Gor Sunguh Commission

Last updated

The Gor Sungu Commission was a Kenya Parliamentary Select Committee investigating circumstances leading to the death of the late Dr. Robert Ouko.

Contents

Committee setup

Between April 2003 and March 2005 Gor Sunguh was the chairman of the 'Parliamentary Select Committee Investigating Circumstances Leading to the Death of the Late Dr. Robert Ouko, EGH, MP' tasked with investigating the death of former Kenyan Foreign Affairs Minister, Dr Robert Ouko, in February 1990 . [1] [2]

Hearings

The Committee heard allegations of a dispute going back to the 1988 General Election (PSCI para 249 [3] ) over opposition to the revival of the Kisumu Molasses Plant in Dr Ouko’s constituency. There were also allegations that ‘senior public figures’ demanded ‘kickbacks’ over the revival of the Kisumu Molasses Plant (PSCI para 250 [4] ).

The Committee also ‘received evidence’ that there had been row between a Nicholas Biwott (Minister of Energy at the time of Ouko’s murder) and Dr Ouko over a meeting with President George Bush Snr during an overseas visit to in late January and early February 1990 when a delegation of 84 ministers and officials led by Kenya’s President Daniel arap Moi, had attended a private ‘Prayer Breakfast’ in Washington D.C. (PSCI paras 251 [5] and 252 [6] ).

According to the ‘Washington trip’ theory Dr Ouko had met with President Bush Snr, US Secretary of State James Baker, President Moi, Nicholas Biwott and others, at which the US President had allegedly urged Moi to hand over the Kenyan presidency to Dr Ouko who ‘could resuscitate Kenya from its diminished international standing due to corruption and human rights abuse’. (PSCI para 252 [7] )

The Sunguh Committee’s ‘Washington trip’ theory also stated that the government of the United Kingdom had urged President Moi to ensure Dr Ouko’s election in Kenya’s 1988 General Elections ‘being one believed capable of succeeding him’. (PSCI para 252 (ii)) [8]

The ‘misconstrued perception’ that Dr Ouko was ‘seeking foreign support to accede to the presidency’ was, according to the Sunguh Committee, ‘sufficiently supported as a motive to cause his death’. (PSCI para 252 (iii) [9] )

As a result of ‘the differences between Dr. R.J, Ouko and Hon. K.N.K. Biwott’ (PSCI para 251 (ii)) the Committee suggested, Dr Ouko had flown back to Kenya on a separate flight from President Moi, his passport had been seized at Nairobi airport, his official car was withdrawn, his bodyguard recalled and he had been ‘sacked’ by President Moi who directed him ‘to rest at his Koru farm’. (PSCI para 253 (iii)) [10]

Sunguh’s Committee concluded that Dr Ouko had disappeared from his farm ‘in the early hours of 13 February, [1990], abducted and taken to State House, Nakuru, 'where he was killed allegedly 'in the presence of among others, Hon. K.N.K. Biwott'. (PSCI para 253 (iv) [11]

In all Sunguh’s Committee named recommended that the Kenyan government should investigate the role of over 40 people for their possible involvement in the murder of Dr Robert Ouko. Sunguh’s Committee however, ‘faced various challenges to its work’ and it operations were ‘dogged by controversy’ (Lest We Forget: The Faces of Impunity in Kenya’. (Kenya Human Rights Commission Report, 2011, page 35 [12] )

Membership

Six members of the Select Committee, Paul Muite, Mirugi Kariuki, Dr Abdulahi Ali, Njoki Susanna Ndung'u and Otieno Kajwang – resigned during its hearings. Four others left to take up other appointments. New members were appointed to the Committee. Of the 10 members of the Committee in post at the end, four did not sign the Committee's report. (KHRC report, page 36 [13] )

Gor Sunguh

Gor Sunguh is a politician and former member of Parliament in Kenya as representative of the Kisumu Town East Constituency (1997-2002). Between April 2003 and March 2005 Sunguh was the chairman of the 'Parliamentary Select Committee Investigating Circumstances Leading to the Death of the Late Dr. Robert Ouko, EGH, MP'. [14] [15]

Report

The Select Committee's report was signed by Gor Sunguh on 15 March 2005, just over 15 years after the minister's murder.

