CityNorth

Last updated

CityNorth is a planned urban mixed-use development in the Northeast Valley of Phoenix, Arizona, US; featuring retail, restaurant, residential, hotel, office, cultural, civic and entertainment uses in a pedestrian-friendly environment. At completion, CityNorth will comprise more than 5,500,000 square feet (0.51 km2; 0.20 sq mi) of development on 144 acres (0.58 km2; 0.23 sq mi). Envisioned by Thomas J. Klutznick as the urban core of the Northeast Valley of Phoenix and the commercial core for the master-planned community of Desert Ridge, CityNorth is sited near the intersection of two major freeways—Loop 101 and State Route 51, making it accessible from throughout the Phoenix metropolitan area. [1] The development will open in phases starting with Phase One, High Street, which opened in November 2008.

Contents

CityNorth is being developed with the assistance of a $97.4 million tax incentive package that was at the heart of a lawsuit between Phoenix and the Goldwater Institute. Future phases for CityNorth have been put on hold due to economic conditions.

The development was originally supposed to have Bloomingdale's, Macy's and Nordstrom as anchor department stores, but they have been pulled out of the project as a result of the Great Recession in 2009.

Construction on the project began on June 25, 2019, with water and sewer infrastructure as a starting point. An official groundbreaking is planned for early October 2019. [2] In 2020, "early site improvements have included grading what eventually will be a four-lane road". [3]

Developers

CityNorth is being developed by Thomas J. Klutznick Company. The initial phases, called CityCenter of CityNorth, are being co-developed by Thomas J. Klutznick Company and Related Companies. Some previous developments by these companies are Chicago’s Water Tower Place, 730 North Michigan Avenue, 340 on the Park and 333 West Wacker Drive; Los Angeles's Fox Plaza office tower; Boston's Copley Place; New York's Time Warner Center; Reston Town Center, Reston, Virginia; CityPlace, West Palm Beach, California; The Inn & Links at Spanish Bay, Pebble Beach, California; and The Little Nell hotel, Aspen, Colorado.

CityNorth master plan summary

+/- 5,500,000 square feet (0.51 km2; 0.20 sq mi) to +/- 6,000,000 square feet (0.56 km2; 0.22 sq mi) development
UseTypeSize
Mixed-use (3,000,000 square feet (0.28 km2; 0.11 sq mi))Office Above Retail450,000 square feet (0.04 km2; 0.02 sq mi)
Retail & Restaurant1,200,000 square feet (0.11 km2; 0.04 sq mi)
Residential Above Retail1,300,000 square feet (0.12 km2; 0.05 sq mi)
Single-use (2,500,000 square feet (0.23 km2; 0.09 sq mi))Office2,500,000 square feet (0.23 km2; 0.09 sq mi)
Residential1,500 – 2,000 units
Hotel200-500 rooms

Phase 1 – High Street

High Street opened in November 2008. It comprises restaurant, retail, residential and office over approximately 20 acres (81,000 m2).

On July 1, 2010, High Street, through foreclosure, reverted to the lenders who provided the construction financing. [4]

Phase 2 - The Boulevard

Originally scheduled to open in November 2009, [4] Phase 2 has been delayed, partly because of the downturn in Arizona's economy and partly because of the Goldwater Institute's lawsuit, Turken v. Gordon, against the $97.4 million economic development agreement with the City of Phoenix for the project.

Disagreement over economic benefit

City and developer claims

The following projections are based on estimates provided by the City of Phoenix and Thomas J. Klutznick Company.

