Solid North

For the bus company, see Pangasinan Solid North Transit Inc.

Areas under the Solid North are colored red.

The Solid North refers to the regional voting bloc of the northern provinces of the Philippines ^[1] for politicians of Ilocano descent, more particularly the Marcos family and their allies, and also economic issues affecting the Ilocanos in general such as the tobacco industry. Often included in Solid North are the provinces in the Ilocos Region, Cordillera Administrative Region (CAR), and Cagayan Valley. ^{[2] [3]} The regions are considered to be a conservative/right-wing bastion for the country. ^[3]

The Solid North was most prominent during the presidency of Ferdinand Marcos Sr., but waned after his ouster as a result of the People Power Revolution; the north no longer delivered a reliable bloc vote from 1992 ^[2] until 2016, when Marcos' son, Ferdinand Marcos Jr., ran for the vice presidency in 2016 and won in the Solid North, except for Batanes. ^[4]

Its southern counterpart, called Solid South (not to be confused with the American Solid South), refers to either part or all of Mindanao as a voting bloc, supporting politicians from Mindanao, especially the Duterte family and their allies. The term "Solid South" first emerged after then Davao City mayor Rodrigo Duterte won the presidency with a majority of provinces in Mindanao voting for him. ^{[3] [5]}

History

The provinces with at least a plurality of its population being Ilocano people are denoted by green on the map.

Prior to independence

In the first national elections in 1907, the North became a stronghold of the Progresista Party, the primary opposition party to the Nacionalista Party at that time. ^[6]

Third Republic presidential elections

Before the election of Ferdinand Marcos in 1965, it was President Elpidio Quirino who consistently carried the Ilocano heartland in the presidential elections during which he was a candidate. Despite Ramon Magsaysay's landslide victory in the 1953 presidential election, Quirino still won in his home province of Ilocos Sur, as well as Ilocos Norte, Abra and La Union.

In the 1965 presidential election, Senator Ferdinand Marcos of the Nacionalista Party, from Ilocos Norte, faced the incumbent president Diosdado Macapagal of the Liberal Party, who hailed from Pampanga. Marcos successfully campaigned on the issues of graft, peace and order, and economic progress, although these had been staple campaign issues since independence. ^[7] Marcos carried not only the Solid North, but most of Luzon as well, with Macapagal only carrying the provinces of Pampanga, Tarlac and Bataan.

While Marcos won an even larger mandate during his successful reelection bid in 1969, support from the Solid North was not as crucial in his victory. Pampanga and Antique in the Visayas were the only provinces that he did not win.

1986 snap presidential election

Marcos eventually declared martial law and stayed in power until 1986, when he called for a "snap election". With his popularity declining after the assassination of Benigno Aquino Jr., Marcos relied heavily on support from the Solid North in the 1986 election, when he faced Aquino's widow, Corazon Aquino. Marcos depended on the Ilocos Region, described as "impregnable to the opposition", and on Eastern Visayas, the home region of his wife, First Lady Imelda Marcos. ^[8] Marcos was eventually declared the winner but allegations of massive fraud erupted into the People Power Revolution which drove the Marcoses into exile and concluded with Aquino's ascension into the presidency.

Fifth Republic elections

Beginning in 1992, the Solid North did not deliver a solid vote for a single candidate. Two figures associated with Ferdinand Marcos, his widow, Imelda Marcos, and one of his allies, Danding Cojuangco, won in several provinces of the Solid North. In 1998, Imelda, who initially planned to run again, endorsed eventual winner Joseph Estrada, who won in all northern provinces except Cagayan.

In 2004, Fernando Poe Jr. was endorsed by Imelda for the presidency. ^[9] He would win in most provinces except Benguet, Ifugao, Ilocos Sur, Kalinga, and Mountain Province. Poe narrowly lost to incumbent president Gloria Macapagal Arroyo, but the election would later be tainted by fraud allegations.

In 2010, the Marcoses supported the candidacy of Manny Villar of the Nacionalista Party, while Joseph Estrada ran again but without support from the Marcoses. ^[10] The bloc was divided between Villar, Estrada, and winner Aquino III. Both Villar and Estrada lost the presidential election. Meanwhile, several Marcoses ran in the elections; Bongbong Marcos, who ran for senator under Villar's slate, won a seat, Imelda Marcos won a seat in the House of Representatives, and Imee Marcos won the gubernatorial election in Ilocos Norte. Bongbong's Senate victory is the highest elected position won by a Marcos since their ouster in 1986. ^[11] According to Bongbong, his candidacy made the Solid North "intact again." ^[12]

In 2016, Bongbong ran for vice president as the running mate of senator Miriam Defensor Santiago. Marcos won in all of the Solid North provinces except Batanes, but lost to Leni Robredo. Marcos later filed an electoral protest which was dismissed. ^[13] In the presidential race, the bloc was not as solid, with some voting for Jejomar Binay, running mate of Estrada in 2010, and Rodrigo Duterte, who has been endorsed by some alongside Marcos, ^[14] and Grace Poe, daughter of Fernando Poe Jr. ^[3]

In 2022, Bongbong ran for president alongside Sara Duterte as his running mate. Marcos won again in all provinces except Batanes, while Duterte won in all of the Solid North provinces. ^{[15] [16]}

Solid North in the presidential elections

Election maps

In these maps, the provinces of the candidates where one won at least a plurality of votes is shaded.

