Cassandra case

Last updated

The Cassandra case (Spanish : Caso Cassandra) was a Spanish court case against Cassandra Vera Paz (born 3 November 1995). Vera was charged in 2016 with injury to victims of terrorism after she posted a series of tweets poking fun at the Franco-era assassination of Luis Carrero Blanco. In 2017, the Audiencia Nacional (National Court) sentenced her to one year in prison plus a seven year penalty of absolute disqualification, which disqualifies a convict from holding public office or employment, and disallows a convict to obtain government grants, scholarships, or any public aid. The ruling was reversed in 2018 by the Supreme Court of Spain, it found that repeating well-known jokes about an attack that happened 44 years ago, about which “endless jokes have been made”, without any abusive comments toward the victim, “is socially and even morally reprehensible in terms of mocking a serious human tragedy,” but “a penal sanction is not proportionate.” The court also took into account Vera’s age – 18 – at the time of publishing the tweets. [1]

Contents

History

Admiral Luis Carrero Blanco, prime minister during the final years of the fascist regime of dictator General Francisco Franco. Luis Carrero Blanco.jpg
Admiral Luis Carrero Blanco, prime minister during the final years of the fascist regime of dictator General Francisco Franco.

Operación Araña (Operation Spider)

Between 2013 and 2016, Cassandra Vera Paz published a series of tweets about the assassination of Francoist Luis Carrero Blanco. Blanco, who was Prime Minister of Spain, was assassinated by the terrorist group Euskadi Ta Askatasuna (ETA) on 20 December 1973. [2] Following an investigation conducted by the information service of the Spanish Civil Guard called Operation Araña (Operation Spider), Vera was charged for injury to victims of terrorism. [3] [4] According to Vera's testimony, on 13 April 2016, the Civil Guard summoned her to make a statement in relation to a robbery she had reported the previous year. After she arrived at the police station, Vera was informed that she had been criminally charged, and her mobile phone was seized.

National Court trial

Vera was charged based on the following thirteen tweets and in nearly all of them the key to the humor was the fact that the car, in which Carrero Blanco was traveling, flew high up into the air and over a five-story church, landing on the second-floor terrace of a building. (Spanish quote plus English translation). [5]

  1. "ETA impulsó una política contra los coches oficiales combinada con un programa espacial." (ETA promoted a policy against official cars combined with a space program).
  2. "Película : A tres metros sobre el cielo. Producción: ETA films. Director: Argala. Protagonista: Carrero Blanco. Género: Carrera espacial" (Film: Three Steps Above Heaven. Production Company: ETA films. Director: Argala. Protagonist: Carrero Blanco. Genre: space race).
  3. "Kissinger le regaló a Carrero Blanco un trozo de la luna, ETA le pagó el viaje a ella" (Kissinger gave Carrero Blanco a piece of the moon, ETA paid for the trip).
  4. "Si hacer chistes de Carrero Blanco es enaltecimiento del terrorismo..." (If making jokes about Carrero Blanco is praising terrorism...)
  5. "Perdone usted, @GcekaElectronic, un respeto por el gran Carrero, la estación internacional de la ETA puso todo su esfuerzo" (Excuse you, @GcekaElectronic, a bit of respect for the great Carrero, ETA's international space station did all it could.)
  6. "¿Ya no puedo hacer chistes de Carrero Blanco?" (Can I no longer make jokes about Carrero Blanco?)
  7. "Elecciones el día del aniversario del viaje espacial de Carrero Blanco. Interesante" (Elections on the anniversary of Carrero Blanco's space flight. Interesting.)
  8. "Spiderman VS Carrero Blanco" Accompanied with an image of Spiderman peering through buildings at a long car.
  9. "¿Carrero Blanco también regresó al futuro con su coche? #RegresoAlFuturo" (Did Carrero Blanco also go back to the future in his car? #BackToTheFuture.)
  10. "Feliz 20 de diciembre" (Happy December 20) Accompanied with three images: one that is a photograph of the effects after the attack on Blanco and two that recreate the explosion and trajectory of Blanco's official vehicle.
  11. "20D" Accompanied with a photo collage of an astronaut with Blanco's face, on what appears to be the surface of the Moon with the Franco-era flag.
  12. "URSS VS SPAIN. URSS Yuri Gagarin VS SPAIN Carrero Blanco" URSS is the Spanish abbreviation for the Soviet Union and Yuri Gagarin, a cosmonaut, was the first human to journey into outer space.
  13. "Contigo quiero volar, para poder verte desde el cielo, en busca de lo imposible, que se escapa entre mis dedos" (With you I want to fly, to be able to see you from the sky, in search of the impossible, that slips through my fingers) Accompanied with an image that depicts the upward flight of Blanco's vehicle.

