Ben Feibleman v. Columbia University

Last updated

Ben Feibleman v. Columbia University (2020), formally known as John Doe v. Columbia University, is a Title IX case that was brought to the United States District Court for the Southern District of New York on the basis of anti-male bias which discriminates against male students accused of sexual assault. [1] Columbia University launched an investigation of a sexual assault that was reported by Jane Doe in which Columbia found Jane Doe to be more credible and revoked Feiblemans degree from the Graduate School of Journalism. Feibleman filed a lawsuit against Columbia University. A settlement for undisclosed sum was made on December 23, 2020, which restored Feibleman's diploma. [2]

Contents

Allegations

On October 4, 2016, Ben Feibleman was accused of sexually assaulting a classmate after a journalism school reception at which both parties had been drinking. [3] Jane Doe asked Feibleman to go with her to the water tower and then ended up in her bedroom; at that point, Feibleman started to record the encounter. [2] Jane Doe can be heard asking Feibleman to engage in sexual intercourse which he declines and attempts to leave Jane Doe's apartment. [3] When Feibleman tries to explain, Jane Doe states that she is confused and does not know what is going on. The following morning on October 5, 2016, Jane Doe filed a formal complaint. [3] In the complaint Jane Doe states that she went to sleep, woke up, and realized another student was sexually assaulting her. [2] Feibleman alleges that Jane Doe sexually assaulted him and made a counter complaint.

Investigation

Feibleman claims that Columbia University failed to provide him with a fair process. [2] Columbia University's Gender-Based Misconduct Policy (GBMP) states that it fosters an environment the is free from gendered-based discrimination including sexual assault and other gender-based discrimination. [4] Through this process Feibleman believes that Jane Doe was given preferential treatment which is the basis of his lawsuit. Both parties were advised not to speak with those who may be connected to the incident but did not enforce this rule on Jane Doe who allegedly spoke to witnesses about her interpretation of the interaction. Columbia interviewed 12 witnesses including Jane Doe and Feibleman between October and December 2016. [2] Columbia Universities Gender-Based Misconduct policy allows students to seek private counsel and states that Columbia will provide an attorney-advisor at no cost to the student. [5] Feibleman alleges that he was discouraged from hiring a lawyer even though Jane Doe was with counsel. [2] Feibleman submitted the recording into evidence and got an expert report from Dr. David Greenblatt that concluded that Jane Doe did not lack the capacity to consent to sexual activity. Title IX investigation team did not allow these documents to be seen or heard by the 3 person panel deciding the outcome of the hearing. [2] Feibleman was barred from cross examining his accuser and was barred from viewing the evidence against him. [6] The panel determined that Jane Doe lacked the capacity to consent and revoked Feiblemans degree. On May 13, 2019, Feibleman filed the lawsuit. [7]

Outside factors

In 2011, the Obama Administration wrote Dear Colleague letter in which universities responded by altering policies to eliminate hearings and cross-examinations for sexual assault victims. The accused students of sexual assault are majority male bringing in the anti-male bias within the Title IX investigations. [1] The Dear Colleague letter allowed institutions to use single-investigator models in Title IX cases. [6] Previously, Columbia received negative attention due to the Columbia University rape accusation controversy. [3] Former United States Secretary of Education, Betsy DeVos, issued a more balanced due process, with due process rights extending to those accused. [6]

Lawsuit

On May 13, 2019, Feibleman commenced action against Columbia University alleging erroneous outcome and selective enforcement under Title IX. [2] Feibleman brought seven claims for violations of Title IX, breach of contract, and violations of New York City Human Rights Laws. July 15, 2019 Columbia University moved to dismiss five out of the seven claims. On February 24, 2020, Judge Valerie Caproni sustained the motion to dismiss and all claims moved forward into discovery. December 23, 2020 both parties reached a settlement before any depositions could take place and Columbia reinstated Feiblemans diploma including his rights and privileges as an alumnus in good standing. [2] [7] Feibleman alleges the conditions of the settlement prevent him from disclosing the sum he won, so to make a point he bought a Lamborghini sports car three days after the settlement. [8]

Related Research Articles

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Title IX</span> United States federal law prohibiting sex discrimination in federally-funded education programs

Title IX is a landmark federal civil rights law in the United States that was enacted as part of the Education Amendments of 1972. It prohibits sex-based discrimination in any school or any other education program that receives funding from the federal government. This is Public Law No. 92‑318, 86 Stat. 235, codified at 20 U.S.C. §§ 1681–1688.

Campus sexual assault is the sexual assault, including rape, of a student while attending an institution of higher learning, such as a college or university. The victims of such assaults are more likely to be female, but any gender can be victimized. Estimates of sexual assault, which vary based on definitions and methodology, generally find that somewhere between 19–27% of college women and 6–8% of college men are sexually assaulted during their time in college.