Municipal Tax Revenues

Construction Sales Tax

Jobs Created

Other

  • $6.5 million in development fees and commercial, restaurant, construction, retail and residential-rental taxes.
  • 75 subcontractors and approximately 600 construction worker jobs for phase one.
  • Numerous intangibles for the City of Phoenix. [6]

Goldwater Institute position

The Goldwater Institute disputes these claims, considering them to be exaggerations. [7] [8] One of the studies finds two errors for the CityNorth economic impact:

According to Dr. Dave Wells, "Gross economic impacts overstate actual impacts as they presume no economic activity would have occurred otherwise—e.g., that if you did not buy shoes at CityNorth you would not buy shoes at all. And it presumes that nothing would be built if CityNorth was not developed as proposed. In addition the estimates by Elliot Pollack and Company overstate the gross retail impact by 50 percent in terms of jobs and 75 percent in terms of economic output." [7]

According to the Goldwater Institute, the economic impact is less than $500 million a year, almost a quarter of the estimated impact by the city. [7]

Lawsuit, Turken v. Gordon

To develop CityNorth, the Thomas J. Klutznick Company entered into a sales tax incentive agreement with the City of Phoenix where the Klutznick company will keep 50% of all sales tax dollars collected at CityNorth, up to $97.4 million for 11.3 years. This sales tax incentive put CityNorth at the center of a lawsuit brought on by the Goldwater Institute, which is seeking to challenge corporate subsidies in Arizona. In exchange for $97.4 million Klutznick will allow Phoenix to lease 3,180 parking spaces, 200 of which will be reserved for city bus carpoolers. The lease will last 45 years.

On April 2, 2008, Maricopa County Superior Court Judge Robert Miles ruled in favor of the City of Phoenix and Thomas J. Klutznick Company. Judge Miles denied the Goldwater Institute's claim that the City's agreement with CityNorth violated the Arizona Constitution. He ruled that the economic activity generated by CityNorth is “undoubtedly” in the public interest. [9] The Goldwater Institute has since replied by appealing the ruling. [10]

The developer of CityNorth and the City of Phoenix filed claims in Maricopa County Superior Court on April 22, 2008, requesting that the court order the Goldwater Institute to pay legal fees incurred while fighting the lawsuit. [11] [12] The CityNorth filing argues that the Institute “compounded the length and complexity of the litigation with irrelevant ‘experts’ who hadn't even read the agreement, and displayed a reckless disregard for the enormous fiscal and business interests with which it was interfering.” [13] According to the City of Phoenix’s filing, “Not only did the Goldwater Institute proceed with this action knowing that it might be ordered to pay the city’s fees and costs, it litigated this case in a manner that increased its scope and expense far beyond that which was required to fully litigate the dispositive issues therin.” [14] [15]

The Goldwater Institute argues the attorney's fees request violates conditions agreed upon by all parties during the trial. Clint Bolick, chief litigator for the Goldwater Institute, states "Courts almost never have awarded attorney fees against firms seeking to vindicate public rights. The reasons were articulated by Arizona Supreme Court Justice Stanley Feldman in the very same case, Wistuber v. Paradise Valley Unified School District, that all the parties agree sets the legal parameters for the Gift Clause under which the CityNorth case is litigated." [16]

Mr. Bolick asserted that constitutional cases, such as Turken v. Gordon, are rarely won at the lower court level, and expected a victory at the appeals court to be more likely. [16] [17]

City of Phoenix/CityNorth position

The agreement between the City of Phoenix and CityNorth's developer allows CityNorth to be built as a dense urban project designed to counter sprawl and reduce traffic. Without an incentive for parking garages, it is likely that more than half of the development would have been consumed by surface parking lots, thus limiting the number of sales-tax-generating businesses. [18] As stated in Judge Miles’ ruling, “The agreement was designed to ensure that the project that is built provides the contemplated benefits – particularly the substantial tax revenues – on a schedule and at a level that is more advantageous to the public than some other, differently configured project that might be built at the site.” [9] [15]

No City funds were advanced and no City tax revenues are at risk. The developer must bear all of the estimated $1.5 billion cost to develop CityNorth and assume all of the financial risk. CityNorth is projected to generate hundreds of millions of tax-revenue dollars for the City and thousands of jobs. [19] CityNorth will pay for itself with the revenues it generates. [18] Judge Miles states, “The monetary value to be received by the agreement is based on the sale-tax revenues to be generated by the CityNorth project from the 1.2 million feet of retail space that the developer must build before it can receive any payment from the city....Under the agreement the city is projected to receive hundreds of millions of dollars in future sales taxes to use for any public purpose it chooses.” [9] [15]

