State v. Driver

Last updated

State v. Driver 38 N.J. 255 (1962) is a New Jersey Supreme Court case governing the admissibility of recorded interrogations in a criminal trial. The test articulated in Driver has been adopted by several other states, and is also followed in by the U.S. federal court system.

Contents

Background

Jacob Mayer was the manager of an A&P Supermarket in Hamilton Township, New Jersey. On April 4 Mayer left the store to go home at 10:30pm. From her bed his wife heard him talking to some people, before seeing car lights leaving their driveway. Her husband had not returned by 2:30pm and the police were called. The next morning police found that $10,468.21 in cash and $505.17 in checks had been taken from the supermarket's safe. At 7am a burned Dodge coupe was found between Carnegie Lake and the Delaware and Raritan Canal in Princeton Township, although police were not notified until the next day. The body of Mayer was found in the canal. There was a laceration on the scalp and adhesive tape around his wrists, mouth, eyes, nose and neck. It was determined that he had died of strangulation. Reginald Driver was charged with murder on December 11, 1959. The trial began on May 15, 1961. [1]

Driver was convicted of murder and sentenced to life imprisonment on June 2. The conviction was overturned 14 months later, following an appeal over the methods in which a taped confession was obtained. [2]

Driver hearing

The Court overturned Driver's murder conviction because the taped recording played for the jury was so garbled and unclear that the trial judge instructed the jury, "[i]f you can't hear it, you can't hear it. Inaudible." [3] [4]

This court decision led to the introduction of the Driver hearing in New Jersey. It states that any sound recording offered into evidence at trial must be competent and relevant. [5] In resolving such disputed questions, the court should determine that the speakers on the recording are identified, and that:

  1. the device was capable of taking the conversation or statement;
  2. its operator was competent;
  3. the recording is authentic and correct;
  4. no changes, additions or deletions have been made; and
  5. the statements, if confessions, are voluntary. [6] [4]

The court also instructed that trial judges "should listen to the recording out of the presence of the jury before allowing it to be used" in order to determine that the recording is "sufficiently audible, intelligible, not obviously fragmented, and... whether it contains any improper and prejudicial matter which ought to be deleted." [3]

Other jurisdictions

The New Jersey Driver approach has generally been adopted by the courts of several other states, including Montana, [7] New Mexico, [8] New York, [9] North Carolina, [10] Washington, [11] and West Virginia. [12]

The federal court system uses an approach that is nearly identical to the Driver test, although the ordering and wording of the particular elements are different, and vary from circuit to circuit. [13]

Related Research Articles

West Memphis Three three men convicted of the 1993 murders of three boys in West Memphis, Arkansas, United States

The West Memphis Three are three men convicted as teenagers in 1994 of the 1993 murders of three boys in West Memphis, Arkansas, United States. Damien Echols was sentenced to death, Jessie Misskelley Jr. to life imprisonment plus two 20-year sentences, and Jason Baldwin to life imprisonment. During the trial, the prosecution asserted that the juveniles killed the children as part of a Satanic ritual.

A miscarriage of justice occurs when a grossly unfair outcome is made in a criminal or civil proceeding, which may include a deportation proceeding under the United States Immigration and Nationality Act (INA). For example, it happens when a national of the United States (American) is forcefully deported as an alien, or a person is convicted of a misconduct or a crime that he/she did not commit. There is no statute of limitations for purposes of investigating and correcting a miscarriage of justice.

Steven Allan Avery is an American convicted murderer from Manitowoc County, Wisconsin, who had previously been wrongfully convicted in 1985 of sexual assault and attempted murder. After serving 18 years of a 32-year sentence, he was exonerated by DNA testing and released in 2003, only to be charged with murder two years later.

A false confession is an admission of guilt for a crime which the individual did not commit. Although such confessions seem counterintuitive, they can be made voluntarily, perhaps to protect a third party, or induced through coercive interrogation techniques. When some degree of coercion is involved, studies have found that subjects with low intelligence or with mental disorders are more likely to make such confessions. Young people are particularly vulnerable to confessing, especially when stressed, tired, or traumatized, and have a significantly higher rate of false confessions than adults. Hundreds of innocent people have been convicted, imprisoned, and sometimes sentenced to death after confessing to crimes they did not commit—but years later, have been exonerated. It was not until several shocking false confession cases were publicized in the late 1980s, combined with the introduction of DNA evidence, that the extent of wrongful convictions began to emerge—and how often false confessions played a role in these.