Vera appeared before the investigating judge on 13 September 2016 with her court-appointed lawyer. The lawyer was later fired because he wanted to base Vera's defense on a claim of mental insanity due to Vera being transgender, and because Vera felt he was ultra-conservative after he told Vera that he was an admirer of Blanco. [6] Vera worked with new lawyers and decided to base her defense on freedom of expression. [2]

The National Court found Vera guilty on 29 March 2017 of the crime of humiliation of the victims of terrorism. The court considered that Vera's tweets, published between 2013 and 2016, constituted contempt, dishonor and mockery towards the victims of terrorism and their families. [7] Public reaction to the ruling was quick and fierce; many, including Blanco's granddaughter, Lucía Carrero-Blanco, thought that, as regrettable as the tweets may be, freedom of expression should not lead to a prison sentence. She wrote a letter to El País criticizing the two year, six month prison sentence and described the jail term as “disproportionate and total madness,” adding: “I am frightened by a society where freedom of speech, however regrettable it might be, can mean a jail term.” [1]

Supporters retweeted the offending tweets with new supportive hashtags and some even made more offensive jokes. [8] Nonetheless, the National Court tribunal, composed of Juan Francisco Martel Rivero, Teresa Palacios, and Carmen Paloma González, sentenced her to one year in prison and revocation of her voting rights for the same time period, and seven years of inhabilitación absoluta (absolute disqualification) which disqualifies a convict from holding public office or employment, and disallows a convict to obtain government grants, scholarships, or any public aid. The court also required payment of court costs and the removal of the tweets. [9] [10] [11] The prosecutor Pedro Martínez Torrijos asked for two years and six months of prison, three years' probation, and eight years and six months of absolute disqualification. [11] [12] The sentence caught the attention of international news media and political parties such as United Left and Podemos . [13] [14] United Left retweeted the offensive tweets from its official Twitter account. [15]

Supreme Court hearing

The sentence was appealed before the Supreme Court of Spain citing six reasons.

  1. For violation of article 20 of the Constitution of Spain, of article 19 of the Universal Declaration of Human Rights and of article 11 of the Charter of Fundamental Rights of the European Union, wherein the right to freedom of speech is inviolable.
  2. For violation of article 24.2 of the Constitution of Spain, the presumption of innocence, since no sufficient proof of the charge has been made.
  3. For miscarriage of justice by improper application of article 578 of the penal code (law against praising terrorism and humiliation of victims of terrorism, introduced by the Ley Orgánica 7/2000, of December 22) without sufficient reason.
  4. For miscarriage of justice, based on article 579bis of the penal code, for ignoring personal circumstances and the context and the content typical of Twitter.
  5. For miscarriage of justice by undue application of article 14.3 of the penal code, by failure to apply invincible error and attenuate penalty based on the feasibility of ignorance of the crime.
  6. For miscarriage of justice by obvious error in the assessment of the evidence presented by the defense.

