In December 2020, Jie "Jack" Zhao and former head fencing coach Peter Brand were indicted by a grand jury on accusations of conspiracy and bribery for Zhao's two sons to be accepted at Harvard University. They were accused of exchanging more than $1.5 million in bribes. [1]
However, both brothers were athletic and academic standouts prior to their recruitment and competed at meets throughout their tenure on the team. Additionally, Eric Zhao served as the team captain of Harvard Fencing (chosen by the team via popular vote).
By the jury's unanimous decision, both Jie "Jack" Zhao and Peter Brand were cleared of all charges on December 21, 2022. The jury deliberated for only five hours before returning the not guilty verdicts. [2]
Fencing is an NCAA sport. Top fencers around the nation have the opportunity to be recruited to a college, often slightly or significantly boosting their chances of acceptance with the opportunity to receive a scholarship. Top universities like MIT, Boston College, and The Ohio State University all have both men's and women's NCAA fencing teams.
Maryland businessman Jie "Jack" Zhao and Harvard's former head fencing coach Peter Brand connected for years before Harvard accepted either of Zhao's sons. Over the course of five years, Zhao was accused of paying for Brand's car, part of Brand's son's college tuition at Penn State, the mortgage on Brand's house, Brand's water and sewer bills, and renovations for Brand's new house. [3] In total, Zhao had been accused of spending over $1.5 million in alleged bribes. In 2016, Zhao bought Brand's house for twice as much as its initial value, paying almost $1 million. Zhao never lived in the house and later sold it for $665,000. [1]
However, the defense was able to prove that the entire sum of money in question were loans to Brand that had already been paid back in full with interest to Zhao by 2021.
Zhao and Brand began communicating in 2012 when Brand told co-conspirator Alexandre Ryjik [4] that Jack doesn't need to take him anywhere and his boys don't have to be great fencers, and what Brand needed is a good incentive to recruit the boys. [5] Ryjik was initially labeled as "co-conspirator 1," or "CC1," in the criminal complaint, but eventually, the Boston Globe identified him as a coach for the Virginia Academy of Fencing. Brand later told Ryjik that he simply needed a "good incentive" to recruit Zhao's sons. [3] Zhao's company allegedly bought Ryjik his 40,000-square-foot building and property and gave about $1 million to Ryjik's fencing foundation. [4] According to prosecutors, Zhao spent about $2.4 million because the co-conspirator took $900,000 of Zhao's money, including more than $31,000 of Zhao's sons' college tuition money. [3] Zhao had a plan to donate $1 million to Ryjik, which would then be passed to a charity organization controlled by Brand. Zhao ultimately paid $100,000 to Brand's charity foundation. [6]
The situation was brought to light on April 1, 2019, when "Harvard was made aware of allegations involving Peter Brand." [7] On April 4, 2019, Harvard's Dean of the Faculty of Arts and Sciences publicly released a statement regarding these allegations, revealing that the admissions process involves a vote of approximately 40 committee members and an interview with the student-athlete. [7]
On July 6, 2019, former athletic director Bob Scalise said in an emailed statement that Harvard had fired Brand due to a violation of their conflict-of-interest policy; [8] "conflict of interest exists when individual commitment to the University may be compromised by personal benefit."
Both Zhao and Brand denied the allegations against them, saying both sons academically and athletically stood out. [6] According to Zhao's attorney, William Weinrub, Zhao did not give anybody money for their acceptance to Harvard. [9] [10]
This case is separate from the infamous Operation Varsity Blues scandal. [11] Zhao and Rick Singer, the driver of the famous scandal, have no connection to one another. Although some people have drawn parallels to the two situations, as both scandals involved parents bribing somebody to get their children into college, [11] there are several differences between the two cases. For example, both of Zhao's sons had high standardized test scores and had a track record of fencing for many years prior to applying to Harvard. Additionally, there was no legal agreement between Zhao and a Harvard University employee which guaranteed that the brothers would be admitted to the university in exchange for financial compensation. [1]
According to court testimony from David L. Evans, a Harvard admissions officer with over 50 years of experience, Brand's athletic designation of the Zhao brothers "made the difference" in their admission. [12] Evans further testified that the brothers' “personal qualities” and extracurricular activities were “nothing special” in comparison to other applicants.
Zhao's older son, Eric, enrolled at Harvard in the fall of 2014. During his time at Harvard, Eric was elected captain of the Harvard fencing team by his peers [13] and was named second-team All-Ivy after helping Harvard win the 2018 Ivy League Championships. [3] Edward, Zhao's younger son, enrolled at Harvard in 2017. [5] Prior to the cancellation of the 2020 fencing season due to the COVID-19 pandemic, Edward posted a 27–24 record during his career on Harvard's fencing team [14]
Eric had already graduated from the university at the time of arrest, while Edward was in his final year of his undergraduate studies. [1] [3] In an interview with Eric, he said he had no knowledge of the donation. [15]
The Harvard Crimson is the nickname of the intercollegiate athletic teams of Harvard College. The school's teams compete in NCAA Division I. As of 2013, there were 42 Division I intercollegiate varsity sports teams for women and men at Harvard, more than at any other NCAA Division I college in the country. Like the other Ivy League colleges, Harvard does not offer athletic scholarships.
Lori Anne Loughlin is an American actress. From 1988 to 1995, she played Rebecca Donaldson Katsopolis on the ABC sitcom Full House, and reprised the role for its Netflix sequel Fuller House (2016–2018). Loughlin is also known for her roles of Jody Travis in The Edge of Night (1980–1983), Debbie Wilson in The CW series 90210 (2008–2012), Jennifer Shannon in the Garage Sale Mystery television film series (2013–2018), and Abigail Stanton in When Calls the Heart (2013–2019). She was a co-creator, producer, and star of the two seasons of The WB series Summerland (2004–2005).
