SS Utopia

Last updated

Sinking of SS Utopia 1891.jpg
Sketch of the sinking of Utopia by a witness, Ms. Georgina Smith
History
Civil Ensign of the United Kingdom.svg
NameSS Utopia
Operator Anchor Line
RouteTransatlantic
Builder Robert Duncan & Co., Glasgow
Launched14 February 1874
Maiden voyage23 May 1874
Refit1890–91
FateSank in Gibraltar on 17 March 1891. Scrapped in 1900.
General characteristics
Tonnage2,371  GRT [1]
Length350 ft (110 m) [1]
Beam35 ft (11 m) [1]
Propulsion Triple expansion steam engine
Speed13 knots (24 km/h) [1]

SS Utopia was a transatlantic passenger steamship built in 1874 by Robert Duncan & Co of Glasgow. From 1874 to 1882 she operated on Anchor Line routes from Glasgow to New York City, from Glasgow to Bombay and from London to New York City. After 1882 she carried Italian immigrants to the United States.

Contents

On 17 March 1891 Utopia accidentally collided with the moored battleship HMS Anson in the Bay of Gibraltar. Utopia sank within 20 minutes; with a loss of 562 [2] of 880 passengers and crew of Utopia and two rescuers from HMS Immortalité died in the accident. The sinking of Utopia was blamed on "grave error of judgement" of her captain John McKeague, who survived the accident.

Anchor Liner

Utopia was built by Robert Duncan of Glasgow as a transatlantic steamer for the Anchor Line. Utopia was a sister ship to Elysia (1873) and Alsatia (1876), [3] designed to carry 120 first class, 60 second class and 600 steerage (third class) passengers. [1] She was launched on 14 February 1874 and sailed out on her maiden voyage to New York City on 23 May 1874. [1] After 12 round trips on the route from Glasgow to New York City she sailed on the route from Glasgow to Bombay. [1] In April 1876, Anchor Line transferred Utopia, Elysia, Anglia and Australia to serve the route from London to New York City. [4] On 6 September 1878, she ran down and sank the German full-rigged ship Helios. Utopia rescued her crew. [5] Utopia made 40 round-trip voyages on this route.

In 1882 she was transferred to the Mediterranean, and regularly carried Italian immigrants to the United States. [1] In 1890–91 she was refitted with a triple expansion steam engine. [1] To maximize revenue on the Italian route her first class accommodation was reduced to 45 passengers, second class was removed altogether, and steerage capacity was increased to 900 bunks. [6]

Sinking

On 25 February 1891 Utopia sailed out from the port of Trieste for New York City, with stopovers at Naples, Genoa and Gibraltar. She carried a total of 880 people: 59 crew (most of them stewards), [7] 3 first class passengers, 815 third class passengers, and 3 stowaways. There were 85 women and 67 children. [8] According to Captain John McKeague's signed statement, Utopia normally carried seven lifeboats that could accommodate up to "460 people in moderate weather" but on the night of the catastrophe one of these boats was missing. [9]

HMS Anson in 1897 HMSAnsonCirca1897.jpg
HMS Anson in 1897

Utopia reached Gibraltar in the afternoon of 17 March. Captain McKeague navigated Utopia to her usual anchorage in the inner harbour, but then realized that it was occupied by two battleships, HMS Anson and HMS Rodney. McKeague later said that he had been temporarily dazzled by Anson's searchlight. When McKeague's eyesight recovered he "suddenly discovered that the inside anchorage was full of ships". [10] McKeague, according to his statement, thought that Anson was "further off than she really was" and attempted to steer Utopia ahead of Anson's bow. Suddenly, a "strong gale combined with current swept the vessel across the bows of the Anson, and in a moment her hull was pierced and cut by the ram of the ironclad". [11] According to third mate Francis Wadsworth, the impact occurred at 6:36 p.m. [12] Anson's ram tore a hole 5 metres (16 ft) wide below Utopia's waterline, and her holds quickly flooded.

