Massacre of Running Waters

Massacre of Running Waters
Approximate location of the massacre site on the Finke River.
Location	Irbmangkara stretch of Finke River, Northern Territory
Coordinates	24°17′40″S132°54′04″E / 24.2945°S 132.9011°E / -24.2945; 132.9011
Date	1875
Attack type	Ambush, massacre, raid
Weapons	Boomerangs, spears
Deaths	80+ [1]
Injured	Unknown
Perpetrators	50 to 60 Matuntara indigenous warriors [2]
Motive	As punishment for an act of sacrilege by the neighbouring southern Arrernte people.

The massacre of Running Waters was the killing of 80 to 100 Arrernte (formerly known as Aranda) men, women and children of the Southern Aranda language group ^[1] of Aboriginal Australians by a raiding party of 50 to 60 Matuntara warriors ^[2] in 1875. The massacre took place at Irbmangkara, a permanent water stretch of the Finke River about 200 kilometres (120 mi) south-west of Alice Springs in the Northern Territory of Australia.

The Matuntara planned the attack as a punishment for an act of sacrilege by the neighbouring southern Arrernte. ^[3]

The account of what occurred at Irbmangkara is based on the writings of Lutheran anthropologist, linguist and genealogist Carl Strehlow, but the people of Hermannsburg have stated that the events have remained a shaping factor in the area's local politics.

Events

Irbangkara (Running Waters)

The massacre was triggered thanks to a middle-aged man called Kalejika, who belonged to a Central Aranda local group. Kalejika paid a visit to Irbmangkara, and then told some Upper Southern Aranda men that Ltjabakuka, the aged and highly respected ceremonial chief of Irbmangkara, together with some of his assistant elders, had committed sacrilege by giving uninitiated boys men's blood to drink from a shield into which it had been poured for ritual purposes. Sacrilege was an offence always punished by death. ^[4]

According to historian Geoffrey Blainey, the party of Aboriginal warriors sent to avenge the sacrilege and selected Running Waters [as the place where the Southern Arrernte could be readily be surprised], "and timed their secret raid for... when their enemies were cooking their meals before making their beds on the ground". ^[3]

Three parties of warriors, hidden among the bushes of the nearby mountain slopes and in the undergrowth in the river bed at their foot, were watching the men and women of Irbmangkara returning to their camp; the armed men [then]... rushed in, like swift dingoes upon flock of unsuspecting emus. Spears and boomerangs flew with deadly aim. Within a matter of minutes Ltjabakuka and his men were lying lifeless in their blood at their brush shelters.^{[ according to whom? ][ citation needed ]}

Then the warriors turned their murderous attention to the women and older children, and either speared or clubbed them to death. Finally, according to the grim custom of warriors and avengers, they broke the limbs of the infants, leaving them to die "natural deaths". The final number of the dead could well have reached the high figure of from 80 to 100 men, women, and children. ^[5] One of the Aranda women had merely pretended to be dead and escaped northward to raise the alarm. ^[1]

As a small boy, Moses Tjalkabota was greatly affected by the massacre, given that two of his friends and their mother were killed in the raid, ^[1] and he had himself witnessed the great clouds of smoke arising from the funeral pyres when the bodies were burnt the next day. ^[6] Much later, his reminiscences of the killings were recorded and translated into English, and in some details, they are the same when describing the ruthlessness of the raid. ^[1]

Sources

The first European explorers had arrived in this area in 1860 and, by 1872 to the east, the Overland Telegraph Line had been surveyed and constructed.^{[ citation needed ][ relevant? ]}

Missionary Carl Strehlow (top); and his son, Ted Strehlow with two Aranda elders (below)

The massacre occurred in 1875,^{[ citation needed ]} two years before the Germans set up their Lutheran mission at Hermannsburg in 1877. ^[7] Tjalkabota, who was an Aboriginal translator for both Carl Strehlow (who led the mission from 1894 to 1922 ^[8] ) and his son Ted Strehlow, ^[9] was a young boy (6 to 9 years of age) at the time of the massacre and, according to researcher Peter Latz, "he recalls it [the massacre] in some detail". ^[10]

