Frances Knorr | |
|---|---|
 Frances Knorr, c. 1892-1894 | |
| Born | Minnie Thwaites 10 December 1868 |
| Died | 15 January 1894 (aged 25) |
| Cause of death | Execution by hanging |
| Other names | Baby Farming Murderess |
| Criminal status | Executed |
| Children | 2 |
| Conviction(s) | Murder |
| Criminal penalty | Death |
Frances Lydia Alice Knorr (10 December 1868 – 15 January 1894) was an English serial killer known as the Baby Farming Murderess. She was found guilty of strangling an infant and hanged on Monday 15 January 1894.
Frances Knorr was born as Minnie Thwaites in London, England on 10 December 1868. She immigrated to Sydney in the Colony of New South Wales in 1887. Her father was reportedly William Sutton Thwaites, a tailor from Chelsea. [1] Initially, she worked as a domestic servant and married Rudolph (or "Randolph") Knorr, a German immigrant. She later had an affair with one Edward Thompson and moved to Melbourne; however, the short-lived affair was not successful and Knorr had to find a means to support herself and her daughter.
In February 1892, Victoria was in the midst of a depression and jobs were scarce when Rudolph Knorr was sent to prison for selling furniture he had bought on hire purchase. Pregnant and penniless, Frances decided to set up business as a child minder (or more specifically baby farming), and moved around Melbourne, frequently using both her maiden and married names.
Frances Knorr strangled some of the babies she could not place elsewhere or sell to childless couples. While she was living on Moreland Road in the Melbourne suburb of Brunswick, she buried a victim in the garden, then two others at her subsequent residence in Davis Street.
The new tenant at the Moreland Road residence discovered the body of a baby girl while preparing a garden bed. The police soon traced them to Knorr, who was ascertained to have moved to Sydney with her husband, and dug up the gardens of other properties around Melbourne where she had lived, finding the corpses of two boys buried in the yard at the Davis St house. Sydney police arrested her on 8 September. [2]
The police also arrested Rudolph Knorr on suspicion that he would also be wanted by the Melbourne police in connection with the murders, however he denied all knowledge of the burial of the infants. He was released from custody on the same day, as the Melbourne authorities indicated they were not investigating him at that time. Rudolph Knorr told police that until the previous April he had not seen his wife for 18 months, but around that time went to live with her in Brunswick. They had moved back to Sydney around 6 weeks before their arrest. [3] Rudolph was rearrested the next day, after new evidence connected him to the murders of the infants found at Davis Street.
Frances, in interrogation by Detective Keating, maintained a "cheerful demeanour", although she was much affected by learning of the arrest of her husband. Throughout questioning, she remained adamant that she was not guilty of any crime such as murder. Police kept her under close watch, considering her a high chance to attempt escape from custody. [2]
Shortly prior to her arrest, Knorr had given birth to a daughter, known as Rita Daisy Knorr, who ultimately was put into the care of the authorities of the Melbourne Gaol and later the Department of Neglected Children. [4]
After some postponements, Knorr came to trial in Melbourne on 27 November 1893, charged with the murder of the girl. [5] She was also charged with having murdered the two other infants together with her husband, Rudolph. [6]
Crown prosecutor Mr Walsh QC alleged that Knorr had the female infant in her possession from 8 to 11 April, after which the child was not seen again. Knorr had been regularly moving house and deceiving people as to her whereabouts, and on 11 April moved from Cardigan Street, Carlton to Moreland Road, Brunswick. Once moved in, she sent a servant girl to borrow a spade from a neighbour and reportedly spent some time attempting to dig in the garden. The following Saturday, she moved house again, this time together with her husband Rudolph to a house in Davis Street, Brunswick. Soon thereafter, the following tenant of the Moreland Road house found the body of the baby girl under a few inches of dirt. [7]
A letter written by Knorr to "Ted Thompson" was presented to the court, which stated that the baby had died of consumption and was buried by another man. [7] The letter was deemed pure fabrication.
