, the state's namesake, although the regalia worn was from the Sioux. The student portraying Chief Illiniwek performed during halftime of Illinois football and basketball games, as well as during women's volleyball matches.

Chief Moccanooga was the former athletic mascot for the University of Tennessee at Chattanooga, until 1996, when the university abandoned the mascot as potentially offensive at the request of the Chattanooga InterTribal Association. Chief Moccanooga was replaced with a mockingbird, the state bird of Tennessee, and the nickname for Chattanooga athletics was changed from 'Moccasins' to simply 'Mocs'.

Charlene Teters American painter

Charlene Teters is a Native American artist, educator, and lecturer. Her paintings and art installations have been featured in over 21 major exhibitions, commissions, and collections. She is a member of the Spokane Tribe, and her Spokane name is Slum Tah. She was born and raised in Spokane, Washington, near the Spokane Indian Reservation.

Chief Wahoo Logo formerly used by the Cleveland Indians baseball franchise

Chief Wahoo was a logo used by the Cleveland Indians, a Major League Baseball (MLB) franchise based in Cleveland, Ohio, from 1951 to 2018.

Native American mascot controversy

Since the 1960s, the issue of Native American and First Nations names and images being used by sports teams as mascots has been the subject of increasing public controversy in the United States and Canada. This has been a period of rising Indigenous civil rights movements, and Native Americans and their supporters object to the use of images and names in a manner and context they consider derogatory. They have conducted numerous protests and tried to educate the public on this issue.

Vernon Bellecourt

Vernon Bellecourt (WaBun-Inini) was a member of the White Earth Band of Ojibwe, a Native American rights activist, and a leader in the American Indian Movement (AIM). In the Ojibwe language, his name meant "Man of Dawn."

Elmer Woggon, who signed his art Wog, was the creator of an early newspaper comic strip that eventually developed into the long-running Steve Roper and Mike Nomad.

Washington Redskins name controversy Controversy involving the name and logo of the Washington Redskins NFL team

The Washington Redskins name controversy involved the name and logo previously used by the Washington Commanders, a National Football League (NFL) franchise located in the Washington metropolitan area. In the 1960s, the team's longtime name—the Redskins—and the associated logo began to draw criticism from Native American groups and individuals. The topic, part of the larger Native American mascot controversy, began receiving widespread public attention in the 1990s. In 2020, the team responded to economic pressure in the wake of widespread recognition of systemic racism by retiring the name and logo. The team called itself the "Washington Football Team" before rebranding as the Commanders in 2022.

Jacqueline Keeler is a Native American writer and activist, enrolled in the Navajo Nation and of Yankton Dakota descent, who co-founded Eradicating Offensive Native Mascotry (EONM), which seeks to end the use of Native American racial groups as mascots.

Sundance is an American Indian civil rights activist. He is perhaps best known for being one of several prominent American Indians to spearhead the movement against the use of Native American imagery as sports mascots.

Philip Yenyo is a Native American civil rights activist. He is one of several prominent activists to spearhead the movement against the use of Native American imagery as sports mascots.

Sports teams named Redskins are part of the larger controversy regarding the use of Native American names, images and symbols by non-native sports teams. Teams of this name have received particular public attention because the term redskin is now generally regarded as disparaging and offensive.

Cleveland Indians name and logo controversy

The Cleveland Indians name and logo controversy referred to the controversy surrounding the club name and logo previously used by Major League Baseball's Cleveland Guardians, an American professional baseball team based in Cleveland, Ohio.

The use of terms and images referring to Native Americans/First Nations as the name or mascot for a sports team is a topic of public controversy in the United States and in Canada, arising as part of the Native American/First Nations civil rights movements. Since the 1960s, there have been a number of protests and other actions by Native Americans and others targeting the more prominent use of such names and images by professional franchises such as the Cleveland Indians and the Washington Redskins. However, discourse surrounding mascot usage by elementary, middle, and high schools has been prominent, as these entities are subject to public legislation and community input.

Chicago Blackhawks name and logo controversy

The Chicago Blackhawks name and logo controversy refers to the controversy surrounding the name and logo of the Chicago Blackhawks, a National Hockey League (NHL) ice hockey team based in Chicago, Illinois. The use of terms and images referring to Native Americans/First Nations as the name or mascot for a sports team without permissions from or consultations with local Indigenous communities, is a topic of public controversy in the United States and Canada. Since the 1960s, as part of the indigenous civil rights movements, there have been a number of protests and other actions by Native Americans and their supporters targeting the more prominent use of such names and images by professional franchises such as the Cleveland Guardians formerly known as the "Indians" of Major League Baseball (MLB) that was officially discontinued in 2016; the Washington Commanders formerly known as the "Redskins" of the National Football League (NFL), the NFL's Kansas City Chiefs and MLB's Atlanta Braves, the latter two attracting criticism of "the tomahawk chop" often performed by their fans. Like other teams with tribal mascots, there are calls from Indigenous activists and organizations to change the Blackhawks' name and logo and eliminate tribal mascots and imagery throughout sports.

