Anthony Garcia (serial killer)

Last updated

Anthony Garcia
Born
Anthony Joseph Garcia

(1973-06-07) June 7, 1973 (age 51)
Los Angeles, California, U.S.
Conviction(s) First degree murder (4 counts)
Criminal penalty Death
Details
Victims4
Span of crimes
2008–2013
CountryUnited States
State(s) Nebraska
Date apprehended
July 15, 2013
Imprisoned at Tecumseh State Correctional Institution, Tecumseh, Nebraska

Anthony Joseph Garcia (born June 7, 1973 [1] ) is an American serial killer and former medical doctor who was convicted of two separate double murders, committed in 2008 and 2013 in Omaha, Nebraska. Garcia was arrested in July 2013 and went to trial in October 2016. He was found guilty on all counts, and later sentenced to death.

Contents

Early life and practice

Garcia was born on June 7, 1973, in Los Angeles, California, to Fred, a postal service worker, and Estella, a nurse born in Mexico. He has two younger siblings. [2]

Garcia received his medical degree from the University of Utah in 1999. He then began a residency at St. Elizabeth's Medical Center where he remained for approximately six months before being forced to resign for "unprofessional and inappropriate conduct." [3]

In July 2000, Garcia began another residency in the pathology department at the Creighton University Medical Center - Bergan Mercy in Omaha, Nebraska. [3] He soon received poor reviews from Dr. Chandra Bewtra, a professor of his, who later told reporters, "He had an attitude problem. He just did not want to learn. I thought he was arrogant; he was mean. He liked to hurt people and derive pleasure from there. And so he was not a nice person." [4] Garcia responded to Bewtra's reviews with threats to sue. [5] Despite his threats, Garcia was terminated for "erratic behavior" within a year by Drs. William Hunter and Roger Brumback. [4]

Garcia then moved on to the University of Illinois Chicago (UIC), where he worked from 2001 to 2003. He later told authorities that he left due to poor health, migraine headaches, and depression. [3]

Garcia then enrolled in a psychiatry residency program at LSU Health Sciences Center Shreveport in Shreveport, Louisiana. He remained there until February 27, 2008, when the State Board of Medical Examiners informed him that he might not qualify for a medical license, due to the fact he had not reported his failure to finish the pathology programs at Creighton or UIC. Garcia left the next day. He then applied for and received a temporary license to practice medicine in Indiana, until he withdrew that application. [3]

In 2009, Garcia was hired to work as a contract physician in Chicago. [3]

The Creighton murders

On March 13, 2008, about two weeks after Garcia left LSU, Dr. William Hunter arrived at his home in Dundee and found the bodies of his 11-year-old son Thomas and 57-year-old housekeeper Shirlee Sherman, both of whom had been stabbed to death with knives apparently taken from the home's kitchen. Omaha police detectives Derek Mois and Scott Warner were assigned to the case. [6] Witnesses described a heavy-set olive-skinned male in the vicinity, correlating him to a silver Honda CRV with an out-of-state license plate. Police produced a sketch of the man's face based on those descriptions. [7]

Omaha police investigated the Hunter family including Thomas' online gaming presence but found no leads. [7] [8] Additionally, detectives investigated Shirlee Sherman and her family, theorizing that she may have been the intended target, but also found no viable suspects. They also investigated another stabbing that had occurred in the area, but detectives could not find a connection between the suspect in that case and the murders at the Hunter home. [7] Shirlee Sherman's family offered a $50,000 reward for information on the case and also hired a private investigator. However, a year after the murders, the case went cold. [8]

On May 14, 2013, piano mover Jason Peterson and his crew arrived at the home of Roger Brumback and his wife Mary. First thinking no one was home, one mover noted a handgun magazine lying in the home's open doorway and police were called. Peterson later told reporters that he saw Roger Brumback's body in the home, but no blood. [9] [10]

Coincidentally, detectives Mois and Warner were dispatched to the Brumback home. Detectives found that Roger had multiple gunshot wounds and a stab wound to his neck, and Mary had been stabbed to death, apparently with knives taken from the home's kitchen. Mois later stated that he and his partner immediately thought that the murders were similar to those at the Hunter home, and their suspicion of a connection between the crimes was bolstered when police learned that Dr. Brumback had been a colleague of Dr. Hunter. Additionally, it was determined that the couple had been dead for a day or two. Reporter Todd Cooper noted that the Brumbacks were last seen and heard from the previous Sunday, Mother's Day, during an online chat with their daughter. [10] [9]

