Medicinal clay

German medicinal clay (Luvos Heilerde) consisting of loess, i.e., a mixture of sand, clay, and silt

The use of medicinal clay in folk medicine goes back to prehistoric times. Indigenous peoples around the world still use clay widely, which is related to geophagy. The first recorded use of medicinal clay goes back to ancient Mesopotamia.

A wide variety of clays are used for medicinal purposes—primarily for external applications, such as the clay baths in health spas (mud therapy). Among the clays most commonly used are kaolin and the smectite clays such as bentonite, montmorillonite, and Fuller's earth. However, their use is declining, and modern evidence-based medicine has ended the use of many types.

History

Ancient Egypt and Mesopotamia

The first recorded use of medicinal clay is on Mesopotamian clay tablets around 2500 BC. Also, ancient Egyptians used clay. The Pharaohs’ physicians used the material as anti-inflammatory agents and antiseptics. It was used as a preservative for making mummies and is also reported that Cleopatra used clays to preserve her complexion. ^{[1] [2]}

The Ebers Papyrus of about 1550 BC (but containing the tradition going back many centuries earlier) is an important medical text from ancient Egypt. It describes the use of ochre for a wide variety of ailments, including for intestinal problems. ^[3]

Classical times

Lemnian clay

This was a clay used in Classical Antiquity. It was mined on the island of Lemnos. Its use continued until the 19th century, as it was still listed in an important pharmacopoeia in 1848 ^[4] (the deposits may have been exhausted by then).

Pliny reports about the Lemnian earth: ^[5]

if rubbed under the eyes, it moderates pain and watering from the same, and prevents the flow from the lachrymal ducts. In cases of haemorrhage it should be administered with vinegar. It is used against complaints of the spleen and kidneys, copious menstruation, also against poisons, and wounds caused by serpents.

Lemnian clay was shaped into tablets, or little cakes, and then distinctive seals were stamped into them, giving rise to its name terra sigillata —Latin for 'sealed earth'. Dioscorides also commented upon the use of terra sigillata. ^[4]

Another physician famous in antiquity, Galen, recorded numerous cases of the internal and external uses of this clay in his treatise on clay therapy.

Galen... used as one of his means for curing injuries, festering wounds, and inflammations terra sigillata, a medicinal red clay compressed into round cakes and stamped with the image of the goddess Diana. This clay, which came from the island of Lemnos, was known throughout the classical world. ^[6]

Clay was prescribed by the Roman obstetrician, gynecologist, and pediatrician Soranus of Ephesus, who practiced medicine around 100–140 AD. ^[7]

Other clays used in classical times

The other types of clay that were famous in antiquity were as follows.

• Terra chia, Terra cymolia (Cimolean earth): these were both white earths and considered of great value.
• Samian earth: Pliny in c. 50 AD (Nat. Hist.) details two distinct varieties, colyrium - an eye salve, and aster, which was used as a soap as well as in medicines.
• Terra sigillata strigoniensis (Strigian earth, derived from Silesia) - this clay, yellow in colour, appears to have been famous later in medieval times.

All the above seem to have been bentonitic clays.

• The earth which did not stain the hands was known as rubrica.

Medieval times

In medieval Persia, Avicenna (980–1037 CE), the 'Prince of Doctors', wrote about clay therapy in his numerous treatises.

Ibn al-Baitar (1197–1248), a Muslim scholar born at Malaga, Spain, and author of a famous work on pharmacology, discusses eight kinds of medicinal earth. ^{[notes 1]} The eight kinds are:

1. the terra sigillata,
2. Egyptian earth,
3. Samian earth,
4. earth of Chios,
5. Cimolean earth or pure clay (cimolite), soft earth, called al-hurr, green in color like verdigris, is smoked together with almond bark to serve as food when it will turn red and assume a good flavor; it is but rarely eaten without being smoked—also called 'Argentiera',
6. earth of vines called ampelitis (Pliny XXXV, 56) or pharmakitis from Seleucia in Syria,
7. Armenian earth (also known as the Armenian bole), salutary in cases of bubonic plague, being administered both externally and internally,
8. earth of Nishapur. ^[8]

Renaissance period

A French naturalist Pierre Belon (1517–1564) was interested in investigating the mystery of the Lemnian clay. In 1543, he visited Constantinople where, after making enquiries, he encountered 18 types of different products marketed as Lemnian Earth (he was concerned about possible counterfeits).

He then made a special journey to Lemnos, where he continued his investigation, and tried to find the source of the clay. He discovered that it was extracted only once a year (on 6 August) under the supervision of Christian monks and Turkish officials.

