Bitter Legacy

Last updated
Bitter Legacy: Polish-American Relations in the Wake of World War II
Author Richard C. Lukas
CountryUnited States
LanguageEnglish
Subjectthe postwar Polish history and Polish-American relations, as well as the American aid that was extended to Poland after World War II
Publisher University Press of Kentucky
Publication date
1982
Pages191
ISBN 978-0813114606

Bitter Legacy: Polish-American Relations in the Wake of World War II is a 1982 book by Richard C. Lukas, published by the University Press of Kentucky. It deals with the postwar Polish history and Polish-American relations, as well as the American aid that was extended to Poland after World War II.

Contents

The book focuses on the postwar period (1945-1947) and describes how during that America steadily lost influence over Poland due to combination of external factors as well as internal American policy decisions, such as prioritizing German-American relations over Polish-American ones.

Contents

The book continues the topic Lukas begun discussing in his earlier book, The Strange Allies: Poland and the United States, 1941-1945 (1978), with most reviewers describing Bitter Legacy as a "sequel" to The Strange Allies. [1] [2] [3] [4]

The work discusses American government views and actions towards Poland from the 1945 Potsdam conference through the fraudulent Polish parliamentary election of 1947. [3] Lukas attempts to explain "why United States policy was unable to reverse the process begun at the Yalta Conference that transformed Poland into a Soviet satellite". [1] According to Lukas this was because Poland "had been written off as a Soviet sphere of influence by the Roosevelt administration" and during the subsequent Truman administration, the US government was focused on other issues (such as the economic recovery of Western Europe and strengthening American control over Germany and Italy). [1]

The book discusses individuals such as Truman's Secretaries of State James Byrnes and George C. Marshall or ambassadors Arthur Bliss Lane and Stanton Griffis. [4] Lukas describes the American policy towards Poland of that time as incoherent and "disastrous because it failed to take advantage of those clauses of the Yalta Agreement that supported Poland's claims and its democracy". [4] This was because American government had already "dissociated itself from Poland and Eastern Europe at Yalta", as Truman was not interested in any serious negotiations regarding Soviet concessions regarding Poland, hoping that pure economic support (through United Nations Relief and Rehabilitation Administration and similar initiatives) would suffice to secure parliamentary victory for parties sympathetic to the US (Stanisław Mikołajczyk and his Polish People's Party). [5] [3] [4]

Lukas points out that Secretary of State Byrnes's Stuttgart speech on rebuilding Germany (Restatement of Policy on Germany in September 1946) was deeply problematic for the Polish-American relations. Byrnes in his speech criticized the post-war Polish-German border (the Oder-Neisse line), which was then used by Polish communists, who could point to that speech to justify their claims that the Soviet Union, not the United States, was the best friend of Poland. This is a prominent example, according to Lukas, of American policy that counterproductively worsened the Polish-American relations - something that the US government either did not foresee or did not care about, likely due to having accepted that improving German-American relationship was more important, and more realistic, than trying to retain some influence in Poland. [1] [3] [5]

Lukas is also critical of American ambassador to Poland, Arthur Bliss Lane, suggesting that he was not "imaginative and flexible enough" for that difficult job. [5]

Lukas also positively reviews the actions of Polish American Congress and American Polonia with regards to their anti-communist attitude, although he notes that overall the Polonia failed to significantly influence American government policy towards Poland. Polonia's disappointment with Democrats (Truman) did impact the domestic American politics, due to "an enlarged Polish vote for the Republicans in [November] 1946, helping them to gain control of Congress". [3] [4]

Reception

The book received several academic reviews in 1983.

Mieczysław B. Biskupski reviewed the book for The Russian Review . He noted that both books in the series exhibit "the author's thorough and enterprising use of sources, conciseness of style, and dispassionate analysis". Biskupski acknowledges that there are "a number of minor flaws in this otherwise fine book" but concludes that "Lukas has produced a brief, tightly-focused account of the first years of post-war American-Polish relations" that "fills a considerable gap" in relevant literature. [3]

J. M. Jackson wrote about the book for the International Affairs . Jackson writes that the book is "an adequate account of the course of postwar relations" between Poland and the US, and the factors influencing American policies. He also notes that the book attempts to speculate on "whether different policies on the part of the United States could have made any significant difference" to the course of history and the Cold War; something that Lukas thinks might have been possible, but Jackson feels is "more doubtful". [5]

George J. Lerski reviewing the book for The American Historical Review called it a professional monography in the field of Polish-American relations and an "important and well-documented study" praising the author for "his impeccable research in primary and secondary sources". He notes that there are occasional minor errors in the work (in particular, "insufficient familiarity with the Polish political spectrum"), or places he would have "disagreements... of a minor character", and concludes that "this is an important contribution toward a better understanding of post-war events in that terra incognita of American historiography". [4]

