Ball-pen probe

Ball-pen probe used on tokamak CASTOR in 2004. A stainless steel collector moves inside a ceramic (boron nitride) shielding tube.

Schematic picture of a single ball-pen probe. Ions (in red) have a large gyromagnetic radius and can reach the collector more easily than electrons (in blue).

A ball-pen probe ^[1] is a modified Langmuir probe used to measure the plasma potential ^[2] in magnetized plasmas. The ball-pen probe balances the electron and ion saturation currents, so that its floating potential is equal to the plasma potential. Because electrons have a much smaller gyroradius than ions, a moving ceramic shield can be used to screen off an adjustable part of the electron current from the probe collector.

Ball-pen probes are used in plasma physics, notably in tokamaks such as CASTOR, (Czech Academy of Sciences Torus) ^{[1] [2] [3]} ASDEX Upgrade, ^{[4] [5] [6] [7] [8] [9] [10]} COMPASS, ^{[6] [7] [11] [12] [13] [14] [10] [15] [16] [17] [1]} ISTTOK, ^{[10] [18]} MAST, ^{[19] [20]} TJ-K, ^{[21] [22]} RFX, ^[23] H-1 Heliac, ^{[24] [25]} IR-T1, ^[26] GOLEM ^[27] as well as low temperature devices as DC cylindrical magnetron in Prague ^{[21] [28] [29] [30] [31]} and linear magnetized plasma devices in Nancy ^{[32] [33]} and Ljubljana. ^{[21] [28] [34] [ excessive citations ]}

Principle

If a Langmuir probe (electrode) is inserted into a plasma, its potential is not equal to the plasma potential ${\displaystyle \Phi }$ because a Debye sheath forms, but instead to a floating potential ${\displaystyle V_{fl}}$. The difference with the plasma potential is given by the electron temperature ${\displaystyle T_{e}}$:

${\displaystyle \Phi -V_{fl}=\alpha T_{e}}$

where the coefficient ${\displaystyle \alpha }$ is given by the ratio of the electron and ion saturation current density (${\displaystyle j_{e}^{sat}}$ and ${\displaystyle j_{i}^{sat}}$) and collecting areas for electrons and ions (${\displaystyle A_{e}}$ and ${\displaystyle A_{i}}$):

${\displaystyle \alpha =\ln \left({\frac {A_{e}j_{e}^{sat}}{A_{i}j_{i}^{sat}}}\right)=\ln(R)}$

The ball-pen probe modifies the collecting areas for electrons and ions in such a way that the ratio ${\displaystyle R}$ is equal to one. Consequently, ${\displaystyle \alpha =0}$ and the floating potential of the ball-pen probe becomes equal to the plasma potential regardless of the electron temperature:

${\displaystyle V_{fl}=\Phi }$

Design and calibration

Potential and ln(R) of the ball-pen probe for different positions of the collector

A ball-pen probe consists of a conically shaped collector (non-magnetic stainless steel, tungsten, copper, molybdenum), which is shielded by an insulating tube (boron nitride, Alumina). The collector is fully shielded and the whole probe head is placed perpendicular to magnetic field lines.

When the collector slides within the shield, the ratio ${\displaystyle R}$ varies, and can be set to 1. The adequate retraction length strongly depends on the magnetic field's value. The collector retraction should be roughly below the ion's Larmor radius.^{[ citation needed ]} Calibrating the proper position of the collector can be done in two different ways:

1. The ball-pen probe collector is biased by a low-frequency voltage that provides the I-V characteristics and obtain the saturation current of electrons and ions. The collector is then retracted until the I-V characteristics becomes symmetric. In this case, the ratio ${\displaystyle R}$ is close to unity, though not exactly. ^{[1] [5] [35]} If the probe is retracted deeper, the I-V characteristics remain symmetric.
2. The ball-pen probe collector potential is left floating, and the collector is retracted until its potential saturates. The resulting potential is above the Langmuir probe potential.^{[ clarification needed ]}

Electron temperature measurements

Using two measurements of the plasma potential with probes whose coefficient ${\displaystyle \alpha }$ differ, it is possible to retrieve the electron temperature passively (without any input voltage or current). Using a Langmuir probe (with a non-negligible) and a ball-point probe (whose associated ${\displaystyle R}$ is close to zero) the electron temperature is given by:

