It's a Cry'n Shame

Last updated
"It's a Cry'n Shame"
Single by The Gentlemen
A-side "You Can't Be True"
Released1966
Recorded1966
Genre Garage rock
Length2:32
Label Vandan
Songwriter(s) Seab Meador, Mike Kelley
Producer(s) Tom Brown

"It's a Cry'n Shame" is a song written by Seab Meador and Mike Kelley and was recorded in 1966 by the Gentlemen, an American garage rock band from Dallas, Texas who were active between 1964 and 1968. It was originally released as the B-side to "You Can't Be True" but has become by far the better-known song. "It's a Cry'n Shame" has been included in several garage rock compilations and is now recognized as one of the greatest songs in the genre.

Contents

History

Background

'"It's a Cry'n Shame" was recorded in 1966 by the Gentlemen a garage rock band from Oak Cliff, a section of Dallas, Texas, who were active from 1964 to 1968. [1] [2] The song was written by Seab Meador and Mike Kelley, who were both guitarists and vocalists in the band. [1] [3] The song heavily drenched in fuzz-treated guitar effects reflects the band's direction which was guided by Seab Meador, whose tastes gravitated towards the harder-rocking and more blues-based English bands such as the Rolling Stones, the Animals, the Kinks, and particularly the Yardbirds, who whose lead guitarist of the time, Jeff Beck, was a key influence on his own playing. [1] [3] The songs' lyrics deal with sadness and heartbreak and are sung with an impassioned vocal by Kelly backed by a frantic and intense performance from the band highlighted by Meador's guitar leads. [3]

In 1965 the band went to Sumet Recording studio and recorded an unreleased acetate of two songs, "Beg, Borrow of Steal" and "Here I Cannot Stay." [4] [5] [6] The Gentlemen also cut a demo acetate of "It's a Cry'n Shame," which would be re-recorded the following year for official release. [7] This unit (with and without Jimmy Randall) played throughout 1965. [3] Towards the end of the year fellow Oak Cliff musician Jimmie Vaughan, later of the Fabulous Thunderbirds, did a several month stint with the group. [3] In early 1966, the roster that most consider the definitive lineup of the group and that recorded the officially released version of "It's a Cry'n Shame," included Seab Meador on lead guitar and vocals, Mike Kelley on guitar and vocals, Tim Justice on drums, as well as new members Bruce Bland on bass and Tommy Turner on keyboards. [1] [3] This incarnation solidified into a driving rock band that was a popular live act. [1] They played venues such as Louann’s Club and The Studio Club in Dallas and Panther A’Go-Go and The Box in Ft. Worth. [1] [3] Later that year, The Gentlemen opened for James Brown at the Dallas Convention Center. [1] [3] The Gentlemen also opened for Mitch Ryder and The Detroit Wheels and The Beau Brummels at Louann’s in 1966. [1] [3]

Recording and release

Tom Brown, president of Vandan Records heard the Gentlemen play at LouAnn’s Club in Dallas, and wondered if the band could do some writing with him and Gene Garretson, his arranger. After several weeks, the band came up with two songs, "You Can’t Be True," a ballad and the hard-rocking fuzz-drenched "It’s a Cry’n Shame." [1] [3] [4] [2] The gentler "You Can’t Be True," was chosen to be the A-side and a considerable amount of time and expense was lavished on it. [3] [1] [2] Whereas "It’s a Cry’n Shame" was recorded quickly, with Mike Kelley on vocals, only requiring a couple of takes. [1] [5] [2] According to Justice:

We liked "Cry’n Shame" better, but Gene spent a lot of time arranging violins and multiple tracks for ‘You Can’t Be True’ so that was the track they pushed. It took us nearly two weeks to record ‘You Can’t Be True’, and as a complete after-thought, 2 takes and probably 1 hour to slam down ‘It’s a Cry’n Shame’. Therein lies the genuine spontaneity that makes it pure straight ahead punk rock, I suppose. ...Seab Meador had a gaping hole in the center of his Vox Super Beatle so that he could stick his guitar neck inside to get the Fuzz tone that is prevalent on "Cry’n Shame." [3]