Knorr gave a statement from the witness box and admitted that she had buried the babies in Moreland Road, but claimed that the children had died of natural causes. The Crown however demonstrated that they had been strangled with a tape and that the neck of one of the little boys had been compressed to less than half its normal size. Knorr was found guilty and, on 15 December, was sentenced to death by Justice Holroyd, with a large crowd having gathered to spectate the sentencing. Knorr, who had sobbed throughout the judge's address to her, collapsed and had to be carried out of the chamber to be transported to Old Melbourne Gaol to await execution. [8]
The prosecution dropped the further charges relating to the bodies found at Davis Street, and Rudolph Knorr was discharged by the supreme court on 16 December. [9] In a statement made after the trial, he insisted that the babies which had been seen alive with him had been adopted to interstate families, and were not the same ones found buried at the Davis St house. [10]
Although Knorr found little support among the newspapers of the day, the public was deeply divided on her sentence. Many letters to the editors of newspapers called for clemency. Thomas Jones, the state's hangman, committed suicide nine days before the execution after his wife threatened to leave him if he hanged Knorr.
Knorr was described as a model and penitent prisoner in the condemned cell and spent her time singing hymns and praying. She also made a written confession on the Saturday before her execution, part of which was made public the day after her execution. It read, in part:
Placed as I am now within a few hours of my death, I express a strong desire that this statement be made public, with the hope that my fall will not only be a warning to others, but also act as a deterrent to those who are perhaps carrying on the same practice. I now desire to state that upon the charges known in evidence as Number 1 & 2 babies, I confess to be guilty. [11]
Knorr's execution was at 10:00am on Monday 15 January 1894. [12] She had spent her last few hours singing hymns. Her last words were recorded as: "Yes, the Lord is with me. I do not fear what men may do to me, for I have peace, perfect peace." When the trap door was released, she dropped seven feet, six inches. Death was recorded as "instantaneous". [13] Her death mask is on display at the Old Melbourne Gaol.
Baby farming is the historical practice of accepting custody of an infant or child in exchange for payment in late-Victorian Britain and, less commonly, in Australia, New Zealand and the United States. If the infant was young, this usually included wet-nursing. Some baby farmers "adopted" children for lump-sum payments, while others cared for infants for periodic payments.
Margaret Waters (1835–1870), otherwise known as Willis, was an English murderer hanged by executioner William Calcraft on 11 October 1870 at Horsemonger Lane Gaol in London.
HM Prison Pentridge was an Australian prison that was established in 1851 in Coburg, Victoria. The first prisoners arrived in 1851. The prison closed on 1 May 1997.
The Old Melbourne Gaol is a former jail and current museum on Russell Street, in Melbourne, Victoria, Australia. It consists of a bluestone building and courtyard, and is located next to the old City Police Watch House and City Courts buildings, and opposite the Russell Street Police Headquarters. It was first constructed starting in 1839, and during its operation as a prison between 1845 and 1924, it held and executed some of Australia's most notorious criminals, including bushranger Ned Kelly and serial killer Frederick Bailey Deeming. In total, 133 people were executed by hanging. Though it was used briefly during World War II, it formally ceased operating as a prison in 1924; with parts of the jail being incorporated into the RMIT University, and the rest becoming a museum.
Joseph Theodore Leslie "Squizzy" Taylor was an Australian gangster from Melbourne. He appeared repeatedly and sometimes prominently in Melbourne news media because of suspicions, formal accusations and some convictions related to a 1919 gang war, to his absconding from bail and hiding from the police in 1921–22, and to his involvement in a robbery where a bank manager was murdered in 1923.
Williamina Dean was a New Zealander who was found guilty of infanticide and hanged. She was the only woman to be executed in New Zealand. Several other women were sentenced to death, but all of them had their sentences commuted to either life or long-duration imprisonment.
Makin v Attorney General for New South Wales is a significant 1893 decision of the Judicial Committee of the Privy Council which gave rise to the modern common law rule of similar fact evidence.