The public prosecutor challenged all of these points. However, on 26 February 2018, the Supreme Court considered the appeal and reversed the National Court ruling; the court rejected the second reason, but accepted the third and considered it unnecessary to examine the remaining reasons. [16] The court concluded that the tweets did not contain any bitter comment against the victim of the attack nor did they express hurtful, cutting, or insulting phrases or comments against their person; the singular subject of the joke was in the manner in which the attack was carried out with special emphasis on the fact that the car reached a great altitude; and that the attack had taken place forty-four years ago, more than enough time to consider it a historical event whose humorous treatment cannot have the same significance as that of a recent event. Therefore, magistrate Alberto Jorge Barreiro  [ es ], speaking for the court, stated that although the conduct of the accused was reproachable from a social and even moral perspective, the case did not require a response from the penal system, and that the actual response was not appropriate or proportionate. [17] The case was heard by magistrates Alberto Jorge Barreiro, Andrés Martínez Arrieta, Miguel Colmenero Menéndez de Luarca  [ es ], Antonio del Moral García, and Ana María Ferrer García  [ es ]. [18]

Vera immediately responded to the news of the Supreme Court ruling: “I’m very happy on a personal level to see the end of a judicial ordeal that no one should have to go through. But I’m very worried about other sentences, such as that of Valtònyc and other rappers and tweeters.” [1]

See also

Related Research Articles

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Luis Carrero Blanco</span> Spanish Admiral-General Prime Minister (1904–1973)

Admiral-General Luis Carrero Blanco was a Spanish Navy officer and politician. A long-time confidant and right-hand man of dictator Francisco Franco, Carrero served as Spain's Premier. Upon graduating from the naval academy Carrero Blanco participated in the Rif War, and later the Spanish Civil War, in which he supported the Rebel faction. He became one of the most prominent figures in the Francoist dictatorship's power structure and held throughout his career a number of high-ranking offices such as those of Undersecretary of the Presidency from 1941 to 1967 and Franco's deputy from 1967 to 1973. He also was the main drafter behind the 1947 Law of Succession to the Headship of the State. Franco handpicked him as his successor in the role of head of government, with Carrero thereby taking office in June 1973.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">GAL (paramilitary group)</span> 1983–87 Spanish government death squads created to fight ETA

GAL were death squads illegally established by officials of the Spanish government during the Basque conflict to fight against ETA, the principal Basque separatist militant group. They were active from 1983 to 1987 under Spanish Socialist Workers' Party (PSOE)-led governments.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Assassination of Luis Carrero Blanco</span> 1973 murder in Madrid, Spain

On 20 December 1973, Luis Carrero Blanco, the Prime Minister of Spain, was assassinated when a cache of explosives in a tunnel set up by the Basque separatist group ETA was detonated. The assassination, also known by its code name Operación Ogro, is considered to have been the biggest attack against the Francoist State since the end of the Spanish Civil War in 1939 and had far-reaching consequences within the politics of Spain.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Arnaldo Otegi</span> Basque pro-independence politician (born 1958)

Arnaldo Otegi Mondragón is a politician from the Basque Country who has been the General Secretary of Basque nationalist party EH Bildu since 2017. He was member of the Basque Parliament for both Herri Batasuna and Euskal Herritarrok. He was a convicted member of the ETA, a banned armed separatist group organization, in his early years. He was one of the key negotiators during the unsuccessful peace talks in Loiola and Geneva, in 2006.

<i>Egunkaria</i> Former Basque-language newspaper

Egunkaria for thirteen years was the only fully Basque language newspaper in circulation until it was closed down on 20 February 2003 by the Spanish authorities due to allegations of an illegal association with ETA, the armed Basque separatist group. After seven years, on 15 April 2010 the defendants were acquitted on all charges related to ties to ETA. The issue of damages for the closure of the newspaper remains open, as well as the alleged torture of the members of the newspaper's executive board during detention.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Josu Urrutikoetxea</span> Basque separatist

José Antonio Urrutikoetxea Bengoetxea, also known as Josu Urrutikoetxea, Josu Urrutikoetxea Bengoetxea, and by the nickname Josu Ternera, is a former member of the Basque separatist organization ETA. In separate trials over a number of years, he was convicted for his involvement in the 1986 Plaza República Dominicana bombing and the 1987 Zaragoza barracks bombing, which together killed 23 people.

Basque National Liberation Movement prisoners are all those people who have been imprisoned, placed on remand, or otherwise kept in custody due to their illegal activity in support of the Basque National Liberation Movement.

Censorship in Spain involves the suppression of speech or public communication and raises issues of freedom of speech.