Goldwater Institute position

The Goldwater Institute claims the incentive is a corporate subsidy, which is illegal according to Arizona's constitution. [20] [21] [22] [23] [24]

According to the Goldwater Institute, Phoenix will pay more than $30,000 per year to lease 200 carpool parking spaces for the next 45 years. [25] The city, which claims the incentive is not a subsidy but a market based incentive, could have bought and owned 6,950 parking spaces in a parking garage for the same price it paid to lease 200. [26] The Goldwater Institute also obtained records on the attorney's fees for the city, claiming that Phoenix spends more than $10,000 per week to defend the subsidy. [27]

The Goldwater Institute also believes that the city has overestimated the benefits of the project. The City estimates a $1.9 billion impact while a Goldwater Institute study argues the true impact will be less than $500 million. [7] The Goldwater Institute also argues that no net benefit will result from the subsidy because the mall would have been built anyway due to the high demand for shopping in a rapidly growing and affluent section of Phoenix. [25] Dr. Wells also questions the public benefit of the CityNorth project, finding that the area in which CityNorth is being constructed has an average income per capita that is $21,000 higher than the rest of Phoenix and the demographic population around CityNorth is 3 times more likely to be white than the rest of Phoenix.

According to the Goldwater Institute, the subsidy violates three provisions of the Arizona state constitution, the Gift Clause, Privilege and Immunities Clause, and the Special Laws Clause. [28] The Goldwater Institute believes the incentive is nothing more than a corporate subsidy aimed at rewarding the politically well connected. [26]

Arizona Supreme Court decision

On January 25, 2010, the Arizona Supreme Court struck down the Appeals Court ruling and allowed the CityNorth agreement to stand. [29] The Court upheld that the City of Phoenix and Klutznick Company acted in good faith based on more than 25 years of case law. The Court's ruling made it clear that deals between the government and private developers like CityNorth must have a direct benefit to the government. Any indirect benefits, such as jobs and sales-tax increases cannot apply to the deal, as a result. [30] Thus, deals in the future must do two things: specify what the government will get in return, and assure that the benefits the government receives in return satisfies the government's investment in the deal. [31]

Related Research Articles

The Baltimore Development Corporation (BDC) is a nonprofit corporation and public-private agency contracted by the City of Baltimore to promote economic development.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Clint Bolick</span> Justice of the Arizona Supreme Court

Clint Bolick is a justice of the Arizona Supreme Court. Previously, he served as Vice President of Litigation at the conservative/libertarian Goldwater Institute. He co-founded the libertarian Institute for Justice, where he was the Vice President and Director of Litigation from 1991 until 2004. He led two cases that went before the Supreme Court of the United States. He has also defended state-based school choice programs in the Supreme Courts of Wisconsin and Ohio.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Tax increment financing</span>

Tax increment financing (TIF) is a public financing method that is used as a subsidy for redevelopment, infrastructure, and other community-improvement projects in many countries, including the United States. The original intent of a TIF program is to stimulate private investment in a blighted area that has been designated to be in need of economic revitalization. Similar or related value capture strategies are used around the world.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Goldwater Institute</span> Conservative and libertarian public policy think tank

The Goldwater Institute is a conservative and libertarian public policy think tank located in Phoenix whose stated mission is "to defend and strengthen the freedom guaranteed to all Americans in the constitutions of the United States and all fifty states". The organization was established in 1988 with the support of former Senator Barry Goldwater.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Phil Gordon (politician)</span> American politician (born 1951)

Phil Gordon is an American politician who served as the 58th mayor of Phoenix, Arizona from 2004 to 2012 and a member of the Phoenix City Council. Gordon is a member of the Democratic Party.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Joe Arpaio</span> American former law enforcement officer and politician

Joseph Michael Arpaio is an American former law enforcement officer and politician. He served as the 36th Sheriff of Maricopa County, Arizona for 24 years, from 1993 to 2017, losing reelection to Democrat Paul Penzone in 2016.