The Yale Bulldogs are the intercollegiate athletic teams that represent Yale University, located in New Haven, Connecticut. The school sponsors 35 varsity sports. The school has won two NCAA national championships in women's fencing, four in men's swimming and diving, 21 in men's golf, one in men's hockey, one in men's lacrosse, and 16 in sailing.
Mossimo was a sportswear and accessories company, founded in 1986 by designer Mossimo Giannulli that was acquired by Iconix Brand Group in 2006. Mossimo specialized in youth and teenage clothing such as shirts, jeans, jackets, socks, underwear, and accessories.
Jorge Salcedo is an American former soccer player and coach. He was the head coach of the UCLA Bruins men's soccer team. He is a retired American soccer defender who played professionally in Mexico and Major League Soccer. He earned three caps with the United States men's national soccer team.
The San Diego Toreros men's basketball team is the men's college basketball program that represents the University of San Diego (USD). The Toreros compete in NCAA Division I as a member of the West Coast Conference (WCC). The team plays its home games at the Jenny Craig Pavilion.
Mossimo Giannulli is an American fashion designer who founded Mossimo, a mid-range clothing company, in 1986; Giannulli sold this company to Iconix Brand Group in 2006, exactly twenty years after it was founded.
The UCLA Bruins men's soccer team is an intercollegiate varsity sports team of the University of California at Los Angeles. The team is a member of the Big Ten Conference of the National Collegiate Athletic Association.
The Harvard Crimson fencing team is the intercollegiate fencing team for Harvard University located in Cambridge, Massachusetts. The team competes in the Ivy League within the NCAA Division I. The university first fielded a team in 1888.
The USC Trojans women's is a US soccer team that represent the University of Southern California in National Collegiate Athletic Association Division I women's soccer. The team competes in the Big Ten Conference. The Trojans won national championships in 2007 and 2016.
Allen Lamont Smith is an American former college basketball coach, who was most recently an assistant coach at the University of Texas at El Paso for the UTEP Miners men's basketball team. He was previously the head coach at his alma mater University of San Diego, which he left in March 2018. Smith resigned from UTEP in March 2019 after the University of San Diego revealed that Smith was accused of accepting a bribe in the 2019 college admissions bribery scandal.
Wei Minzhou is a Chinese politician who served as Chinese Communist Party Committee Secretary of Xi'an between 2012 and 2016.
Louis Marino Palatella is a former American football player who played for San Francisco 49ers of the National Football League (NFL).
Yanni Hufnagel is an American entrepreneur, former college basketball coach, and the founder and CEO of Atlanta-based The Lemon Perfect Company, maker of the enhanced water brand Lemon Perfect. Before starting Lemon Perfect, he served as an assistant coach of the Nevada Wolf Pack men's basketball team under Eric Musselman.
The 2017–18 NCAA Division I men's basketball corruption scandal was a corruption scandal, initially involving sportswear manufacturer Adidas as well as several college basketball programs associated with the brand but now involving many programs not affiliated with Adidas.
Andrew E. Lelling is an American attorney who served as the United States Attorney for the District of Massachusetts from 2017 to 2021. He is best known for leading Operation Varsity Blues, the federal investigation and prosecution of a massive nationwide college admissions scandal, He also oversaw the largest-ever prosecution of MS-13, which all but eliminated the notorious Salvadoran gang in the Boston area and the prosecution of six eBay employees involved in the eBay stalking scandal which involved the terrorizing of a middle-aged couple living in greater Boston, Massachusetts. His tenure was also marked by major gang and healthcare enforcement actions. Lelling, however, was also criticized by some as being "overzealous, grandstanding, and politically motivated" for his prosecution of a local trial judge who helped an undocumented immigrant charged with drug crimes avoid arrest by immigration authorities.
Operation Varsity Blues was the code name for the investigation into the 2019 criminal conspiracy scandal to influence undergraduate admissions decisions at several top American universities.
David Sidoo is a Canadian stock promoter, businessman, philanthropist, and former Canadian football player. Sidoo played for the University of British Columbia Thunderbirds, and is an inductee in the UBC Sports Hall of Fame and the BC Football Hall of Fame. David Sidoo was inducted into the University of British Columbia (UBC) Football Frank Gnup Wall of Honour in the athlete category in 2019. The Wall of Honour recognizes the outstanding contributions and achievements of UBC Football players, coaches, and builders. Sidoo, a former UBC Thunderbirds defensive back, was also named one of the UBC Football Top 100 Players of All-Time.
Douglas M. Hodge is an American businessman. He is the former CEO of Pacific Investment Management Company (PIMCO), the world's largest bond manager. He pleaded guilty in October 2019 to the felony of conspiring to commit fraud and money laundering. In February 2020 he was sentenced to nine months in federal prison, and to pay a $750,000 fine and serve 500 hours of community service, for his participation in the 2019 college admissions bribery scandal.
Jovan Vavic is the former head coach of both the University of Southern California (USC) men's and women's water polo teams. In 2012, he was interim head coach of the United States men's national water polo team. While coaching USC he won the National Coach of the Year award 15 times, and the Mountain Pacific Sports Federation Coach of the Year award 13 times. He was fired by USC in March 2019 in the wake of his indictment in the 2019 college admissions bribery scandal. After his indictment, Vavic was arrested on charges of accepting at least $250,000 in bribes. In April 2022, he was convicted of fraud and bribery. However, the conviction was later overturned and a new trial ordered.