McKeague at first considered beaching the ship, but Utopia almost instantly lost engine power: The engineers had shut down the engines to prevent a steam explosion. [9] McKeague ordered the lowering of the lifeboats and to abandon ship, but Utopia suddenly listed 70 degrees, crushing and sinking the boats. The survivors clung to the starboard of Utopia while hundreds were trapped inside steerage holds. 20 minutes after the impact Utopia sank to a depth of 17 metres (56 ft). Her masts, protruding above the waves, became the last refuge for survivors. [11]

Anson, the Swedish Navy corvette Freja, and other nearby ships immediately sent rescue crews to the site, but rough weather and a strong current made it difficult for them to approach the wreck. "Rescuers, blinded by the wind and rain, saw nothing but a confused, struggling mass of human beings entangled with wreckage." [11] Two sailors from HMS Immortalité, James Croton and George Hales, drowned attempting to rescue survivors [2] when their boat drifted on the rocks. [11] Search and rescue continued until 11 p.m. [11] Out of 880 passengers and crew of Utopia, there were 318 survivors: 290 steerage passengers, 2 first class passengers, 3 Italian interpreters, and 23 crew. [2] The remaining 562 passengers and crew of Utopia were dead or missing. [2]

Aftermath

Wreck of Utopia in Gibraltar Harbour Wreck of the SS Utopia in Gibraltar Harbour.jpg
Wreck of Utopia in Gibraltar Harbour
Members of the Gibraltar Port Authority - most of them unidentified Gibraltarian men - wearing medals awarded for their bravery during the disaster. Tentative identification can be found at . Members of the Gibraltar Port Authority wearing medals.jpg
Members of the Gibraltar Port Authority – most of them unidentified Gibraltarian men – wearing medals awarded for their bravery during the disaster. Tentative identification can be found at .

Croton and Hales were buried with military honours on 19 March. [2] The first group of Utopia victims, 28 adults and 3 children, were buried in a trench in Gibraltar on 20 March. Divers sent to examine the wreck reported that the inner spaces of Utopia "were closely packed with the bodies ... who had become wedged into an almost solid mass"; [2] and that "the bodies of many of the drowned were found so firmly clasped together that it was difficult to separate them." [13] Hundreds of bodies remained trapped in the steerage holds of the sunken ship. [14]

Captain McKeague was arrested and released on the same day for a bail of £480. [13] The British court of inquiry chaired by Charles Cavendish Boyle, Captain of the Port of Gibraltar, convened on 23 March 1891 "under the provisions of the Merchant Shipping Ordinance, Gibraltar, 1886". [10] McKeague was found guilty of grave errors in judgement: "firstly, in attempting to enter the anchorage ... without having first opened out and ascertained what vessels were there" and "secondly, in attempting to turn his ship out across the bows of HMS Anson." [15] [16]

After the accident the port authority of Gibraltar obliged Anchor Line to light up the remains of Utopia. [17] For a few days the wreck was illuminated by lights hoisted on each masthead. [17] The precaution, however, did not prevent another incident: SS Primula, entering the harbour, collided with the wreck of Utopia. [17] At the inquiry the crew of Primula said that they did see the lights, but not the ship. [17] They recognized the masts and funnel protruding above the water when the collision was already inevitable. [17] The court ruling on the second Utopia collision set a precedent of maritime law that remained in place for 35 years. Judge Sir Frances Jeune, contrary to established practice, [18] absolved the owners of Utopia from liability because they had legitimately transferred "control and management of the wreck" to the Port of Gibraltar. [17] In 1928 his obiter dictum was expressly overruled in Dee Conservancy Board vs. McConnell. [17] [18]

The wreck of Utopia was raised in July 1892 [19] and brought back to Scotland. Her owners gave up plans of reviving the ship and left her to rust in the River Clyde. The hulk was scrapped in 1900.

See also

Notes

  1. 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 Bonsor, p. 154.
  2. 1 2 3 4 5 6 "The Dead of the Utopia". The New York Times, 20 March 1891.
  3. Bonsor, p. 142.
  4. Bonsor, p. 143.
  5. "A Vessel Run Down at Sea". Glasgow Herald. No. 12094. Glasgow. 26 September 1878.
  6. Bonsor, p. 145: "passengers on the southern route consisted almost entirely of steerage."
  7. McKeague described his crew as "7 A.B.'s, 4 quartermasters, a boatswain, an apprentice and a boy, 6 firemen, 2 coal trimmers, 3 officers, 3 engineers, and 1 doctor." – Board of Trade Wreck Report, page 2.
  8. Board of Trade Wreck Report, page 1: "with a crew of 59 hands all told, and 815 emigrants, 3 saloon passengers, and 3 stowaways, on a voyage from Genoa and Naples".
  9. 1 2 Board of Trade Wreck Report, page 2.
  10. 1 2 Board of Trade Wreck Report, page 1.
  11. 1 2 3 4 5 "Lost in Gibraltar Bay". The New York Times , 19 March 1891.
  12. Board of Trade Wreck Report, page 3.
  13. 1 2 "The Utopia Victims". The New York Times, 21 March 1891.
  14. After the shipwreck was raised in July 1892 the remains of 33 victiums were recovered and buried in the middle of the Straits. See Raising of the Utopia .p.52
  15. Board of Trade Wreck Report, p. 4.
  16. "Report of the investigation into the shipwreck of the steamship "Utopia" (PDF). Retrieved 24 September 2016.
  17. 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 Mandaraka-Sheppard 2007, pp. 567–568.
  18. 1 2 Gault, pp. 119–120.
  19. Fry, p. 188.