The Parliamentary Select Committee's 'Recommendations and Conclusions' (PSCI paras 249–258 [16] ) suggested several possible factors leading to the murder of Dr Robert Ouko.

The parliamentary Select Committee’s Report was re-introduced to Kenya’s parliament on 8 December 2010 and debated on 15 December. It was rejected on 22 December, ‘with members of Parliament accusing the committee of doing shoddy work and using the committee’s investigations to settle political scores’. ( KHRC Report, page 36 [17] )

Critical to the weakness of the Sunguh Committee's investigation and reports were two facts that had been in the public domain since 1990 and 1991.

The forensic evidence and analysis submitted by Britain's Scotland Yard as set out in Detective Superintendent John Troon's 'Final Report' stated that Dr Ouko had been shot where his body was found, or a few feet from that spot (TFR para 290 [18] ). [19] And eye witness testimony gathered at the time of Ouko’s murder and set out in both Troon’s ‘Final Report’ and the ‘Further Investigations’ report from the Kenyan police released a year later, placed Dr Ouko’s day and time of death at somewhere between 3am and 1pm on 13 February 1990. (Kenya Police Further Investigations, pages 12–13 [20] and TFR)

Committee decision

This evidence made it impossible for Dr Robert Ouko to have been shot at State House Nakuru and his body taken to where it was subsequently found some time between 12 and 16 February 1990, as Sunguh's Committee had concluded.

Related Research Articles

Daniel arap Moi President of Kenya from 1978 to 2002

Daniel Toroitich arap Moi was a Kenyan politician and kleptocrat who served as the second president of Kenya from 1978 to 2002. He was the country's longest-serving president. Moi previously served as the third vice president of Kenya from 1967 to 1978 under President Jomo Kenyatta, becoming president following the latter's death.

Kenya African National Union Political party in Kenya

The Kenya African National Union (KANU) is a Kenyan political party that ruled for nearly 40 years after Kenya's independence from British colonial rule in 1963 until its electoral loss in 2002. It was known as Kenya African Union (KAU) from 1944 to 1952. The KAU was banned by the colonial government from 1952 to 1960. It was re-established by James Gichuru in 1960 and renamed KANU on 14 May 1960 after a merger with Tom Mboya's Kenya Independence Movement.

The Goldenberg scandal was a political scandal where the Kenyan government was found to have subsidised exports of gold far beyond standard arrangements during the 1990s, by paying the company Goldenberg International 35% more than their foreign currency earnings. Although it notionally appears that the scheme was intended to earn hard currency for the country, it is estimated to have cost Kenya the equivalent of more than 10% of the country's annual gross domestic product, and it is possible that no or minimal amounts of gold were actually exported. The scandal appears to have involved political corruption at the highest levels of the government of Daniel Arap Moi. Officials in the former government of Mwai Kibaki have also been implicated.

Smith Hempstone American diplomat

Smith Hempstone was a journalist, author, and the United States ambassador to Kenya in 1989–93. He was a vocal proponent of democracy, advocating free elections for Kenya.

Nicholas Kipyator Kiprono arap Biwott was a Kenyan businessman, politician and philanthropist. Biwott served as a civil servant, Member of Parliament and government minister, during which time he held eight senior ministerial positions during the presidency of Daniel arap Moi.

Robert Ouko (politician) Kenyan politician

The Honorable Dr. John Robert Ouko, commonly known as Robert Ouko, was a Kenyan politician who served as Foreign Minister of Kenya from 1979 to 1983 and from 1988 to 1990. Robert Ouko served in the government of Kenya from the colonial period through the presidencies of Jomo Kenyatta and Daniel arap Moi. He was a member of the National Assembly for Kisumu and a cabinet minister, rising to the post of Minister of Foreign Affairs and International Cooperation by 1990. He was murdered in Kenya on 13 February 1990. The murder case, perhaps the most intriguing in Kenyan history, remains unsolved.

Jonah Anguka is a Kenyan author and former District Commissioner at Nakuru, known as the only person to date to have been tried for the murder of Dr Robert Ouko, Kenya's Minister of Foreign Affairs, who was shot dead on 13 February 1990.