Tom Brown had or two thousand copies pressed and sent them to several deejays her knew in places such as Detroit, Philadelphia, and Boston. [1] A few weeks later Brown showed the band members a copy of the January 1967 edition of Record World Magazine, which included the B-side song "It's a Cry'n Shame" alongside "Somebody to Love" by Jefferson Airplane, in its Four-Star Rating column of hits to watch. [1] [3] The song received airplay on KLIF and KNOK radio stations in Dallas, upping the band's local profile considerably. [1] The Gentlemen played a “go-go” show on the bill with several other bands at a large auditorium in south Dallas. The promoters had to provide police protection for the band, who were greeted by a queue of screaming girls begging for autographs. According to Justice: "...we were very happy, as this was about as close to "That 60's British Rock Star Magic" as a bunch of 16-year old kids from Dallas would ever get." [1] [3]

Subsequent events

However, the expense pressing all of the records, as well as recording the intended A-side left Vandan Records owner Tom Brown out of money. According to Justice: "Shortly after he showed up with the magazine, we showed up at his home to find a for sale sign and no furniture. We would find our later that he was down to his last cash and skipped town to avoid creditors. We never saw him again, but read that he moved to Los Angeles to start over. He died there not long after." [3]

In 1967, Seab Meador left The Gentlemen, and did stints in Dallas bands such as the Bridge. [1] [3] The Gentlemen disbanded in early 1968. [1] [3] Seab Meador and the Gentlemen's original bass player Jimmie Randal went on to form bands such as the Hurricanes, a Houston-based band, and later the Werewolves in the late 1970s, were managed and produced by former Rolling Stones Svengali, Andrew Loog Oldham, who cut two albums for RCA records. [8] [3] [9] On January 24, 1980, Seab Meador died of a brain tumour. [10] According to Randall: "Seab was a great friend I was at the hospital the night before he died. He taught me a lot. I miss him still." [3] [7]

Legacy

"It’s a Cry’n Shame," is often mentioned as one of the greatest songs in garage rock. [1] It has been referred to by the G45 Legends listings as “One of the top 10 tracks to play to anyone you need to convert to ‘60s-garageism." [1] In Mike Markesich's Teenbeat Mayhem, based on the balloting of a panel of noted writers and garage rock experts, the song is rated as a ten out of ten, and in the section listing the 1000 greatest garage rock recordings, is ranked #2, second only to the 13th Floor Elevators' "You're Gonna Miss Me." [11] "It's a Cry’n Shame," has appeared on several compilations such as Pebbles, Volume 5 , Essential Pebbles, Volume 1, and Fort Worth Teen Scene! Volume 3. [1] [2] [7] The demo acetate version is included on the Back From the Grave Vol. 9 compilation. The song has been featured on Little Steven’s Underground Garage and on Sirius Satellite Radio and on Bill Kelly’s Black Hole of Rock and Roll on New York’s WFMU. [1] [3]

Personnel

Discography

Related Research Articles

Garage rock is a raw and energetic style of rock and roll that flourished in the mid-1960s, most notably in the United States and Canada, and has experienced a series of subsequent revivals. The style is characterized by basic chord structures played on electric guitars and other instruments, sometimes distorted through a fuzzbox, as well as often unsophisticated and occasionally aggressive lyrics and delivery. Its name derives from the perception that groups were often made up of young amateurs who rehearsed in the family garage, although many were professional.

The Grodes Former American garage rock band

The Grodes, sometimes known as The Tongues of Truth, were an American garage rock band from Tucson, Arizona, that featured lead singer and songwriter Manny Freiser, and were active between 1965 and 1968. They are best remembered for two Manny Freiser written songs, the original version of “Let’s Talk about Girls" and Cry A Little Longer, recorded by The Grodes, the #46 single on the All-Time Garage Rock singles chart.

The Savages (Bermuda band)

The Savages were a garage rock band from Bermuda that were active in the mid-1960s. They are best remembered for their album, Live 'n Wild, which was composed largely of self-penned tunes and recorded in front of a live audience, has been mentioned as a seminal work in the genre, and features the song, "The World Ain't Round It's Square". This song has become regarded as a classic 1960s anthem of youthful defiance.

