Bush White House email controversy

Last updated

During the 2007 Congressional investigation of the dismissal of eight U.S. attorneys, it was discovered that administration officials had been using a private Internet domain, called gwb43.com, owned by and hosted on an email server run by the Republican National Committee, [1] for various official communications. The domain name is an abbreviation for "George W. Bush, 43rd" President of the United States. The use of this email domain became public when it was discovered that Scott Jennings, the White House's deputy director of political affairs, was using a gwb43.com email address to discuss the firing of the U.S. attorney for Arkansas. [2] Communications by federal employees were also found on georgewbush.com (registered to "Bush-Cheney '04, Inc." [3] ) and rnchq.org (registered to "Republican National Committee" [4] ). Congressional requests for administration documents while investigating the dismissals of the U.S. attorneys required the Bush administration to reveal that not all internal White House emails were available. Conducting governmental business in this manner is a possible violation of the Presidential Records Act of 1978. [5] Over 5 million emails may have been lost. [6] [7] Greg Palast claims to have come up with 500 of the Karl Rove emails, leading to damaging allegations. [8] In 2009, it was announced that as many as 22 million emails may have been lost. [9]

Contents

The "gwb43.com" [10] domain name was publicized by Citizens for Responsibility and Ethics in Washington (CREW), who sent a letter to Oversight and Government Reform Committee chairman Henry A. Waxman requesting an investigation. [11] Waxman sent a formal warning to the RNC, advising them to retain copies of all emails sent by White House employees. According to Waxman, "in some instances, White House officials were using nongovernmental accounts specifically to avoid creating a record of the communications." [12] The Republican National Committee claims to have erased the emails, supposedly making them unavailable for Congressional investigators. [13]

On April 12, 2007, White House spokesman Scott Stanzel stated that White House staffers were told to use RNC accounts to "err on the side of avoiding violations of the Hatch Act, but they should also retain that information so it can be reviewed for the Presidential Records Act," and that "some employees ... have communicated about official business on those political email accounts." [14] Stanzel also said that even though RNC policy since 2004 has been to retain all emails of White House staff with RNC accounts, the staffers had the ability to delete the email, themselves.

On December 14, 2009, CNN reported [15] that 22 million missing emails had been found on backup tapes, and that the Obama Administration reached a settlement with two watchdog groups who had sued to obtain the emails.

Use by senior White House staff

According to a former White House official, Karl Rove used RNC-hosted addresses for roughly "95 percent" of his email. [16] Rove provided email from his kr@georgewbush.com [17] address in exhibits to the United States House Committee on the Judiciary. [18]

White House deputy Jennifer Farley told Jack Abramoff not to use the official White House system "because it might actually limit what they can do to help us, especially since there could be lawsuits, etc." [2] Abramoff responded, "Dammit. It was sent to Susan on her RNC pager and was not supposed to go into the WH system." [19]

Investigations with missing emails

House Committee on Oversight and Government Reform

The House Oversight committee in an interim staff report, released on June 18, 2007: [20]

Dismissal of U.S. attorneys controversy

During the investigation into the firing of eight U.S. attorneys, [21] it became known White House staff was using Republican National Committee (RNC) email accounts. [22] The White House stated it might have lost five million emails. [6]

On May 2, 2007, the Senate Judiciary Committee issued a subpoena to Attorney General Alberto Gonzales and the Department of Justice (DOJ) compelling the production of email Karl Rove sent to DOJ staff, regarding evaluation and dismissal of attorneys, no matter what email account Rove used, whether White House or National Republican party accounts, or other accounts, with a deadline of May 15, 2007 for compliance. The subpoena also demanded relevant email previously produced in the Valerie Plame controversy and investigation for the CIA leak scandal (2003). [23]

CIA leak grand jury investigation

Ambassador Joseph C. Wilson alleged that his wife's identity was covert and that members of the George W. Bush administration knowingly revealed that information as retribution for his New York Times op-ed entitled "What I Didn't Find in Africa," of July 6, 2003, regarding the claim that Saddam Hussein was seeking uranium.[ citation needed ] Patrick J. Fitzgerald, while investigating the leak, found that emails were missing from the White House server. [24] [25] Mother Jones wrote that this is possibly the reason the RNC changed the policy of deleting emails after 30 days to saving all email sent and received by White House officials. [25] In light of the apparent vanished emails Citizens for Responsibility and Ethics in Washington (CREW) has asked to reopen the investigation. [26] [27]

