Estimation of stature

Last updated
The body proportions of Vitruvian Man. The armspan is marked equal to the stature of the subject. Leonardo da Vinci developed rules for drawing human proportions. For example, human body height is to be the length of eight heads, with an additional one-quarter head for neck length. Leg length is to be four head lengths. Vitruvian.jpg
The body proportions of Vitruvian Man. The armspan is marked equal to the stature of the subject. Leonardo da Vinci developed rules for drawing human proportions. For example, human body height is to be the length of eight heads, with an additional one-quarter head for neck length. Leg length is to be four head lengths.

Forensic estimation of stature is part of the identification process necessary when dismembered body parts are found. It is also possible to estimate the stature from bones. [2] Even measurements of body parts of body such as a finger can be used to estimate the stature. [3] [4]

Contents

The principle behind this forensic anthropology technique is the fact that for a given combination of age, race, and gender there measurements of different body parts which have a relationship to the stature. This relationship between the measurements of body parts was known to sculptors and artists. In modern times, regression formulae are used to estimate stature from bones, fragments of bones or measurements of body parts.

History

"Vitruvian Man", illustration in the edition of De architectura by Vitruvius; illustrated edition by Cesare Cesariano (1521) De Architectura030.jpg
"Vitruvian Man", illustration in the edition of De architectura by Vitruvius; illustrated edition by Cesare Cesariano (1521)

Vitruvius, who lived in the first century BC had put forth the proportions of human body in Book III, Chapter 1..

3. Just so the parts of Temples should correspond with each other, and with the whole. The navel is naturally placed in the centre of the human body, and, if in a man lying with his face upward, and his hands and feet extended, from his navel as the centre, a circle be described, it will touch his fingers and toes. It is not alone by a circle, that the human body is thus circumscribed, as may be seen by placing it within a square. For measuring from the feet to the crown of the head, and then across the arms fully extended, we find the latter measure equal to the former; so that lines at right angles to each other, enclosing the figure, will form a square. [5]

Leonardo da Vinci had based the proportions of the famous Vitruvian man on his writings.

Modern Research

In 1888 Rollet measured the stature and the lengths of the long bones of 50 male and 50 female French cadavers ranging in age from 24 to 99 years, and presented tables for stature estimation. He determined the average length of the long bones of those who presented the same stature. [6]

Manouvrier (1892 and 1893) found that due to the effect of old age the length of the trunk was 3 cm less than the maximum stature. He excluded those aged above 60 years from his sample and derived tables of average stature corresponding to given long bone lengths. Manouvrier determined the average stature of those individuals who presented the same lengths for a given long bone. [6]

Karl Pearson (1899) applied stature regression formulae utilizing all of Rollet's cases. [6]

In 1929 Stevenson accumulated data on Northern Chinese male cadavers using the same methods as those used by Rollet. He found that the stature regression formulae he derived could not be used to determine the stature of French population and Pearson's formulae derived for the French could not be used in his sample. [6]

Breitinger (1937) measured the distance between certain anatomical prominence in a sample of 2400 German males of whom 1400 were participants in an athletic meet in Munich in 1923. 1000 members of the sample were students in 1925–26. The average age of the group was about 26 years. [6]

Telkka (1950) studied 154 Finnish cadavers, 115 males and 39 females. The average age of the males in the sample was 42.3 years and of the females 50.4 years. The stature of the cadavers was measured on the "prostrate" corpse and the bones were measured after maceration and drying. [6]

Dupertuis and Hadden (1951) derived regression equations for calculation of stature from a sample of 100 male whites, 100 female whites, 100 male Blacks and 100 female Negroes. [7]

Mildred Trotter and Goldine Gleser (1952) compared the stature of servicemen (male American Whites and Negroes) in their military records and the length of bones of the skeletal remains measured at the time of repatriation of their skeletal remains. [6] They later analyzed same data obtained after the Korean War. This time, regression equations for Whites, Blacks, Mongoloids, Mexicans and Puerto Ricans were derived. [8]

Calculation of Stature from the Length of Long Bones

Many different equations are in use for estimation of stature from the length of long bones.

