Health Utilities Index

Last updated

The Health Utilities Index (HUI) is a rating scale used to measure general health status and health-related quality of life (HRQoL). HUI questionnaires are designed to map onto two classification systems, HUI-2 and HUI-3, capable of measuring 24,000 and 972,000 unique health states, respectively. HUI classifications measure a range of health domains with examples including sensation, mobility, pain, cognition, ambulation, and emotion. Health utility values are commonly produced using HUI as a component of the quality-adjusted life years (QALY) calculation used in population health and economics. [1]

Contents

Development

Originally developed by McMaster University in Canada, HUI has subsequently evolved and been adapted by Health Utilities Inc. The purpose of developing HUI was to create a standardized classification system using preference-based scoring. [2] HUI was modeled using multi-attribute utility theory to assess a participants overall health-related quality of life. HUI was first used to evaluate HRQoL in very-low birth weight infants and adolescent cancer morbidity and has since been taken by thousands of respondents from hundreds of researchers. [1]

The attribute categories were decided upon after consulting the general public to rank their order of importance. Using Von Neumann-Morganstern utility theorem to measure a participants health status, health state responses for each attribute are converted to a standardized health utility value which is discussed in detail below.[ citation needed ]

HUI-2 and HUI-3 questionnaires are proprietary and available for use from Health Utilities Inc. website. [1] There is a licensing fee to use the questionnaire and generally costs $3,000 for a single research project use. Included in the license is a manual describing how to convert survey responses into attribute levels.[ citation needed ]

Scale classification systems

HUI-2

HUI-2 classification system consists of 7 attributes including sensation, mobility, emotion, cognition, self-care, pain and fertility. Fertility is not currently used in the HUI-2 questionnaire, but was included historically to account for the effects of infertility on health-related quality of life. Participants answering each attribute chooses one of three to five response items. HUI-2 is capable of identifying 24,000 unique health states. A level 1 response indicates no difficulty or interference while the highest level in each of the attributes corresponds to the lowest possible quality of life. The following table shows the number of health state levels for each attribute:[ citation needed ]

SensationMobilityEmotionCognitionSelf-carePainFertility
Number of health state levels4554453

HUI-3

HUI-3 classification system consists of 8 attributes including vision, hearing, speech, ambulation, dexterity, emotion, cognition, and pain. These attributes range from five or six levels of health states for each attribute. HUI-3 is capable of identifying 972,000 unique health states. Consistent with HUI-2, a level 1 response indicates the best possible health state for a given attribute while the highest level indicates the worst possible health state. The following table show the number of health state levels for each attribute:[ citation needed ]

Number of health state levels for each attribute
VisionHearingSpeechAmbulationDexterityEmotionCognitionPain
Number of health state levels66566565

Differences between HUI-2 and HUI-3

The HUI-3 was created to update the HUI-2 response categories after some of the attribute response items were criticized for not having application to the general population studies. For example, the HUI-2 emotion attribute focuses on distress and anxiety while HUI-3 emotion focuses on happiness compared to depression. The HUI-2 pain attribute is primarily concerned with the severity of pain whereas HUI-3 is concerned with frequency and control of pain. Cognition in HUI-2 focuses on learning while HUI-3 focuses on problem-solving ability of participants. In addition, sensation in the HUI-2 was broken down into vision, hearing, and speech for HUI-3 update.

Scoring

A health state identification can be established for each of the possible health states in the HUI-2 and HUI-3. A unique health state is described as a sequence of numbers based on the level selected for each attribute. In HUI-2, perfect health is described as a sequence of seven ones in a row (i.e., 1111111). HUI health state levels are converted to health utilities using either single-attributes and multi-attributes. Each defined health state level are assigned a health utility value and used in the formula described below. The utility values are determined using time-trade-off methods which determine preferences for particular health states.[ citation needed ]

In HUI, utility values range from −0.03 and −0.36 for the HUI-2 and HUI-3, respectively, to 1.00. A health utility value of 1.00 indicates perfect health while a score of 0.00 indicates death. Negative values account for the fact that some health states are identified by the general public as being worse than death. To calculate a health utility score, health states for each response are converted using a look-up table and mathematical formula. Each attribute and level has a corresponding coefficient value to be input into the formula to calculate health utility.[ citation needed ]