General Services Administration

It is feared that the missing emails might also affect congressional investigation of General Services Administration. [28]

Department of Education

While investigating the Reading First program CREW learned that employees use private emails to conduct official business. This might be a violation of the Federal Records Act. [29] [30]

Legalities

The Hatch Act

The Hatch Act prohibits the use of government resources, including email accounts, for political purposes. The Bush administration stated the RNC accounts were used to prevent violation of this Act. [6] [25]

Presidential Records Act

The Presidential Records Act mandates the preservation of all presidential records. Citizens for Responsibility and Ethics in Washington and The Wall Street Journal contend that the missing emails may constitute a violation of this Act. [5] [6] [26] [31]

See also

Related Research Articles

Executive privilege is the right of the president of the United States and other members of the executive branch to maintain confidential communications under certain circumstances within the executive branch and to resist some subpoenas and other oversight by the legislative and judicial branches of government in pursuit of particular information or personnel relating to those confidential communications. The right comes into effect when revealing information would impair governmental functions. Neither executive privilege nor the oversight power of Congress is explicitly mentioned in the United States Constitution. However, the Supreme Court of the United States has ruled that executive privilege and congressional oversight each are a consequence of the doctrine of the separation of powers, derived from the supremacy of each branch in its own area of Constitutional activity.

In politics, opposition research is the practice of collecting information on a political opponent or other adversary that can be used to discredit or otherwise weaken them. The information can include biographical, legal, criminal, medical, educational, or financial history or activities, as well as prior media coverage, or the voting record of a politician. Opposition research can also entail using "trackers" to follow an individual and record their activities or political speeches.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Hatch Act</span> United States law

The Hatch Act of 1939, An Act to Prevent Pernicious Political Activities, is a United States federal law. Its main provision prohibits civil service employees in the executive branch of the federal government, except the president and vice president, from engaging in some forms of political activity. It became law on August 2, 1939. The law was named for Senator Carl Hatch of New Mexico. It was most recently amended in 2012.

Voter caging involves challenging the registration status of voters and calling into question the legality of allowing them to vote. Usually it involves sending mail directly to registered voters and compiling a list from mail returned undelivered. Undeliverable mail is seen as proof that the person no longer resides at the address on their voter registration. The resultant list is then used by election officials to purge names from the voter registration rolls or to challenge voters' eligibility to vote on the grounds that the voters no longer reside at their registered addresses.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">National Security Archive</span> Open government advocacy and investigative journalism nonprofit at George Washington University

The National Security Archive is a 501(c)(3) non-governmental, non-profit research and archival institution located on the campus of the George Washington University in Washington, D.C. Founded in 1985 to check rising government secrecy. The National Security Archive is an investigative journalism center, open government advocate, international affairs research institute, and the largest repository of declassified U.S. documents outside the federal government. The National Security Archive has spurred the declassification of more than 10 million pages of government documents by being the leading non-profit user of the U.S. Freedom of Information Act (FOIA), filing a total of more than 50,000 FOIA and declassification requests in its over 30 years of history.

Citizens for Responsibility and Ethics in Washington (CREW) is a nonprofit 501(c)(3) and nonpartisan U.S. government ethics and accountability watchdog organization. Founded in 2003 as a counterweight to conservative government watchdog groups such as Judicial Watch, CREW works to expose ethics violations and corruption by government officials and institutions and to reduce the role of money in politics.

The Plame affair was a political scandal that revolved around journalist Robert Novak's public identification of Valerie Plame as a covert Central Intelligence Agency officer in 2003.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Susan Ralston</span>

Susan Bonzon Ralston, is the President of SBR Enterprises, LLC, a government affairs, public relations and business consulting firm, which assists businesses with strategic partnership development, public affairs and public relations activities. Ralston was formerly Special Assistant to President George W. Bush and a deputy to Karl Rove, the Deputy Chief of Staff and Senior Advisor at the White House, from 2001 until her resignation in 2006.