Additionally, four days after the Brumback murders, Dr. Chanda Bewtra reported that someone had attempted to break into her home on Mother's Day. She and her husband were not home at the time, and she noted that nothing was missing. Police surmised that the intruder was scared off by the home's alarm system. [11] [12]

Investigations and arrest

After the Brumback murders, it was theorized that the attempted break-in at the Bewtra home was connected to the double homicides. [13] Mois came upon Garcia's file and saw that Garcia's dismissal from Creighton had interfered with his ability to get employment or licensure in other states, and surmised that Garcia had enough motive to harm all three doctors. [3] [12]

Mois then confirmed that shortly before the Brumback murders, Garcia, now living in Terre Haute, Indiana, had purchased a firearm that would fit the magazine found at the Brumback home. Also, Garcia's credit card had been used twice in the area near the Brumback murders on that Mother's Day, and Garcia's phone showed a search for the Brumback address only a few minutes after the alarm sounded at the Bewtra home. [13]

Omaha detectives coordinated with Indiana law enforcement and the FBI to track Garcia. On July 15, he was arrested on a highway in Union County, Illinois. As his blood alcohol level was twice the legal limit, Garcia was immediately charged with DUI. When officers searched his car, they found a .45 caliber handgun, 50 bullets, an LSU lab coat, and a stethoscope. Nebraska authorities then took him into custody and charged Garcia with four counts of first-degree murder and use of a handgun. [2] The State of Illinois suspended his medical license within days of his arrest. [14]

Trial, conviction, sentencing

Garcia's trial began on October 3, 2016. [15] Douglas County Attorneys Don Kleine and Brenda Beadle prosecuted the case. Defense counsel included lead attorney Bob Motta Jr., his wife Alison Motta, father Robert Motta Sr., and Jeremy Jorgenson. [16] However, before the trial began, Judge Gary Randall removed Alison Motta from the case for trying to "poison the jury pool" after she made public statements about DNA evidence. [17]

During the trial, prosecutors showed evidence from Garcia's home including a trash bag in the kitchen sink, in which were his termination letter from Creighton and handwritten notes with a "to-do" list that included such items as "put tape on your fingers" and "buy common shoes." Investigators also found that when Garcia was in Louisiana, he had owned a silver Honda CRV fitting the description of the car seen around the Hunter home at the time of the first killings. [18] In addition, his saliva sample matched DNA left behind by the intruder who had broken into the Bewtra's house on the day the Brumbacks were killed. [11]

Prosecutors also called a former stripper from Terre Haute, Cecilia Hoffman, who said that four years after the Dundee murders, when Garcia had tried to pursue her romantically, she attempted to rebuff him by saying that she only dated "bad boys." According to her statements, Garcia responded by saying that he had "killed a young boy and an old woman." [11] [18] Motta responded by noting that she had admitted to drinking the day of her conversation with the police about the incident, but Hoffman denied being drunk. [19]

Prosecutors also pointed out that the four victims had been stabbed in a similar manner and that the gun found in Garcia's car matched the type of handgun magazine that had been left behind at the Brumback crime scene. Throughout a majority of the proceedings, Garcia wore headphones and appeared to be asleep. [20]

On October 26, 2016, Garcia was convicted on nine counts; four counts of first-degree murder, four counts of use of a deadly weapon to commit a felony, and one count of felony burglary. [1] The Mottas withdrew from the case before sentencing, leaving Garcia with a public defender. [21] Sentencing was initially delayed, as the state of Nebraska was set to vote on whether to repeal or retain the death penalty. [20] In November of that year, the state voted to retain the death penalty, and in September 2018, a three-judge panel sentenced Garcia to death. [22]

Post conviction

Garcia remained on death row at the Tecumseh State Correctional Institution in Tecumseh. [1] In November 2022, the public defender's office began attempts to appeal his sentencing [23] and by March 2023 had filed a motion for a new trial, calling his previous attorneys "a nightmare." [24] In his appeal, Garcia noted 130 alleged errors made during his trial that involved 15 topics, including motions to suppress, DNA and digital evidence, ineffective counsel, and constitutionality of the death penalty. Garcia also claimed that his counsel was ineffective for “failing to seek a third competency hearing when he stopped communicating with his counsel prior to trial.” He described himself as having a “diminished capacity.” On Friday, Sept. 8th, 2023, the Nebraska Supreme Court rejected his appeal for a new trial. The court ruled that, “We cannot determine on direct appeal whether counsel was ineffective in certain regards. We otherwise affirm Garcia’s convictions and sentences.”