Fiesta Mall is a former shopping mall in Mesa, Arizona, United States. Opened in 1979 after nine years of development, it was built by Homart Development Company, the former shopping mall development division of the department store Sears. Sears was the first anchor store to open in the mall, doing so in 1977. Also present as anchor stores were The Broadway and Goldwater's, with Diamond's following in 1980. The mall began experiencing declines in traffic following the opening of Arizona Mills in 1997, and saw numerous anchor store and inline tenancy changes. After a long period of decline, it was shuttered in January 2018.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Los Arcos Mall</span> Shopping mall in Scottsdale, Arizona, United States

Los Arcos Mall was an enclosed shopping mall on the southeast corner of Scottsdale and McDowell roads in Scottsdale, Arizona. The mall, which operated from 1969 to 1999, featured a Spanish architectural motif and took its name from "The Arches" in Spanish. In the 1990s, the mall lost shoppers and both of its anchors, particularly to the Scottsdale Fashion Square center, which was closer to population growth in the city. The last anchor, Sears, left Los Arcos for Fashion Square in February 1999.

The Domain is a high-density office, retail, and residential center in northwest Austin, Texas, United States that has been described as being "Austin's second downtown" and that primarily consists of 5-over-1 construction. The initial phase of the project was completed in March 2007.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Metrocenter (Phoenix, Arizona)</span> Former shopping mall

Metrocenter was a regional enclosed shopping mall in northwest Phoenix, Arizona. It was bounded by Interstate 17, 31st, Dunlap and Peoria Avenues. Before its closure, the three most recently open anchor stores were Harkins Theatres, Walmart Supercenter, and Dillard's Clearance Center; three additional vacant anchor stores included former Sears, JCPenney, and Macy's locations. The mall featured 100 stores, a 12 screen movie theater, and a food court. Since January 2021, the mall had been owned by the Carlyle Development Group based in New York City. The mall officially closed on June 30, 2020.

The metropolitan area of Phoenix in the U.S. state of Arizona contains one of the nation's largest and fastest-growing freeway systems, with over 1,405 lane miles (2,261 km) as of 2005.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Arizona</span> U.S. state

Arizona is a state in the Southwestern United States. It is the 6th-largest and the 14th-most-populous of the 50 states. Its capital and largest city is Phoenix. Arizona is part of the Four Corners region with Utah to the north, Colorado to the northeast, and New Mexico to the east; its other neighboring states are Nevada to the northwest, California to the west and the Mexican states of Sonora and Baja California to the south and southwest.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">History of Phoenix, Arizona</span> Aspect of history

The history of Phoenix, Arizona, goes back millennia, beginning with nomadic paleo-Indians who existed in the Americas in general, and the Salt River Valley in particular, about 7,000 BC until about 6,000 BC. Mammoths were the primary prey of hunters. As that prey moved eastward, they followed, vacating the area. Other nomadic tribes moved into the area, mostly from Mexico to the south and California to the west. Around approximately 1,000 BC, the nomadic began to be accompanied by two other types of cultures, commonly called the farmers and the villagers, prompted by the introduction of maize into their culture. Out of these archaic Indians, the Hohokam civilization arose. The Hohokam first settled the area around 1 AD, and in about 500 years, they had begun to establish the canal system which enabled agriculture to flourish in the area. They suddenly disappeared by 1450, for unknown reasons. By the time the first Europeans arrived at the beginning of the 16th century, the two main groups of native Indians who inhabited the area were the O'odham and Sobaipuri tribes.

