Her Secret Is Patience

Last updated
Her Secret Is Patience
Her Secret Is Patience Phoenix Sculpture.jpg
Artist Janet Echelman
Year2009;15 years ago (2009)
TypeHigh-tenacity Polyester
Location Phoenix Civic Space Park, Phoenix, Arizona, United States

Her Secret Is Patience is a public art sculpture commission designed by artist Janet Echelman for the city of Phoenix. Its creation was the result of collaboration between the artist and a team of award-winning engineers, architects, planners, and fabricators. It is located downtown in the Civic Space Park across from the Walter Cronkite School of Journalism at Arizona State University. The sculpture consists of painted, galvanized steel; polyester twine netting; and colored lights. The piece cost $2.5 million. [1] [2] The title of the piece is a quote from Ralph Waldo Emerson and during construction it was unofficially titled Sky Bloom. [3]

Contents

Design

Her Secret Is Patience net wind simulation PhoenixWindResults 1pg.jpg
Her Secret Is Patience net wind simulation

The netting is 38 ft off the ground and 100 ft. tall and the three support poles are 102 ft, 125 ft. and 145 ft. tall. [4] The netting is designed to show the movements of the wind. Its shape reflects Arizona's enormous cumulus clouds. At night, the colors gradually change with the seasons adding cool hues in the summer and warm hues in the winter. [5]

The initial design process began with the creation of a three-dimensional computer model created using custom software. Those forms were then translated into CAD software in order to define the geometry and surfaces of the sculpture. These digital structures were then exported to a gravity and wind simulator in order to determine the necessary twine tenacity to withstand the desert winds. From this information, construction drawings were created which include specific looming patterns, color information, and lengths of meshes.

Fabrication

The fabrication process involved several North American factories specializing in hand-craftsmanship. There are several layers of nets in the sculpture. The main body of colored net including the "wormhole" at the center, a structural net, which helps give the primary net its shape, and a cover net. [6] The edge of every mesh is a different length, requiring the use of manual splicing on each joint. The two shortest steel support towers were shipped to the site complete; the third tower was shipped in halves, which were assembled and welded on-site. The suspension rings were created by a manufacturer specializing in fabricating roller coaster equipment. The rings hang concentrically 100 ft above the ground and are bound together with 1 in. diameter steel cable. The rings are secured to the base of each support tower with tie-down cables, which provide structural stability against strong winds and minimize ring movement.

The fabrication and engineering of the project was conducted by multiple firms. [5]

Repairs

The netting is required to be repaired roughly every 5 years, with the first repair taking place in December 2014. The existing netting is recycled and replaced with a new net and lighting. [7] This process will need to continue on for the life of the sculpture. The cost of each net and its installation is currently unknown.

Reception

Author Prof. Patrick Frank writes "...most Arizonans look on the work with pride: this unique visual delight will forever mark the city of Phoenix just as the Eiffel Tower marks Paris." [8]

The Arizona Republic editorialized: "This is just what Phoenix need: a distinctive feature that helps create a real sense of place." [9]

Some internet users have likened the sculpture to a jellyfish or a vagina. [10] Others liken it to a floating used condom.

Controversy

Some people have questioned [11] the extremely high ($2.5 Million USD) cost of the project which was undertaken during the "Great Recession" More recently there have been question about the ongoing cost of the project which requires a new net to be constructed roughly every 5 years. [7] The costs of replacing the nets has not been disclosed and this has led to fears of what the true cost of ownership for this project is in the long term. In addition the fact that the project was awarded to an out of state artist and the majority of fabrication and engineering was conducted by out of state firms has created discussions regarding the true positive local economic impact of such an expensive project.

Awards

Best Public Art – Phoenix New Times [12]
2009 Best of Phoenix 2009
Environmental Excellence Award – Valley Forward Association [13]
2009 Art In Public Places
Award for Excellence in Structural Engineering – Structural Engineers Association of Arizona (SEAoA)
2008 M3 Engineering

Related Research Articles

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Santiago Calatrava</span> Spanish engineer and architect

Santiago Calatrava Valls is a Spanish architect, structural engineer, sculptor and painter, particularly known for his bridges supported by single leaning pylons, and his railway stations, stadiums, and museums, whose sculptural forms often resemble living organisms. His best-known works include the Olympic Sports Complex of Athens, the Milwaukee Art Museum, the Turning Torso tower in Malmö, Sweden, the World Trade Center Transportation Hub in New York City, the Auditorio de Tenerife in Santa Cruz de Tenerife, the Margaret Hunt Hill Bridge in Dallas, Texas, and his largest project, the City of Arts and Sciences and Opera House in his birthplace, Valencia. His architectural firm has offices in New York City, Doha, and Zürich.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Burj Khalifa</span> Skyscraper in Dubai, United Arab Emirates

The Burj Khalifa is a skyscraper in Dubai, United Arab Emirates. It is the world's tallest structure. With a total height of 829.8 m and a roof height of 828 m (2,717 ft), the Burj Khalifa has been the tallest structure and building in the world since its topping out in 2009, surpassing Taipei 101, the previous holder of that status.