The Trenton Six is the group name for six African-American defendants tried for murder of an elderly white shopkeeper in January 1948 in Trenton, New Jersey. The six young men were convicted in August 1948 by an all-white jury of the murder and sentenced to death.

Glasgow Ice Cream Wars Turf war in Glasgow, Scotland, in the 1980s between criminal organisations selling drugs and stolen goods from ice cream vans

The Ice Cream Wars were turf wars in the East End of Glasgow, Scotland, in the 1980s between rival criminal organisations selling drugs and stolen goods from ice cream vans. Van operators were involved in frequent violence and intimidation tactics, the most notable example of which involved a driver and his family who were killed in an arson attack that resulted in a twenty-year court battle. The conflicts generated widespread public outrage, and earned the Strathclyde Police the nickname of "Serious Chimes Squad" for its perceived failure to address them.

The Norfolk Four are four United States Navy veterans: Joseph J. Dick Jr., Derek Tice, Danial Williams, and Eric C. Wilson, who are known for having been wrongfully convicted in 1999 and 2000 on charges related to the 1997 rape and murder of Michelle Moore-Bosko in Norfolk, Virginia. They each declared that they had made false confessions, and their convictions are considered highly controversial. A fifth man, Omar Ballard, confessed and pleaded guilty to the crime in 2000, insisting that he had acted alone. He had been in prison since 1998 because of violent attacks on two other women in 1997. He was the only one of the suspects whose DNA matched that collected at the crime scene, and whose confession was consistent with other forensic evidence.

The Double Jeopardy Clause of the Fifth Amendment to the United States Constitution provides: "[N]or shall any person be subject for the same offence to be twice put in jeopardy of life or limb..." The four essential protections included are prohibitions against, for the same offense:

Brenton Butler case

The Brenton Butler case was a murder case in Jacksonville, Florida. During the investigation of a shooting death outside a motel in 2000, police arrested 15-year-old Brenton Butler and charged him with the murder. Butler subsequently confessed to the crime, and the case went to trial. However, during the trial he testified that he had been brutalized into his confession, and he was acquitted. The case gained significant notice in the media, and became the subject of an award-winning documentary, Murder on a Sunday Morning.

Curtis Flowers African-American man

Curtis Giovanni Flowers is an American man who was tried for murder six times in the U.S. state of Mississippi. Four of the trials resulted in convictions, all of which were overturned on appeal. Flowers was alleged to have committed the July 16, 1996, shooting deaths of four people inside Tardy Furniture store in Winona, seat of Montgomery County. Flowers was first convicted in 1997; in five of the six trials, the prosecutor, Montgomery County District Attorney Doug Evans sought the death penalty against Flowers. As a result, Flowers was held on death row at the Parchman division of Mississippi State Penitentiary for over 20 years.

Murder of Mark Fisher 2004 Murder of Mark Fisher

The murder of Mark S. Fisher occurred in the early morning hours of October 12, 2003. The college student was brutally beaten, shot five times, and left on Argyle Road in Prospect Park South, Brooklyn. He was 19 years old.

People v. Newton, 8 Cal. App. 3d 359, was a controversial appeal arising from the voluntary manslaughter conviction of Huey P. Newton, the reputed co-founder of the Black Panther Party for Self Defense. The California Court of Appeal reversed Newton's conviction due to prejudicial error stemming from the trial court's failure to instruct the jury as to the possibility of involuntary unconsciousness as a complete defense to the charges. Though Newton's attorney arguably withdrew the defense at trial, the Court nonetheless held that the failure to instruct violated Newton's constitutional right to have the jury determine all material issues based on the evidence. This case stands for the proposition that trial courts have an affirmative duty to instruct juries as to a defense of involuntary unconsciousness where there exists evidence that may support that conclusion.

Debra Jean Milke is a German-American woman who spent over 25 years in prison in the state of Arizona. She was one of three people sentenced to death for the December 2, 1989 shooting death of her four-year-old son, Christopher Conan Milke. Her alleged conspirators were her roommate James Lynn Styers and his friend Roger Mark Scott. Neither testified against her and both agreed that she was not present at the shooting. Scott implicated Milke as the mastermind while Styers said she had no involvement whatsoever. They implicated each other as the actual shooter. Who that was remains a subject of speculation.