<i>Live n Wild</i> 1966 live album by The Savages

Live 'N Wild is a live album released in 1966 by The Savages, a garage rock band from Bermuda, which was recorded live at the Hub, a nightclub at the Princess Hotel in their native country. Consisting of mostly self-composed songs, the album is considered a seminal work in the garage rock genre, and features the song, "The World Ain't Round It's Square," which has come to be regarded as a classic '60s anthem of youthful defiance.

The Shames were a garage rock band from Ipswich, Massachusetts who were active in the mid-1960s. They are known amongst collectors for two songs which are highly regarded: "Special Ones" and especially "My World is Upside Down," which has been mentioned as a classic in the genre.

The Gentlemen (Dallas band) American garage rock band

The Gentlemen were an American garage rock band from Dallas, Texas, who were active from 1964 to 1968. They are best known for their 1966 song, "It's a Cry'n Shame", which has been recognized as one of the greatest songs in garage rock. The band is noted for the contributions of guitarist and songwriter, Seab Meador. Jimmie Vaughan, later a member the Fabulous Thunderbirds and brother of Stevie Ray Vaughan, served a brief stint for several months in the Gentlemen in late 1965 and early 1966, but did not appear on any of their recordings. He went on to play in another Dallas garage rock band, the Chessmen.

The World Aint Round Its Square

"The World Ain't Round It's Square" is a song recorded in 1966 by The Savages, a garage rock band from Bermuda and was written by Howie Rego and Bobby Zuill. It was recorded live at the Hub, a nightclub at the Princess Hotel in Bermuda and appeared on their live album taped from the event, Live 'n Wild. The song has been mentioned as a landmark anthem of 1960s youthful defiance and is ranked #4 in the list of the 1000 greatest garage rock records in Mike Markesich's Teenbeat Mayhem. It has been featured on the Teenage Shutdown! The World Ain't Round, It's Square! compilation as well as included the reissue of Live 'n Wild.

The Liberty Bell (band) American rock band

The Liberty Bell was an American garage rock/psychedelic rock band from Corpus Christi, Texas who were active in the 1960s. They specialized in a blues-based brand of proto-punk influenced by British groups such as the Yardbirds. The band failed to reach wider audience in the time, but have come to the attention of garage rock collectors and enthusiasts in the intervening years since their breakup, with their work appearing on several compilations.

<i>Back from the Grave, Volume 9</i>

Back from the Grave, Volume 9, released on LP in 2015, is the ninth installment in the Back from the Grave series of garage rock compilations. Like all the entries in the series it was assembled by Tim Warren of Crypt Records. As indicated in the subheading which reads "Raw Blastin' Mid 60s Punk," this collection consists of many songs which display the rawer and more aggressive side of the genre and are often characterized by the use of fuzztone-distorted guitars and rough vocals. In typical fashion, the set generally excludes psychedelic, folk rock, and pop-influenced material in favor of basic primitive rock and roll.

The Shy Guys were an American garage rock band from Oak Park, Michigan who were active in the 1960s. They are known for songs such as "We Gotta Go," which became a hit in Detroit and the southern Michigan area, and also in the Buffalo, New York region.

The Penthouse 5 were an American garage rock band from Oak Cliff, Texas, a suburb of Dallas and were active from 1964-1967. The band's style was highly influenced by popular British act, such as of the Beatles and the Kinks, as well as the folk rock of the Byrds. In 1967 they shortened their name to the Penthouse and also began to play occasional gigs with a horn section as a soul outfit under the name of Dr. William’s Soul Emporium.

Sir Winston and the Commons American garage-rock band, formed 1963

Sir Winston and the Commons were an American garage rock band formed in Indianapolis, Indiana, in 1963. The group released two highly regarded singles, which, upon release, earned the band a regional following, and resulted in reinterest in their music over the years. At the height of their popularity, Sir Winston and the Commons were regulars at the teen dance club the Cellar, in Chicago.

The Novas American garage rock band

Novas were an American garage rock band from Dallas/Fort Worth, Texas, who were active in the 1960s. Noted for their harmonies, they became one of the most popular bands in the local area and toured throughout the Texas, Oklahoma, and Louisiana region, enjoying a following outside of their immediate vicinity. The group released a single featuring the song "William Junior" in 1966. In the intervening years since their breakup, the Novas' music has come to the attention of garage rock collectors and enthusiasts and their collected work is included on two anthologies.