HUI-2

The multi-attribute coefficients for converting

Health state levelSensationMobilityEmotionCognitionSelf-carePainFertility
11.001.001.001.001.001.001.00
20.950.970.930.950.970.970.97
30.860.840.810.880.910.850.88
40.610.730.700.650.800.64
50.580.530.38

Each of these coefficients would be entered into the following formula to yield a general health utility:

HUI-3

For single attribute utility scores in HUI-3, a table published on the Health Utilities Inc. website provides the corresponding health utility score. [1] For multi-attribute utility functions, a separate table is used that accounts for an overall health utility based on each of the eight attributes in HUI-3. The following table provides the associated coefficients used in the health utility formula:

Multi-attribute coefficients for each attribute level
Health state levelVisionHearingSpeechAmbulationDexterityEmotionCognitionPain
11.001.001.001.001.001.001.001.00
20.980.950.940.930.950.950.920.96
30.890.890.890.860.880.850.950.90
40.840.800.810.730.760.640.830.77
50.750.740.680.650.650.460.600.55
60.610.610.580.560.42

For each health state, the attribute level selected in the response is entered into the following health utility formula:

Example

A health state for a respondent of the following:

VisionHearingSpeechAmbulationDexterityEmotionCognitionPain
Level12232324

The corresponding coefficients associated with each attribute and level are entered into the above formula as:

The results of the calculation yields an overall health utility of 0.231. This value indicates the respondents overall health status on a standardized scale which can be compared to other utilities.

Current use

Since its development, HUI classification systems have been used extensively in clinical studies. HUI-2 and HUI-3 are used to elicit health status score from respondents which are converted to health utility scores. Health utility scores are then used in clinical trials to assess quality-adjusted life years as a result of clinical interventions. HUI has been studied in disease states across the health spectrum including cancer, stroke, and mental health. [3] [4] Examples of treatments include comparisons between two or more pharmaceuticals, medical devices, and other medical technologies.

Quality-adjusted life years are calculated by multiplying the number of life years gained by the health utility. The adjustment accounts for the changes in health-related quality of life for a given health state as a result of treatment. Common applications include cost-effectiveness analysis and comparative-effectiveness analysis which are types of economic analysis. These type of analyses are used to inform decisions about the amount of value a particular treatment provides relative to other treatments at a population level of health. [5]

To date, HUI classification systems have focused on evaluating population health to make macro-level decisions about health care utilization; however, its use to identify health status of individuals for use in a clinical setting is being considered. [6]

Validity and reliability

Since its introduction in 1991, HUI questionnaires and classification systems have been translated into 35 different languages and have been used by 300 investigators across 20 different countries around the world. [1] Research has demonstrated that HUI provides comparable measures of general health status to the SF-36 and EQ-5D, other well established questionnaires used in this field. [7]

Related Research Articles

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Gini coefficient</span> Measure of inequality in income or wealth distribution

In economics, the Gini coefficient, also known as the Gini index or Gini ratio, is a measure of statistical dispersion intended to represent the income inequality, the wealth inequality or the consumption inequality within a nation or a social group. It was developed by statistician and sociologist Corrado Gini.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Decision tree</span> Decision support tool

A decision tree is a decision support hierarchical model that uses a tree-like model of decisions and their possible consequences, including chance event outcomes, resource costs, and utility. It is one way to display an algorithm that only contains conditional control statements.

Stress management is a wide spectrum of techniques and psychotherapies aimed at controlling a person's level of stress, especially chronic stress, usually for the purpose of improving everyday functioning. Stress produces numerous physical and mental symptoms which vary according to each individual's situational factors. These can include a decline in physical health, such as headaches, chest pain, fatigue, and sleep problems, as well as depression. The process of stress management is named as one of the keys to a happy and successful life in modern society. Life often delivers numerous demands that can be difficult to handle, but stress management provides a number of ways to manage anxiety and maintain overall well-being.

Alexithymia is a neuropsychological phenomenon expressing important difficulties in identifying and describing the experienced emotions by oneself or others. It also involves emotional issues in terms of social attachment and interpersonal relations. There is no scientific agreement whether this neuropsychological phenomenon is a personality trait, a medical symptom or eventually a mental disorder.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Quality-adjusted life year</span> Measure of disease burden

The quality-adjusted life year (QALY) is a generic measure of disease burden, including both the quality and the quantity of life lived. It is used in economic evaluation to assess the value of medical interventions. One QALY equates to one year in perfect health. QALY scores range from 1 to 0 (dead). QALYs can be used to inform health insurance coverage determinations, treatment decisions, to evaluate programs, and to set priorities for future programs.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Beck Depression Inventory</span> 21-question multiple-choice self-report inventory.