Eduard Mark reviewed it for The Journal of American History . He noted that the book has "considerable merit" and that the author "writes clearly, and his narrative is easily followed", although he writes that Lukas work would benefit more from engaging with literature on Soviet policy (in particular, Vojtech Mastny's) which in Mark opinion lead Lukas to overestimate what the United States might have achieved had it tried harder to retain some control over Poland in its sphere of influence. Mark notes that Lukas important contribution is that he successfully demonstrates how Poland's importance continued to wane throughout the war and afterwar years for American policymakers. [2]

David S. Mason reviewed the book for the Slavic Review . Mason's assessment was that "while the book adds little to our understanding of Poland's role in the development of the Cold War, it presents a thorough overview of the period written in a lively and engaging style and illustrated with delightful anecdotes". [1]

See also

Related Research Articles

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Potsdam Conference</span> 1945 Allied meeting on the postwar world

The Potsdam Conference was held at Potsdam in the Soviet occupation zone from July 17 to August 2, 1945, to allow the three leading Allies to plan the postwar peace, while avoiding the mistakes of the Paris Peace Conference of 1919. The participants were the Soviet Union, the United Kingdom, and the United States. They were represented respectively by General Secretary Joseph Stalin, Prime Ministers Winston Churchill and Clement Attlee, and President Harry S. Truman. They gathered to decide how to administer Germany, which had agreed to an unconditional surrender nine weeks earlier. The goals of the conference also included establishing the postwar order, solving issues on the peace treaty, and countering the effects of the war.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Potsdam Agreement</span> 1945 agreement between the major 3 Allies regarding the end of World War II

The Potsdam Agreement was the agreement between three of the Allies of World War II: the United Kingdom, the United States, and the Soviet Union after the war ended in Europe on 1 August 1945 and it was published the next day. A product of the Potsdam Conference, it concerned the military occupation and reconstruction of Germany, its border, and the entire European Theatre of War territory. It also addressed Germany's demilitarisation, reparations, the prosecution of war criminals and the mass expulsion of ethnic Germans from various parts of Europe. France was not invited to the conference but formally remained one of the powers occupying Germany.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Yalta Conference</span> 1945 WWII allied discussion of postwar reorganization

The Yalta Conference, held 4–11 February 1945, was the World War II meeting of the heads of government of the United States, the United Kingdom and the Soviet Union to discuss the postwar reorganization of Germany and Europe. The three states were represented by President Franklin D. Roosevelt, Prime Minister Winston Churchill, and General Secretary Joseph Stalin. The conference was held near Yalta in Crimea, Soviet Union, within the Livadia, Yusupov, and Vorontsov palaces.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">James F. Byrnes</span> American politician (1882–1972)

James Francis Byrnes was an American judge and politician from South Carolina. A member of the Democratic Party, he served in U.S. Congress and on the U.S. Supreme Court, as well as in the executive branch, most prominently as the 49th U.S. Secretary of State under President Harry S. Truman. Byrnes was also the 104th governor of South Carolina, making him one of the very few politicians to have served in the highest levels of all three branches of the American federal government while also being active in state government.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Curzon Line</span> Historical demarcation of territories of Poland and the Soviet Union

The Curzon Line was a proposed demarcation line between the Second Polish Republic and the Soviet Union, two new states emerging after World War I. Based on a suggestion by Herbert James Paton, it was first proposed in 1919 by Lord Curzon, the British Foreign Secretary, to the Supreme War Council as a diplomatic basis for a future border agreement.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Origins of the Cold War</span>

The Cold War originated in the breakdown of relations between the two main victors in World War II: United States and the Soviet Union, and their respective allies, the Western Bloc and the Eastern Bloc, in the years 1945–1949.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Western betrayal</span> Concept in international relations among European countries

Western betrayal is the view that the United Kingdom, France, and sometimes the United States failed to meet their legal, diplomatic, military, and moral obligations with respect to the Czechoslovak and Polish states during the prelude to and aftermath of World War II. It also sometimes refers to the treatment of other Central and Eastern European states at the time.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Polish Underground State</span> Polish government in exile during World War II in German-occupied Poland

The Polish Underground State was a single political and military entity formed by the union of resistance organizations in occupied Poland that were loyal to the Government of the Republic of Poland in exile in London. The first elements of the Underground State were established in the final days of the German and Soviet invasion of Poland, in late September 1939. The Underground State was perceived by supporters as a legal continuation of the pre-war Republic of Poland that waged an armed struggle against the country's occupying powers: Nazi Germany and the Soviet Union. The Underground State encompassed not only military resistance, one of the largest in the world, but also civilian structures, such as justice, education, culture and social services.