In 2014, detectives Derek Mois, Scott Warner, Ryan Davis, and Nick Herfordt were named Crime Stoppers Officer of the Year for their work on the Garcia case. [25] [26]

In 2010, Creighton University unveiled a memorial to Thomas Hunter, installed on the southeast lawn of the school's Cardiac Center. [27] In 2023, the statue was moved near the CL Rachel and Werner Center.

48 Hours reported on the case in the 2017 episode, "Resident Evil". Dateline reported on the case in a two-hour 2017 episode, "Haunting". A fictionalized version of the case was included in the true crime series, James Patterson’s Murder is Forever, on the Investigation Discovery channel. [28]

See also

Related Research Articles

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Murder of Laci Peterson</span> 2002 murder of an American woman in California

Laci Denise Peterson was an American woman murdered by her husband, Scott Lee Peterson, while eight months pregnant with their first child. She disappeared in 2002, from the couple's home in Modesto, California, after which Scott reported her missing. The next year, her remains and those of her unborn son, whom the couple had planned to name Conner, were discovered on the shores of San Francisco Bay; subsequently, Scott was arrested and charged with two counts of murder. In 2004, Scott was found guilty of the first-degree murder of Laci and the second-degree murder of Conner.

Capital punishment is a legal penalty in the U.S. state of Nebraska. In 2015, the state legislature voted to repeal the death penalty, overriding governor Pete Ricketts' veto. However, a petition drive secured enough signatures to suspend the repeal until a public vote. In the November 2016 general election, voters rejected the repeal measure, preserving capital punishment in the state. Nebraska currently has 12 inmates on death row.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">CHI Health Center Omaha</span> Indoor arena in Omaha, Nebraska

The CHI Health Center Omaha is an arena and convention center in the central United States, located in the North Downtown neighborhood of Omaha, Nebraska. Operated by the Metropolitan Entertainment & Convention Authority (MECA), the 1.1-million-square-foot (100,000 m2) facility has an 18,975-seat arena, a 194,000 sq ft (18,000 m2) exhibition hall, and 62,000 sq ft (5,800 m2) of meeting space.

David Rice and Edward Poindexter were African-American activists charged and convicted of the murder of Omaha Police Officer Larry Minard. Minard died when a suitcase bomb containing dynamite exploded in a North Omaha home on August 17, 1970. Officer John Tess was also injured in the explosion. Poindexter and Rice had been members of the Black Panther Party.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Lords of Chaos (criminal group)</span> 1996 teen criminal group

The Lords of Chaos was a self-styled teen militia formed on April 13, 1996, in Fort Myers, Florida, United States. It was led by Kevin Donald Foster. The group gained notoriety for a crime spree that ended on April 30, 1996, with the murder of one of the boys' teachers, Mark Schwebes, the Riverdale High School's band director.

Joshua Paul "Josh" Mankiewicz is an American journalist, who has been reporting for Dateline NBC since 1995. He has reported for The Today Show and NBC Nightly News with Brian Williams, and Sunday Night with Megyn Kelly. Before moving to NBC, Mankiewicz worked as a producer and reporter for ABC News.

The civil rights movement in Omaha, Nebraska, has roots that extend back until at least 1912. With a history of racial tension that starts before the founding of the city, Omaha has been the home of numerous overt efforts related to securing civil rights for African Americans since at least the 1870s.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Frank Carter (murderer)</span>

Frank Carter was a notorious murderer and self-confessed serial killer in Omaha, Nebraska. Confirmed to have committed two murders, Carter claimed to have murdered 43 people. However, reporters doubted most of his claims. The Lexington Herald-Leader called most of the alleged murders "obviously fictitious".

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Westroads Mall shooting</span> 2007 mass shooting in Omaha, Nebraska

On December 5, 2007, 19-year-old Robert Hawkins shot and killed eight people and wounded four others in a Von Maur department store at Westroads Mall in Omaha, Nebraska, before committing suicide by shooting himself in the head. It was the deadliest mass murder in Nebraska since the rampage of Charles Starkweather in 1958. It is also the deadliest mass shooting in Nebraska history.