Lawson and Four More

Lawson and Four More were an American garage rock/psychedelic rock band from Memphis, Tennessee, who were active in the 1960s. The group was led by Bobby Lawson and was known for their hard, blues-based sound which, as they evolved, increasingly incorporated esoteric psychedelic elements. The group regularly worked with musician, songwriter, and producer Jim Dickinson and cut the first rock release for Memphis label, Ardent Records. As a side-project, they briefly recorded under the name The Avengers, as a Batman-themed takeoff group in 1966.

The Dagenites American garage rock band

The Dagenites were an American garage rock a band from Oxon Hill, Maryland near Washington, DC, who were active in the 1960s. They shared management and frequent billing with noted guitarist and performer Link Wray. In recent years their work has become highly regarded amongst garage rock enthusiasts and collectors and has been included on several compilations. The Dagenites are especially known for their proto-punk anthems, "I Don't Want to Try it Again" and "I'm Gone Slide", both of which have been mentioned as garage rock classics.

The Kings Ransom American garage rock band from Allentown, Pennsylvania

The Kings Ransom were an American garage rock band from Allentown, Pennsylvania who were active from 1965-1968 and were a popular act in the Lehigh Valley area, as well as around Philadelphia. Their record "Shame" became a hit in Milton, Pennsylvania and received airplay in Michigan. In the intervening years the Kings Ransom's music has come to the attention of garage rock enthusiasts with the release of several of their songs on compilations such as Allentown Anglophile and Teenage Shutdown! Teen Jangler Blowout!

The Humans (New York band)

The Humans were an American garage rock band from Albion, New York who were active in the 1960s. They were popular in the region, touring throughout the Northeast, and enjoyed a regional hit, with the single "Take a Taxi" b/w "Warning", that received airplay in other markets around the country. "Warning" has become especially valued amongst garage rock enthusiasts and was included on the Back from the Grave compilation series.

The Chessmen American garage rock band

The Chessmen were an American garage rock band from Denton, Texas, near Dallas, who were active since the 1960s till date. They were one of the most popular bands in the region and recorded for Bismark Records, where they recorded three singles including, "I Need You There", which is now considered a garage rock classic. The band is notable for including several members who went on to greater fame. Jimmie Vaughan, brother of Stevie Ray Vaughan was briefly a member, joining after the death of original band leader, guitarist, and vocalist, Robert Patton, who died in a boating accident in 1966. Drummer Doyle Bramhall later played with and wrote songs for Stevie Ray Vaughan, and Bill Etheridge later played bass with ZZ Top. Following the breakup of the Chessmen, several of their members, including Jimmie Vaughan, went on to form a group that would come to be known as Texas Storm, which eventually included Stevie Ray Vaughan on bass, in 2010 Ejim Chukwudiebube Daniel started it up and the group it's active till date, head office is now located in Abuja Nigeria.

Danny and the Counts were an American garage rock band from El Paso, Texas, who were active in the 1960s. They were one of the most popular bands in the thriving Latino rock scene in El Paso. They had a local hit with their 1965 R&B-flavored debut single, "For Your Love", but afterward switched their approach to reflect British Invasion influence. In 1966 they released a single on Coronado Records featuring the two songs for which they have become best-known, "You Need Love" and "Ode to the Wind". In the intervening years their work has come to be highly regarded by garage rock enthusiasts.

Dean Ellis Kohler is an American rock musician from Portsmouth, Virginia who has been active in various groups and as a solo artist since 1962. That year he formed Dean & the Mustangs, who later changed their name and recorded demos as the Satellites. In 1966 Kohler was drafted into the army as an MP in the Vietnam War. While stationed in Qui Nhơn, he formed the group, the Electrical Banana, who recorded several songs in an army tent, amongst which a version of Lou Reed's "There She Goes Again" and Kohler's original, "She's Gone" were pressed into a limited number of 45RPM records and came to the attention of garage rock enthusiasts. In 1968, when he returned from duty to Portsmouth, he assembled a backing band and recorded the single "Gooseberry Pie". Later in 1968, he formed the band, the Soft Light, who appeared weekly on a local TV show. and by the end of the decade the hard rock group, Mad Wax, who remained active into the 1970s. He chronicled his Vietnam War experiences in Rock 'N' Roll Soldier: A Memoir, published in 2009. Kohler's recordings with the Satellites and the Electrical Banana are included on the compilation, Aliens, Psychos & Wild Things, Volume 1, and "Gooseberry Pie" on Essential Pebbles, Volume 2.