Operation Araña is the codename given to the 2014–17 Civil Guard operation in Spain against the defense of terrorism on social media, mainly on Facebook and Twitter. The name Araña means Spider. Until now, it has consisted on four phases:

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Carmen Lamela</span> Spanish judge

Carmen Lamela Díaz is a Spanish judge. Lamela serves as examining magistrate at the Third Court of the National Court of Spain. Her area of expertise is criminal law.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Valtònyc</span> Catalan rapper

José Miguel Arenas Beltrán, popularly known as Valtònyc, is a Spanish rapper, originally from Mallorca, Spain. He describes himself as an independentist. His lyrics are based on an anti-capitalist, republican and anti-fascist ideology.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Altsasu incident (2016)</span>

The Altsasu incident is a judicial case against eight young people from Altsasu, a small town in Navarre, Spain, for their involvement in a fight taking place on 15 October 2016 at a bar in which two off-duty Civil Guard officers stationed in the town and their girlfriends sustained injuries. One of the officers was knocked down, with the other victims reported to have suffered "psychological trauma". The lawsuit was initially conducted by the judge of the Spanish special court Audiencia Nacional Carmen Lamela. As of March 2018, Concepción Espejel was appointed as magistrate ahead of the trial held in late April.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Fernando Grande-Marlaska</span> Spanish judge and politician (born 1962)

Fernando Grande-Marlaska Gómez is a Spanish judge and politician who has served as minister of the Interior since June 2018. An independent politician close to the Spanish Socialist Workers' Party, he has been Member of the Congress of Deputies from 2019 to 2020, and briefly from August to December 2023, representing Cádiz.

José Ignacio Iruretagoyena was a Spanish politician and victim of terrorism of the Basque separatist group Euskadi Ta Askatasuna (ETA).

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Belgium–Spain relations</span> Bilateral relations

Belgium–Spain relations are the bilateral relations between Belgium and Spain. Belgium has an embassy in Madrid and four consulates general in: Madrid, Barcelona, Santa Cruz de Tenerife and Alicante. Spain has an embassy and a consulate in Brussels. The relations between both countries are defined mainly by their membership in the European Union and by being allies in NATO, as well as belonging to numerous international organizations, which makes their relations have ample development in the framework of them.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Government of Luis Carrero Blanco</span>

The government of Luis Carrero Blanco was formed on 12 June 1973, following his appointment and swearing-in as Prime Minister of Spain on 9 June by Head of State Francisco Franco, who for the first time since 1938 had chosen to detach the figure of the head of government from that he held of head of state. It succeeded the eighth Franco government and was the Government of Spain from 12 June to 31 December 1973, a total of 202 days, or 6 months and 19 days.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Eva Forest</span> Spanish activist and writer

Genoveva Forest Tarrat was a Spanish far-left activist, writer and prisoner. Born into an anarchist family in Barcelona, she studied medicine in Madrid. During the 1970s, she supported the Basque terrorist group ETA in their resistance to the government of dictator Francisco Franco. From 1974 to 1977, she was imprisoned for complicity in the Cafetería Rolando bombing (1974), which killed 13 people in Madrid. After Spain's transition to democracy, she served a term as a senator from 1992 until 1993. The wife of the Spanish writer Alfonso Sastre, she died in May 2007.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Pablo Hasél</span> Spanish rapper

Pablo Rivadulla Duró, known artistically as Pablo Hasél, is a Catalan rapper, writer, poet, and political activist. His songs and actions, often controversial and in support of far-left politics, have led to a number of criminal charges and convictions in his country. In June 2020 he was sentenced to six months in prison for pushing and spraying washing-up liquid at a TV3 journalist and to two and a half years for kicking and threatening a witness in the trial of a policeman. He was imprisoned on 16 February 2021 on a nine-month sentence for recidivism in insulting the Spanish monarchy, insulting the Spanish army and police forces, and praising terrorism and banned groups. This has been labeled an attack on free speech by certain groups both in Spain and overseas, including Amnesty International, and led to numerous protests and riots.