<i>B of the Bang</i> 2005–2009 sculpture by Thomas Heatherwick

B of the Bang was a sculpture by Thomas Heatherwick next to the City of Manchester Stadium in Manchester, England, United Kingdom, which was commissioned to mark the 2002 Commonwealth Games; at 56 metres (184 ft) it was one of the tallest structures in Manchester and the tallest sculpture in the UK until the completion of Aspire in 2008. The sculpture took its name from a quotation of British sprinter Linford Christie, in which he said that he started his races not merely at the "bang" of the starting pistol, but at "the B of the Bang".

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Navajo Bridge</span> Bridge pair in Arizona, United States

Navajo Bridge is the name of twin steel spandrel arch bridges that cross the Colorado River in the Grand Canyon National Park in northern Coconino County, Arizona, United States. The newer of the two spans carries vehicular traffic on U.S. Route 89A (US 89A) over Marble Canyon between Bitter Springs and Jacob Lake, allowing travel into a remote Arizona Strip region north of the Colorado River including the North Rim of Grand Canyon National Park.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Arizona Canal</span> Canal in Maricopa County, Arizona, United States

The Arizona Canal is a major canal in central Maricopa County that led to the founding of several communities, now among the wealthier neighborhoods of suburban Phoenix, constructed in the late 1880s. Flood irrigation of residential yards is still common in these neighborhoods, using a system of lateral waterways connected via gates to the canal itself. Like most Valley canals, its banks are popular with joggers and bicyclists.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Mike O'Callaghan–Pat Tillman Memorial Bridge</span> Arch bridge over the Colorado River near Hoover Dam

The Mike O'Callaghan–Pat Tillman Memorial Bridge is an arch bridge in the United States that spans the Colorado River between the states of Arizona and Nevada. The bridge is located within the Lake Mead National Recreation Area approximately 30 miles (48 km) southeast of Las Vegas, and carries Interstate 11 and U.S. Route 93 over the Colorado River. Opened in 2010, it was the key component of the Hoover Dam Bypass project, which rerouted US 93 from its previous routing along the top of Hoover Dam and removed several hairpin turns and blind curves from the route. It is jointly named for Mike O'Callaghan, Governor of Nevada from 1971 to 1979, and Pat Tillman, an American football player who left his career with the Arizona Cardinals to enlist in the United States Army and was killed in Afghanistan in 2004 by friendly fire.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Radio masts and towers</span> Tall structure designed to support antennas

Radio masts and towers are typically tall structures designed to support antennas for telecommunications and broadcasting, including television. There are two main types: guyed and self-supporting structures. They are among the tallest human-made structures. Masts are often named after the broadcasting organizations that originally built them or currently use them.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Stonecutters Bridge</span> Bridge in Hong Kong

Stonecutters Bridge is a high level cable-stayed bridge spanning the Rambler Channel in Hong Kong, connecting Nam Wan Kok, Tsing Yi to Stonecutters Island. The bridge deck was completed on 7 April 2009, and opened to traffic on 20 December that year. The bridge was the second-longest cable-stayed span in the world at the time of its completion.

<i>Quantum Cloud</i> Sculpture by Antony Gormley

The Quantum Cloud is a contemporary sculpture, designed by Antony Gormley, located next to The O2 in London. The sculpture was commissioned for the site and was completed in 1999.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Richmond Olympic Oval</span>

The Richmond Olympic Oval is an indoor multi-sports arena in the Canadian city of Richmond, British Columbia. The oval was built for the 2010 Winter Olympics and was originally configured with a speed skating rink. The venue has since been reconfigured and now serves as a community multi-sport park and includes two ice hockey rinks, two running tracks, a climbing wall, a rowing tank and a flexible area which can be used for, among other sports, basketball, volleyball, indoor soccer and table tennis.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Janet Echelman</span> American sculptor and artist

Janet Echelman is an American sculptor and fiber artist. Her sculptures have been displayed as public art, often as site-specific installations.

<i>Singing Ringing Tree, Burnley</i> Sound sculpture in Lancashire, England

The Singing Ringing Tree is a wind powered sound sculpture resembling a tree set in the landscape of the Pennine hill range overlooking Burnley, in Lancashire, England.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Construction of Assembly Hall (Champaign)</span>

The construction of State Farm Center, originally known as the Assembly Hall, at the University of Illinois at Urbana–Champaign consisted of building a huge indoor arena with a 400-foot-diameter (120 m) concrete dome whose center height is 125 feet (38 m) above the center floor, and which weighs 10 million pounds. The building is considered an engineering marvel because of the unique method used to build the concrete roof. State Farm Center, the first-ever concrete dome arena, hosts the campus's teams in men's and women's basketball, numerous concerts and other events. It holds sentimental value for numerous alumni and fans alike and attracts attention for its design and construction. The construction of the Assembly Hall was conceived to provide UIUC with needed space for ceremonies and athletic events. The university’s population had outgrown the largest building on campus at that time, the Auditorium, and desired one building that could hold the entire university class. The design of the new building, by Max Abramovitz, called for the construction of one of the world’s largest edge-supported structure. The assembly hall was completed in 1963, and was dedicated on Honors Day, Friday May 3.

