Living entombed animal

Last updated

Living entombed animals are animals supposedly found alive after being encased in solid rock, coal, or wood for a long period of time. [1] The accounts usually involve frogs or toads. No physical evidence exists, and the phenomenon has been dismissed by science. [2]

Contents

Reports

References to entombed animals have appeared in the writings of William of Newburgh, [3] J. G. Wood, [4] Ambroise Paré, [5] Robert Plot, [6] André Marie Constant Duméril, John Wesley, and others. [7] [8] Even Charles Dickens mentioned the phenomenon in his journal All the Year Round . [9] According to the Fortean Times , about 210 entombed animal cases have been described in Europe, North America, Africa, Australia, and New Zealand since the fifteenth century. [7] In 1771, an experiment was supposedly conducted by the Academy of Sciences at Paris in which three toads were encased in plaster and sealed in a box for 3 years, upon which it was found that two of the toads were still alive. [10]

A mummified toad within a hollow flint nodule, presented by Charles Dawson and claimed to have been found by workmen in a Lewes quarry around 1900. It is thought to be a fake. Booth Museum, Brighton Toad in a hole - Booth Museum Brighton.jpg
A mummified toad within a hollow flint nodule, presented by Charles Dawson and claimed to have been found by workmen in a Lewes quarry around 1900. It is thought to be a fake. Booth Museum, Brighton

At times, a number of animals are said to have been encased in the same place. Benjamin Franklin wrote an account of four live toads supposedly found enclosed in quarried limestone. [11] In a letter to Julian Huxley, one Eric G. Mackley claimed to have freed 23 frogs from a single piece of concrete while widening a road in Devonshire. An 1876 report from South Africa said that 63 small toads were found in the middle of a 16-foot-wide (5 m) tree trunk. [8]

Explanations

Though reports of entombed animals have occurred as recently as the 1980s, scientists have paid little serious attention to the phenomenon since the nineteenth century. During the 1820s, English geologist William Buckland conducted an experiment to see how long a toad could remain alive while encased in stone. He placed toads of different sizes and ages into carved chambers within limestone and sandstone blocks sealed with glass covers, then buried the blocks in his garden. A year later, he dug up the blocks and found that most of the toads were dead and decayed. A few toads that had been in the porous limestone were still living, but the glass had developed cracks which Buckland believed may have admitted small insects. However, Buckland found them all dead after reburying them in the limestone for another year. Buckland concluded that toads could not survive inside rock for extreme lengths of time, and determined that reports of the entombed animal phenomenon were mistaken. Most scientists agreed. [12] A writer from the journal Nature wrote in 1910,

The true interpretation of these alleged occurrences appears to be simply this a frog or toad is hopping about while a stone is being broken, and the non-scientific observer immediately rushes to the conclusion that he has seen the creature dropping out of the stone itself. One thing is certainly remarkable, that although numbers of field geologists and collectors of specimens of rocks, fossils, and minerals are hammering away all over the world, not one of these investigators has ever come upon a specimen of a live frog or toad imbedded in stone or in coal. [13]

Some of the stories may be based on outright fabrications. Charles Dawson, quite probably the perpetrator of the Piltdown Man hoax, had some years earlier presented the Brighton "Toad in the Hole" (a toad entombed within a flint nodule), likely another forgery. [14] Dawson presented the toad to the Brighton and Hove Natural History and Philosophical Society on 18 April 1901, claiming that two workmen had found the flint nodule in a quarry north-east of Lewes a couple of years earlier, which revealed a toad inside when they broke it open. The toad was eventually passed on to the Booth Museum of Natural History in Brighton via Henry Willett. However, the toad has since shrunk, suggesting that it cannot have been very old at the time of its discovery. [15] [16]

In literature

D. H. Lawrence, in the forward to his book, Studies in Classic American Literature , writes:

All right, Americans, let's see you set about it. Go on then, let the precious cat out of the bag. If you're sure he's in.
Et interrogatum ab omnibus:
"Ubi est ille Toad-in-the-Hole?
"Et iteratum est ab omnibus:
"Non est inventus!”
Is he or isn't he inventus? [17]

A fictional example of an entombed animal occurs in the Warner Bros. Merrie Melodies six-minute cartoon "One Froggy Evening". The character Michigan J. Frog is twice discovered inside the cornerstone of a razed building. [18]

A reference to the phenomenon occurs in Dante Gabriel Rossetti's poem "Jenny", which mentions a "toad within a stone / Seated while time crumbles on". [7]

In Victor Hugo's Ninety-Three , Danton says to Marat: "for six thousand years, Cain has been preserved in hatred like a toad in a stone. The rock is broken, and Cain leaps forth among men, and that is Marat." [19]

See also

Related Research Articles

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Pierre Teilhard de Chardin</span> French philosopher and Jesuit priest (1881–1955)

Pierre Teilhard de Chardin ; 1 May 1881 – 10 April 1955) was a French Jesuit priest, scientist, paleontologist, theologian, philosopher and teacher. He was Darwinian in outlook and the author of several influential theological and philosophical books.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Piltdown Man</span> Paleoanthropological hoax

