Gallaudet Eleven

Last updated

The Gallaudet Eleven were a group of eleven deaf men recruited in the late 1950s and 1960s to participate in a joint research program led by NASA and the U.S. Naval School of Aviation Medicine to study the effects of prolonged weightlessness on the human body. They were selected for participation in the study because damage they had sustained to the vestibular systems of their inner ears had granted them immunity to motion sickness, making them uniquely resilient to certain physical studies that would have made other test subjects nauseous. [1]

Contents

History

In the 1960s, the Gallaudet Eleven were recruited from Gallaudet College (now Gallaudet University) for a study on how spaceflight might affect the human body, conducted in Pensacola, Florida by NASA and the U.S. Naval School of Aviation Medicine (NSAM). The study was directed by Captain Ashton Graybiel, a cardiologist who had previously led similar studies for NASA and NSAM.

The men selected were Harold Domich, Robert Greemun, Barron Gulak, Raymond Harper, Jerald Jordan, Harry Larson, David Myers, Donald Peterson, Raymond Piper, Alvin Steele, and John Zakutney. During the decade of studies, Robert Greemun wrote many letters to his family, which provided a vivid written record of the Gallaudet Eleven's experiences as test subjects. These letters have been donated to Gallaudet University for exhibition use by the Drs. John S. and Betty J. Schuchman Deaf Documentary Center and preservation in Gallaudet University's Deaf Collections and Archives. [2]

Experiments

The study consisted of a wide variety of tests in which subjects were challenged to perform physically and mentally demanding tasks while experiencing accelerations from things like centrifuges, zero-gravity flights, and other devices. Among other metrics, researchers evaluated the subjects' performance using urine tests, blood pressure recordings, electrocardiograms, eye tracking, and self-reporting from the subjects. [2] [3]

The Slow Rotation Room

The Slow Rotation Room (SRR) was a 20-foot diameter circular room in which subjects lived for periods up to two consecutive days. Across multiple trials, the room was made to rotate at speeds ranging from 2.4 to 10.0 rotations per minute. The room was equipped with all the necessities for basic living, including a sink, refrigerator, stove, shower, and toilet, so its rotation had to be paused only for occasional supply deliveries and visits from researchers. Of the four test subjects who lived in the SRR, the only member of the Gallaudet Eleven was Robert Greemun, who served as a control subject for the experiment. The other subjects were researchers and Navy medical officers who did not have Greemun's immunity to motion sickness. [2]

In a series of 1959 letters, Greemun described a few of the tests that subjects performed in the SRR. They included games involving throwing tennis balls, basketballs, and darts at targets, tests of dexterity in which subjects were to place styluses into small holes, balancing tests where subjects attempted to walk in straight lines, and a "dial test", in which subjects were instructed to set the positions of dials which were placed all around them, requiring the subjects to frequently rotate their heads and bodies. [2]

Coriolis Acceleration Platform

The Coriolis Acceleration Platform (CAP) was the successor to the SRR. It was a 20-foot diameter circular room that could spin at speeds up to 10 revolutions per minute. In addition, it could travel down a 40-foot linear track and tilt in angular directions. The room was entirely closed off from the outside, equipped with no windows and a set of cameras that researchers used to observe subjects from an external control room. Like the SRR, the CAP included all the necessities for living, including running water, a refrigerator, a toilet, a television, bedding, and a dining space.

In 1964, Greemun, Harper, Larson, and Myers spent between 17 and 18 days in the CAP, with 12 of those days being consecutive. While the CAP was running, it would stop only for a few minutes each day for supplies to be dropped off and for researchers to visit. Much of the testing in the CAP was the same as the SRR, with the addition of some new tests, including one where subjects were presented with a two-by-two grid of lights that could each flash a number. The subjects were to perform varying calculations in quick succession depending on the arrangement of two random numbers flashed in the grid. Greemun reports having developed certain habits of movement while living in the CAP and SRR that made it difficult to readjust to normal rooms in the first hours after the end of a trial. For example, he and other subjects were unable to walk without stumbling or to throw a ball in a straight line for a short period of time after they left the CAP and SRR. [2]

Elevator Rides and the Human Disorientation Device (HDD)