Carl Strehlow's recordings of the massacre appear in his grandson John Strehlow's historical biography of this grandparents. ^[11]

Ted Strehlow wrote a detailed account of the massacre in his 1969 book, Journey to Horseshoe Bend. ^[12]

Aftermath and analysis

Strehlow wrote of the massacre as an example of an incompatibility in integrating Indigenous Australian customary law with the modern Australian legal system. He describes the capital punishment enacted against the Arrernte people who were unwitting in the crime as an unacceptably harsh punishment in the Australian legal mind and contrary to mens rea. ^[13]

Professor Sam Gill of the University of Colorado Boulder has analysed Strehlow's account in his book Storytracking, published in 1998. He concluded that it was likely that something occurred at Irbangkara on a scale that was considered important by the peoples of the region. ^[14] Gill was assured by the local people at Hermannsburg/Ntaria that the events at Irbangkara remained a shaping factor in the local politics of the area, ^[15] and believed that a possible source of the evidence of manoeuvres and stealth of the Mantuntara attackers could have been an existing story tradition told by the Arrernte that was built on circumstantial evidence. ^[16] He also stated that there was independent evidence of subsequent attacks, one of a hunter survivor of the 1875 incident, Nameia, in 1890; ^[14] and where local constable William Willshire had been involved in the deaths of Aboriginal people at nearby Tempe Downs Station in 1891. ^[14]

However, Gill noted that Strehlow's accounts are embellished with a literary trope ^[17] and go beyond reporting the events, ^[14] and that the account must be read in light of Strehlow's role as a missionary, academic and literary figure in order for the account to be critically appreciated and responsibly used. ^[18]

See also

• List of massacres of Indigenous Australians

References

1. Blainey 2015, p. 117.
2. Strehlow 1969, p. 37.
3. Blainey 2015, p. 116.
4. Strehlow 1969, pp. 36–37.
5. Strehlow 1969, p. 38.
6. Strehlow 2011, p. 409.
7. Kenny, Anna (20 December 2013). The Aranda's Pepa: An introduction to Carl Strehlow's Masterpiece Die Aranda- und Loritja-Stämme in Zentral-Australien (1907-1920). ANU Press. doi: 10.22459/ap.12.2013 . ISBN   978-1-921536-77-9. PDF
8. "Strehlow, Rev. Carl (1871-1922)". German Missionaries in Australia. Griffith University . Retrieved 12 November 2022.
9. Albrecht 2005.
10. Latz 2014, p. 13.
11. Strehlow 2011, pp. 408ff.
12. Strehlow 1969, pp. 35ff.
13. Kirby 1978, pp. 27–29.
14. Gill 1998, p. 73.
15. Gill 1998, p. 71.
16. Gill 1998, p. 72.
17. Gill 1998, pp. 71–72.
18. Gill 1998, p. 74.

Sources

• Albrecht, Paul (2005). "Tjalkabota, Moses (1869–1954)". Australian Dictionary of Biography . Vol. Supplementary. Canberra: National Centre of Biography, Australian National University. ISBN   978-0-522-84459-7. ISSN   1833-7538. OCLC   70677943 . Retrieved 2 October 2020.
• Blainey, Geoffrey (2015). The Story of Australia's People – The Rise and fall of Ancient Australia. Penguin Random House Australia. ISBN   978-1-76014-103-5.
• Gill, Sam D. (1998). Storytracking : Texts, Stories, and Histories in Central Australia. New York: Oxford University Press. ISBN   9780195353891 . Retrieved 8 October 2022.
• Kirby, Michael (October 1978). "TGH Strehlow and Aboriginal Customary Law" (PDF). Michael Kirby. Open Publishing. Retrieved 2 October 2020.
• Latz, Peter (2014). Blind Moses: Aranda man of high degree and Christian evangelist. IAD Press. ISBN   9780992572709.
• Strehlow, John (2011). The Tale of Frieda Keyser – Frieda Keyser & Carl Strehlow : an historical biography. Wild Cat Press.
• Strehlow, T. G. H. (1969). Journey to Horseshoe Bend (PDF). Angus and Robertson.