A Mathematician's Lament

Last updated
A Mathematician's Lament
A Mathematician's Lament.png
Front cover
AuthorPaul Lockhart
LanguageEnglish
Genre Philosophy, Mathematics
Published2009 Bellevue Literary Press
Publication placeUnited States
Media typePrint (paperback)
Pages140
ISBN 978-1-934137-17-8

A Mathematician's Lament, often referred to informally as Lockhart's Lament, is a short book on mathematics education by Paul Lockhart, originally a research mathematician at Brown University and U.C. Santa Cruz, and subsequently a math teacher at Saint Ann's School in Brooklyn, New York City for many years. This strongly worded opinion piece is organized into two parts. The first part, "Lamentation", criticizes the way mathematics is typically taught in American schools and argues for an aesthetic, intuitive, and problem-oriented approach to teaching. The second part, "Exultation", gives specific examples of how to teach mathematics as an art.

Contents

Background

This book was developed from a 25-page essay that was written in 2002, originally circulated in typewritten manuscript copies, and subsequently published by Keith Devlin on his online column for the Mathematical Association of America's webzine MAA Online. [1]

Lockhart has since written Measurement (2012) and Arithmetic (2017). [2] [3]

Summary

In the first part, “Lamentation”, Lockhart emphasizes mathematics as an art. He criticizes mathematics education for prioritizing rote memorization and notation, which he argues is of little interest to the average student. Lockhart pushes instead for a focus on mathematical proofs and showcasing the beauty in mathematics, absent of any application. He also criticizes the use of two-column proofs in the teaching of geometry for obscuring this beauty and misrepresenting how mathematicians create proofs.

In the second part, “Exultation”, Lockhart gives specific examples from number theory, geometry, and graph theory to argue that math primarily arises from play. He argues that this play should be the primary focus of mathematics education.

Reception

Daniel Farlow and William Schmidt, writing in Math Horizons and Notices of the American Mathematical Society , respectively, praised Lockhart's criticisms of mathematics education. [4] [5] Schmidt, however, also criticized Lockhart's proposed approach to math education for exacerbating preexisting inequalities within the education system. Timo Tossavainen, writing in The Mathematical Intelligencer , criticized Lockhart for "overlook[ing] what is realistically possible in mathematics teachers’ education", but he ultimately praised the book as a "necessary reminder of how all is lost if the joy of doing mathematics and the students’ right to experience it are not at the heart of mathematics education." [6]

Related Research Articles

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Fibonacci</span> Italian mathematician (c. 1170 – c. 1240/50)

Fibonacci was an Italian mathematician from the Republic of Pisa, considered to be "the most talented Western mathematician of the Middle Ages".

Mathematics is a field of study that discovers and organizes methods, theories and theorems that are developed and proved for the needs of empirical sciences and mathematics itself. There are many areas of mathematics, which include number theory, algebra, geometry, analysis, and set theory.

<i>Where Mathematics Comes From</i> 2000 mathematics book by Lakoff & Núñez

Where Mathematics Comes From: How the Embodied Mind Brings Mathematics into Being is a book by George Lakoff, a cognitive linguist, and Rafael E. Núñez, a psychologist. Published in 2000, WMCF seeks to found a cognitive science of mathematics, a theory of embodied mathematics based on conceptual metaphor.

Philosophy of mathematics is the branch of philosophy that deals with the nature of mathematics and its relationship with other human activities.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Paul Halmos</span> Hungarian-American mathematician (1916–2006)

Paul Richard Halmos was a Hungarian-born American mathematician and probabilist who made fundamental advances in the areas of mathematical logic, probability theory, operator theory, ergodic theory, and functional analysis. He was also recognized as a great mathematical expositor. He has been described as one of The Martians.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Mathematics education</span> Teaching, learning, and scholarly research in mathematics

In contemporary education, mathematics education—known in Europe as the didactics or pedagogy of mathematics—is the practice of teaching, learning, and carrying out scholarly research into the transfer of mathematical knowledge.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Pure mathematics</span> Mathematics independent of applications

Pure mathematics is the study of mathematical concepts independently of any application outside mathematics. These concepts may originate in real-world concerns, and the results obtained may later turn out to be useful for practical applications, but pure mathematicians are not primarily motivated by such applications. Instead, the appeal is attributed to the intellectual challenge and aesthetic beauty of working out the logical consequences of basic principles.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Keith Devlin</span> British mathematician

Keith James Devlin is a British mathematician and popular science writer. Since 1987 he has lived in the United States. He has dual British-American citizenship.