In another set of experiments, participants were subject to larger accelerations, but for shorter periods of time. In one such study, subjects rode inside a machine called the Human Disorientation Device (HDD), a cylindrical cabin attached to large machinery that could move and rotate in multiple directions, designed to simulate the accelerations of a spinning satellite. In another, subjects rode one of the express elevators in the Empire State Building, repeatedly traveling between the first and 80th floors. Some rides were carried out in total darkness, while in others, participants were subject to bursts of light from flash bulbs, which produced afterimages that they reported to the researchers. In some cases, electrodes were wired to the areas around the subject's eyes, which allowed researchers to monitor ocular motions during rides. [2]

Saint Pierre and Miquelon

In 1964, ten of the Gallaudet Eleven took a ferry ride on a 145-foot (44 m) long tugboat through a 200-mile (320 km) stretch of the North Atlantic Seas between St. Pierre and Miquelon and North Sydney, Nova Scotia, a journey that lasted 28 hours. These waters were known to be some of the roughest in the North Atlantic, and the team of researchers intentionally scheduled a voyage through a storm. Researchers observed 40-foot (12 m) waves, 40-knot winds, and 80-knot gusts in addition to accelerations exceeding 3 times that of gravity. [4] Participants were subject to similar tests as in previous experiments, including blood and urine analysis, physical tests of steadiness, and questionnaires for self-reporting. [2] The research staff and other non-deaf people on board experienced extreme seasickness and vomiting, while those part of the Gallaudet Eleven were largely unaffected, with some even reporting that they enjoyed the experience. [2] [5] [1]

Legacy

Christopher Altman conducting space motion sickness test and acclimation protocol at the Ashton Graybiel Spatial Orientation Laboratory (AGSOL). AGSOL Astronaut Training.jpg
Christopher Altman conducting space motion sickness test and acclimation protocol at the Ashton Graybiel Spatial Orientation Laboratory (AGSOL).

For their contributions to the understanding of motion sickness and the physiological and mental effects of prolonged accelerations on the human body, the Gallaudet Eleven have been recognized in museum exhibits and other ceremonies. On April 11, 2017, the National Deaf Life Museum at Gallaudet University opened an on-campus exhibit called Deaf Difference + Space Survival featuring over 150 photographs and various footage, letters, and scientific reports documenting the Gallaudet Eleven's experiences. [6] In April 2018, Harry Larson, David Myers, and James Greemun (Robert Greemun's son) were invited to NASA's Johnson Space Center to receive a special presentation and a tour of various facilities to thank them for their contributions and to show them the impacts of the research they participated in. [7] Modern day motion sickness research is carried out, among other topics, at the Ashton Graybiel Spatial Orientation Laboratory at Brandeis University. [8]

Related Research Articles

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Human spaceflight</span> Spaceflight with a crew or passengers

Human spaceflight is spaceflight with a crew or passengers aboard a spacecraft, often with the spacecraft being operated directly by the onboard human crew. Spacecraft can also be remotely operated from ground stations on Earth, or autonomously, without any direct human involvement. People trained for spaceflight are called astronauts, cosmonauts (Russian), or taikonauts (Chinese); and non-professionals are referred to as spaceflight participants or spacefarers.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Motion sickness</span> Nausea caused by motion or perceived motion

Motion sickness occurs due to a difference between actual and expected motion. Symptoms commonly include nausea, vomiting, cold sweat, headache, dizziness, tiredness, loss of appetite, and increased salivation. Complications may rarely include dehydration, electrolyte problems, or a lower esophageal tear.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">STS-61-A</span> 1985 American crewed spaceflight funded and directed by West Germany

STS-61-A was the 22nd mission of NASA's Space Shuttle program. It was a scientific Spacelab mission, funded and directed by West Germany – hence the non-NASA designation of D-1. STS-61-A was the ninth and last successful flight of Space Shuttle Challenger before the disaster. STS-61-A holds the current record for the largest crew—eight people—aboard any single spacecraft for the entire period from launch to landing.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">STS-54</span> 1993 American crewed spaceflight to deploy TRDS-6

STS-54 was a NASA Space Transportation System mission using Space Shuttle Endeavour. This was the third flight for Endeavour, and was launched on January 13, 1993 with Endeavour returning to the Kennedy Space Center on January 19, 1993.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Vestibular system</span> Sensory system that facilitates body balance

