H.W. v. France

Last updated

On 23 January 2025, the European Court of Human Rights (ECtHR) ruled in H.W. v. France that a French woman was not at fault for her divorce due to not engaging in sexual relations with her husband during their marriage. The ruling overturned a French court decision that deemed her failure to fulfil "marital duties" (devoir conjugal) as grounds for fault.

Contents

The concept of "marital duty" (devoir conjugal) in French law has its origins in Catholic canon law which viewed marriage as a framework for sexual reproduction, making sexual intercourse between husband and wife obligatory. Article 215 of the Napoleonic Code (1804) says that "spouses mutually oblige themselves to a community of life". While the law does not explicitly mandate sexual relations, judges have interpreted it as such. [1]

This began to be criticised with the advent of the feminist movement in France. [1] In 1990, Court of Cassation, France's highest court, authorised prosecution of spouses for rape or sexual assault (marital rape). [2]

French court ruling

H.W., a 69-year-old French woman, married J.C. in 1984. In 2002, her husband became physically abusive toward her following a period of her illness. By 2004, they ceased sexual relations. [3] [4]

In 2012, they filed for divorce, which was granted. While H.W. wanted a no-fault divorce, J.C. argued H.W. was at fault for not performing her "marital duties". In 2018, a family court judge in Versailles ruled that H.W.'s health problems justified the absence of sexual relations; this was overturned by the Versailles Court of Appeal who said that H.W.'s refusal to have "intimate relations (relations intimes) with her husband" was a "fault". [5] The Court of Cassation dismissed her appeal. [3]

ECtHR ruling

H.W. brought the case to the European Court of Human Rights (ECtHR) in 2021. [3] On 23 January 2025, the ECtHR unanimously ruled that France violated H.W.'s right to respect for private and family life under Article 8 of the European Convention on Human Rights. [5] The Court said that "any non-consensual sexual act constitutes a form of sexual violence" [6] and emphasised that "consent to marriage could not imply consent to future sexual relations. Such an interpretation would be tantamount to denying that marital rape was reprehensible in nature". [7] It further said that the concept of "marital duties" as interpreted by French courts was incompatible with modern understandings of consent, bodily autonomy and sexual freedom. [3] [8]

Response

Lilia Mhissen, H.W's lawyer, said following the ruling: "I hope this decision will mark a turning point in the fight for women's rights in France. It is now imperative that France [...] takes concrete measures to eradicate this rape culture and promote a true culture of consent and mutual respect." [9] Mhissen said that the ruling would stop French judges from making similar rulings where the refusal of sexual relations is considered grounds of divorce. [9]

The ruling came during a period of heightened debate in France about sexual consent, especially following high-profile cases like that of Gisèle Pelicot, where her husband and others were was convicted of drugging and raping her. [3]

In the aftermath of the ruling, the French feminist groups Fondation des Femmes  [ fr ] and Collectif Féministe Contre le Viol  [ fr ] highlighted the need for legal changes to reflect contemporary understandings of consent and autonomy. They celebrated the ruling as a victory for women's rights, pushing for legislative changes to ensure that marriage does not require "sexual servitude". [10]

See also

Related Research Articles

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Marriage</span> Culturally recognised union between people

Marriage, also called matrimony or wedlock, is a culturally and often legally recognised union between people called spouses. It establishes rights and obligations between them, as well as between them and their children, and between them and their in-laws. It is nearly a cultural universal, but the definition of marriage varies between cultures and religions, and over time. Typically, it is an institution in which interpersonal relationships, usually sexual, are acknowledged or sanctioned. In some cultures, marriage is recommended or considered to be compulsory before pursuing sexual activity. A marriage ceremony is called a wedding, while a private marriage is sometimes called an elopement.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Spouse</span> Partner in a marriage or similar union

A spouse is a significant other in a marriage. A male spouse is called a husband while a female spouse is called a wife.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Adultery</span> Type of extramarital sex

