Year | Award | Category | Title | Result |
---|
1989 | Young Artist Award | Best Leading Young Actor in a Feature Film | Clara's Heart | Nominated |
1990 | Young Artist Award | Best Young Actor Starring in a Television Series | Doogie Howser, M.D. | Won |
People's Choice Award | Favorite Male Performer in a New TV Series | Won |
Favorite Male TV Performer | Nominated |
Viewers for Quality Television Award | Best Actor in a Quality Comedy Series | Nominated |
1991 | Young Artist Award | Best Young Actor Starring in a Television Series | Won |
2007 | Teen Choice Award | Choice TV Actor: Comedy | How I Met Your Mother | Nominated |
2008 | People's Choice Award | Favorite Scene Stealing Star | Nominated |
Teen Choice Award | Choice TV Actor: Comedy | Nominated |
2009 | TCA Award | Individual Achievement in Comedy | Nominated |
Teen Choice Award | Choice TV Actor: Comedy | Nominated |
Streamy Award | Best Male Actor in a Comedy Web Series | Dr. Horrible's Sing-Along Blog | Won |
Satellite Award | Best Supporting Actor – Series, Miniseries or Television Film | How I Met Your Mother | Nominated |
2010 | Spike Video Game Award | Best Performance by a Human Male | Spider-Man: Shattered Dimensions | Won |
Satellite Award | Best Supporting Actor – Series, Miniseries or Television Film | How I Met Your Mother | Nominated |
2011 | People's Choice Award | Favorite TV Comedy Actor | Won |
Favorite TV Guest Star | Glee | Nominated |
Critics' Choice Television Award | Best Supporting Actor in a Comedy Series | How I Met Your Mother | Won |
Satellite Award | Best Supporting Actor – Series, Miniseries or Television Film | How I Met Your Mother | Nominated |
2012 | People's Choice Award | Favorite TV Comedy Actor | Won |
TV Guide Award | Favorite Actor | Nominated |
Teen Choice Award | Choice TV Actor: Comedy | Nominated |
2013 | Webby Award | Best Comedy: Long Form or Series | Neil's Puppet Dreams | Nominated |
People's Choice Award | Favorite TV Comedy Actor | How I Met Your Mother | Nominated |
2014 | Nominated |
Favorite TV Bromance | Nominated |
Nickelodeon Kids' Choice Award | Favorite Movie Actor | The Smurfs 2 | Nominated |
Drama Desk Award | Outstanding Actor in a Musical | Hedwig and the Angry Inch | Won |
Drama League Award | Distinguished Performance | Won |
Outer Critics Circle Award | Outstanding Actor in a Musical | Nominated |
Hasty Pudding Theatricals | Hasty Pudding Man of the Year | Won |
Dorian Award | TV Musical Performance of the Year | 68th Tony Awards | Won |
2015 | Alliance of Women Film Journalists Award | Best Depiction of Nudity, Sexuality, or Seduction | Gone Girl | Nominated |
Dorian Award | Wilde Artist of the Year | | Nominated |
Saturn Award | Best Guest Performance in a Television Series | American Horror Story: Freak Show | Nominated |
2017 | Saturn Award | Best New Media Television Series | A Series of Unfortunate Events | Nominated |
2018 | Satellite Award | Best Actor – Television Series Musical or Comedy | Nominated |
Peabody Award | Entertainment, Children's & Youth Programming | Won |
2019 | Producers Guild of America Awards | Outstanding Children's Program | Nominated |
Kid's Choice Awards | Favorite TV Drama | Nominated |
Favorite Male TV Star | Nominated |
2020 | Producers Guild of America Awards | Outstanding Children's Program | Nominated |
2023 | Theater Fans’ Choice Awards | Best Featured Performer In A Play | Peter Pan Goes Wrong | Won |
Drama League Award | Distinguished Performance | Nominated |
2024 | BroadwayWorld Washington DC Award | Best Direction of a Musical | Tick, Tick... Boom! | Nominated |