The vestibular system, in vertebrates, is a sensory system that creates the sense of balance and spatial orientation for the purpose of coordinating movement with balance. Together with the cochlea, a part of the auditory system, it constitutes the labyrinth of the inner ear in most mammals.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">STS-90</span> 1998 American crewed spaceflight and final flight of Spacelab

STS-90 was a 1998 Space Shuttle mission flown by the Space Shuttle Columbia. The 16-day mission marked the last flight of the European Space Agency's Spacelab laboratory module, which had first flown on Columbia on STS-9, and was also the last daytime landing for Columbia.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Space adaptation syndrome</span> Condition caused by weightlessness

Space adaptation syndrome (SAS) or space sickness is a condition experienced by as many as half of all space travelers during their adaptation to weightlessness once in orbit. It is the opposite of terrestrial motion sickness since it occurs when the environment and the person appear visually to be in motion relative to one another even though there is no corresponding sensation of bodily movement originating from the vestibular system.

Spatial disorientation is the inability to determine position or relative motion, commonly occurring during periods of challenging visibility, since vision is the dominant sense for orientation. The auditory system, vestibular system, and proprioceptive system collectively work to coordinate movement with balance, and can also create illusory nonvisual sensations, resulting in spatial disorientation in the absence of strong visual cues.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Life-support system</span> Technology that allows survival in hostile environments

A life-support system is the combination of equipment that allows survival in an environment or situation that would not support that life in its absence. It is generally applied to systems supporting human life in situations where the outside environment is hostile, such as outer space or underwater, or medical situations where the health of the person is compromised to the extent that the risk of death would be high without the function of the equipment.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Artificial gravity</span> Use of circular rotational force to mimic gravity

Artificial gravity is the creation of an inertial force that mimics the effects of a gravitational force, usually by rotation. Artificial gravity, or rotational gravity, is thus the appearance of a centrifugal force in a rotating frame of reference, as opposed to the force experienced in linear acceleration, which by the equivalence principle is indistinguishable from gravity. In a more general sense, "artificial gravity" may also refer to the effect of linear acceleration, e.g. by means of a rocket engine.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Effect of spaceflight on the human body</span> Medical issues associated with spaceflight

The effects of spaceflight on the human body are complex and largely harmful over both short and long term. Significant adverse effects of long-term weightlessness include muscle atrophy and deterioration of the skeleton. Other significant effects include a slowing of cardiovascular system functions, decreased production of red blood cells, balance disorders, eyesight disorders and changes in the immune system. Additional symptoms include fluid redistribution, loss of body mass, nasal congestion, sleep disturbance, and excess flatulence. Overall, NASA refers to the various deleterious effects of spaceflight on the human body by the acronym RIDGE.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Motion simulator</span> Type of mechanism

A motion simulator or motion platform is a mechanism that creates the feelings of being in a real motion environment. In a simulator, the movement is synchronised with a visual display of the outside world (OTW) scene. Motion platforms can provide movement in all of the six degrees of freedom (DOF) that can be experienced by an object that is free to move, such as an aircraft or spacecraft:. These are the three rotational degrees of freedom and three translational or linear degrees of freedom.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Orbiting Frog Otolith</span> NASA space program which sent frogs into orbit

The Orbiting Frog Otolith (OFO) was a NASA space program which sent two bullfrogs into orbit on 9 November 1970 for the study of weightlessness. The name, derived through common use, was a functional description of the biological experiment carried by the satellite. Otolith referred to the frog's inner ear balance mechanism.

The sopite syndrome is a neurological disorder that relates symptoms of fatigue, drowsiness, and mood changes to prolonged periods of motion. The sopite syndrome has been attributed to motion-induced drowsiness such as that experienced by a baby when rocked. Researchers Ashton Graybiel and James Knepton at the Naval Aerospace Medical Research Laboratory first used the term "the sopite syndrome", in 1976, to refer to the sometimes sole manifestation of motion sickness, though other researchers have referred to it as "Sopite syndrome."