On December 7, 2006, the George W. Bush Administration's Department of Justice ordered the unprecedented midterm dismissal of seven United States attorneys. Congressional investigations focused on whether the Department of Justice and the White House were using the U.S. Attorney positions for political advantage. Allegations were that some of the attorneys were targeted for dismissal to impede investigations of Republican politicians or that some were targeted for their failure to initiate investigations that would damage Democratic politicians or hamper Democratic-leaning voters. The U.S. attorneys were replaced with interim appointees, under provisions in the 2005 USA PATRIOT Act reauthorization.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Bud Cummins</span> American lawyer

Harry Earnest Cummins, III, known as Bud Cummins, is an American attorney, businessman and politician. He served as United States Attorney with five years of service from 2001 to 2006 in the United States District Court for the Eastern District of Arkansas.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Tim Griffin</span> 20th lieutenant governor of Arkansas

John Timothy Griffin is an American lawyer and politician serving as the 57th attorney general of Arkansas. He previously served as the 20th lieutenant governor of Arkansas, from 2015 to 2023. A member of the Republican Party, he previously was the United States Attorney for the Eastern District of Arkansas between 2006 and 2007 and U.S. Representative for Arkansas's 2nd congressional district from 2011 to 2015. Griffin defeated Democrat John Burkhalter for lieutenant governor in 2014 and served under Governor Asa Hutchinson. In summer 2020, Griffin announced his candidacy for the 2022 Arkansas gubernatorial election, but withdrew from the race in February 2021 to run for Arkansas Attorney General instead.

Scott Jennings is an American writer and conservative commentator. He is an on-air contributor for CNN, and writes for CNN.com, USA Today, and the Los Angeles Times.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Dismissed U.S. attorneys summary</span>

This article about dismissed U.S. attorneys summarizes the circumstances surrounding a number of U.S. attorneys dismissed from office in the United States Department of Justice in 2006. Eight were dismissed In December 2006, and others may have been forced out of office under similar circumstances in 2005 and 2006. The manner of the firings, the congressional response to them, and the explanations offered by Bush administration officials are aspects of a political controversy starting in the first quarter of 2007. As of May 2007 a clear explanation of why the attorneys were dismissed had not been put forward by the Bush administration or the Department of Justice leadership. There are in total 93 U.S. attorneys that serve 94 Federal district courts.

A detailed chronology of events in the dismissal of U.S. attorneys controversy.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Barry Steven Jackson</span> American presidential advisor

Barry Steven Jackson is the former chief of staff to U.S. House Speaker John Boehner. He also served as Senior Advisor to the President for George W. Bush.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">David Gewirtz</span> American computer scientist

David Allen Gewirtz is a journalist, author, and U.S. policy advisor working in technology and national security policy. He currently serves as director of the U.S. Strategic Perspective Institute.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Karl Rove</span> American political consultant and policy advisor (born 1950)

Karl Christian Rove is an American Republican political consultant, policy advisor, and lobbyist. He was Senior Advisor and Deputy Chief of Staff during the George W. Bush administration until his resignation on August 31, 2007. He has also headed the Office of Political Affairs, the Office of Public Liaison, and the White House Office of Strategic Initiatives.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Fort Lee lane closure scandal</span> Scandal involving the closure of lanes leading to the George Washington Bridge

The Fort Lee lane closure scandal, also known as the George Washington Bridge lane closure scandal or Bridgegate, was a political scandal involving a staff member and political appointees of New Jersey Governor Chris Christie colluding to create traffic jams in Fort Lee, New Jersey, by closing lanes at the main toll plaza for the upper level of the George Washington Bridge.

During her tenure as United States Secretary of State, Hillary Clinton drew controversy by using a private email server for official public communications rather than using official State Department email accounts maintained on federal servers. After a years-long FBI investigation, it was determined that Clinton's server did not contain any information or emails that were clearly marked classified. Federal agencies did, however, retrospectively determine that 100 emails contained information that should have been deemed classified at the time they were sent, including 65 emails deemed "Secret" and 22 deemed "Top Secret". An additional 2,093 emails were retroactively designated confidential by the State Department.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Richard Painter</span> American lawyer

Richard William Painter is an American lawyer, professor, and political candidate. From 2005 to 2007 Painter was the chief White House ethics lawyer in the George W. Bush administration. He is the S. Walter Richey Professor of Corporate Law at the University of Minnesota, and since 2016 has served as vice-chair of Citizens for Responsibility and Ethics in Washington (CREW), a government watchdog group.