In 2013, two prosecutors and a prosecutor's wife were murdered in Kaufman County, Texas. The case gained national attention in the United States due to speculation that the Aryan Brotherhood prison gang was responsible, but this was later found to be untrue. Eric Lyle Williams, a former lawyer and justice of the peace whose theft case was prosecuted by two of the victims, was tried, found guilty, and sentenced to death for two of the murders. He was also charged with the murder of prosecutor Mark Hasse, but a decision was made not to prosecute him as he had already received a death sentence for the other murders. His wife, Kimberly Irene "Kim" Williams, was tried separately, and sentenced to 40 years in prison.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Murders of Bernice and Ben Novack Jr.</span> 2009 murders in Florida and NY

In 2009, Bernice Novack and her son, Fontainebleau Miami Beach hotel heir Ben Novack Jr., were murdered three months apart. Narcy Novack, Ben's estranged wife was convicted of orchestrating the murders, and after a highly publicized trial was sentenced to life in prison without the possibility of parole.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Nikko Jenkins</span> American murderer on death row (born 1986)

Nikko Allen Jenkins is an American spree killer convicted of committing four murders in Omaha, Nebraska, in August 2013. The murders occurred within a month after he had been released from prison after serving 10-and-a-half years of the 18 years to which he had been sentenced for a carjacking committed at age 15 and for assaults committed in prison. Jenkins stated that he had committed the killings at the command of the ancient serpent god Apophis. He was found competent to stand trial, found guilty of the four murders, and was sentenced to death in May 2017.

Michelle O'Keefe was an 18-year-old American college student and aspiring actress who was murdered in Palmdale, California on her way home from appearing in a Kid Rock music video. The case has attracted significant media national attention, including episodes of America's Most Wanted and Dateline NBC.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Daniel Wozniak (murderer)</span> American convicted of murder on death row

Daniel Patrick Wozniak is a former American community theatre actor who was convicted of two counts of murder in September 2016. In May 2010, Wozniak killed his neighbor and friend, Private First Class Samuel Eliezer "Sam" Herr, and Herr's friend, Juri "Julie" Kibuishi, as part of a plan to frame Herr for Kibuishi's murder and steal his combat pay. Wozniak was deeply in debt and wanted money to finance his upcoming wedding and honeymoon. Wozniak and his then-fiancée, Rachel Mae Buffett, lived in the same apartment complex as Herr in Costa Mesa, California.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Murder of Angela Samota</span> 1984 murder in Texas, US

The murder of Angela Samota occurred on October 13, 1984, when she was attacked while in her apartment, raped and killed. The case remained unsolved until DNA evidence surfaced in the 2000s, following which charges were brought against a convicted rapist, Donald Andrew Bess Jr., who was subsequently tried and received a death sentence. He died of natural causes while awaiting execution in October 2022.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Pam Hupp</span> American murderer (born 1958)

Pamela Marie Hupp is an American murderer serving a life sentence in Missouri's Chillicothe Correctional Center for the 2016 shooting of Louis Gumpenberger in her home in O'Fallon, Missouri. Hupp's claim that she had shot Gumpenberger in self-defense after he pursued her into her home wielding a knife was not accepted by law enforcement. She ultimately entered an Alford plea before charges of first-degree murder and armed criminal action could go to trial.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Murder of Jennifer Dulos</span> 2019 murder in U.S. state of Connecticut

Jennifer Dulos was an American woman who went missing on May 24, 2019. Authorities believe that she was killed in an attack at her home in New Canaan, Connecticut, United States. Her estranged husband, Fotis Dulos, and his girlfriend, Michelle Troconis, were arrested on charges of tampering with evidence and hindering prosecution in connection with Jennifer's disappearance. Later, the two – along with Fotis's attorney Kent Mawhinney – faced additional charges related to Jennifer's murder.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Killing of James Scurlock</span> Shooting in Omaha, Nebraska in 2020

On May 30, 2020, James Scurlock, a 22-year-old black male protester, was fatally shot by a 38-year-old bar owner, Jacob "Jake" Gardner. The shooting took place during George Floyd protests in Omaha, Nebraska, in the Old Market area of the city. Scurlock had been among the thousands of protesters who flooded the city's downtown area.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Murder of Carla Walker</span> Victim of solved cold case

The murder of Carla Jan Walker is a former cold homicide case that occurred in Fort Worth, Texas. On February 17, 1974, 17-year-old Carla Walker was abducted from a bowling alley parking lot in Fort Worth, Texas. Her body was found three days later in a drainage ditch 30 minutes south of Fort Worth. Walker was beaten, tortured, raped, and strangled to death.

On November 15, 2017, Sydney Loofe left work for a Tinder date in Wilber, Nebraska. The day after, Loofe was reported missing after failing to appear for work at a local Menards store in Lincoln. Three weeks later, Loofe's dismembered remains were found along a gravel road sixty miles from her date location.