2018 Cleveland Indians season Major League Baseball season

The 2018 Cleveland Indians season was the 118th season for the franchise. It was the sixth season under the leadership of manager Terry Francona and third under general manager Mike Chernoff. The Indians played all of their home games at Progressive Field in Cleveland, Ohio. This was the last season in which the Indians logo Chief Wahoo was used on uniforms or on stadium signs. They won their third straight American League Central title before being swept by the defending World Series champion Houston Astros in the 2018 American League Division Series. Due to the Indians losing to the Astros, the Indians became the 5th team in MLB history to have a 70 year title drought.

Indigenous activists in Cleveland, Ohio, have advocated Indigenous issues and rights since the early 1900s. After the removal of the last American Indians from their traditional territory in Ohio in 1842, Cleveland, and the greater Cuyahoga County, had an almost nonexistent Indigenous population. However, in the early 1900s, an Osaukee man named Chief Thunderwater engaged in activism, protesting the displacement of the Erie Street Cemetery and creating the Supreme Council of Indian Nations, which advocated for Indigenous peoples' right to cross the United States–Canada border in the Supreme Court Case, McCandless v. United States. Later in the century, the Indian Relocation Act of 1956 moved a variety of Native Americans from their different reservations in the West into Ohio, specifically metropolitan areas like Cleveland. With the resurgent population came a wave of activism, as the Cleveland American Indian center was created and the national American Indian Movement established a chapter in the city in 1970. Annual mascot protests in Cleveland began in 1972, with local groups AIM and the Committee of 500 Years of Dignity and Resistance participating. An important Ohio Supreme Court case, Bellecourt v. City of Cleveland, protected protestors first amendment rights in court. The Cleveland Indians ended the use of their old mascot, Chief Wahoo, in 2019 and in 2020 announced that they would consider changing their team name, in response to ongoing protests. In July 2021, the Cleveland baseball team announced their new name: The Cleveland Guardians. Mascot protests also extend to local schools in the Cleveland area, where the Oberlin School District ended their use of Indians as their mascot.