${\displaystyle T_{e}={\frac {\Phi -V_{fl}}{\alpha }}}$

where ${\displaystyle \Phi }$ is measured by the ball-pen probe, ${\displaystyle V_{fl}}$ by the standard Langmuir probe, and ${\displaystyle \alpha }$ is given by the Langmuir probe geometry, plasma gas composition, the magnetic field, and other minor factors (secondary electron emission, sheath expansion, etc.). It can be calculated theoretically, its value being about 3 for a non-magnetized hydrogen plasma. ^{[36] [37]}

In practice, the ratio ${\displaystyle R}$ for the ball-pen probe is not exactly equal to one, ^[5] so that the coefficient ${\displaystyle \alpha }$ must be corrected by an empirical value for ${\displaystyle R}$:

${\displaystyle T_{e}={\frac {\Phi _{BPP}-V_{fl}}{\bar {\alpha }}},}$

where ${\displaystyle {\bar {\alpha }}=\alpha -ln(R).}$

References

1. Adámek, J.; J. Stöckel; M. Hron; J. Ryszawy; M. Tichý; R. Schrittwieser; C. Ionită; P. Balan; E. Martines; G. Van Oost (2004). "A novel approach to direct measurement of the plasma potential". Czechoslovak Journal of Physics. 54 (3): 95–99. Bibcode:2004CzJPS..54C..95A. doi:10.1007/BF03166386. ISSN   1572-9486. S2CID   54869196.
2. Adámek, J.; J. Stöckel; I. Ďuran; M. Hron; R. Pánek; M. Tichý; R. Schrittwieser; C. Ionit; P. Balan; E. Martines; G. Oost (2005). "Comparative measurements of the plasma potential with the ball-pen and emissive probes on the CASTOR tokamak". Czechoslovak Journal of Physics. 55 (3): 235–242. Bibcode:2005CzJPh..55..235A. doi:10.1007/s10582-005-0036-8. ISSN   0011-4626. S2CID   54002051.
3. J. Adámek, C. Ionita, R. Schrittwieser, J. Stöckel, M. Tichy, G. Van Oost. "Direct Measurements of the Electron Temperature by a Ball-pen/Langmuir probe", 32nd EPS Conference on Plasma Phys. Tarragona, 27 June - 1 July 2005 ECA Vol.29C, P-5.081 (2005)
4. Adamek, J.; V. Rohde; H.W. Müller; A. Herrmann; C. Ionita; R. Schrittwieser; F. Mehlmann; J. Stöckel; J. Horacek; J. Brotankova (2009). "Direct measurements of the plasma potential in ELMy H-mode plasma with ball-pen probes on ASDEX Upgrade tokamak". Journal of Nuclear Materials. 390–391: 1114–1117. Bibcode:2009JNuM..390.1114A. doi:10.1016/j.jnucmat.2009.01.286. hdl: 11858/00-001M-0000-0026-F6E0-E .
5. Adamek, J.; J. Horacek; H.W. Müller; V. Rohde; C. Ionita; R. Schrittwieser; F. Mehlmann; B. Kurzan; J. Stöckel; R. Dejarnac; V. Weinzettl; J. Seidl; M. Peterka (2010). "Ball-Pen Probe Measurements in L-Mode and H-Mode on ASDEX Upgrade". Contributions to Plasma Physics. 50 (9): 854–859. Bibcode:2010CoPP...50..854A. doi: 10.1002/ctpp.201010145 . S2CID   122712744.
6. Adamek, J.; J. Horacek; J. Seidl; H.W. Müller; R. Schrittwieser; F. Mehlmann; P. Vondracek; S. Ptak (2014). "Direct Plasma Potential Measurements by Ball-Pen Probe and Self-Emitting Langmuir Probe on COMPASS and ASDEX Upgrade". Contributions to Plasma Physics. 54 (4): 279–284. Bibcode:2014CoPP...54..279A. doi:10.1002/ctpp.201410072. S2CID   117937384.
7. J. Adamek, H.W. Müller, J. Horacek, R. Schrittwieser, P. Vondracek, B. Kurzan, P. Bilkova, P. Böhm, M. Aftanas, R. Panek. "Radial profiles of the electron temperature on COMPASS and ASDEX Upgrade from ball-pen probe and Thomson scattering diagnostic", 41st EPS Conference on Plasma Physics, Berlin, P2.011