• 
  Provinces where Marcos won at least a plurality are in light green.
• 
  Provinces where Marcos won at least a plurality are in light green.
• 
  Provinces where Marcos won at least a plurality are in red. This is the clearest manifestation of the Solid North.
• 
  Provinces where Marcos won at least a plurality are in red; provinces where Marcos' ally Danding Cojuangco won at least a plurality are in dark green.
• 
  Provinces where Estrada won at least a plurality are in orange; provinces where Marcos' ally Juan Ponce Enrile won at least a plurality are in gray. The Marcoses supported Estrada in the election.
• 
  Provinces where Poe won at least a plurality are in dark blue. The Marcoses supported Poe in the election.
• 
  Provinces where Villar won at least a plurality are in light green; provinces where Estrada won at least a plurality are in orange. The Marcoses supported Villar in the election.
• 
  Provinces where Duterte won at least a plurality are in bright yellow. The Marcoses supported both Duterte and Defensor-Santiago in the election. Provinces where Binay (former running mate of Estrada) won at least a plurality are in orange. Provinces where Poe's daughter won at least a plurality are in blue.
• 
  Provinces where Marcos won at least a plurality are in jade green.

Key:

• Boldface: Winner
• Italicized: Marcos, or candidate supported by the Marcoses.

Year	Ilocos Region				Cagayan Valley					Cordillera Administrative Region
	Ilocos Norte	Ilocos Sur	La Union	Pangasinan	Batanes	Cagayan	Isabela	Nueva Vizcaya	Quirino	Abra	Kalinga	Apayao	Baguio	Benguet	Ifugao	Mountain Province
1965	Marcos
1969	Marcos
1981	Marcos
1986	Marcos
1992	Marcos		Cojuangco	Ramos		Marcos	Cojuangco		Mitra	Cojuangco	Marcos		Santiago	Mitra		Ramos
1998	Estrada			de Venecia	Lim	Enrile	Estrada						de Venecia	Estrada
2004	Poe	Arroyo	Poe								Arroyo	Poe	Arroyo
2010	Villar		Estrada	Aquino		Estrada							Aquino
2016	Duterte	Poe			Roxas	Binay							Duterte	Poe
2022	Marcos				Robredo	Marcos

Solid North in the vice presidential elections

Key:

• Boldface: Winner
• Italicized: Marcos, or candidate supported by the Marcoses.

Year	Ilocos Region				Cagayan Valley					Cordillera Administrative Region
	Ilocos Norte	Ilocos Sur	La Union	Pangasinan	Batanes	Cagayan	Isabela	Nueva Vizcaya	Quirino	Abra	Kalinga	Apayao	Baguio	Benguet	Ifugao	Mountain Province
1965	Lopez				Roxas	Lopez
1969	Lopez
1986	Tolentino
1992	Estrada												Magsaysay, Jr.		Estrada
1998	Arroyo
2004	Legarda	de Castro	Legarda	de Castro		Legarda					de Castro	Legarda		de Castro		Legarda
2010	Binay	Roxas	Binay	Roxas		Binay							Roxas
2016	Marcos				Robredo	Marcos
2022	Duterte

See also

• Counterparts in other countries
  • Blue wall, American counterpart
  • Canadian Prairies, Canadian counterpart
  • Red wall, British counterpart
  • Solid South, near-defunct American counterpart
• Lingayen–Lucena corridor, where the national elections have said to be "won".
• Ticket balance

References

Citations

1. Pawilen, Reidan M. (May 2021). "The Solid North myth: an Investigation on the status of dissent and human rights during the Marcos Regime in Regions 1 and 2, 1969-1986". University of the Philippines Los Baños University Knowledge Digital Repository. Archived from the original on 2021-11-13. Retrieved 2022-05-22.
2. Nicolas, Fiona (October 9, 2015). "How many votes can the 'Solid North' deliver?". CNN Philippines . Archived from the original on October 10, 2015. Retrieved May 15, 2022.
3. Pacia, Sara Isabelle (May 12, 2016). "Duterte can credit new 'Solid South,' NCR and Cebu for win". INQUIRER.net. Retrieved May 15, 2022.
4. "How regions voted for Robredo, Marcos in 2016 VP race". RAPPLER. 2016-05-15. Retrieved 2022-05-15.
5. "Move over 'Solid North,' 'Solid South' is new PH power base". ABS-CBN News. 2019-05-21.
6. Philippine Commission. Report of the Philippine Commission to the Secretary of War 1907.
7. Tan (1987), p. 89
8. Quinn-Judge (1986)
9. Romero, Paolo. "FPJ can continue what FM did for the poor — Imelda". Philstar.com. Retrieved 2022-05-15.
10. "Marcos-Aquino rivalry fires again". South China Morning Post. February 25, 2010. Retrieved May 15, 2022.
11. "3 wins in Philippine elections mark Marcos family's highest rise since dictator ousted in 1986". Fox News. Associated Press. 2010-05-10.
12. Guillang, Michelle R. "North solid as a rock, BBM claims" . Retrieved May 15, 2022.
13. Torres-Tupas, Tetch (16 February 2021). "PET dismisses Marcos poll protest vs Robredo, stresses 'entire' case junked". INQUIRER.net. Philippine Daily Inquirer . Retrieved 17 February 2021.
14. Ramirez, Robertzon. "INC endorses Duterte-Marcos". Philstar.com. Retrieved 2022-05-15.
15. Manahan, Job (May 10, 2022). "Duterte's popularity, regionalism crystalized votes for Marcos Jr., Sara Duterte: analysts". ABS-CBN News . Retrieved May 15, 2022.
16. "Solid North delivers for Marcos, Duterte". RAPPLER. 2022-05-10. Retrieved 2022-05-15.

Sources

• "3 wins in Philippine elections mark Marcos family's highest rise since dictator ousted in 1986". Fox News. Associated Press. 2010-05-10.
• Quinn-Judge, Paul (1986-02-04). "What you need to know about THE PHILIPPINE ELECTION. A presidential election: issues and candidates". The Christian Science Monitor .
• Tan, Samuel K. (1987). A history of the Philippines. University of the Philippines Press. ISBN   9789715425681.