The Maricopa County Sheriff's Office (MCSO) is a law enforcement agency in Maricopa County, Arizona that was involved in a number of controversies. It is the largest sheriff's office in the state of Arizona and provides general and specialized law enforcement to unincorporated areas of Maricopa County, serving as the primary law enforcement for unincorporated areas of the county as well as incorporated cities within the county which have contracted with the agency for law-enforcement services. It also operates the county jail system. Elected in 2016, Paul Penzone is the current sheriff of Maricopa County. Penzone replaced Joe Arpaio after his 24-year tenure as sheriff.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Phoenix Coyotes bankruptcy and sale</span> Legal issues of the professional ice hockey team

The Phoenix Coyotes, a professional ice hockey team now known as the Arizona Coyotes and playing in the National Hockey League (NHL), filed for bankruptcy in 2009 after incurring several hundred million dollars of losses since their move to Phoenix, Arizona from Winnipeg, Manitoba, where they were known as the Winnipeg Jets. Bankruptcy court rejected a plan to sell the team and move it to Canada, and the team was purchased by the NHL. The NHL operated the team in Phoenix for four seasons while seeking a new owner. After several prospective purchases fell through, the team was finally sold in the summer of 2013.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Government incentives for plug-in electric vehicles</span>

Government incentives for plug-in electric vehicles have been established around the world to support policy-driven adoption of plug-in electric vehicles. These incentives mainly take the form of purchase rebates, tax exemptions and tax credits, and additional perks that range from access to bus lanes to waivers on fees. The amount of the financial incentives may depend on vehicle battery size or all-electric range. Often hybrid electric vehicles are included. Some countries extend the benefits to fuel cell vehicles, and electric vehicle conversions.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">2011 Phoenix mayoral election</span> American mayoral election

The mayoral election for Phoenix, Arizona, United States, in 2011 was held in a two-round system on August 30, 2011, and November 8, 2011. Greg Stanton, a former city councilman, was elected over Wes Gullett, and took office on January 3, 2012, succeeding Phil Gordon, who held the office of Mayor of Phoenix from 2004 to 2012. The election coincided with the Phoenix City Council elections to the four odd-numbered districts.

The following is a timeline of the history of the city of Phoenix, Arizona, United States.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Harper Court</span>

Harper Court is a mixed-use commercial development in the Hyde Park community area on the South Side of Chicago, Illinois, United States, that includes a Hyatt Hotel and a 12-storey office tower that is leased and occupied by the University of Chicago. Although the hotel opened on September 17, 2013, the commercial structure, which also has extensive retail and parking space, officially opened on November 8, 2013. The University of Chicago exercised its option to purchase most of the development on November 13 and then put most of what it acquired up for sale in March 2014. The University provided much of the financing and retains a master lease over the retail tenants. The development was acquired by Clal Insurance Company in July 2014.

Leapfrog development occurs when developers skip over land to obtain cheaper land further away from cities, thus, leaving huge areas empty between the city and the new development. It can be seen when it comes to the development or urbanization of more rural areas.