Corruption in Kenya Institutional corruption in the country

Corruption in the government of Kenya has a history which spans the era of the founding president Jomo Kenyatta, to Daniel arap Moi's KANU, Mwai Kibaki's PNU government and the current Uhuru Kenyatta's Jubilee Party government. In the Corruption Perceptions Index 2021 Kenya is ranked 128th out of 180 countries for corruption, tied with seven other countries, including Bolivia, Azerbaijan, Laos, and Paraguay.

George Saitoti Kenyan politician

George Musengi Saitoti, E.G.H. was a Kenyan politician, businessman and American- and British-trained economist, mathematician and development policy thinker.

John Anthony Kaiser 20th-century American Catholic priest and missionary

John Anthony Kaiser was a Roman Catholic priest and Mill Hill father from Perham, Minnesota, US, who was assassinated near his mission at Morendat, in western Kenya.

Hezekiah Oyugi was head of internal security for the Republic of Kenya in 1990 when Foreign Minister Robert Ouko was murdered. Both he and energy minister Nicholas Biwott were named as "principal suspects" in the crime by a British investigator during a commission of inquiry. Both were arrested but freed after two weeks for "lack of evidence".

Bethwell Allan Ogot Kenyan historian

Bethwell Allan Ogot is a historian from Kenya. He specialises in African history, research methods and theory. One of his works starts by saying that "to tell the story of a past so as to portray an inevitable destiny is, for humankind, a need as universal as tool-making. To that extent, we may say that a human being is, by nature, historicus.

Eisha Stephen Atieno Odhiambo (1945 – 25 February 2009)) was a Kenyan academic born in Muhoroni, known for his contributions to the understanding of dangers inherent in politics of knowledge and sociology of power. Dr Odhiambo was professor of history at Rice University in the United States, where he led in the study of cultures. He was educated at Makerere University in Uganda and the University of Nairobi in Kenya.

Dr. Zachary T. Onyonka (1939–1996) was a Kenyan politician. Onyonka was the foreign minister of his country from 1969 to 1996 under several other ministries up to and including Education, Economic Planning & Development and Trade and Foreign Affairs. Well Known within the Kisii community, he was always at loggerheads with then Nyaribari Chache MP Simeon Nyachae until he died. Onyonka was elected to parliament in the 1969 elections from Kitutu West Constituency when he trounced the first cabinet minister from Kisii, Lawrence Sagini Ndemo. He was the youngest MP at about 25 years. He retained his parliamentary seat until his death. He was famous for leading an anti-Nyachae crusade in Kisii after he was released from Kodiaga prison in Kisumu. He had been arrested and charged with murder following a fatal shooting incident involving his bodyguards and a voter in then Kiututu West constituency campaigns. Ouru Ndege was shot dead after he attempted to attack Dr. Onyonka with a knife during the stormy 1983 campaigns along Kisii-Migori road junction. His rival, John Bosco Mboga had just addressed his supporters in the area and when Onyonka, who was a cabinet minister in President Moi's government arrived, Ndege attempted to stab him with a sword leading to the minister's bodyguards shooting him to death. Onyonka and his guards did not have a car at the time of the shooting. He was rescued by a matatu driver, Joseph Moya Nyambariga, from Botori area in Bomorenda, Bonchari, who drove the sieged minister in his matatu, christened Bolingo Na Ngai Express to safety at Suneka Chief's camp. He was arrested soon after and locked up in Kisumu awaiting trial on murder charges. The prosecution was unable to prove the case against him and in 1984, Onyonka was set free. He had won the hotly contested election in absentia and after two years in the cold, Moi appointed him Minister for Foreign Affairs. Before the 1988 elections, Onyonka led a group of politicians from Kisii dubbed the Four Os. This stands for Onyonka, Obure Omanga and Onyancha to launch the famous "Kebirigo Declaration" in which Nyachae was denounced. The Kebirigo declaration was a strong political ideology that stood for independence of each constituency in Kisii against manipulation from Nyachae. At that time, it had become increasingly evident that Nyachae who was a powerful civil servant was planning to plunge into active politics. Onyonka alleged that Nyachae had embarked on a series of secret campaigns, recruiting candidates against incumbent MPs so that he could make it to parliament with a clean slate of leaders, if he was cleared by KANU to run for elective seat. The Kebirigo declaration was therefore meant to assert the authority and legitimacy of each member of parliament from Kisii and also sought to reject the political dominion from Nyaribari, Nyachae's home constituency. After Onyonka's death in 1996, he was succeeded by Jimmy Nuru Angwenyi as MP for Kitutu Chache. His son Richard Momoima Onyonka, later dethroned Angwenyi to become the area MP. After the 2013 electoral review, Kitutu Chache was hived into two constituencies, North and South (Mosocho).