References

  1. The Guardian . White House Says It Still Backs Gonzales. 25 March 2007.
  2. 1 2 The Washington Post . GOP Groups Told to Keep Bush Officials' E-Mails. 27 March 2007
  3. "georgewbush.com Whois Record". (domaintools.com). Retrieved 2009-08-11.
  4. "rnchq.org Whois Record". (domaintools.com). Retrieved 2009-08-11.
  5. 1 2 Rove and Co. Broke Federal Law With Email Scam by Jonathan Stein, Mother Jones, April 12, 2007
  6. 1 2 3 4 CREW Releases New Report - Without A Trace: The White House Emails and The Violations of The Presidential Records Act Archived 2008-05-16 at the Wayback Machine "Archived copy" (PDF). Archived from the original (PDF) on 2007-05-02. Retrieved 2007-04-25.{{cite web}}: CS1 maint: archived copy as title (link) Citizens for Responsibility and Ethics in Washington, April 13, 2006
  7. Officials' e-mails may be missing, White House says Democrats in Congress want messages from private system for probe of U.S. attorney firings By Tom Hamburger, Los Angeles Times, April 12, 2007
  8. "I have Karl Rove's emails". gregpalast.com. 11 May 2007. Retrieved 2007-05-26.
  9. "Millions of Bush administration e-mails recovered - CNN.com". www.cnn.com. Retrieved 2019-08-03.
  10. "gwb43.com" - who is .com
  11. CREW asks for House Investigation into White House violations of Presidential Records Act. Archived April 20, 2007, at the Wayback Machine . Citizens for Responsibility and Ethics in Washington (CREW), 15 March 2007.
  12. The Hill . Waxman wants RNC, Bush campaign to preserve e-mails. 26 March 2007
  13. News from CNN
  14. White House - April 12, 2007 Press Gaggle by Scott Stanzel Archived April 15, 2007, at the Wayback Machine
  15. CNN Politics
  16. Froomkin, Dan. The Rovian Theory washingtonpost.com 2007-03-23
  17. "georgewbush.com" - who is .com
  18. "Rove Exhibits Part 1" (PDF). pp. 50, 55, 113 etc. Archived from the original (PDF) on 2009-08-25. and "Rove Exhibits Part 2" (PDF). pp. 8, 10, 40, 46. Archived from the original (PDF) on 2009-08-15. and "White House Documents". United States House Committee on the Judiciary. Archived from the original on 2009-08-13. Retrieved 2009-08-11.
  19. Financial Times . Aides to Bush told not to destroy e-mails. 26 March 2007
  20. Committee Staff (2007-06-18). "The Use of RNC E-Mail Accounts by White House Officials". Interim Report: Administration Oversight, White House Use of Private E-mail Accounts. U.S. House Committee on Oversight and Government Reform. Archived from the original on 2007-06-27. Retrieved 2007-06-18.
  21. Dismissal attorneys uncommon
  22. Advisers' E-Mail Accounts May Have Mixed Politics and Business, White House Says By SHERYL GAY STOLBERG, The New York Times , April 12, 2007
  23. Lahey, Patrick Rove Email Subpoena United States Senate Committee on the Judiciary (via Findlaw) May 2, 2007. Retrieved May 8, 2007.
  24. Fitzgerald
  25. 1 2 3 Mother Jones: RE: Those Missing White House Emails. April 13, 2007
  26. 1 2 Citizens for Responsibility and Ethics in Washington: CREW Writes Patrick Fitzgerald Asking to Re-Open Rove Case in Light of Missing Emails Archived March 6, 2015, at the Wayback Machine . April 13, 2007.
  27. CREW Writes Patrick Fitzgerald Asking to Re-Open Rove Case in Light of Missing Emails [ permanent dead link ] Yahoo, April 13, 2007
  28. Immunity for Ex-Gonzales Aide Weighed Potential Witness's Role in Firings Cited By Paul Kane, The Washington Post, April 18, 2007; Page A08
  29. CREW learns Dept. of Education staff are using private e-mails in violation of federal law Archived May 23, 2007, at the Wayback Machine CREW, May 16, 2007
  30. Ethics watchdog accuses Education Department of illegal e-mail use by Nick Juliano, Raw Story, May 16, 2007
  31. LEGAL WORRIES OVER MISSING EMAILS GROW Archived 2007-09-27 at the Wayback Machine by John D. McKinnon, Wall Street Journal