Principles and Standards for School Mathematics (PSSM) are guidelines produced by the National Council of Teachers of Mathematics (NCTM) in 2000, setting forth recommendations for mathematics educators. They form a national vision for preschool through twelfth grade mathematics education in the US and Canada. It is the primary model for standards-based mathematics.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Carl B. Allendoerfer</span> American mathematician

Carl Barnett Allendoerfer was an American mathematician in the mid-twentieth century, known for his work in topology and mathematics education.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">David Eugene Smith</span> American mathematician

David Eugene Smith was an American mathematician, educator, and editor.

Lynn Arthur Steen was an American mathematician who was a professor of mathematics at St. Olaf College, Northfield, Minnesota, in the U.S. He wrote numerous books and articles on the teaching of mathematics. He was a past president of the Mathematics Association of America (MAA) and served as chairman of the Conference Board of the Mathematical Sciences.

Reform mathematics is an approach to mathematics education, particularly in North America. It is based on principles explained in 1989 by the National Council of Teachers of Mathematics (NCTM). The NCTM document Curriculum and Evaluation Standards for School Mathematics (CESSM) set forth a vision for K–12 mathematics education in the United States and Canada. The CESSM recommendations were adopted by many local- and federal-level education agencies during the 1990s. In 2000, the NCTM revised its CESSM with the publication of Principles and Standards for School Mathematics (PSSM). Like those in the first publication, the updated recommendations became the basis for many states' mathematics standards, and the method in textbooks developed by many federally-funded projects. The CESSM de-emphasised manual arithmetic in favor of students developing their own conceptual thinking and problem solving. The PSSM presents a more balanced view, but still has the same emphases.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Mathematical beauty</span> Aesthetic value of mathematics

Mathematical beauty is the aesthetic pleasure derived from the abstractness, purity, simplicity, depth or orderliness of mathematics. Mathematicians may express this pleasure by describing mathematics as beautiful or describe mathematics as an art form, or, at a minimum, as a creative activity.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Napkin ring problem</span> Problem in geometry

In geometry, the napkin-ring problem involves finding the volume of a "band" of specified height around a sphere, i.e. the part that remains after a hole in the shape of a circular cylinder is drilled through the center of the sphere. It is a counterintuitive fact that this volume does not depend on the original sphere's radius but only on the resulting band's height.

Fernando Quadros Gouvêa is a Brazilian number theorist and historian of mathematics who won the Lester R. Ford Award of the Mathematical Association of America (MAA) in 1995 for his exposition of Wiles's proof of Fermat's Last Theorem. He also won the Beckenbach Book Prize of the MAA in 2007 for his book with William P. Berlinghoff, Math through the Ages: A Gentle History for Teachers and Others . He is the Carter Professor of Mathematics at Colby College in Waterville, Maine.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Burkard Polster</span>

Burkard Polster is a German mathematician who runs and presents the Mathologer channel on YouTube. He is a professor of mathematics at Monash University in Melbourne, Australia.

Bonnie Gold is an American mathematician, mathematical logician, philosopher of mathematics, and mathematics educator. She is a professor emerita of mathematics at Monmouth University.

Elena Anne Corie Marchisotto is a mathematician, mathematics educator, and historian of mathematics. She is a professor emeritus of mathematics at California State University, Northridge.

Susan Hammond Marshall is an American mathematician specializing in number theory, arithmetic geometry, and mathematical proof techniques. She is an associate professor of mathematics at Monmouth University.

References

  1. Devlin, Keith (2009). Foreword, p. 9 of Lockhart, Paul (2009), A Mathematician's Lament
  2. Amy Ackerberg-Hastings (October 5, 2017). "Review of Arithmetic". MAA Reviews. Mathematical Association of America. Retrieved October 31, 2024.
  3. Katherine Safford-Ramus (July 16, 2013). "Review of Measurement". MAA Reviews. Mathematical Association of America. Retrieved October 31, 2024.
  4. Farlow, Daniel W. (April 2015). "THE VIEW FROM HERE: How School Cheats Us". Math Horizons . 22 (4): 16–17 via JSTOR.
  5. Schmidt, William (April 2013). "A Mathematician's Lament" (PDF). Notices of the American Mathematical Society . 60 (4): 461–462. Archived from the original (PDF) on May 16, 2024.
  6. Tossavainen, Timo (February 28, 2014). "A Mathematician's Lament: How School Cheats Us Out of Our Most Fascinating and Imaginative Art Form by Paul Lockhart, Foreword by Keith Devlin". The Mathematical Intelligencer . 36: 68–69.

Further reading