<i>Water Sky Garden</i> Sculpture in Vancouver

Water Sky Garden is a sculptural environment designed by artist Janet Echelman. The garden is located outside the Richmond Olympic Oval, an official venue for the 2010 Vancouver Olympic Games. The installation consists of a wetland treatment pond, 300 ft. boardwalk, two 52 ft. pedestrian bridges, two net sculptures, and a fountain.

<i>She Changes</i> Sculpture by Janet Echelman

She Changes, known locally as anémona, is a sculpture designed by artist Janet Echelman for the cities of Porto and Matosinhos, Northern Portugal. The installation consists of three steel poles, cables, a 20-ton steel ring and a net structure of varying densities and colors. The sculpture is Echelman's first permanent public art installation.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Phoenix Civic Space Park</span> Urban park in Phoenix, Arizona

Civic Space Park is an urban park in Downtown Phoenix, Arizona which first opened to the public in April 2009. It is located directly across Central Avenue from the main part of the ASU Downtown Campus. It is also located north of the Central Station Valley Metro Rail and bus transfer stations.

ArcelorMittal <i>Orbit</i> Sculpture and observation tower in London, England

The ArcelorMittal Orbit is a 114.5-metre (376-foot) sculpture and observation tower in Queen Elizabeth Olympic Park in Stratford, London. It is Britain's largest piece of public art, and is intended to be a permanent lasting legacy of London's hosting of the 2012 Summer Olympic and Paralympic Games, assisting in the post-Olympics regeneration of the Stratford area. Sited between London Stadium and the Aquatics Centre, it allows visitors to view the whole Olympic Park from two observation platforms.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">NASA wind turbines</span>

Starting in 1975, NASA managed a program for the United States Department of Energy and the United States Department of Interior to develop utility-scale wind turbines for electric power, in response to the increase in oil prices. A number of the world's largest wind turbines were developed and tested under this pioneering program. The program was an attempt to leap well beyond the then-current state of the art of wind turbine generators, and developed a number of technologies later adopted by the wind turbine industry. The development of the commercial industry however was delayed by a significant decrease in competing energy prices during the 1980s.

<i>Every Beating Second</i>

Every Beating Second is a large netted sculpture designed by artist Janet Echelman. The sculpture is located in Terminal 2 of the San Francisco International Airport, which opened in April 2011. The piece is composed of three separate netted structures, each connected to a skylight, hanging from the ceiling of the terminal.

<i>Halo</i> (sculpture) Kinetic sculpture in Sydney, Australia

Halo is a wind powered kinetic sculpture in Sydney, Australia. Located at Central Park, the artwork is part of a major mixed-use urban renewal project to redevelop the old Kent Brewery site in Broadway.

References

  1. Price, Michelle (14 April 2009). "Floating sculpture key to downtown's rebirth". Arizona Republic. Gannett. Cronkite News Service. Retrieved 31 March 2017.
  2. "Scaling Public Space: Janet Echelman". Sculpture Magazine. Retrieved 2010-02-15.
  3. Sexton, Connie Cone (13 February 2009). "Sculpture gets a name, and it's not 'jellyfish'". Arizona Republic. Gannett. Retrieved 31 March 2017.
  4. "Her Secret Is Patience". Janet Echelman, Inc. Archived from the original on 2013-03-01. Retrieved 2010-02-15.
  5. 1 2 "Her Secret is Patience, Phoenix, AZ, 2009". Janet Echelman. Retrieved Apr 1, 2020.
  6. Her Secret Is Patience Fact Sheet [ permanent dead link ] Janet Echelman's website
  7. 1 2 Sieg, Stina (1 December 2014). "Downtown Phoenix Sculpture Gets Revamped". KJZZ. Retrieved 31 March 2017.
  8. Frank, Patrick (2011). Prebles' ARTFORMS. Prentice Hall. ISBN   0-205-79753-9.
  9. "Park's details, sculpture a nod to city's future". Arizona Republic. 20 April 2009. Retrieved 31 March 2017.
  10. "Nicknames for the new sculpture downtown". Yelp. 19 March 2009. Retrieved 1 April 2017.
  11. Plato, Gayle (25 April 2009). "Her Secret is Patience: Our Costs are Rising out of the Ashes". Sonoran Alliance. Archived from the original on 2017-04-01.
  12. "Phoenix Best Public Art". Phoenix New Times. Retrieved 2010-01-15.
  13. "Janet Echelman CV" (PDF). Janet Echelman, Inc. Archived from the original (PDF) on 2010-07-13. Retrieved 2010-02-18.

33°27′12″N112°4′28″W / 33.45333°N 112.07444°W / 33.45333; -112.07444