References

  1. "Native Americans, others protest Indians' logo". The Washington Times. 4 April 2014. Retrieved 20 June 2014.
  2. 1 2 3 4 5 Allard, Sam (1 October 2014). "Native Cleveland: Robert Roche and the Origins of American Indian Activism in Cleveland". Cleveland Scene. Retrieved 11 October 2014.
  3. Roche, Robert. "Robert Roche" (PDF). University of Dayton. Retrieved 11 October 2014.
  4. Honaker, Abby (8 November 2010). "Robert Roche to Discuss American Indian Movement". Mount Union. Retrieved 11 October 2014.
  5. 1 2 3 "American Indian Education Center (AIEC)". NetzKraft. Retrieved 20 June 2014.
  6. 1 2 3 Naymik, Mark (2 July 2014). "Robert Roche battles Chief Wahoo, the Cleveland Indians and troubles of his own: Mark Naymik". NetzKraft. Retrieved 5 July 2014.
  7. "CLEVELAND AMERICAN INDIAN CENTER - The Encyclopedia of Cleveland". Case Western Reserve University. 5 April 2014. Retrieved 20 June 2014.
  8. 1 2 "Native American group protests Chief Wahoo". NetzKraft. 5 April 2014. Retrieved 20 June 2014.
  9. "Course Offerings". Oberlin Course Offerings. Retrieved 22 August 2014.
  10. 1 2 Sangiacomo, Michael (21 July 1998). "Indian group says man does not represent it". Cleveland Blog. Retrieved 6 July 2014.
  11. "BACKGROUND: The United States Government War Against the American Indian Movement". AIM Council on Security and Intelligence. 3 November 1999. Retrieved 6 July 2014.
  12. Moya-Smith, Simon (6 April 2014). "Facing Off: Man in Redface Goes Toe-to-Toe With AIM Member". Indian Country Media. Retrieved 20 June 2014.
  13. "In the United States District Court" (PDF). Cleveland Magazine. 4 April 2014. Retrieved 7 July 2014.
  14. Blackwell, Brandon (4 August 2013). "Convicted murderer Billy Slagle hangs himself days before scheduled execution". Cleveland.com. Retrieved 11 October 2014.
  15. "STATE OF OHIO ADULT PAROLE AUTHORITY COLUMBUS, OHIO" (PDF). STATE OF OHIO. 16 July 2013. Retrieved 11 October 2014.
  16. "Amanda Berry, the Media and Her Mother". Dragonfly Services. 22 May 2013. Archived from the original on 4 March 2016. Retrieved 20 June 2014.
  17. Glasier, David (4 April 2014). "Fans brave weather for Cleveland Indians, Lake County Captains home openers". The News-Herald. Retrieved 5 July 2014.
  18. Schilling, Vincent (17 April 2014). "Standing Up And Staying Put: Four Decades of Protesting the Cleveland Indians' Chief Wahoo". Indian Media. Retrieved 5 July 2014.
  19. Helsel, Phil. "Native Groups Look to Retire the Cleveland Indians' Chief Wahoo". NBC News. Retrieved 5 July 2014.
  20. "Awkward: Native American comes face to face with Indian caricature". Cleveland Frowns. 4 April 2014. Retrieved 20 June 2014.
  21. Calcaterra, Craig (4 April 2014). "Photo of the Day: Real Indian meets racist caricature". NBC Sports. Retrieved 20 June 2014.
  22. Wagner, Kyle (4 April 2014). "Photo of the Day: Real Indian meets racist caricature". NBC Sports. Retrieved 20 June 2014.
  23. Perry, Dayn (4 April 2014). "PHOTO: Native American protester meets Indians fan in redface". CBS Sports. Retrieved 20 June 2014.
  24. Brisbee, Grant (4 April 2014). "The most uncomfortable picture in the world, courtesy of Cleveland Indians baseball". SBNation. Retrieved 20 June 2014.
  25. Mackey, Robert (8 April 2014). "An Editorial Cartoon on Native American Mascots Comes to Life in Cleveland". The New York Times . Retrieved 20 June 2014.
  26. Schwartz, Nick (5 April 2014). "Four powerful photos from the protest of Cleveland's Chief Wahoo". For The WIN. Retrieved 20 June 2014.
  27. Oz, Mike (4 April 2014). "Cleveland Indians fan in redface comes face to face with Native American protestor". Yahoo Sports. Retrieved 20 June 2014.
  28. Allard, Sam (9 April 2014). "Chief Wahoo's Waterloo: A Photo from Protests Outside the Indians' Home Opener Goes Viral and the Debate Over the Team's Logo Grows". Cleve Scene. Retrieved 20 June 2014.
  29. "Native American Group Plans Federal Lawsuit Against Cleveland Indians Logo, Team Name". CBS Sports. 25 June 2014. Retrieved 1 July 2014.
  30. Wells, Adam (25 June 2014). "Tracking Cleveland Indians' Potential $9B Lawsuit from Native American Group". CBS Sports. Retrieved 1 July 2014.
  31. Epstein, Jane (25 June 2014). "Are Chief Wahoo's Days Numbered?". National Review. Retrieved 1 July 2014.
  32. Oz, Mike (25 June 2014). "Native American group threatens Cleveland Indians with $9 billion lawsuit". Yahoo Sports. Retrieved 1 July 2014.
  33. "Bugs or No Bugs, Indians fans Ready for Red Sox". 19 Action News. Retrieved 11 October 2014.
  34. Withers, Tom (5 April 2015). "Indians fans face protest at home opener: 'We are people, not your mascots'". Washington Times. Retrieved 26 October 2015.
  35. Allard, Sam (1 October 2014). "American Indian Movement of Ohio". Native Cleveland. Retrieved 11 October 2014.
  36. 1 2 Naymik, Mark (8 January 2015). "Anti-Chief Wahoo activist Robert Roche faces federal scrutiny: Mark Naymik". Cleveland.com News. Retrieved 9 January 2015.
  37. 1 2 Colangelo, BJ (30 August 2018). "American Indian Activist Robert Roche Sentenced to Four Months in Prison for Embezzlement". Cleveland Scene. Retrieved 22 December 2018.
  38. 1 2 3 Heisig, Eric (16 May 2018). "Prominent Chief Wahoo protester pleads guilty to stealing federal money meant for Native Americans". Cleveland.com News. Retrieved 22 December 2018.
  39. Chamberlain, Samuel (17 May 2018). "Chief Wahoo protester admits he stole money meant for Native Americans". Cleveland Scene. Retrieved 22 December 2018.