Related Research Articles

Admiral-class ironclad Class of pre-dreadnoughts of the Royal Navy

The British Royal Navy's ironclad Admiral-class battleships of the 1880s followed the pattern of the Devastation class in having the main armament on centreline mounts fore and aft of the superstructure. This pattern was followed by most following British designs until HMS Dreadnought in 1906. They were known as the Admiral class because they were all named after British admirals, such as Admiral George Anson.

SS <i>Norge</i> Danish passenger liner

SSNorge was a transatlantic ocean liner that was launched in 1881 in Scotland, and lost in 1904 off Rockall with great loss of life. Her final voyage was from Copenhagen, Kristiania and Kristiansand, bound for New York, carrying passengers many of whom were emigrants. It was the biggest civilian maritime disaster in the Atlantic Ocean until the sinking of Titanic eight years later, and is still the largest loss of life from a Danish merchant ship.

SS <i>City of Glasgow</i> British passenger ship

SS City of Glasgow of 1850 was a single-screw passenger steamship of the Inman Line, which disappeared en route from Liverpool to Philadelphia in March 1854 with 480 passengers and crew. Based on ideas pioneered by Isambard Kingdom Brunel's SS Great Britain of 1845, City of Glasgow established that Atlantic steamships could be operated profitably without government subsidy. After a refit in 1852, she was also the first Atlantic steamship to carry steerage passengers, representing a significant improvement in the conditions experienced by immigrants. In March 1854 City of Glasgow vanished at sea with no known survivors.

HMS <i>Anson</i> (1886) Admiral-class battleship

HMS Anson was the last of six Admiral-class ironclad battleships built for the Royal Navy during the 1880s. The ship was completed, except for her armament, in 1887, but had to wait two years for her guns to be installed. She was assigned to the Channel Fleet in mid-1889 as a flagship for the fleet's second-in-command. Two years later, the passenger ship SS Utopia sank with the loss of 562 lives after colliding with Anson in the Bay of Gibraltar. In mid-1893, Anson was transferred to the Mediterranean Fleet, subsequently returning home in 1900 when she was assigned to the Reserve Fleet. She recommissioned for the Home Fleet in early 1901. Anson was paid off three years later and then sold for scrap in 1909.

HMS <i>Anson</i> (1781) Intrepid-class ship of the line

HMS Anson was a ship of the Royal Navy, launched at Plymouth on 4 September 1781. Originally a 64-gun third rate ship of the line, she fought at the Battle of the Saintes.

SS <i>Abyssinia</i>

SS Abyssinia was a British mail liner built in 1870, and originally operated by the Cunard Line on the Liverpool–New York route. She later served the Guion Line on the same route and the Canadian Pacific Line in the Pacific. In December 1891, Abyssinia was destroyed mid-Atlantic without loss of life by a fire that started in her cargo of cotton, further highlighting the danger in carrying both cotton and passengers on the same ship.

RMS <i>Carpathia</i> Ocean liner known for rescuing survivors of RMS Titanic

RMS Carpathia was a Cunard Line transatlantic passenger steamship built by Swan Hunter & Wigham Richardson in their shipyard in Wallsend, England.

<i>Cato</i> (1800 ship) Shipwreck in Queensland, Australia

Cato was launched at Stockton in 1800 and registered in London to Reeve & Green. She was wrecked on the Great Barrier Reef, Australia, in 1803 at.

SS <i>California</i> (1907)

SS California was a twin-screw steamer that D. and W. Henderson and Company of Glasgow built for the Anchor Line in 1907 as a replacement for the aging ocean liner Astoria, which had been in continuous service since 1884. She worked the Glasgow to New York transatlantic route and was sunk by the German submarine SM U-85 on 7 February 1917.

<i>Marlborough</i> (1876 ship)

Marlborough was an iron-built two-decked merchant sailing ship which disappeared in 1890. She was built by the firm of Robert Duncan and Co., Port Glasgow and launched in 1876 for her owner John Leslie, who later sold her to the Albion Line. Marlborough disappeared during a voyage in January 1890, and has not been seen or heard from in over a century. Searches and investigations have yielded nothing conclusive, and the ship's ultimate fate, and that of her crew, remains unknown.