The Beck Depression Inventory, created by Aaron T. Beck, is a 21-question multiple-choice self-report inventory, one of the most widely used psychometric tests for measuring the severity of depression. Its development marked a shift among mental health professionals, who had until then, viewed depression from a psychodynamic perspective, instead of it being rooted in the patient's own thoughts.

The Crohn's Disease Activity Index or CDAI is a research tool used to quantify the symptoms of patients with Crohn's disease. This is of useful importance in research studies done on medications used to treat Crohn's disease; most major studies on newer medications use the CDAI in order to define response or remission of disease. As Crohn's disease is a disease with a variety of symptoms that affect quality of life, the quantification of symptoms may be of secondary importance to a quantitative assessment of the effect on quality of life. This has been addressed by the Inflammatory Bowel Disease Questionnaire (IBDQ) and other indices of quality of life for patients with Crohn's disease.

A patient-reported outcome (PRO) is a health outcome directly reported by the patient who experienced it. It stands in contrast to an outcome reported by someone else, such as a physician-reported outcome, a nurse-reported outcome, and so on. PRO methods, such as questionnaires, are used in clinical trials or other clinical settings, to help better understand a treatment's efficacy or effectiveness. The use of digitized PROs, or electronic patient-reported outcomes (ePROs), is on the rise in today's health research setting.

Mixed logit is a fully general statistical model for examining discrete choices. It overcomes three important limitations of the standard logit model by allowing for random taste variation across choosers, unrestricted substitution patterns across choices, and correlation in unobserved factors over time. Mixed logit can choose any distribution for the random coefficients, unlike probit which is limited to the normal distribution. It is called "mixed logit" because the choice probability is a mixture of logits, with as the mixing distribution. It has been shown that a mixed logit model can approximate to any degree of accuracy any true random utility model of discrete choice, given appropriate specification of variables and the coefficient distribution.

Positive affectivity (PA) is a human characteristic that describes how much people experience positive affects ; and as a consequence how they interact with others and with their surroundings.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Quality of life (healthcare)</span> Notion in healthcare

In general, quality of life is the perceived quality of an individual's daily life, that is, an assessment of their well-being or lack thereof. This includes all emotional, social and physical aspects of the individual's life. In health care, health-related quality of life (HRQoL) is an assessment of how the individual's well-being may be affected over time by a disease, disability or disorder.

In statistics, the phi coefficient is a measure of association for two binary variables. In machine learning, it is known as the Matthews correlation coefficient (MCC) and used as a measure of the quality of binary (two-class) classifications, introduced by biochemist Brian W. Matthews in 1975. Introduced by Karl Pearson, and also known as the Yule phi coefficient from its introduction by Udny Yule in 1912 this measure is similar to the Pearson correlation coefficient in its interpretation. In fact, a Pearson correlation coefficient estimated for two binary variables will return the phi coefficient. Two binary variables are considered positively associated if most of the data falls along the diagonal cells. In contrast, two binary variables are considered negatively associated if most of the data falls off the diagonal. If we have a 2×2 table for two random variables x and y

The Diabetes Health Profile (DHP) is a diabetes-specific patient reported outcome measure (PROM) developed to evaluate the health-related quality of life (HRQoL) of people living with Type 1 and Type 2 diabetes aged 16 years and older. It has been used in community surveys, research studies, clinical trials, and educational interventions both in Europe and completed globally by more than 10,000 patients. The DHP was the diabetes-specific PROM selected by the UK Department of Health for their Long Terms Conditions PROM Pilot Study being carried out by Oxford University.

Humor styles are a subject of research in the field of personality psychology that focuses on the ways in which individuals differ in their use of humor. People of all ages and cultures respond to humor, but their use of it can vary greatly. There are multiple factors, such as culture, age, and political orientation, that play a role in determining what people find humorous. Although humor styles can be somewhat variable depending on social context, they tend to be a relatively stable personality characteristic among individuals. Humor can play an instrumental role in the formation of social bonds, enabling people to relate to peers or to attract a mate, and can help to release tension during periods of stress. There is a lack of current, reliable research that explores the impact of humor usages on others because it is difficult to distinguish a healthy humor usage from one that is unhealthy. Justifications for harmful versus benign humor styles are subjective and lead to varying definitions of either usage.