<i>Allen v. City of Oakland</i> Lawsuit against the Oakland Police Department

Delphine Allen et al. v. City of Oakland was a civil rights lawsuit in Federal District Court regarding police misconduct in Oakland, California which has resulted in ongoing Federal oversight. Plaintiffs alleged mistreatment at the hands of four veteran officers, known as the "Riders", who were alleged to have kidnapped, planted evidence, and beaten citizens. Plaintiffs also alleged that the Oakland Police Department (OPD) turned a blind eye to police misconduct.

Andrea Lynn Pino (born February 15, 1992) is an American women's rights and civil rights activist, author, and a public scholar on issues of global gender based violence, media framing of violence, gender and sexuality, and narratives of survivorhood. She is the queer daughter of Cuban refugees and has stated that she is a survivor of sexual assault.

Angie Epifano, a former student at Amherst College, gained widespread media attention and millions of page views after she wrote an essay on her personal experience of sexual assault that was published in the Amherst student newspaper, The Amherst Student. After the publication of her essay, Amherst College began investigating its sexual assault procedures, and women from other college campuses in the United States came forward to file federal complaints under Title IX and to form groups to reduce sexual assault on college campuses.

The Campus Accountability and Safety Act (CASA) was a bill introduced in the 114th United States Congress with the goal of reducing sexual violence on college and university campuses. First introduced in 2014, a revised bill was introduced in February 2015 by Senator Claire McCaskill of Missouri with nine bi-partisan cosponsors. 43 cosponsors eventually signed on. The bill died in committee at the end of the session without reaching a floor vote in either house.

In April 2013, Occidental College was one of the first in a series of US higher education institutions to be accused of failing to take campus sex crimes seriously by improperly reporting and adjudicating sexual assaults and covering up rapes. Occidental students and faculty filed two federal complaints against the College, alleging violations of Title IX of the US Education Amendments of 1972 and the Clery Act.

<i>Mattress Performance (Carry That Weight)</i> American performance art piece

Mattress Performance (Carry That Weight) (2014–2015) was a work of endurance/performance art which Emma Sulkowicz conducted as a senior thesis during the final year of a visual arts degree at Columbia University in New York City.

Families Advocating for Campus Equality (FACE) is an American advocacy group whose stated goal is to ensure fairness and due process for all parties involved in allegations of sexual misconduct on college and university campuses. FACE was started by Sherry Warner Seefeld and two other mothers who say their sons were falsely accused of sexual misconduct on their college campuses.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Emma Sulkowicz</span> American performance artist and activist

Emma Sulkowicz is best known as a political activist and performance artist. While still a college student, Sulkowicz developed a national reputation with the performance artwork Mattress Performance (2014–2015). In 2019, they said they had stopped making art and began a master's program in traditional Chinese medicine.

In April 2013, Emma Sulkowicz, an American fourth-year visual arts major at Columbia University in New York City, filed a complaint with Columbia University requesting expulsion of fellow fourth-year student and German national, Paul Nungesser, alleging he had raped Sulkowicz in her dorm room on August 27, 2012. Nungesser was found not responsible by a university inquiry.

Title IX of the United States Education Amendments of 1972 prohibits discrimination "on the basis of sex" in educational programs and activities that receive financial assistance from the federal government. The Obama administration interpreted Title IX to cover discrimination on the basis of assigned sex, gender identity, and transgender status. The Trump administration determined that the question of access to sex-segregated facilities should be left to the states and local school districts to decide. The validity of the executive's position is being tested in the federal courts.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Baylor University sexual assault scandal</span> Allegations and convictions of Baylor University students of sexual assault between 2012 and 2016

The Baylor University sexual assault scandal was the result of numerous allegations of and convictions for sexual and non-sexual assaults committed by Baylor University students, mostly players on the Baylor Bears football team. During a period from about 2012 to 2016, school officials suppressed reports of rapes and sexual misconduct. In 2016, Baylor's football team came under fire when it was revealed university officials had failed to take action regarding the alleged rapes and assaults. The scandal led to the ousting of head football coach Art Briles, the demotion and eventual resignation of Baylor president Ken Starr, the resignation of athletic director Ian McCaw, and the firing of two others connected with the football program. It also led to the resignation of Baylor's Title IX Coordinator, Patty Crawford. A plaintiff's attorney, Jim Dunnam, accused Baylor of implementing a ″concerted strategy to get the public to believe this is entirely and only a football-related problem."