Karl Pearson

He derived reconstruction formulae for living stature from dry bones. The probable error is given in parentheses. [9]

Bone Male Whites Female Whites
Femur 81.306 + 1.880 F (±0.3047)72.844 + 1.945 F (±0.3058)
Tibia 78.664 + 2.376 T (±0.3275)74.774 + 2.352 T (±0.3146)
Humerus 70.641 + 2.894 H (±0.3056)71.475 + 2.754 H (±0.3284)
Radius 85.925 + 3.271 R (±0.3728)81.224 + 3.343 R (±0.3816)
Femur & Tibia 71.272 + 1.159 (F + T) (±0.2835)69.154 + 1.126 (F + T) (±0.2898)
Humerus & Radius 66.855 + 1.730 (H + R) (±0.3139)69.911 + 1.628 (H + R) (±0.3380)
Femur & Tibia 71.443 + 1.220 F + 1.080 T (±0.2845)69.561 + 1.117 F + 1.125 T (±0.2922)
Humerus & Radius 69.788 + 2.769 H + 0.195 R (±0.3054)70.542 + 2.582 H + 0.281 R (±0.3279)
Femur & Humerus 68.397 + 1.030 F + 1.557 H (±0.2750)67.435 + 1.339 F + 1.037 H (±0.2971)
Femur, Tibia, Humerus & Radius 67.049 + 0.913 F + 0.600 T + 1.225 H - 0.187 R (±0.2748)67.469 + 0.782 F + 1.120 T + 1.059 H - 0.711 R (±0.2836)

Trotter and Gleser

The regression equations to calculate stature in centimeters for male servicemen belonging to different races derived by Trotter and Gleser. Probable errors are given within parentheses. [8]

Bone Whites Blacks Mongoloids Mexicans Puerto Ricans
Rt Humerus 2.88 HR + 77.70 (±4.61)2.88 HR + 75.52 (±4.26)2.69 HR + 82.80 (±4.32)3.01 HR + 70.40 (±4.29)2.45 HR + 88.45 (±3.96)
Lt Humerus 2.89 HL + 77.47 (±4.54)2.89 HL + 75.10 (±4.21)2.68 HL + 83.27 (±4.18)2.82 HL + 77.32 (±4.20)2.79 HL + 77.18 (±3.63)
Rt Radius 3.77 RR + 79.13 (±4.66)3.28 RR + 86.22 (±4.65)3.58 RR + 80.71 (±4.64)3.79 RR + 74.59 (±4.09)3.24 RR + 86.76 (±4.00)
Lt Radius 3.73 RL + 80.62 (±4.59)3.36 RL + 84.63 (±4.50)3.51 RL + 83.40 (±4.55)3.30 RL + 87.05 (±4.00)3.33 RL + 85.20 (±3.80)
Rt Ulna 3.59 UR + 76.95 (±4.71)3.13 UR + 84.42 (±4.73)3.50 UR + 76.07 (±4.84)3.82 UR + 67.67 (±3.92)3.11 UR + 84.60 (±4.02)
Lt Ulna 3.64 UL + 76.14 (±4.57)3.28 UL + 80.85 (±4.76)3.46 UL + 78.84 (±4.49)3.30 UL + 81.46 (±4.18)3.48 UL + 75.59 (±3.81)
Rt Femur 2.25 FR + 68.40 (±4.04)2.07 FR + 73.78 (±3.83)2.12 FR + 74.03 (±3.92)2.41 FR + 59.84 (±3.10)2.09 FR + 72.86 (±3.18)
Lt Femur 2.30 FL + 65.82 (±3.97)2.14 FL + 70.19 (±3.99)2.18 FL + 71.11 (±3.67)2.47 FL + 57.51 (±2.88)2.11 FL + 72.36 (±3.19)
Rt Tibia 2.40 TR + 82.24 (±3.97)2.20 TR + 84.90 (±3.88)2.42 TR + 80.36 (±3.26)2.29 TR + 83.46 (±3.59)2.05 TR + 90.49 (±3.61)
Lt Tibia 2.43 TL + 80.98 (±3.95)2.18 TL + 85.82 (±4.04)2.36 TL + 82.54 (±3.28)2.42 TL + 78.13 (±3.88)1.95 TL + 94.57 (±3.80)
Rt Fibula 2.57 FR + 76.13 (±3.86)2.38 FR + 78.48 (±3.96)2.39 FR + 81.10 (±3.20)2.56 FR + 73.30 (±3.32)2.09 FR + 89.88 (±3.48)
Lt Fibula 2.59 FL + 75.37 (±3.83)2.29 FL + 82.02 (±4.08)2.40 FL + 80.38 (±3.28)2.44 FL + 77.58 (±3.72)2.16 FL + 87.27 (±3.79)