References

  1. ↑ www.bizjournals.com https://www.bizjournals.com/phoenix/stories/2006/05/08/story6.html . Retrieved 2021-02-18.{{cite web}}: Missing or empty |title= (help)
  2. ↑ "Construction begins on City North in northeast Phoenix area". yourvalley.net. 25 June 2019. Retrieved 17 September 2019.
  3. ↑ www.bizjournals.com https://www.bizjournals.com/phoenix/news/2020/02/14/developers-aim-for-city-in-the-city-at-desert.html . Retrieved 2021-02-18.{{cite web}}: Missing or empty |title= (help)
  4. 1 2 Clancy, Michael (July 2, 2010). "CityNorth's High Street taken over by original lenders". The Arizona Republic . Retrieved 2020-07-21.{{cite web}}: CS1 maint: url-status (link)
  5. 1 2 Gordon, Phil and Peggy Neely. "CityNorth project a big win for Phoenix”, The Arizona Republic , April 7, 2008.
  6. ↑ Fairbanks, Frank (July 26, 2009). "Hobbled for the future". The Arizona Republic . Retrieved 2020-07-21.{{cite web}}: CS1 maint: url-status (link)
  7. 1 2 3 4 Wells, Dave. "CityNorth Retail Economic Analysis" Archived 2012-04-14 at the Wayback Machine October 30, 2007
  8. ↑ Pavlov, Andrey. "Review of CityNorth Project" Archived 2012-04-14 at the Wayback Machine October 30, 2007
  9. 1 2 3 Miles, Judge Robert. "Turken v. Gordon Ruling" Archived 2012-04-14 at the Wayback Machine . Superior Court of Arizona, Maricopa County. April 2, 2008.
  10. ↑ "Goldwater Institute Will Promptly Appeal CityNorth Subsidy Ruling" Goldwater Institute , April 2, 2008
  11. ↑ Buccholtz, Jan. "CityNorth developer, city of Phoenix sue Goldwater Institute for legal fees", The Business Journal of Phoenix, April 23, 2008.
  12. ↑ “Developer and City of Phoenix File Claims for Attorneys’ Fees”, April 22, 2008.
  13. ↑ “Developer Petition for Attorneys’ Fees” [ permanent dead link ], Superior Court of Arizona, Maricopa County, No. CV2007-013766, April 22, 2008.
  14. ↑ “City of Phoenix Petition for Attorneys’ Fees” [ permanent dead link ], Superior Court of Arizona, Maricopa County, No. CV2007-013766, April 22, 2008.
  15. 1 2 3 Buccholtz, Jan. "CityNorth developer, city of Phoenix sue Goldwater Institute for legal fees", The Business Journal of Phoenix, April 23, 2008
  16. 1 2 Bolick, Clint. "The Empire Strikes Back With Massive Attorneys’ Fee Request in CityNorth Case" Archived 2014-10-06 at the Wayback Machine Goldwater Institute, April 24, 2008
  17. ↑ Clancy, Michael. "Institute hopes to block CityNorth agreement on appeal" The Arizona Republic , April 16, 2008
  18. 1 2 "CityNorth Incentive Agreement Fact Sheet" (PDF). 0162f72.netsolhost.com. 2011-07-14. Archived (PDF) from the original on 2011-07-14. Retrieved 2020-07-21.
  19. ↑ Keuth, Don. "CityNorth deal an incentive, not a subsidy" Archived 2011-07-14 at the Wayback Machine , The Tribune, May 20, 2008.
  20. ↑ Fenske, Sarah."Revolting Development", New Times September 9, 2008.
  21. ↑ Boyd, Lindsay."Goldwater Institute suit against city of Phoenix Update" Townhall.com, March 5, 2008
  22. ↑ Ducey, Lynn (Feb 15, 2008). "Bloomingdale's joins CityNorth mix as lawsuit continues over project's tax deals". Phoenix Business Journal. Archived from the original on 2008-02-21. Retrieved 2020-07-21.
  23. ↑ Will, George F. (2008-03-16). "What taxpayers don't know they're paying for". seattlepi.com. Archived from the original on 2012-10-12. Retrieved 2020-07-21.
  24. ↑ Clancy, Michael. "Judge hears arguments in CityNorth case", Arizona Republic, February 12, 2008
  25. 1 2 Schlomach, Byron. "Deal Breaker: A Critique of Phoenix's Subsidy of CityNorth" Goldwater Institute, August 8, 2007
  26. 1 2 Gibbons, Patrick. "Problematic Parking" Goldwater Institute, March 4, 2008
  27. ↑ "City of Phoenix Spends $10,000 Per Week on Attorneys to Defend CityNorth Subsidy" Goldwater Institute, January 8, 2008
  28. ↑ "Arizona's constitution prohibits corporate subsidies" [ permanent dead link ] Goldwater Institute, August 09, 2007
  29. ↑ Clancy, Michael (Jan 26, 2010). "CityNorth agreement stands for now, but court clarifies position on future cases". The Arizona Republic . Retrieved 2020-07-21.{{cite web}}: CS1 maint: url-status (link)
  30. ↑ Clancy, Michael. "CityNorth agreement stands for now", The Arizona Republic, January 25, 2010.
  31. ↑ Clancy, Michael. "CityNorth decision to impact future development deals", The Arizona Republic, February 1, 2010.
33°41′00″N112°00′00″W / 33.68333°N 112.00000°W / 33.68333; -112.00000
This page is based on this Wikipedia article
Text is available under the CC BY-SA 4.0 license; additional terms may apply.
Images, videos and audio are available under their respective licenses.