After a sexual assault or rape, victims are often subjected to scrutiny and, in some cases, mistreatment. Victims undergo medical examinations and are interviewed by police. If there is a criminal trial, victims suffer a loss of privacy, and their credibility may be challenged. Victims may also become the target of slut-shaming, abuse, social stigmatization, sexual slurs and cyberbullying. These factors, contributing to a rape culture, are among some of the reasons that may contribute up to 80% of all rapes going unreported in the U.S, according to a 2016 study done by the U.S. Department of Justice.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Debra Katz</span> American civil rights and employment lawyer

Debra S. Katz is an American civil rights and employment lawyer and a founding partner of Katz Banks Kumin in Washington, D.C. She is best known for representing alleged victims of sexual assault and sexual harassment, notably Christine Blasey Ford Charlotte Bennett, Vanessa Tyson, Chloe Caras, and accusers of Congressmen Pat Meehan and Eric Massa, and whistleblowers facing retaliation, including most recently Dr. Rick Bright. Katz's primary practice areas at her firm are employment and whistleblower law, where she represents victims of workplace discrimination and retaliation.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Douglas Wigdor</span> American lawyer

Douglas Holden Wigdor is a founding partner of the law firm Wigdor LLP, and works as a litigator in New York City, specializing in anti-discrimination law. Wigdor is best known for representing seven victims of alleged sexual abuse by Harvey Weinstein, the hotel maid in the Dominique Strauss-Kahn sexual assault case, over twenty employees at Fox News in sexual harassment and discrimination cases, and NFL coaches Brian Flores, Steve Wilks, and Ray Horton in a 2022 class action lawsuit against the National Football League alleging racist and discriminatory practices against Black coaches.

David W. Sanford is an American civil rights attorney. He is the chairman and co-founder of Sanford Heisler Sharp and is based in New York City. He works primarily on gender and race discrimination class action and individual cases, as well as wage and hour overtime cases and False Claims Act matters. He is the lawyer who brought gender discrimination actions against Greenberg Traurig and Howrey, which folded in 2011. He has earned a reputation for representing women suing BigLaw firms over pay equity and gender discrimination. Sanford has recovered more than one billion dollars for individual clients and the United States government since 2004.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">History of the University of Southern California</span>

The University of Southern California was founded in 1880, and is the oldest private research university in California.

McAllister Olivarius is an international law firm dual-headquartered in London and New York. It specializes in civil litigation and plaintiff work, particularly in education and employment law.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Alen Hadzic</span> American fencer (born 1991)

Alen Hadzic is an American former épée fencer. In 2023, he was ranked 361st in the world in men's epee. He had attended Montclair High School and Columbia University, competing for the fencing teams at both schools. A Title IX complaint of sexual abuse was lodged against him with the university, and after an investigation Hadzic was suspended by Columbia University for one year, and barred from the fencing team. Though he was banned from representing Columbia University, he wasn’t banned from fencing at large, and Hadzic went on to coach boys and girls on the Tappan Zee High School fencing team. In 2013 the lawyer for the woman who was the victim in Hadzic's Title IX case urged USA Fencing to bar Hadzic from competitions, referring to him as a "known rapist" and noting his suspension, but USA Fencing CEO Kris Ekeren asserted that Hadzic hadn’t violated any of USA Fencing's policies.

References

  1. 1 2 Yetter, Alexandra (July 23, 2019). "Title IX policies have 'anti-male bias' and treat students accused of sexual assault unfairly, lawsuit alleges". The Columbia Chronicle. Retrieved March 21, 2023.
  2. 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 "Feibleman v. Trs. of Columbia Univ. in N.Y., 19-CV-4327 (VEC) | Casetext Search + Citator". casetext.com. Retrieved March 21, 2023.
  3. 1 2 3 4 Hartocollis, Anemona (January 11, 2021). "Columbia Settles a Complicated Sexual Assault Case". The New York Times. ISSN   0362-4331 . Retrieved March 21, 2023.
  4. ↑ "Gender-Based Misconduct | Student Conduct | Center for Student Success and Intervention". studentconduct.columbia.edu. Retrieved March 21, 2023.
  5. ↑ Gender-Based Misconduct Policy and Procedures for Students (Revised August 23, 2019 ed.). Columbia University In The City of New York. pp. 7–47.
  6. 1 2 3 "Guilty until Proven Innocent: Biden Title IX Changes Mean Return to 'Dark Ages' for Falsely Accused Students". National Review. July 25, 2022. Retrieved March 28, 2023.
  7. 1 2 "Warshaw Burstein LLP | Warshaw Burstein Prevails Over Columbia University in High-Profile Title IX Action". www.wbny.com. Retrieved March 21, 2023.
  8. ↑ "Guilty until Proven Innocent: Biden Title IX Changes Mean Return to 'Dark Ages' for Falsely Accused Students". nationalreview.com. July 7, 2022.
This page is based on this Wikipedia article
Text is available under the CC BY-SA 4.0 license; additional terms may apply.
Images, videos and audio are available under their respective licenses.