Theresa Jimmie Francine Knorr is an American woman convicted of torturing and murdering two of her six children while using the others to facilitate and cover up her crimes. She was acquitted of murdering her first husband and was also considered a suspect in the unsolved murder of her sister. She is currently serving two consecutive life sentences at the California Institution for Women in Chino, California.
Amelia Elizabeth Hobley, popularly dubbed the Ogress of Reading, was an English serial killer who murdered infants in her care over a thirty-year period during the Victorian era.
The Ballarat Gaol, a former maximum security prison for males, females and children, is located in Ballarat, Victoria, Australia. Replacing temporary structures including prison hulks in the Bay of Port Phillip and holding yards in Ballarat, the gaol operated between 1862 and 1965.
Martha Needle was an Australian serial killer known for poisoning her husband, three children, and prospective brother-in-law. She was hanged on 22 October 1894 when she was 31. She was convicted for the murder of Louis Juncken, brother of her fiancé Otto Juncken, on 15 May 1894. Although Needle collected substantial sums of insurance money, her exact motive for murdering her family has not been determined. Several times she stated her innocence, but she was eventually hanged.
Rizana Nafeek was a Sri Lankan woman convicted and subsequently executed in Saudi Arabia for the murder of four-month-old Naif al-Quthaibi. Her parents alleged that in order to get work in Saudi Arabia, the date of birth was altered on Nafeek's passport, and in reality she was under 18 when the offence took place; this made her execution contrary to the Convention on the Rights of the Child. Nafeek claimed that her initial confession was made under duress and without linguistic assistance.
John Sidney Makin and Sarah Jane Makin were Australian 'baby farmers' who were convicted in New South Wales for the murder of infant Horace Murray. The couple answered a series of advertisements from unmarried mothers seeking adoption of their babies, taking on the care of the infants on payment of a "premium". The remains of fifteen infants were found by police buried in the yards of houses where the Makins had resided. The exact cause of death was not determined but due to the bloodstains on the infants's clothing It's believed they had been stabbed in the heart with a large needle, hence the name "Hatpin Murders".
Daniel Richard Cooper of New Zealand was a convicted baby farmer and illegal abortionist. In 1922, he was apprehended at a Wellington suburban property and in 1923 found guilty of murder and executed. His wife, Martha Elizabeth Cooper, was acquitted.
Infanticide in 19th-century New Zealand was difficult to assess, especially for newborn indigenous Māori infants. Resultantly, many New Zealand women who might otherwise have been sentenced to penal servitude or capital punishment had their sentences commuted to the lesser charge of "concealment of birth" under the Offences Against the Person Act 1867. However, the relative leniency extended only to mothers of concealed or hidden infants who subsequently died. Fathers, grandparents and "baby farmers" like Minnie Dean, the only woman to be executed in New Zealand history, and Daniel Cooper in the 1920s were viewed as more culpable for the death of such infants.
Arthur Brennan was an Australian rules footballer who played with St Kilda in the Victorian Football League (VFL). He also played for Richmond, Port Melbourne, and Footscray in the Victorian Football Association (VFA).
Athelstan Braxton Hicks was a coroner in London and Surrey for two decades at the end of the 19th century. He was given the nickname "The Children's Coroner" for his conscientiousness in investigating the suspicious deaths of children, and especially baby farming and the dangers of child life insurance. He would later publish a study on infanticide.
From 1996 to 2006, Megan Huntsman, an American woman, murdered six of her newborn children shortly after giving birth to them in Utah.
Robert Rice Howard (known as "Nosey Bob" Howard) (c. March 1832 – 3 February 1906) was an Australian executioner. He was employed as a hangman for the colony of New South Wales from 1875, initially as an assistant hangman. Howard held the position of senior executioner from 1877 until he retired in 1904. Throughout a career spanning twenty-eight years, Robert Howard assisted or supervised the execution of sixty-two persons in New South Wales. Howard had a facial disfigurement, resulting in the loss of his nose, that occurred while working as a cabman in the mid-1870s. His missing nose and lengthy high-profile career as an executioner led to him being generally known, in newspapers and common parlance, as 'Nosey Bob'.