Francisco Javier García Gaztelu, alias "Txapote", is a Basque separatist terrorist who is responsible for the assassination of several Basque politicians. He is also known by the aliases Perretxiko, Jon, Xabier, and Otsagi, among others. He was part of the "hard wing" of ETA and never showed any sign of repentance for his actions or condemned those of the group.

Marey case is the name given to the trial for the 1983 kidnapping of Segundo Marey—one of the first victims of the Spanish government's dirty war against ETA—carried out by the so-called Grupos Antiterroristas de Liberación (GAL).

References

  1. 1 2 3 Spanish court throws out jail sentence for woman who posted jokes on Twitter, El País, 2 March 2018
  2. 1 2 Munárriz, Ángel. "Cassandra Vera: "La Fiscalía quiere coartar la libertad de expresión, pero no tiene apoyo social"". infoLibre.es (in Spanish). Retrieved 6 March 2018.
  3. ↑ López-Fonseca, Óscar (31 March 2017). "'Operación Araña': dos absoluciones, 42 condenas y 33 casos pendientes". EL PAÍS (in Spanish). Retrieved 17 January 2018.
  4. ↑ Cuartopoder (3 April 2017). "Cassandra y los chistes que son ETA". Cuartopoder (in European Spanish). Retrieved 6 March 2018.
  5. ↑ "Estos son los tuits sobre Carrero Blanco por los que la Audiencia Nacional condenó a prisión a Cassandra Vera". eldiario.es (in Spanish). Retrieved 8 March 2018.
  6. ↑ "La tuitera imputada renuncia a su abogado de oficio por ser "admirador de Carrero Blanco"". El Español (in Spanish). Retrieved 6 March 2018.
  7. ↑ "Un año de prisión para Cassandra por mofarse de Carrero Blanco". El Huffington Post (in European Spanish). 29 March 2017. Retrieved 16 January 2018.
  8. ↑ "Caso Cassandra: un ridículo jurídico nacional (que se convertirá en internacional). Blogs de Homepage". El Confidencial (in Spanish). Retrieved 17 January 2018.
  9. ↑ Pérez, Fernando J. (30 March 2017). "La Audiencia Nacional condena a Cassandra Vera, la tuitera que hizo chistes de la muerte de Carrero Blanco". EL PAÍS (in Spanish). Retrieved 17 January 2018.
  10. ↑ Heredia, Ana María Valero. "El 'caso Cassandra', la gota que colma el vaso". infoLibre.es (in Spanish). Retrieved 17 January 2018.
  11. 1 2 "Cassandra no es la única: estos 5 casos de chistes en redes sociales también han llegado a juicio en España" (in European Spanish). Europa Press. 4 April 2017. Retrieved 17 January 2018.
  12. ↑ "La cara B de las acusaciones de los fiscales por enaltecimiento en redes sociales" (in European Spanish). Retrieved 17 January 2018.
  13. ↑ "Así ve la prensa internacional la condena a Cassandra por sus tuits sobre Carrero Blanco". eldiario.es (in Spanish). Retrieved 17 January 2018.
  14. ↑ "Franco se ha reencarnado en Audiencia Nacional. Blogs de España is not Spain". El Confidencial (in Spanish). Retrieved 17 January 2018.
  15. ↑ "IU desafía a la Audiencia Nacional difundiendo los tuits por los que han condenado a Cassandra". eldiario.es (in Spanish). Retrieved 6 March 2018.
  16. ↑ Pérez, Fernando J. (1 March 2018). "El Supremo absuelve a Cassandra Vera por sus tuits con chistes sobre Carrero Blanco". El País. Retrieved 6 March 2018.
  17. ↑ Alberto Gumersindo Jorge Barreiro (26 February 2018). "Recurso Casacion/979/2017" (PDF) (in European Spanish). Madrid: Tribunal Supremo. Sala de lo Penal.
  18. ↑ "El Supremo absuelve a Cassandra Vera por sus "chistes de mal gusto" sobre Carrero Blanco". El Comercio (in Spanish). 1 March 2018. Retrieved 6 March 2018.
This page is based on this Wikipedia article
Text is available under the CC BY-SA 4.0 license; additional terms may apply.
Images, videos and audio are available under their respective licenses.