In 1588 the English ethnographer and translator Thomas Harriot wrote in A Briefe and True Report of the New Found Land of Virginia that Algonquians of the mid–Atlantic region of North America treated various sores and wounds with wapeih, "very like to terra sigillata" that English surgeons and physicians found to be of the same kind "of vertue and more effectuall" than the contemporary European sort. ^[9]

Preparation of clay

Clay gathered from its original source deposit is refined and processed in various ways by manufacturers. This can include heating or baking the clay, since the raw clay tends to contain a variety of microorganisms. ^{[notes 2]}

Too much processing, likewise, may reduce the clay's therapeutic potential. In particular, Mascolo et al. studied 'pharmaceutical grade clay' versus 'the natural and the commercial herbalist clay', and found an appreciable depletion of trace elements in the pharmaceutical grade clay. ^[11] On the other hand, certain clays are typically heated or cooked before use. ^{[notes 3]}

Medicinal clay is typically available in health food stores as a dry powder, or in jars in its liquid hydrated state – which is convenient for internal use. For external use, the clay may be added to the bath, or prepared in wet packs or poultices for application to specific parts of the body.

Often, warm packs are prepared; the heat opens up the pores of the skin, and helps the interaction of the clay with the body. ^{[notes 4]}

In the European health spas, the clay is prepared for use in a multitude of ways – depending on the traditions of a particular spa; typically it is mixed with peat and matured in special pools for a few months or even up to two years.

"The majority of spas … use artificial ponds where the natural ("virgin") clay is mixed with mineral, thermo-mineral, or sea water that issues in the vicinity of the spas or inside the spa buildings." ^[13]

Trace minerals

Clays contain large amounts of trace minerals. It is common to see as many as 75 different trace minerals in Montmorillonite clays. ^[14] Specific trace minerals that various clays possess vary very widely. Also, the amount of any particular trace mineral in any specific clay varies a lot among clays from different locations. For example, the amount of iron in various bentonite clays can vary from 2.5 to 3%. ^[15]

Uses

Skin conditions

Many types of skin conditions have been treated by the application of medicinal clay. Montmorillonite has shown its effectiveness in this area. ^{[16] [17] [18] [19]} It has also been used as a base ingredient for tissue engineering. ^[20] Clay is used in many dermatological over-the-counter remedies, such as in acne treatments (this information may not be mentioned on the label specifically).

Internal use

There are many over-the-counter remedies for internal (oral) use that contained clay before discontinuation. Examples included Kaopectate (Upjohn), Rheaban (Leeming Div., Pfizer), and Diar-Aid (Thompson Medical Co.). The labels on all of these showed the active ingredient to be Attapulgite, each tablet containing 600 (or 750 mg) of this component along with inert materials or adjuvants. ^[21] However, since April 2003, attapulgite medication was discontinued due to lack of evidence according to the U.S. Food and Drug Administration. ^[22]

Kaolin was also used to treat cholera around the start of the 20th century. An early proponent was German physician Julius Stumpf. ^[23]

Heavy metal chelation

It has been used as a scientifically unsupported chelation treatment for heart disease and autism. ^{[24] [25]}

Aflatoxicosis

Bentonite has the ability to reduce the adverse effects of aflatoxicosis. ^[26]

A mountain of clay — Petrified Forest National Park, Arizona. The white bands represent pure bentonite clay.

Side effects of ingestion

Substances discontinued such as kaolin and attapulgite were formerly considered gastric demulcents and diarrhea medication, until official studies by the USFDA disproved these views. Clays are classified as excipients and their main side-effects are that of neutral excipients, which is to impair and slow down absorption of antibiotics, hormones and heart medication amongst others by coating the digestive tract ^[27] and this slowed down absorption can lead to increased toxicity of some medication (e.g. citrate salts) which can become toxic if not metabolized quickly enough, which is one contraindication of attapulgite. ^[28] Usual mild side-effects are nausea, slowed down absorption of nutrients from food (in excess dosage of medicinal clay) and constipation. It has been found that prolonged exposure to bentonite in humans can actually have harmful effects. ^[29]

Common medicinal clays

• Bentonite-type clay has been used to treat infections, indigestion, and other medical problems by both applying wet clay topically to the skin as a poultice, and by ingesting it. Bentonite has been prescribed as a bulk laxative, and it is also used as a base for many dermatologic formulas. ^[30] Dermatologically, it is used as part of a treatment for pruritus. ^[31] Bentonite itself is not classified as a carcinogen, but some bentonite may contain variable amounts of respirable crystalline silica, a human carcinogen. ^[32]
• Montmorillonite is the main constituent of bentonite and Heilerde loess. A medical preparation is called diosmectite.
• Palygorskite or attapulgite is a very absorbent clay, somewhat similar to bentonite. When used in medicine, it physically binds to acids and toxic substances in the stomach and digestive tract. For this reason, it has been used in several anti-diarrheal medications, ^[33] but studies of such have since been rejected by the U.S. Food and Drug Administration as insufficient. ^{[34] [35]}
• Kaolin is not as absorbent as most clays used medicinally (it has a low shrink–swell capacity). Also, it has a low cation exchange capacity. This clay is also known as 'white cosmetic clay'. Clay, in the form of kaolin, was a common ingredient in western medicines such as Kaopectate, Rolaids and Maalox, but is no longer present in them nor in similar preparations, as it is considered ineffective by the USFDA. ^[36]