Adultery is extramarital sex that is considered objectionable on social, religious, moral, or legal grounds. Although the sexual activities that constitute adultery vary, as well as the social, religious, and legal consequences, the concept exists in many cultures and shares some similarities in Judaism, Christianity and Islam. Adultery is viewed by many jurisdictions as offensive to public morals, undermining the marriage relationship.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Women's rights</span> Rights claimed for women and girls worldwide

Women's rights are the rights and entitlements claimed for women and girls worldwide. They formed the basis for the women's rights movement in the 19th century and the feminist movements during the 20th and 21st centuries. In some countries, these rights are institutionalized or supported by law, local custom, and behavior, whereas in others, they are ignored and suppressed. They differ from broader notions of human rights through claims of an inherent historical and traditional bias against the exercise of rights by women and girls, in favor of men and boys.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Consummation</span> First sex act as part of a marriage or relationship

The consummation of a marriage, or simply consummation, is the first officially credited act of sexual intercourse following marriage. In many traditions and statutes of civil or religious law, the definition usually refers to penile–vaginal penetration, and some religious doctrines hold an additional requirement prohibiting contraception. In this sense, "a marriage is consummated only if the conjugal act performed deposits semen in the vagina."

Marital rape or spousal rape is the act of sexual intercourse with one's spouse without the spouse's consent. The lack of consent is the essential element and doesn't always involve physical violence. Marital rape is considered a form of domestic violence and sexual abuse. Although, historically, sexual intercourse within marriage was regarded as a right of spouses, engaging in the act without the spouse's consent is now widely classified as rape by many societies around the world, and increasingly criminalized. However it is repudiated by some more conservative cultures.

Rape is a type of sexual assault initiated by one or more persons against another person without that person's consent. The act may be carried out by physical force, under threat or manipulation, by impersonation, or with a person who is incapable of giving valid consent.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Divorce law by country</span>

Divorce law, the legal provisions for the dissolution of marriage, varies widely across the globe, reflecting diverse legal systems and cultural norms. Most nations allow for residents to divorce under some conditions except the Philippines and the Vatican City, an ecclesiastical sovereign city-state, which has no procedure for divorce. In these two countries, laws only allow annulment of marriages.

Article 8 of the European Convention on Human Rights provides a right to respect for one's "private and family life, his home and his correspondence", subject to certain restrictions that are "in accordance with law" and "necessary in a democratic society". The European Convention on Human Rights (ECHR) is an international treaty to protect human rights and fundamental freedoms in Europe.

Implied consent is consent which is not expressly granted by a person, but rather implicitly granted by a person's actions and the facts and circumstances of a particular situation. For example, if a person is unconscious as a result of injuries sustained during a traffic collision, medical treatment may be provided to that person, despite the unconscious person being unable to expressly grant consent for that treatment.

Criticisms of marriage are arguments against the practical or moral value of the institution of marriage or particular forms of matrimony. These have included the effects that marriage has on individual liberty, equality between the sexes, the relationship between marriage and violence, philosophical questions about how much control can a government have over its population, the amount of control a person has over another, the financial risk when measured against alternatives and divorce, and questioning of the necessity to have a relationship sanctioned by government or religious authorities.

Punishment for rape in Pakistan under the Pakistani laws is either death penalty or imprisonment of between ten and twenty-five years. For cases related to gang rape, the punishment is either death penalty or life imprisonment. DNA test and other scientific evidence are used in prosecuting rape cases in Pakistan.

Rape is the fourth most common crime against women in India. According to the 2021 annual report of the National Crime Records Bureau (NCRB), 31,677 rape cases were registered across the country, or an average of 86 cases daily, a rise from 2020 with 28,046 cases, while in 2019, 32,033 cases were registered. Of the total 31,677 rape cases, 28,147 of the rapes were committed by persons known to the victim. The share of victims who were minors or below 18 – the legal age of consent – stood at 10%.

In English law, restitution of conjugal rights was an action in the ecclesiastical courts and later in the Court for Divorce and Matrimonial Causes. It was one of the actions relating to marriage, over which the ecclesiastical courts formerly had jurisdiction.