The Rheumatoid Arthritis Quality of Life Questionnaire (RAQoL) is a disease-specific patient-reported outcome measure which determines the effect rheumatoid arthritis has on a patient’s quality of life. The RAQoL has 30 items with a yes and no response format and takes about six minutes to complete.

The Quality of Life In Depression Scale (QLDS), originally proposed by Sonja Hunt and Stephen McKenna, is a disease specific patient-reported outcome which assesses the impact that depression has on a patient's quality of life. It is the most commonly used measure of quality of life in clinical trials and studies of depression. The QLDS was developed as a measure to be used in future clinical trials of anti-depressant therapy.

The Quality of Well-Being Scale (QWB) is a general health quality of life questionnaire which measures overall status and well-being over the previous three days in four areas: physical activities, social activities, mobility, and symptom/problem complexes.

EQ-5D is a standardised measure of health-related quality of life developed by the EuroQol Group to provide a simple, generic questionnaire for use in clinical and economic appraisal and population health surveys. EQ-5D assesses health status in terms of five dimensions of health and is considered a ‘generic’ questionnaire because these dimensions are not specific to any one patient group or health condition. EQ-5D can also be referred to as a patient-reported outcome (PRO) measure, because patients can complete the questionnaire themselves to provide information about their current health status and how this changes over time. ‘EQ-5D’ is not an abbreviation and is the correct term to use when referring to the instrument in general.

The 9-question Patient Health Questionnaire (PHQ-9) is a diagnostic tool introduced in 2001 to screen adult patients in a primary care setting for the presence and severity of depression. It rates depression based on the self-administered Patient Health Questionnaire (PHQ). The PHQ is part of Pfizer's larger suite of trademarked products, called the Primary Care Evaluation of Mental Disorders (PRIME-MD). The PHQ-9 takes less than 3 minutes to complete and simply scores each of the 9 DSM-IV criteria for depression based on the mood module from the original PRIME-MD. Primary care providers frequently use the PHQ-9 to screen for depression in patients.

References

  1. 1 2 3 4 5 "Health Utilities Inc. "Leaders in Health-Related Quality of Life Research"". www.healthutilities.com. Retrieved 2016-03-20.
  2. Horsman, John; Furlong, William; Feeny, David; Torrance, George (2003-10-16). "The Health Utilities Index (HUI®): concepts, measurement properties and applications". Health and Quality of Life Outcomes. 1: 54. doi:10.1186/1477-7525-1-54. ISSN   1477-7525. PMC   293474 . PMID   14613568.
  3. Grootendorst, Paul; Feeny, David; Furlong, William (March 2000). "Health Utilities Index Mark 3: Evidence of Construct Validity for Stroke and Arthritis in a Population Health Survey". Medical Care. 38 (3): 290–299. doi:10.1097/00005650-200003000-00006. PMID   10718354.
  4. Ramsey, Scott D.; Berry, Kristin; Moinpour, Carol; Giedzinska, Antoinette; Andersen, M. Robyn (2002). "Quality of life in long term survivors of colorectal cancer". The American Journal of Gastroenterology. 97 (5): 1228–1234. doi:10.1111/j.1572-0241.2002.05694.x. PMID   12017152. S2CID   22808052.
  5. "HUI Update". fhs.mcmaster.ca. Retrieved 2016-03-20.
  6. Furlong, William J.; Feeny, David H.; Torrance, George W.; Barr, Ronald D. (2001-01-01). "The Health Utilities Index (HUI®) System for Assessing Health-Related Quality of Life in Clinical Studies". Hamilton, Canada: Centre for Health Economics and Policy Analysis (CHEPA), McMaster University.{{cite journal}}: Cite journal requires |journal= (help)
  7. Raat, Hein; Bonsel, Gouke J.; Essink-Bot, Marie-Louise; Landgraf, Jeanne M.; Gemke, Reinoud J. B. J. (2002). "Reliability and validity of comprehensive health status measures in children". Journal of Clinical Epidemiology. 55 (1): 67–76. doi:10.1016/s0895-4356(01)00411-5. PMID   11781124.