The Piltdown Man was a paleoanthropological fraud in which bone fragments were presented as the fossilised remains of a previously unknown early human. Although there were doubts about its authenticity virtually from the beginning, the remains were still broadly accepted for many years, and the falsity of the hoax was only definitively demonstrated in 1953. An extensive scientific review in 2016 established that amateur archaeologist Charles Dawson was responsible for the fraudulent evidence.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Out-of-place artifact</span> Objects that challenge historical chronology

An out-of-place artifact is an artifact of historical, archaeological, or paleontological interest found in an unusual context, which challenges conventional historical chronology by its presence in that context. Such artifacts may appear too advanced for the technology known to have existed at the time, or may suggest human presence at a time before humans are known to have existed. Other examples may suggest contact between different cultures that is hard to account for with conventional historical understanding.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Timeline of paleontology</span> Timeline of notable events in the sudy of ancient life

Timeline of paleontology

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Beringer's Lying Stones</span> 18th century hoax fossils

Beringer's Lying Stones are pieces of limestone which were carved into the shape of various fictitious animals and "discovered" in 1725 by Johann Bartholomeus Adam Beringer (1667–1740), Dean of the Faculty of Medicine at the University of Würzburg. Beringer believed them to be fossils, and because some of them bore the name of God in Hebrew, suggested that they might be of divine origin. The scientific community at the time was still unsure as to what fossils actually were, the notion that they were the petrified remains of once-living organisms being merely one of several competing hypotheses.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Fiji mermaid</span> Fake mummified body of a half-monkey half-fish

The Fiji mermaid was an object composed of the torso and head of a juvenile monkey sewn to the back half of a fish. It was a common feature of sideshows where it was presented as the mummified body of a creature that was supposedly half mammal and half fish, a version of a mermaid. The original had fish scales with animal hair superimposed on its body and pendulous breasts on its chest. The mouth was wide open with its teeth bared. The right hand was against the right cheek, and the left tucked under its lower left jaw. This mermaid was supposedly caught near the Fiji Islands in the South Pacific. Several replicas and variations have also been made and exhibited under similar names and pretexts. P. T. Barnum exhibited the original in Barnum's American Museum in New York in 1842, but it then disappeared—likely destroyed in one of the many fires that destroyed parts of Barnum's collections.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Toad in the hole</span> Traditional English dish

Toad in the hole or sausage toad is a traditional English dish consisting of sausages in Yorkshire pudding batter, usually served with onion gravy and vegetables. Historically, the dish has also been prepared using other meats, such as rump steak and lamb's kidney.

<i>Fortean Times</i> British monthly magazine devoted to anomalous phenomena

Fortean Times is a British monthly magazine devoted to the anomalous phenomena popularised by Charles Fort. Previously published by John Brown Publishing, I Feel Good Publishing, Dennis Publishing, and Exponent (2021), as of December 2021 it is published by Diamond Publishing, part of Metropolis International.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Ol' Rip the Horned Toad</span> Legendary Texas horned lizard (died 1929)

Ol' Rip was a Texas horned lizard⁠—commonly referred to as a "horned toad" or "horny toad"⁠—famous during the Jazz Age which supposedly survived a 31-year hibernation as an entombed animal. The reptile's name was a reference to American writer Washington Irving's fictional character Rip Van Winkle.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Common toad</span> Species of amphibian

The common toad, European toad, or in Anglophone parts of Europe, simply the toad, is a frog found throughout most of Europe, in the western part of North Asia, and in a small portion of Northwest Africa. It is one of a group of closely related animals that are descended from a common ancestral line of toads and which form a species complex. The toad is an inconspicuous animal as it usually lies hidden during the day. It becomes active at dusk and spends the night hunting for the invertebrates on which it feeds. It moves with a slow, ungainly walk or short jumps, and has greyish-brown skin covered with wart-like lumps.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Midwife toad</span> Genus of amphibians

Midwife toads are a genus (Alytes) of frogs in the family Alytidae, and are found in most of Europe and northwestern Africa. Characteristic of these toad-like frogs is their parental care; the males carry a string of fertilised eggs on their backs, hence the name "midwife". The female expels a strand of eggs, which the male fertilizes externally. He then wraps them around his legs to protect them from predators in the water. When they are ready to hatch, the male wades into shallow water, where he allows the tadpoles to leap out of their eggs. Five separate species of midwife toads are found across western Europe, northern Africa, and Majorca.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Ica stones</span> Decorated andesite stones found in Ica Province, Peru

The Ica stones are a collection of andesite stones from the Ica Province in Peru, known for their engraved motifs. Largely regarded to be modern hoaxes, the stones in some cases utilize art styles from various pre-Columbian Peruvian civilizations and often depict anachronistic scenes or objects, including dinosaurs and advanced technology.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Gef</span> Supposed talking mongoose

