| Year | Seed | Round | Opponent | Result |
|---|
| 1982 | #5 | First Round | #28 Kearney State | L 87–92 |
| 1985 | #17 | First Round
Second Round | #16 William Carey
#1 Fort Hayes State | W 68–66
L 48–55 |
| 1986 | #11 | First Round
Second Round
Quarterfinals
Semifinals
National Championship | #22 Minnesota–Duluth
#6 Emporia State
#14 Central Washington
#7 Saint Thomas Aquinas
#25 Arkansas–Monticello | W 62–56
W 79–76
W 80–64
W 102–91
W 67–54 |
| 1988 | #3 | First Round
Second Round | #30 East Texas Baptist
#14 College of Idaho | W 89–63
L 108–123 |
| 1990 | #1 | First Round
Second Round
Quarterfinals
Semifinals | #32 Midland Lutheran
#17 Central Arkansas
#24 Pfeiffer
#4 Birmingham–Southern | W 92–73
W 70–66
W 125–83
L 96–98 |
| 1991 | #3 | First Round
Second Round
Quarterfinals | #30 Holy Family
#14 Briar Cliff
#6 Pfeiffer | W 106–75
W 89–87
L 95–105 |
| 1992 | #11 | First Round
Second Round | #22 Findlay
#6 BYU–Hawaiʻi | W 67–66
L 66–90 |
| 1993 | #4 | First Round
Second Round
Quarterfinals | #29 McKendree
#13 Life
#21 Georgetown (KY) | W 87–72
W 94–89
L 91–101 |
| 1994 | #12 | First Round | #21 Saint Mary's (TX) | L 62–77 |
| 1995 | #18 | First Round
Second Round | #15 Oklahoma Baptist
#31 Montana State–Northern | W 74–63
L 78–92 |
| 1996 | #4 | First Round
Second Round
Quarterfinals
Semifinals | #29 Talladega
#20 McKendree
#21 East Central
#1 Georgetown (KY) | W 91–78
W 95–87
W 93–75
L 84–97 |
| 1997 | #7 | First Round | #26 Point Park | L 100–111 |
| 1999 | #17 | First Round | #16 Biola | L 46–51 |
| 2000 | #2 | First Round
Second Round
Quarterfinals | #31 Saint Gregory's
#15 Central State
#10 Biola | W 77–66
W 77–41
L 71–82 |