In psychophysical perception, the Coriolis effect is the misperception of body orientation and induced nausea due to the Coriolis force. This effect comes about as the head is moved in contrary or similar motion with the body during the time of a spin, this rotation of the head affects the semicircular canals within the ear which causes a sense of dizziness or nausea before equilibrium is restored after the head returns to a stabilized state.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Weightlessness</span> Absence of stress and strain resulting from externally applied mechanical contact-forces

Weightlessness is the complete or near-complete absence of the sensation of weight, i.e., zero apparent weight. It is also termed zero gravity, zero g-force, or zero-g. Micro-g environment is more or less synonymous, with the recognition that g-forces are never exactly zero.

Space neuroscience or astroneuroscience is the scientific study of the central nervous system (CNS) functions during spaceflight. Living systems can integrate the inputs from the senses to navigate in their environment and to coordinate posture, locomotion, and eye movements. Gravity has a fundamental role in controlling these functions. In weightlessness during spaceflight, integrating the sensory inputs and coordinating motor responses is harder to do because gravity is no longer sensed during free-fall. For example, the otolith organs of the vestibular system no longer signal head tilt relative to gravity when standing. However, they can still sense head translation during body motion. Ambiguities and changes in how the gravitational input is processed can lead to potential errors in perception, which affects spatial orientation and mental representation. Dysfunctions of the vestibular system are common during and immediately after spaceflight, such as space motion sickness in orbit and balance disorders after return to Earth.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Astronaut training</span> Preparing astronauts for space missions

Astronaut training describes the complex process of preparing astronauts in regions around the world for their space missions before, during and after the flight, which includes medical tests, physical training, extra-vehicular activity (EVA) training, procedure training, rehabilitation process, as well as training on experiments they will accomplish during their stay in space.

Simulator sickness is a subset of motion sickness that is typically experienced while playing video games from first-person perspective. It was discovered in the context of aircraft pilots who undergo training for extended periods of time in flight simulators. Due to the spatial limitations imposed on these simulators, perceived discrepancies between the motion of the simulator and that of the vehicle can occur and lead to simulator sickness. It is similar to motion sickness in many ways, but occurs in simulated environments and can be induced without actual motion. Symptoms of simulator sickness include discomfort, apathy, drowsiness, disorientation, fatigue, and nausea. These symptoms can reduce the effectiveness of simulators in flight training and result in systematic consequences such as decreased simulator use, compromised training, ground safety, and flight safety. Pilots are less likely to want to repeat the experience in a simulator if they have suffered from simulator sickness and hence can reduce the number of potential users. It can also compromise training in two safety-critical ways:

  1. It can distract the pilot during training sessions.
  2. It can cause the pilot to adopt certain counterproductive behaviors to prevent symptoms from occurring.
<span class="mw-page-title-main">Locomotion in space</span> Movement of astronauts bodies in outer space

Locomotion in space includes all actions or methods used to move one's body in microgravity conditions through the outer space environment. Locomotion in these conditions is different from locomotion in a gravitational field. There are many factors that contribute to these differences, and they are crucial when researching long-term survival of humans in space.

References

  1. 1 2 Almeida, Andres (2017-05-02). "How 11 Deaf Men Helped Shape NASA's Human Spaceflight Program". NASA. Retrieved 2022-04-01.
  2. 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 Bergey, Jean Lindquist Bergey (2018). "Deaf Perspective: Inside View of Early Space Research" (PDF). Quest: The History of Spaceflight Quarterly. 25: 12–28.
  3. "How Being Deaf Made the Difference in Space Research". airandspace.si.edu. Retrieved 2022-04-01.
  4. Graybiel, Ashton. "Residual Effects of Storm Conditions and Sea Upon the Postural Equilibrium Functioning of Vestibular Normal and Vestibular Defective Human Subjects" (PDF). Bureau of Medicine and Surgery. Archived (PDF) from the original on June 1, 2022.
  5. Larimer, Sarah. "'I wanted to serve': These deaf men helped NASA understand motion sickness in space". The Washington Post.
  6. "Deaf Difference Space Survival Opening". Gallaudet University. Retrieved 2022-04-09.
  7. "Little-known piece of NASA history: Members of Gallaudet 11 visit NASA's Johnson Space Center".
  8. "Ashton Graybiel Spatial Orientation Laboratory".