Dupertuis and Hadden

The regression equations derived by Dupertuis and Hadden for Whites and Blacks to estimate the stature in centimeters from individual long bones and different combinations are given below. Probable errors are given within parentheses. [7]

BoneMale WhitesFemale WhitesMale BlacksFemale Blacks
Femur 77.048 + 2.116 F (±0.2308)62.872 + 2.322 F (±0.2256)55.021 + 2.540 F (±0.2819)54.235 + 2.498 F (±0.2419)
Tibia 92.766 + 2.178 T (±0.2436)71.652 + 2.635 T (±0.2433)72.123 + 2.614 T (±0.2983)72.391 + 2.521 T (±0.2867)
Humerus 98.341 + 2.270 H (±0.3094)56.287 + 3.448 H (±0.2762)50.263 + 3.709 H (±0.2762)69.978 + 3.035 H (±0.3189)
Radius 88.881 + 3.449 R (±0.2907)68.238 + 4.248 R (±0.2963)69.168 + 4.040 R (±0.3522)74.906 + 3.761 R (±0.3277)
Femur & Tibia 84.898 + 1.072 (F + T) (±0.2508)57.872 + 1.354 (F + T) (±0.2016)52.702 + 1.411 (F + T) (±0.2485)70.584 + 1.165 (F + T) (±0.2953)
Humerus & Radius 87.543 + 1.492 (H + R) (±0.2889)42.386 + 2.280 (H + R) (±0.2134)57.601 + 1.962 (H + R) (±0.3564)61.982 + 1.866 (H + R) (±0.2926)
Femur & Tibia 76.201 + 1.330 F + 0.991 T (±0.2173)60.377 + 1.472 F + 1.133 T (±0.2063)54.438 + 1.615 F + 1.123 T (±0.2559)52.989 + 2.112 F + 0.501 T (±0.2397)
Humerus & Radius 82.831 + 0.907 H + 2.474 R (±0.2835)53.187 + 2.213 H + 1.877 R (±0.2632)48.275 + 2.182 H + 2.032 R (±0.3251)62.402 + 1.906 H + 1.796 R (±0.3082)
Femur & Humerus 78.261 + 2.129 F - 0.055 H (±0.2328)55.179 + 1.835 F + 0.935 H (±0.1827)48.802 + 2.175 F + 0.696 H (±0.2749)55.103 + 2.517 F + 0.033 H (±0.2380)
Tibia & Radius 88.581 + 1.945 T + 0.524 R (±0.2385)64.702 + 2.089 T + 1.169 R (±0.2328)67.964 + 2.260 T + 0.689 R (±0.2964)66.005 + 2.076 T + 0.952 R (±0.2832)
Femur, Tibia, Humerus & Radius 52.618 + 1.512 F + 0.927 T - 0.490 H + 1.386 R (±0.1582)56.660 + 1.267 F + 0.992 T + 0.449 H + 0.164 R (±0.2068)53.873 + 1.637 F + 1.101 T + 0.084 H - 0.093 R (±0.2626)53.342 + 2.201 F + 0.359 T - 0.663 H + 0.930 R (±0.2365)

Calculation of Stature from the measurement of Body Parts

Various studies have been undertaken into methods to device the estimation of stature from foot prints, measurement of severed body parts etc.

Related Research Articles

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Least squares</span> Approximation method in statistics

The method of least squares is a parameter estimation method in regression analysis based on minimizing the sum of the squares of the residuals made in the results of each individual equation.

In physiology, body water is the water content of an animal body that is contained in the tissues, the blood, the bones and elsewhere. The percentages of body water contained in various fluid compartments add up to total body water (TBW). This water makes up a significant fraction of the human body, both by weight and by volume. Ensuring the right amount of body water is part of fluid balance, an aspect of homeostasis.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Anthropometry</span> Measurement of the human individual

Anthropometry refers to the measurement of the human individual. An early tool of physical anthropology, it has been used for identification, for the purposes of understanding human physical variation, in paleoanthropology and in various attempts to correlate physical with racial and psychological traits. Anthropometry involves the systematic measurement of the physical properties of the human body, primarily dimensional descriptors of body size and shape. Since commonly used methods and approaches in analysing living standards were not helpful enough, the anthropometric history became very useful for historians in answering questions that interested them.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Forensic anthropology</span> Application of the science of anthropology in a legal setting