8. Horacek, J.; J. Adamek; H.W. Müller; J. Seidl; C. Ionita; F. Mehlmann; A.H. Nielsen; V. Rohde; E. Havlickova (2010). "Interpretation of fast measurements of plasma potential, temperature and density in SOL of ASDEX Upgrade". Nuclear Fusion. 50 (10): 105001. Bibcode:2010NucFu..50j5001H. doi:10.1088/0029-5515/50/10/105001. hdl: 11858/00-001M-0000-0026-EFA1-2 . S2CID   123227789.
9. Müller, H.W.; J. Adamek; R. Cavazzana; G.D. Conway; C. Fuchs; J.P. Gunn; A. Herrmann; J. Horacek; et al. (2011). "Latest investigations on fluctuations, ELM filaments and turbulent transport in the SOL of ASDEX Upgrade". Nuclear Fusion. 51 (7): 073023. Bibcode:2011NucFu..51g3023M. doi:10.1088/0029-5515/51/7/073023. hdl: 11858/00-001M-0000-0026-EBAB-0 . S2CID   121614262.
10. Adamek, J.; H.W. Müller; C. Silva; R. Schrittwieser; C. Ionita; F. Mehlmann; S. Costea; J. Horacek; B. Kurzan; P. Bilkova; P. Böhm; M. Aftanas; P. Vondracek; J. Stöckel; R. Panek; H. Fernandes; H. Figueiredo (2016). "Profile measurements of the electron temperature on the ASDEX Upgrade, COMPASS, and ISTTOK tokamak using Thomson scattering, triple, and ball-pen probes". Review of Scientific Instruments. 87 (4): 043510. Bibcode:2016RScI...87d3510A. doi:10.1063/1.4945797. PMID   27131677.
11. J. Seidl, B. Vanovac, J. Adamek, J. Horacek, R. Dejarnac, P. Vondracek, M. Hron "Probe measurement of radial and parallel propagation of ELM filaments in the SOL of the COMPASS tokamak", 41st EPS Conference on Plasma Physics, Berlin, P5.059
12. Loureiro, J.; C. Silva; J. Horacek; J. Adamek; J. Stockel (2014). "Scrape-off layer width of parallel heat flux on tokamak COMPASS". Plasma Physics & Technology. 1 (3): 121–123. ISSN   2336-2634.
13. J. Adamek, J. Seidl, R. Panek, M. Komm, P. Vondracek, J. Stöckel. "Fast measurements of the electron temperature in divertor region of the COMPASS tokamak using ball-pen probe", 42nd EPS Conference on Plasma Physics, lisbon, P4.101
14. Panek, R.; J. Adamek; M. Aftanas; P. Bilkova; P. Böhm; F. Brochard; P. Cahyna; J. Cavalier; R.Dejarnac; M. Dimitrova; O. Grover; J. Harrison; P. Hacek; J. Havlicek; A. Havranek; J. Horacek; M. Hron; M. Imrisek; F. Janky; A. Kirk; M. Komm; K. Kovarik; J. Krbec; L. Kripner; T. Markovic; K. Mitosinkova; J. Mlynar; D. Naydenkova; M. Peterka; J. Seidl; J. Stöckel; E. Stefanikova; M. Tomes; J. Urban; P. Vondracek; M. Varavin; J. Varju; V. Weinzettl; J. Zajac (2016). "Status of the COMPASS tokamak and characterization of the first H-mode". Plasma Phys. Control. Fusion. 58 (1): 014015. Bibcode:2016PPCF...58a4015P. doi: 10.1088/0741-3335/58/1/014015 .
15. Grover, O.; J. Adamek; J. Seidl; A. Devitre; M. Sos; P. Vondracek; P. Bilkova; M. Hron (2017). "First simultaneous measurements of Reynolds stress with ball-pen and Langmuir probes". Review of Scientific Instruments. 88 (6): 063501. Bibcode:2017RScI...88f3501G. doi:10.1063/1.4984240. PMID   28668002.
16. Adamek, J.; J. Seidl; M. Komm; V. Weinzettl; R. Panek; J. Stöckel; M. Hron; P. Hacek; M. Imrisek; P. Vondracek; J. Horacek; A. Devitre (2017). "Fast measurements of the electron temperature and parallel heat flux in ELMy H-mode on the COMPASS tokamak". Nuclear Fusion. 57 (2): 022010. Bibcode:2017NucFu..57b2010A. doi:10.1088/0029-5515/57/2/022010. S2CID   125525532.