In France, rape is illegal, and marital rape is also illegal. In recent years there has been increase of reported rape cases in France.

Marital duty is a spouse's sexual commitment to one another. The concept stems from descriptions found in canon law of medieval Europe.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Rape in Islamic law</span> Sexual violation as interpreted in Islamic theological jurisprudence

In Islam, human sexuality is governed by Islamic law, also known as Sharia. Accordingly, sexual violation is regarded as a violation of moral and divine law. Islam divides claims of sexual violation into 'divine rights' and 'interpersonal rights' : the former requiring divine punishment and the latter belonging to the more flexible human realm.

Marital rape generally refers to non-consensual sexual intercourse between married spouses. In Singapore, there used to be a partial immunity for marital rape first introduced during British colonial rule because it was deemed not a criminal offence except when the wife is below 13 years of age or when any of the specific circumstances provided under section 375(4) of the Singapore Penal Code are satisfied. Since 1 January 2020, the law was repealed and its immunity lifted under the Criminal Law Reform Act 2019, criminalising marital rape.

Adultery laws are the laws in various countries that deal with extramarital sex. Historically, many cultures considered adultery a very serious crime, some subject to severe punishment, especially in the case of extramarital sex involving a married woman and a man other than her husband, with penalties including capital punishment, mutilation, or torture. Such punishments have gradually fallen into disfavor, especially in Western countries from the 19th century. In countries where adultery is still a criminal offense, punishments range from fines to caning and even capital punishment. Since the 20th century, criminal laws against adultery have become controversial, with most Western countries repealing them.

Sexual consent plays an important role in laws regarding rape, sexual assault and other forms of sexual violence. In a court of law, whether or not the alleged victim had freely given consent, and whether or not they were deemed to be capable of giving consent, can determine whether the alleged perpetrator is guilty of rape, sexual assault or some other form of sexual misconduct.

References

  1. 1 2 Gabel, Barbara (24 January 2025). "Le "devoir conjugal", une notion archaïque du Code civil français invalidé par la CEDH" ['Marital duty', an archaic notion of the French Civil Code invalidated by the ECHR]. France 24 (in French).
  2. ↑ Simon, Rita James (May 2001). A comparative perspective on major social problems. Lexington Books. p. 20. ISBN   978-0-7391-0248-0.
  3. 1 2 3 4 5 Hagan, Rachel (23 January 2025). "French woman wins ECHR case over refusal of sex in divorce ruling". BBC News . Retrieved 25 January 2025.
  4. ↑ Restrepo, Manuela López (24 January 2025). "French woman who refused sex with husband not to blame for divorce, rights court says". NPR .
  5. 1 2 Brioulet, Cyril (23 January 2025). ""Devoir conjugal" : une femme refuse des rapports sexuels à son mari, la justice prononce un divorce pour faute, la France condamnée" ['Marital duty': a woman refuses sexual relations with her husband, the court grants a divorce for fault, France condemned]. La Dépêche (in French). Retrieved 26 January 2025.
  6. ↑ Uguen, Lola (23 January 2025). "Divorce pour manquement au « devoir conjugal » : pourquoi la condamnation de la France est un tournant" [Divorce for breach of 'marital duty': why France's condemnation is a turning point]. Elle France (in French). Retrieved 26 January 2025.
  7. ↑ Petrequin, Samuel (23 January 2025). "Top European rights court rules woman's refusal to have sex not a fault in divorce case". AP News . Retrieved 25 January 2025.
  8. ↑ "HUDOC - European Court of Human Rights". European Convention on Human Rights (in French).
  9. 1 2 "French woman who stopped having sex with husband wins ruling at European court". Reuters . 23 January 2025. Retrieved 25 January 2025.
  10. ↑ Chrisafis, Angelique (23 January 2025). "Woman who refuses sex is not 'at fault' in divorce in France, court rules". The Guardian . Retrieved 25 January 2025.
This page is based on this Wikipedia article
Text is available under the CC BY-SA 4.0 license; additional terms may apply.
Images, videos and audio are available under their respective licenses.