| Title | Holder | Date gained | Date lost | Notes |
|---|
| Earl of Surrey (1088) | John de Warenne, 6th Earl of Surrey | 1240 | 1304 | |
| Earl of Warwick (1088) | William Maudit, 8th Earl of Warwick | 1253 | 1267 | Died |
| William de Beauchamp, 9th Earl of Warwick | 1267 | 1298 | |
| Earl of Leicester (1107) | Simon de Montfort, 6th Earl of Leicester | 1218 | 1265 | Attainted, and the title became forfeited |
| Earl of Gloucester (1122) | Richard de Clare, 6th Earl of Gloucester | 1230 | 1262 | 5th Earl of Hertford; Died |
| Gilbert de Clare, 7th Earl of Gloucester | 1262 | 1295 | 6th Earl of Hertford |
| Earl of Arundel (1138) | John FitzAlan, 6th Earl of Arundel | 1243 | 1267 | Died |
| John FitzAlan, 7th Earl of Arundel | 1267 | 1272 | |
| Earl of Derby (1138) | Robert de Ferrers, 6th Earl of Derby | 1254 | 1266 | Title became forfeited |
| Earl of Norfolk (1140) | Roger Bigod, 4th Earl of Norfolk | 1225 | 1270 | |
| Earl of Devon (1141) | Baldwin de Redvers, 7th Earl of Devon | 1245 | 1262 | Died |
| Isabella de Fortibus, Countess of Devon | 1262 | 1293 | |
| Earl of Oxford (1142) | Hugh de Vere, 4th Earl of Oxford | 1221 | 1263 | Died |
| Robert de Vere, 5th Earl of Oxford | 1263 | 1297 | |
| Earl of Salisbury (1145) | Ela of Salisbury, 3rd Countess of Salisbury | 1196 | 1261 | Died |
| Margaret Longespée, 4th Countess of Salisbury | 1261 | 1310 | |
| Earl of Hereford (1199) | Humphrey de Bohun, 2nd Earl of Hereford | 1220 | 1275 | 1st Earl of Essex (1239) |
| Earl of Winchester (1207) | Roger de Quincy, 2nd Earl of Winchester | 1219 | 1264 | Died, title became extinct |
| Earl of Lincoln (1217) | Margaret de Quincy, Countess of Lincoln | 1232 | 1266 | Died |
| Henry de Lacy, 3rd Earl of Lincoln | 1266 | 1311 | |
| Earl of Cornwall (1225) | Richard, 1st Earl of Cornwall | 1225 | 1272 | |
| Earl of Richmond (1241) | Peter of Savoy, 1st Earl of Richmond | 1241 | 1268 | |
| Earl of Pembroke (1247) | William de Valence, 1st Earl of Pembroke | 1247 | 1296 | |
| Earl of Chester (1253) | Edward, Earl of Chester | 1253 | 1272 | |
| Earl of Leicester (1265) | Edmund Plantagenet, 1st Earl of Leicester | 1267 | 1296 | New creation; 1st Earl of Lancaster (1267) |
| Earl of Richmond (1268) | John I, Duke of Brittany | 1268 | 1268 | New creation; surrendered the title to his son |
| John II, Duke of Brittany | 1268 | 1305 | |
| Baron de Ros (1264) | Robert de Ros | 1264 | 1285 | New creation |
| Baron le Despencer (1264) | Hugh le Despencer, 1st Baron le Despencer | 1264 | 1265 | New creation; Died |
| Hugh le Despencer, 2nd Baron le Despencer | 1265 | 1326 | |
| Baron Basset of Drayton (1264) | Ralph Basset, 1st Baron Basset of Drayton | 1264 | 1264 | New creation; Died |
| Ralph Basset, 2nd Baron Basset of Drayton | 1265 | 1299 | |
| Baron Basset of Sapcote (1264) | Ralph Basset, 1st Baron Basset of Sapcote | 1264 | 1282 | New creation |
| Baron Marmion (1264) | William Marmion [1] | 1264 | 1265 | New creation for leading rebel. Not recalled after the Battle of Evesham. |