References

  1. 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 Justice, Tim. "Gentlemen". 60s Garage Bands.com. 60s Garage Bands.com. Retrieved August 12, 2015.
  2. 1 2 3 4 5 gilesi, n/a (August 30, 2013). "Classic Singles #56: The Gentlemen – It's a Cry'n Shame / You Can't Be True (1966)". Cosmic Mind at Play. Word Press.com. Retrieved August 14, 2015.
  3. 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 Bishop, Chris (January 7, 2008). "The Gentlemen". Garage Hangover. Garage Hangover. Retrieved August 12, 2015.
  4. 1 2 Markesich, Mike (2012). Teen Beat Mayhem (First ed.). Branford, Connecticut: Priceless Info Press. p.  118. ISBN   978-0-9856482-5-1. - According to Markesich, the recordings for "Beg, Borrow of Steal" and "Here I Cannot Stay" were done by Boyd Rec. Studio. But, more specifically, based on other references and quotes by drummer Tim Justice, the acetates were recorded at Sumet Studio, which was located downstairs in the same building, and then mastered upstairs by Boyd Recording Services. In addition, Justice indicates (see Bishop) that the later songs, "It's a Cry'n' Shame" and "You Can’t Be True," were also recorded at Sumet and mastered at Boyd, then released on Vandan.
  5. 1 2 Bishop, Chris (January 7, 2008). "The Gentlemen". Garage Hangover. Garage Hangover. Retrieved August 12, 2015. - According to drummer Tim Justice: "Jimmie reminds me that these AND the later ‘It’s a Cry’n Shame’ sessions were recorded at Sumet Studio, and the master acetates were made upstairs at Boyd Recording Service. [This first session] cost $150 that we split 4 ways. We just wanted to see what we sounded like and never tried to find a label."
  6. ↑ gilesi, n/a (August 30, 2013). "Classic Singles #56: The Gentlemen – It's a Cry'n Shame / You Can't Be True (1966)". Cosmic Mind at Play. Word Press.com. Retrieved August 14, 2015. - According to drummer Tim Justice: "The Gentlemen didn’t release any more singles, though an acetate does exist of earlier recordings from 1965, ‘Beg, Borrow Or Steal’ and ‘Here I Cannot Stay’."
  7. 1 2 3 Warren, Tim. Back From the Grave Vol. 9 and 10 (CD). Crypt Records serial number 114, rel. 2015 - The demo acetate appears on the Back From the Grave Vol. 9 LP and Vol. 9 and 10 CD, which combines both albums onto one CD.
  8. ↑ Patterson, Rob (May 10, 1979). "Werewolves' elegant waste". 813 College Street Bowling Green, KY: Bowling Green Daily News (bgdailynews.com). Daily News (Bowling Green Kentucky). p. 10-B. Retrieved August 16, 2015.{{cite news}}: CS1 maint: location (link)
  9. ↑ Pebbles Volume 5 (CD). AIP Records CD 5022, rel. 1992 - In liner notes (probably written by Greg Shaw), it mentions that the Werewolves were signed to a major label.
  10. ↑ "The 1980s". The Dead Rock Stars Club. Doc-Rock@TheDeadRockStarsClub.com. Retrieved August 16, 2015.
  11. ↑ Markesich, Mike (2012). Teen Beat Mayhem (First ed.). Branford, Connecticut: Priceless Info Press. p.  118, 387. ISBN   978-0-9856482-5-1.
This page is based on this Wikipedia article
Text is available under the CC BY-SA 4.0 license; additional terms may apply.
Images, videos and audio are available under their respective licenses.