17. Adamek, J.; J. Seidl; J. Horacek; M. Komm; T. Eich; R. Panek; J. Cavalier; A. Devitre; M. Peterka; P. Vondracek; J. Stöckel; D. Sestak; O. Grover; P. Bilkova; P. Böhm; J. Varju; A. Havranek; V. Weinzettl; J. Lovell; M. Dimitrova; K. Mitosinkova; R. Dejarnac; M. Hron (2017). "Electron temperature and heat load measurements in the COMPASS divertor using the new system of probes". Nuclear Fusion. 57 (11): 116017. Bibcode:2017NucFu..57k6017A. doi:10.1088/1741-4326/aa7e09. hdl: 11858/00-001M-0000-002D-BA59-3 . S2CID   125143428.
18. Silva, C.; J. Adamek; H. Fernandes; H. Figueiredo (2015). "Comparison of fluctuations properties measured by Langmuir and ball-pen probes in the ISTTOK boundary plasma". Plasma Physics and Controlled Fusion. 57 (2): 025003. Bibcode:2015PPCF...57b5003S. CiteSeerX   10.1.1.691.3443 . doi:10.1088/0741-3335/57/2/025003. S2CID   59151012.
19. Walkden, N R; J. Adamek; S. Allan; B. D. Dudson; S. Elmore; G. Fishpool; J. Harrison; A. Kirk; M. Komm (2015). "Profile measurements in the plasma edge of MAST using a ball pen probe". Review of Scientific Instruments. 86 (2): 023510. arXiv: 1411.7298 . Bibcode:2015RScI...86b3510W. doi:10.1063/1.4908572. PMID   25725845. S2CID   21518172.
20. N. R. Walkden, "Properties of Intermittent Transport in the Mega Ampere Spherical Tokamak", PhD Thesis,
21. 1 2 3 Adamek, Jiri; Matej Peterka; Tomaz Gyergyek; Pavel Kudrna; Mirko Ramisch; Ulrich Stroth; Jordan Cavalier; Milan Tichy (2013). "Application of the ball-pen probe in two low-temperature magnetised plasma devices and in torsatron TJ-K". Contributions to Plasma Physics. 53 (1): 39–44. Bibcode:2013CoPP...53...39A. doi:10.1002/ctpp.201310007. S2CID   120969312.
22. "Plasma Dynamics and Diagnostics | Institute of Interfacial Process Engineering and Plasma Technology | University of Stuttgart". 13 September 2023.
23. "Welcome to Consorzio RFX site". Archived from the original on 2009-09-01. Retrieved 2020-06-26.
24. Michael, C.A.; F. Zhao; B. Blackwell; M. F. J. Vos; J. Brotankova; S. R. Haskey; B. Seiwald; J. Howard (2017). "Influence of magnetic configuration on edge turbulence and transport in the H-1 Heliac" (PDF). Plasma Physics and Controlled Fusion. 59 (2): 024001. Bibcode:2017PPCF...59b4001M. doi:10.1088/1361-6587/59/2/024001. hdl: 1885/112461 . S2CID   73588015.
25. Hole, M.J.; B.D. Blackwell; G. Bowden; M. Cole; A. Koenies; C.A. Michael; F. Zhao; S.R. Haskey (2017). "Global Alfven eigenmodes in the H-1 heliac". Plasma Physics and Controlled Fusion. 59 (12): 125007. arXiv: 1704.02089 . Bibcode:2017PPCF...59l5007H. doi:10.1088/1361-6587/aa8bdf. S2CID   119096017.
26. Ghoranneviss, M.; S. Meshkani (2016). "Techniques for improving plasma confinement in IR-T1 Tokamak". International Journal of Hydrogen Energy. 41 (29): 12555–12562. Bibcode:2016IJHE...4112555G. doi:10.1016/j.ijhydene.2016.03.075.
27. J. Cerovsky, M. Farnik, M. Sos, J. Svoboda, O. Ficker, M. Hetflejs, P. Svihra, M. Shkut, O. Grover, J. Veverka, V. Svoboda, J. Stockel, J. Adamek, M. Dimitrova, "Tokamak GOLEM for fusion education", 44th EPS Conference on Plasma Physic, 26–30 June 2017, Belfast, Northern Ireland (UK), P1.107,