Gef, also referred to as the Talking Mongoose or the Dalby Spook, was an allegedly talking mongoose which was claimed to inhabit a farmhouse owned by the Irving family. The Irvings' farm was located at Cashen's Gap near the hamlet of Dalby on the Isle of Man. The story was given extensive coverage by the tabloid press in Britain in the early 1930s. The Irvings' claims gained the attention of parapsychologists and ghost hunters, such as Harry Price, Hereward Carrington, and Nandor Fodor. Some investigators of the era as well as contemporary critics have concluded that the phenomenon was a hoax that the Irving family perpetuated by using ventriloquism.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Charles Dawson</span> British archaeologist and fraudster (1864–1916)

Charles Dawson was a British amateur archaeologist who claimed to have made a number of archaeological and palaeontological discoveries that were later exposed as frauds. These forgeries included the Piltdown Man, a unique set of bones that he claimed to have found in 1912 in Sussex. Many technological methods such as fluorine testing indicate that this discovery was a hoax, and Dawson, the only one with the skill and knowledge to generate this forgery, was a major suspect.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Majorcan midwife toad</span> Species of amphibian

The Majorcan midwife toad is a frog in the family Alytidae. It is endemic to the Balearic Island of Majorca in the Mediterranean Sea. An example of Lazarus taxon, the species was first described from fossil remains in 1977, but living animals were discovered in 1979.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Booth Museum of Natural History</span> Natural history museum in East Sussex, England

Booth Museum of Natural History is a charitable trust managed, municipally-owned museum of natural history in the city of Brighton and Hove in the South East of England. Its focus is on Victorian taxidermy, especially of British birds, as well as collections focusing on entomology, chalk fossils, skeletons and botany. It is part of "Royal Pavilion & Museums Trust". Admission to the museum is free.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Tarrare</span> French showman and eater

Tarrare, sometimes spelled Tarar, was a French showman and soldier noted for his unusual appetite and eating habits. Able to eat vast amounts of meat, he was constantly hungry; his parents could not provide for him and he was turned out of the family home as a teenager. He travelled France in the company of a band of prostitutes and thieves before becoming the warm-up act for a travelling charlatan. In this act, he swallowed corks, stones, live animals, and a whole basketful of apples. He then took this act to Paris where he worked as a street performer.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Rouffignac Cave</span> Cave and archaeological site with prehistoric art in France

The Rouffignac cave, in the French commune of Rouffignac-Saint-Cernin-de-Reilhac in the Dordogne département, contains over 250 engravings and cave paintings dating back to the Upper Paleolithic. In conjunction with other caves and abris of the Vézère valley, the Rouffignac cave was classified a Monument historique in 1957 and a World Heritage Site in 1979 by UNESCO as part of the Prehistoric Sites and Decorated Caves of the Vézère Valley.

Miles Russell, is a British archaeologist best known for his work and publications on the prehistoric and Roman periods and for his appearances in television programmes such as Time Team and Harry Hill's TV Burp.

References

  1. Mark Pilkington. "Toads in the hole". The Guardian. January 20, 2005. Retrieved on January 9, 2009.
  2. Bressan, David (31 October 2014). "The (Zombie-)Toad-in-the-Hole". Scientific American.
  3. William of Newburgh. Trans. Joseph Stevenson. "The History of William of Newburgh", in The Church Historians, volume IV, part II . 1856. 722.
  4. J. G. Wood and Harrison Weir. Sketches and Anecdotes of Animal Life . 1856. 39.
  5. Ambroise Paré. Trans. Janis L. Pallister. Of Monsters and Marvels . 1995. 93.
  6. qtd. in George Griffiths. A History of Tong, Shropshire . 1894. 192.
  7. 1 2 3 Jan Bondeson. "Toad in the Hole". Fortean Times . June 2007.
  8. 1 2 Jerome Clark. "Entombed animals". Unexplained! Farmington Hills, MI: Visible Ink, 1999. 164–69.
  9. Charles Dickens. All the Year Round . Volume VIII. 1862–1863. 255.
  10. Chamber's Journal of Popular Literature, Science and the Arts Volume VIII, pg 631.
  11. Benjamin Franklin. "An Account of Toads Found Enclosed in Solid Stone." In The Works of Benjamin Franklin, ed. Jared Sparks. Volume VI. 1882. 441–42.
  12. "Curiosities of Natural History". Blackwood's Edinburgh Magazine. March 1858. 360.
  13. "Notes". Nature 83 (1910): 406–07.
  14. Russell, Miles (2003). Piltdown Man: The Secret Life of Charles Dawson & the World's Greatest Archaeological Hoax. Stroud: Tempus Publishing. ISBN   0752425722.
  15. Mark Jones; Paul T. Craddock; Nicolas Barker, eds. (1992). Fake?: The Art of Deception. University of California Press. p.  95. ISBN   978-0520070875.
  16. Miles Russell (2012). The Piltdown Man Hoax: Case Closed. The History Press. ISBN   978-0752487809.
  17. Lawrence, D. H. Studies in Classic American Literature. Publisher: Thomas Seltzer. (1923 p. vii)
  18. David George Gordon. "Hibernating Hoppers: Can Toads Live Buried for Decades?" MSN Encarta. Retrieved 2 September 2007. Archived 2009-10-31.
  19. Hugo, Victor, "Magna Testantur Voce per Umbras.", Ninety-three, retrieved 2023-11-22

Further reading