The Polish American Congress (PAC) is an American umbrella organization of Polish-Americans and Polish-American organizations. Its membership has individuals as well as fraternal, educational, veterans, religious, cultural, social, business, and political organizations.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Richard C. Lukas</span> American historian (born 1937)

Richard Conrad Lukas is an American historian and author of books and articles on military, diplomatic, Polish, and Polish-American history. He specializes in the history of Poland during World War II.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Restatement of Policy on Germany</span> 1946 speech by U.S. Secretary of State Byrnes

"Restatement of Policy on Germany", or the "Speech of Hope", is a speech given by James F. Byrnes, the US Secretary of State, in Stuttgart on September 6, 1946.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Poland–United States relations</span> Bilateral relations

Official relations between Poland and the United States on a diplomatic level were initiated in 1919 after Poland had established itself as a republic after 123 years of being under foreign rule from the Partitions of Poland. However, ties with the United States date back to the 17th century, when the Polish–Lithuanian Commonwealth was one of Europe's largest powers, and many Poles immigrated to the Thirteen Colonies. During the American Revolutionary War, the Polish military commanders Tadeusz Kościuszko and Casimir Pułaski contributed greatly to the Patriot cause, with Kościuszko becoming a national hero in America. Since 1989, Polish–American relations have been strong and Poland is one of the chief European allies of the United States, being part of both NATO and the European Union. There is a strong cultural appreciation between the two nations (Polonophilia). According to the US Department of State, Poland remains a "stalwart ally" and "one of strongest Continental partners in fostering security and prosperity, throughout Europe and the world." Poland was also one of four participating countries in the American-led Iraq War coalition in 2003.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Historiography of the Cold War</span> Historiography of the Cold War

As soon as the term "Cold War" was popularized to refer to postwar tensions between the United States and the Soviet Union, interpreting the course and origins of the conflict became a source of heated controversy among historians, political scientists and journalists. In particular, historians have sharply disagreed as to who was responsible for the breakdown of Soviet Union–United States relations after the World War II and whether the conflict between the two superpowers was inevitable, or could have been avoided. Historians have also disagreed on what exactly the Cold War was, what the sources of the conflict were and how to disentangle patterns of action and reaction between the two sides. While the explanations of the origins of the conflict in academic discussions are complex and diverse, several general schools of thought on the subject can be identified. Historians commonly speak of three differing approaches to the study of the Cold War: "orthodox" accounts, "revisionism" and "post-revisionism". However, much of the historiography on the Cold War weaves together two or even all three of these broad categories and more recent scholars have tended to address issues that transcend the concerns of all three schools.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Oder–Neisse line</span> German-Polish border since the end of World War II

The Oder–Neisse line is an unofficial term for the modern border between Germany and Poland. The line generally follows the Oder and Lusatian Neisse rivers, meeting the Baltic Sea in the north. A small portion of Polish territory does fall west of the line, including the cities of Szczecin and Świnoujście.

Polish-Americans in the United States comprise a voting bloc sought after by both the Democratic and Republican parties as they have a bellwether status. Polish Americans comprise 3.2% of the United States population, but were estimated at nearly 10% of the overall electorate as of 2012. The Polish-American population is concentrated in several Midwestern swing states that make issues important to Polish-Americans more likely to be heard by presidential candidates. According to John Kromkowski, a Catholic University professor of political science, Polish-Americans make up an "almost archetypical swing vote". The Piast Institute found that Polish Americans are 36% Democrats, 33% Independents, and 26% are Republicans as of 2008. Ideologically, they were categorized as being in the more conservative wing of the Democratic Party, and demonstrated a much stronger inclination for third-party candidates in presidential elections than the American public.

National Committee of Americans of Polish Extraction, also known as the National Committee of Americans of Polish Descent or its Polish abbreviation KNAPP, was a Polish-American organization active in the years 1942-1959 in the United States.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Foreign policy of the Harry S. Truman administration</span> Review of the topic

The main issues of the United States foreign policy during the 1945–1953 presidency of Harry S. Truman include:

The Strange Allies: Poland and the United States, 1941-1945 is a 1978 book by Richard C. Lukas, published by University of Tennessee Press. It deals with the relationship between the United States and the Polish government-in-exile during World War II and highlighted the impact of American Polonia in United States-Polish relations.

This is a select bibliography of English language books and journal articles about the history of Poland. A brief selection of English translations of primary sources is included. Book entries have references to journal articles and reviews about them when helpful. Additional bibliographies can be found in many of the book-length works listed below; see Further Reading for several book and chapter-length bibliographies. The External Links section contains entries for publicly available select bibliographies from universities and national libraries. This bibliography specifically excludes non-history related works and self-published books.

This is a select bibliography of English language books and journal articles about the history of Poland during World War II. A brief selection of English translations of primary sources is included. Book entries have references to journal articles and reviews about them when helpful. Additional bibliographies can be found in many of the book-length works listed below; see Further Reading for several book and chapter-length bibliographies. The External Links section contains entries for publicly available select bibliographies from universities. This bibliography specifically excludes non-history related works and self-published books.

References

This page is based on this Wikipedia article
Text is available under the CC BY-SA 4.0 license; additional terms may apply.
Images, videos and audio are available under their respective licenses.