Barry Allan Beach is an American who was sentenced to life imprisonment without parole in 1984 for the 1979 murder of Kimberly Nees in Poplar, Montana. During the years following his conviction, Beach gained support from influential state and national advocates who said his murder confession, the lynchpin of his conviction, was coerced. In 2015, his sentence was commuted to time served, plus ten years on probation.

Juan Rivera (wrongful conviction) American man (born 1972)

Juan A. Rivera Jr. is an American man who was wrongfully convicted three times for the 1992 rape and murder of 11-year-old Holly Staker in Waukegan, Illinois. He was convicted twice on the basis of a confession that he said was coerced. No physical evidence linked him to the crime scene. In 2015 he received a $20 million settlement from Lake County, Illinois for wrongful conviction, formerly the largest settlement of its kind in United States history.

Brendan Ray Dassey is an American convicted murderer from Manitowoc County, Wisconsin, who, at age 16, confessed to being a party to first-degree murder, mutilation of a corpse, and second-degree sexual assault. He was sentenced to life in prison, with the earliest possibility of parole in 2048. His videotaped interrogation and confession, which he recanted at trial, substantially contributed to his conviction. Parts were shown in the Netflix documentary series Making a Murderer (2015). The series examined the 2005–2007 investigation, prosecution and trials of Dassey and his uncle, Steven Avery, who were both convicted of murdering photographer Teresa Halbach on October 31, 2005.

Walter Ogrod is an American man who was convicted and sentenced to death for the July 12, 1988, sexual assault and murder of four-year-old Barbara Jean Horn in Philadelphia, Pennsylvania. According to police, Ogrod confessed to Horn's murder four years after it occurred, but in 2020 the "confession" was recognized to be false. On June 5 of that year, Ogrod's conviction was vacated by the Philadelphia Court of Common Pleas and he was ordered to be released from prison. He had spent more than two decades on death row.

Mario A. Casciaro is an American man who was originally convicted for the 2002 disappearance and presumed murder of Brian Carrick in Johnsburg, Illinois, then later released due to an overturned verdict.

Isaac Wright Jr. American attorney

Isaac Wright Jr. is an American attorney, consultant, entrepreneur, and philanthropist. He is best known for being falsely accused and convicted as a drug lord and sentenced to life in prison in 1991 facing 10 charges involving the sale of cocaine. His conviction was overturned in 1997 after litigation brought by him on the basis of police corruption during his investigation and the prosecutor’s knowing presentation of perjured testimony at his trial. His story is depicted in the television drama/series production "For Life", which premiered in 2020 on American Broadcasting Company. He was a candidate for mayor of New York City in the 2021 New York City mayoral election.

Crooker v. California, 357 U.S. 433 (1958), was a decision by the Supreme Court of the United States that limited criminal suspects' constitutional right to counsel before trial, refusing to overturn a subsequent conviction without a showing that the refusal of counsel had a coercive or prejudicial effect. This holding was later overturned by Escobedo v. Illinois and Miranda v. Arizona.

References

  1. ↑ State v. Driver, 38N.J.255 (1962).
  2. ↑ Queen, Bob (September 8, 1962). "Convicted of Murder Man Finally is Freed". The Pittsburgh Courier. p. 3. Retrieved 2018-08-15.
  3. 1 2 Driver at 288.
  4. 1 2 Kathryn R. Howell, Sound Recordings: The Confusing Test of State v. Cusmano, 48 Rutgers L. Rev. 227, 230 (1995).
  5. ↑ "Criminal Division Overview" (PDF). New Jersey Judiciary. December 2007. p. 29. Retrieved August 15, 2018.
  6. ↑ Driver at 287.
  7. ↑ State v. Warwick , 494 P.2d 627, 633 (Mont. 1972)
  8. ↑ State v. Baca , 82 N.M. 144, 477 P.2d 320, 322 (1970)
  9. ↑ People v. Sacchitella , 31 A.D.2d 180, 181 (N.Y. App. Div. 1968)
  10. ↑ State v. Lynch , 279 N.C. 1, 181 SE 2d 561, 571 (1971)
  11. ↑ State v. Cole , 67 Wn.2d 522, 533 (Wash. 1965)
  12. ↑ State v. Harris , 169 W. Va. 150, 286 S.E.2d 251, 255 (1982)
  13. ↑ Howell at 231.
This page is based on this Wikipedia article
Text is available under the CC BY-SA 4.0 license; additional terms may apply.
Images, videos and audio are available under their respective licenses.