28. 1 2 Adamek, Jiri; J. Adamek; M. Peterka; P. Kudrna; M. Tichy T.; Gyergyek (2012). "Diagnostics of magnetized low temperature plasma by ball-pen probe" (PDF). Nukleonika. 57 (2): 297–300.
29. Zanaska, Michal; J. Adamek; M. Peterka; P. Kudrna; M. Tichy (2015). "Comparative measurements of plasma potential with ball-pen and Langmuir probe in low-temperature magnetized plasma". Physics of Plasmas. 22 (3): 033516. Bibcode:2015PhPl...22c3516Z. doi:10.1063/1.4916572.
30. Peterka M., "Experimental and theoretical study of utilization of probe methods for plasma diagnostics", Diploma Thesis, Department of Surface and Plasma Science, Faculty of Mathematics and Physics, Charles University in Prague, 2014 (only Czech language)
31. Zanaska M., "Measurement of the plasma potential by means of the ball-pen and Langmuir probe", Bachelor thesis, Department of Surface and Plasma Science, Faculty of Mathematics and Physics, Charles University in Prague, 2013 (only Czech language)
32. G. Bousselin, J. Cavalier, J. Adamek, G. Bonhomme. "Ball-pen probe measurements in a low-temperature magnetized plasma", 39th EPS Conference & 16th Int. Congress on Plasma Physics, Stockholm, Sweden, P4.042 (2012)
33. Bousselin, G.; J. Cavalier; J. F. Pautex; S. Heuraux; N. Lemoine; G. Bonhomme (2013). "Design and validation of the ball-pen probe for measurements in a low-temperature magnetized plasma". Review of Scientific Instruments. 84 (1): 013505–013505–8. Bibcode:2013RScI...84a3505B. doi: 10.1063/1.4775491 . ISSN   0034-6748. PMID   23387648.
34. Kovacic, Jernej; Salamon, Lino; Ikovic, Gabrijela; Gyergyek, Tomaz; Fonda, Boris (2016). "Ball-Pen Probe Diagnostics of a Weakly Magnetized Discharge Plasma Column". Proceedings of 1st EPS conference on Plasma Diagnostics — PoS(ECPD2015). p. 052. doi: 10.22323/1.240.0052 .
35. Silva, C.; J. Adamek; H. Fernandes; H. Figueiredo (2014). "Comparison of fluctuations properties measured by Langmuir and ball-pen probes in the ISTTOK boundary plasma". Plasma Physics and Controlled Fusion. 57 (2): 025003. Bibcode:2015PPCF...57b5003S. CiteSeerX   10.1.1.691.3443 . doi:10.1088/0741-3335/57/2/025003. S2CID   59151012.
36. Stangeby P.C.: The Plasma Boundary of Magnetic Fusion Devices, Institute of Physics Publishing. Bristol and Philadelphia (2000).
37. Hutchinson I.H.: Principles of Plasma Diagnostics, Cambridge University Press (1992).

External links

• PhD thesis, Jiri Adamek (Czech and English language)
• Overview: Ball-pen probe design, theory and first results at different fusion devices.
• Examination of plasma current spikes and general analysis of H-mode shots in the tokamak COMPASS
• Electrical Probe Measurements on the COMPASS Tokamak
• Probe Measurements on the COMPASS Tokamak
• Scanning ion sensitive probe for plasma profile measurements in the boundary of the Alcator C-Mod tokamak
• Development of Probes for Assessment of Ion Heat Transport and Sheath Heat Flux in the Boundary of the Alcator C-Mod Tokamak ^{[ permanent dead link ‍]}
• Video: Temporal evolution of Type-I ELM in the divertor region on the COMPASS tokamak.
• The new divertor Ball-pen and Langmuir probes on the COMPASS tokamak.