SS <i>Kroonland</i> American steamship (1902–1927)

SS Kroonland was an ocean liner for International Mercantile Marine (IMM) from her launch in 1902 until she was scrapped in 1927. Kroonland was the sister ship of Finland and a near sister ship of Vaderland and Zeeland of the same company. Kroonland sailed for IMM's Red Star Line for 15 years, and also sailed for IMM's American Line and Panama Pacific Line. During World War I, the ship served as United States Army transport USAT Kroonland through April 1918, and as the Navy auxiliary USS Kroonland (ID-1541) from April 1918 to October 1919.

SS <i>La Touraine</i>

SS La Touraine was an ocean liner that sailed for the Compagnie Générale Transatlantique from the 1890s to the 1920s. Built in France in 1891, she was primarily employed in transatlantic service on the North Atlantic. The liner was scrapped in Dunkirk in October 1923.

SS <i>La Bretagne</i>

SS La Bretagne was an ocean liner that sailed for the Compagnie Générale Transatlantique (CGT) from her launch in 1886 to 1912, sailing primarily in transatlantic service on the North Atlantic. Sold to Compagnie de Navigation Sud-Atlantique in 1912, she sailed for that company under her original name and, later, as SS Alesia on France–South America routes. The liner was sold for scrapping in the Netherlands in December 1923, but was lost while being towed.

SS <i>City of Boston</i>

The SSCity of Boston was a British iron-hulled single-screw passenger steamship of the Inman Line which disappeared in the North Atlantic Ocean en route from Halifax, Nova Scotia, to Liverpool in January 1870.

SS <i>Delhi</i>

SS Delhi was a steamship of the Peninsular & Orient Line (P&O) that was lost off Cape Spartel, northern Morocco, at the entrance to the Strait of Gibraltar, on 12 December 1911. Among the passengers was Alexander Duff, 1st Duke of Fife, whose subsequent death in Egypt was ascribed to ill-health caused during the wreck, and his family, the Princess Royal and daughters Princesses Alexandra and Maud.

SS <i>Catalonia</i> Cargo passenger liner built in 1881

SS Catalonia was a cargo passenger vessel built in 1881 and owned by the Cunard Line.

RMS <i>Slavonia</i>

Slavonia was a 10,606 GRT passenger ship that was built in 1902 as Yamuna for the British India Line. She was sold to the Cunard Line in 1903 and renamed Slavonia. She was wrecked in the Azores in 1909, but sent out the first SOS message. All on board were rescued.

SS <i>Cheribon</i>

SS Cheribon (1882-1902) was a transatlantic ocean liner steamship built for Compagnie Nationale de Navigation by William Denny & Brothers in Dumbarton, Scotland. Compagnie Nationale de Navigation initially employed the ship as a military troop transporter to French Indochina. Subsequently, the Cheribon was commissioned as a passenger ship for Italian immigrants, offering a New York route, as well as a South American route. She also was used at various times in her career as a cargo ship. The Cheribon was retired in 1899 and sold to Captain W. T. Pitt. In 1901, Pitt sold majority share of her to E. Gerrad, while retaining one-third ownership and command of the ship. On April 11, 1902, while carrying a shipment of coffee, the Cheribon wrecked on a reef off of Punta Remedios near Acajutla, El Salvador. All crew were eventually saved, however, the ship eventually sank.

USS <i>Black Arrow</i>

USS Black Arrow (ID-1534) was a troop transport commissioned in 1919 to assist in the post-World War I repatriation of U.S. troops from France. Black Arrow was originally SS Rhaetia, a passenger-cargo ship built in Germany in 1904–05 for the Hamburg-America Line. From 1905 to 1914, Rhaetia operated primarily between Hamburg, Germany and South America, though she was also intermittently employed as an immigrant ship to the United States. With the outbreak of World War I in August 1914, Rhaetia was interned in Philadelphia.

SS <i>Florida</i> (1905) Italian passenger ship (1905–1917)

SS Florida was an Italian ocean liner, built in 1905 for Lloyd Italiano, which operated between Italy and both North and South America. In 1909 she collided with, and sank, White Star Line's Republic off the American coast. Later, as Cavour with Transatlantica Italiana, she was sunk by collision with the Italian auxiliary cruiser Caprera off the Spanish Mediterranean coast on 12 December 1917, without loss of life.

References

Further reading