References

  1. 1 2 3 "Nebraska Inmate Details". Nebraska Department of Correctional Services. Archived from the original on April 19, 2023. Retrieved November 24, 2022.
  2. 1 2 Mankiewicz, Josh (host) (September 23, 2017). "Haunting, Part 8". Dateline. NBC.
  3. 1 2 3 4 5 6 Michelle Manchir, Jodi S. Cohen and Jeremy Gorner (July 17, 2013). "Doctor charged in 4 killings". Chicago Tribune . p. 10 – via Newspapers.com.
  4. 1 2 Slifer, Stephanie (May 8, 2017). ""If we were home, we wouldn't be alive." Doctors recall near-encounter with killer resident". CBS News. Retrieved November 25, 2022.
  5. ↑ Engdahl, Kristyna (October 19, 2016). "Professor recalls accused killer as 'worst resident' she'd ever seen". KETV. Retrieved November 25, 2022.
  6. ↑ Mankiewicz, Josh (host) (September 23, 2017). "Haunting, Part 1". Dateline. NBC.
  7. 1 2 3 Mankiewicz, Josh (host) (September 23, 2017). "Haunting, Part 2". Dateline. NBC.
  8. 1 2 Mankiewicz, Josh (host) (September 23, 2017). "Haunting, Part 4". Dateline. NBC.
  9. 1 2 Molly Born (May 17, 2013). "Area native's death raises questions". Pittsburgh Post-Gazette . p. 9 – via Newspapers.com.
  10. 1 2 Mankiewicz, Josh (host) (September 23, 2017). "Haunting, Part 5". Dateline. NBC.
  11. 1 2 3 "Police: Garcia told stripper about killings". Lincoln Journal Star . August 15, 2013 – via Newspapers.com.
  12. 1 2 Mankiewicz, Josh (host) (September 23, 2017). "Haunting, Part 6". Dateline. NBC.
  13. 1 2 Mankiewicz, Josh (host) (September 23, 2017). "Haunting, Part 7". Dateline. NBC.
  14. ↑ "Days after arrest, Garcia's medical license suspended". KETV. July 23, 2013. Retrieved December 27, 2022.
  15. ↑ Ruane, Collin (October 3, 2016). "Garcia murder trial underway". WOWT. Retrieved December 28, 2022.
  16. ↑ Mankiewicz, Josh (host) (September 23, 2017). "Haunting, Part 11". Dateline. NBC.
  17. ↑ Doan, Chinh (April 5, 2016). "Alison Motta thrown off Anthony Garcia case". KETV. Retrieved November 27, 2022.
  18. 1 2 Mankiewicz, Josh (September 23, 2017). "Haunting, Part 10". Dateline. NBC.
  19. ↑ Murray, Erin (October 13, 2016). "Garcia trial turns to exotic dancer's testimony of interactions with 'Doctor Tony'". WOWT. Retrieved November 27, 2022.
  20. 1 2 David J. Krajicek (November 6, 2016). "REVENGE OF THE LOUSY DOCTOR". New York Daily News – via Newspapers.com.
  21. ↑ Mankiewicz, Josh (September 23, 2017). "Haunting, Part 12". Dateline. NBC.
  22. ↑ "Death sentence for ex-doctor who killed 4 people". Fremont Tribune . September 15, 2018 – via Newspapers.com.
  23. ↑ Pilger, Lori (November 29, 2022). "Defense attorney argues Garcia should face resentencing trial in Omaha killings". Omaha World-Herald. Retrieved January 19, 2023.
  24. ↑ Mastre, Brian (March 14, 2023). "Attorneys for Nebraska death row inmate want new trial". WOWT. Retrieved March 15, 2023.
  25. ↑ McCartney, Rob (March 20, 2014). "Six detectives named Crime Stoppers Officer of the Year". KETV. Retrieved November 27, 2022.
  26. ↑ "Officer of the Year Nominees". KETV. March 20, 2014. Retrieved December 27, 2022.
  27. ↑ "Thomas Hunter Memorial Sculpture". Creighton University. YouTube. June 17, 2010. Retrieved November 27, 2022.
  28. ↑ Conley, Alia (February 12, 2018). "Anthony Garcia quadruple murder case featured on another TV show". AP News. Associated Press News. Retrieved November 27, 2022.
This page is based on this Wikipedia article
Text is available under the CC BY-SA 4.0 license; additional terms may apply.
Images, videos and audio are available under their respective licenses.