Forensic anthropology is the application of the anatomical science of anthropology and its various subfields, including forensic archaeology and forensic taphonomy, in a legal setting. A forensic anthropologist can assist in the identification of deceased individuals whose remains are decomposed, burned, mutilated or otherwise unrecognizable, as might happen in a plane crash. Forensic anthropologists are also instrumental in the investigation and documentation of genocide and mass graves. Along with forensic pathologists, forensic dentists, and homicide investigators, forensic anthropologists commonly testify in court as expert witnesses. Using physical markers present on a skeleton, a forensic anthropologist can potentially determine a person's age, sex, stature, and race. In addition to identifying physical characteristics of the individual, forensic anthropologists can use skeletal abnormalities to potentially determine cause of death, past trauma such as broken bones or medical procedures, as well as diseases such as bone cancer.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Glomerular filtration rate</span> Renal function test

Renal functions include maintaining an acid–base balance; regulating fluid balance; regulating sodium, potassium, and other electrolytes; clearing toxins; absorption of glucose, amino acids, and other small molecules; regulation of blood pressure; production of various hormones, such as erythropoietin; and activation of vitamin D.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Waist</span> Part of the abdomen between the rib cage and hips

The waist is the part of the abdomen between the rib cage and hips. Normally, the waist is the narrowest part of the torso.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Human height</span> Aspect of human growth

Human height or stature is the distance from the bottom of the feet to the top of the head in a human body, standing erect. It is measured using a stadiometer, in centimetres when using the metric system or SI system, or feet and inches when using United States customary units or the imperial system.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Regression dilution</span> Statistical bias in linear regressions

Regression dilution, also known as regression attenuation, is the biasing of the linear regression slope towards zero, caused by errors in the independent variable.

The anthropometry of the upper arm is a set of measurements of the shape of the upper arms.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Mildred Trotter</span> American anthropologist

Mildred Trotter was an American pioneer as a forensic historian and forensic anthropologist.

The Robert J. Terry Anatomical Skeletal Collection is a collection of some 1,728 human skeletons held by the Department of Anthropology of the National Museum of Natural History of the Smithsonian Institution, Washington, D.C., United States. The skeletons have been widely used in research for anthropology and forensic science.

The body fat percentage (BFP) of a human or other living being is the total mass of fat divided by total body mass, multiplied by 100; body fat includes essential body fat and storage body fat. Essential body fat is necessary to maintain life and reproductive functions. The percentage of essential body fat for women is greater than that for men, due to the demands of childbearing and other hormonal functions. Storage body fat consists of fat accumulation in adipose tissue, part of which protects internal organs in the chest and abdomen. A number of methods are available for determining body fat percentage, such as measurement with calipers or through the use of bioelectrical impedance analysis.

In physical fitness, body composition refers to quantifying the different components of a human body. The selection of compartments varies by model but may include fat, bone, water, and muscle. Two people of the same gender, height, and body weight may have completely different body types as a consequence of having different body compositions. This may be explained by a person having low or high body fat, dense muscles, or big bones.

<i>Necrolemur</i> Extinct genus of primates

Necrolemur is a small bodied omomyid with body mass estimations ranging from 114 grams to 346 grams. Necrolemur’s teeth feature broad basins and blunt cusps, suggesting their diet consisted of mostly soft fruit, though examination of microwear patterns suggests that populations from lower latitudes also consumed insects and gums. While they do not sport a true tooth comb like modern lemurs, microwear patterns on their lower incisors suggest they engaged in fur grooming behaviors. Like tarsiers, Necrolemur had large, front-facing, close set eyes and were likely nocturnal. Analysis of cranial and postcranial fossils by paleontologists suggest members of the family Omomyidae, including the genus Necrolemur, possessed highly specialized adaptations for leaping.

Distance matrices are used in phylogeny as non-parametric distance methods and were originally applied to phenetic data using a matrix of pairwise distances. These distances are then reconciled to produce a tree. The distance matrix can come from a number of different sources, including measured distance or morphometric analysis, various pairwise distance formulae applied to discrete morphological characters, or genetic distance from sequence, restriction fragment, or allozyme data. For phylogenetic character data, raw distance values can be calculated by simply counting the number of pairwise differences in character states.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Tree allometry</span> Quantitative relations between some key characteristic dimensions of trees

Tree allometry establishes quantitative relations between some key characteristic dimensions of trees and other properties. To the extent these statistical relations, established on the basis of detailed measurements on a small sample of typical trees, hold for other individuals, they permit extrapolations and estimations of a host of dendrometric quantities on the basis of a single measurements.