Newton Kulundu was a Kenyan politician. He was the Minister of Labour and Human Resource Development in the Ministry of Labour (2006–2008), and a Member of Parliament in Lurambi Constituency (2002–2007).

Wilson Ndolo Ayah Kenyan politician

Wilson Ndolo Ayah was a Kenyan politician. He served as Foreign Minister from 1990 to 1993 during Kenya's return to a multi-party system of governance. Wilson Ndolo Ayah served in the government of Daniel Arap Moi as minister from 18 August 1987 when he was first appointed Minister for Research Science and Technology. He was also a beneficiary of the Kennedy Airlifts.

The Kenya Human Rights Commission (KHRC) is a non-government organisation founded in 1992 and registered in 1994. The Commission campaigns to create a culture in Kenya where human rights and democratic culture are entrenched. It does this through monitoring, documenting and publicising rights violations.

Grace Monica Akech Onyango, popularly known as Nya'Bungu is a retired Kenyan politician. She holds several firsts in post-independence Kenyan politics, as the first female to climb up the ranks of the political system, defying cultural barriers. She was the first Kenyan female mayor, after she replaced Mathias Ondiek as the Kisumu Mayor in 1965. She was also the first female Member of Parliament in post-independence Kenya after she was elected to represent Kisumu Town Constituency in 1969. In Parliament, Grace Onyango was the first woman to sit on the speaker's chair as temporary deputy speaker, and served as Deputy Speaker from 1979 to 1984. Her political career ended after she lost her parliamentary seat in 1984.

Denis Daudi Afande (1937-2021) was a long-serving career Kenyan diplomat who held eight ambassadorial positions during his career. A consummate Diplomat, Afande joined the public service at Kenya's Independence (1964). He served as Kenya’s Deputy Chief of Protocol under founding President Jomo Kenyatta and chief of protocol under President Danial arap Moi. He later served as Kenya’s ambassador to Washington (1988-1994), the United Nations Mission in Geneva, Switzerland, the UK, Germany, France, Egypt and Saudi Arabia.

References

  1. ↑ Parliament Launches Fresh Probe into Ouko Murder. Publication: Asia Africa Intelligence Wire Publication Date: 27-MAR-03 http://www.accessmylibrary.com/coms2/summary_0286-22817845_ITM
  2. ↑ A minister's death received with disbelief http://www.eastandard.net/InsidePage.php?id=1144006539&cid=259&%5B%5D
  3. ↑ "Parliamentary Select Committee Report".
  4. ↑ "Parliamentary Select Committee Report".
  5. ↑ "Parliamentary Select Committee Report".
  6. ↑ "Parliamentary Select Committee Report".
  7. ↑ "Parliamentary Select Committee Report".
  8. ↑ "Parliamentary Select Committee Report".
  9. ↑ "Parliamentary Select Committee Report".
  10. ↑ "Parliamentary Select Committee Report".
  11. ↑ "Parliamentary Select Committee Report".
  12. ↑ "Lest we Forget: The Faces of Impunity in Kenya". KHRC.
  13. ↑ "Lest we Forget: The Faces of Impunity in Kenya". KHRC.
  14. ↑ Parliament Launches Fresh Probe Into Ouko Murder. Publication: Asia Africa Intelligence Wire Publication Date: 27-MAR-03
  15. ↑ A minister's death received with disbelief [ permanent dead link ]
  16. ↑ "Parliamentary Select Committee Report".
  17. ↑ "Lest we Forget: The Faces of Impunity in Kenya". KHRC.
  18. ↑ "Troons final report para 290".
  19. ↑ "Who killed Dr Robert Ouko?..and Why?". murder at Got Alila. WPMS/INCA/CitizenTV. Archived from the original on 22 April 2017. Retrieved 25 April 2017.
  20. ↑ "Kenya Police Further Investigations pages 11,12 and 13". Kenya Police.{
This page is based on this Wikipedia article
Text is available under the CC BY-SA 4.0 license; additional terms may apply.
Images, videos and audio are available under their respective licenses.