In statistics, linear regression is a statistical model which estimates the linear relationship between a scalar response and one or more explanatory variables. The case of one explanatory variable is called simple linear regression; for more than one, the process is called multiple linear regression. This term is distinct from multivariate linear regression, where multiple correlated dependent variables are predicted, rather than a single scalar variable. If the explanatory variables are measured with error then errors-in-variables models are required, also known as measurement error models.

Post-mortem chemistry, also called necrochemistry or death chemistry, is a subdiscipline of chemistry in which the chemical structures, reactions, processes and parameters of a dead organism is investigated. Post-mortem chemistry plays a significant role in forensic pathology. Biochemical analyses of vitreous humor, cerebrospinal fluid, blood and urine is important in determining the cause of death or in elucidating forensic cases.

Mortuary archaeology is the study of human remains in their archaeological context. This is a known sub-field of bioarchaeology, which is a field that focuses on gathering important information based on the skeleton of an individual. Bioarchaeology stems from the practice of human osteology which is the anatomical study of skeletal remains. Mortuary archaeology, as well as the overarching field it resides in, aims to generate an understanding of disease, migration, health, nutrition, gender, status, and kinship among past populations. Ultimately, these topics help to produce a picture of the daily lives of past individuals. Mortuary archaeologists draw upon the humanities, as well as social and hard sciences to have a full understanding of the individual.

Goldine C. Gleser was an American psychologist and statistician known for her research on the statistics of psychological testing, on generalizability theory, on defence mechanisms, on the psychological effects on child survivors of the Buffalo Creek flood, for her work with Mildred Trotter on estimation of stature, and for her participation in the Cincinnati Radiation Experiments. She was a professor of psychiatry and psychology at the University of Cincinnati.

References

  1. Bogin, Barry; Inês Varela-Silva, Maria (2010). "Leg Length, Body Proportion, and Health: A Review with a Note on Beauty". Int. J. Environ. Res. Public Health. 7 (3): 1047–1075. doi: 10.3390/ijerph7031047 . PMC   2872302 . PMID   20617018.
  2. Kamal, Renu; Yadav, Praveen Kumar (December 2016). "Estimation of stature from different anthropometric measurements in Kori population of North India". Egyptian Journal of Forensic Sciences. 6 (4): 468–477. doi: 10.1016/j.ejfs.2016.12.001 .
  3. Hussain, Sheik Shakeer S; Balachandran, Ajay (August 2017). "Determination of Stature from the Length of Middle Finger - An Autopsy Study". Journal of Evolution of Medical and Dental Sciences. 6 (70): 5009–12. doi: 10.14260/Jemds/2017/1088 . Retrieved 17 October 2017.
  4. Hussein, Sheik Shakeer S; Balachandran, Ajay (September 2017). "The Relationship Between Foot Index and Stature in Kerala Population - A Descriptive Study". Journal of Evolution of Medical and Dental Sciences. 6 (73): 5221–24. doi: 10.14260/Jemds/2017/1134 . Retrieved 17 October 2017.
  5. "LacusCurtius • Vitruvius on Architecture — Book III". penelope.uchicago.edu. Retrieved 20 June 2017.
  6. 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 Trotter, M; Gleser, GC (Dec 1952). "Estimation of stature from long bones of American Whites and Negroes". Am. J. Phys. Anthropol. 10 (4): 463–514. doi:10.1002/ajpa.1330100407. PMID   13007782.
  7. 1 2 Dupertuis, CW; Hadden, JA Jr (March 1951). "On the reconstruction of stature from long bones". Am. J. Phys. Anthropol. 9 (1): 15–53. doi:10.1002/ajpa.1330090104. PMID   14819267.
  8. 1 2 Trotter, M; Gleser, GC (March 1958). "A re-evaluation of estimation of stature based on measurements of stature taken during life and of long bones after death". Am. J. Phys. Anthropol. 16 (1): 79–123. doi:10.1002/ajpa.1330160106. PMID   13571400.
  9. Pearson, K (January 1899). "IV. Mathematical contributions to the theory of evolution.—V. On the reconstruction of the stature of prehistoric races". Phil. Trans. R. Soc. A. 192 (193): 169–244. Bibcode:1899RSPTA.192..169P. doi: 10.1098/rsta.1899.0004 . Retrieved 27 October 2017.