See also

• Diatomaceous earth
• Peloid
• Zeolite
• Fuller's earth

Notes

1. For further discussion see:
   
   • Leclerc, L (1881). Traite des Simples (in French). Vol. II. pp. 421–7.
   • Baron Carra de Vaux (1921). Les Penseurs de L'islam (in French). Vol. II. pp.  289–96.
     Cited in Laufer (1930)
2. "Soil, including kaolinitic and montmorillonitic clays, contains considerable amounts of organic material, including many live microorganisms." ^[10]
3. An example of this is the medieval 'Argentiera' clay, mentioned in this article.
4. "Hot application is recommended in geotherapy, pelotherapy or paramuds in beauty therapy..." ^[12]

References

1. Harth, Richard (17 May 2013). "Attacking MRSA with metals from antibacterial clays". ASU Now (Press release). Arizona State University. Retrieved 20 October 2017.
2. Coulumbe, Margaret (7 April 2008). "'Healing clays' hold promise in fight against MRSA superbug infections and disease" (Press release). The Biodesign Institute: Arizona State University. Retrieved 20 October 2017.
3. "The Papyrus Ebers: The Greatest Egyptian Medical Document". www.macalster.edu. Translated by Ebbell, B. Copenhagen: Levin & Munksgaard. 1937. Archived from the original on 26 February 2005.
4. Selinus, Olle; Alloway, BJ (2005). Essentials of medical geology: Impacts of the natural environment on public health. Academic Press. p. 446. ISBN   0-12-636341-2.
5. Thompson, CJS (1929). The Mystery and Art of the Apothecary. London: John Lane. p.  44.
6. Van Der Loos, H. (1965). The Miracles of Jesus. Leiden, the Netherlands: Brill. p. 82.
7. Soranus' gynecology. Translated by Temkin, Owsei (reprint ed.). JHU Press. 1991. pp. 239–40. ISBN   0-8018-4320-0.
8. Laufer, Berthold (1930). Geophagy. Chicago: Field Museum Press – via Archive.org.
9. Hariot, Thomas (1588). Royster, Paul (ed.). A Brief and True Report of the New Found Land of Virginia. University of Nebraska Digital Commons.
10. Callahan, GN (August 2003). "Eating dirt". Emerg Infect Dis. 9 (8): 1016–1021. doi:10.3201/eid0908.ad0908. PMC   3020602 . PMID   12971372.
11. Mascolo, N; Summa, V; et al. (1999). "Characterization of toxic elements in clays for human healing use". Applied Clay Science. 15 (5–6): 491–500. doi:10.1016/S0169-1317(99)00037-X.
12. Carretaro, MI; Gomes, CSF; et al. (2006). "Clays and human health". In Bergaya, F; Theng, BKG; et al. (eds.). Handbook of Clay Science, Developments in Clay Science. Vol. 1. Amsterdam: Elsevier Ltd. p. 723. ISBN   0-08-044183-1.
13. Carretaro, Gomes et al. (2006), p. 724.
14. US 6962718,Ramaekers, Joseph C.,"Compositions for treating animal diseases and syndromes",published 8 November 2005  (US patent). See: Table 1: Montmorillonite Components; Average Nutrient Content. Retrieved 20 October 2017.
15. Torstenfelt, B (April 1983). "Iron content and reducing capacity of granites and bentonite" (PDF). SKBF - KBS Teknisk Rapport. 83–36.
16. Saary, J; Qureshi, R; et al. (November 2005). "A systematic review of contact dermatitis treatment and prevention". J Am Acad Dermatol. 53 (5): 845. doi:10.1016/j.jaad.2005.04.075. PMID   16243136.
17. Guin, JD (2001). "Treatment of toxicodendron dermatitis (poison ivy and poison oak)". Skin Therapy Letter. 6 (7): 3–5. PMID   11376396.
18. Lee, YH; Chen, BY; et al. (2008). "Cytotoxic assessment of L-ascorbic acid/montmorillonite upon human dermal fibroblasts in vitro: MTT activity assay". Biomedical Engineering: Applications, Basis and Communications. 20 (6): 337–43. doi:10.4015/s1016237208000957.
19. Carretaro, Gomes et al. (2006), p. 722.
20. Zheng, JP; Wang, CZ; et al. (2007). "Preparation of biomimetic three-dimensional gelatin/montmorillonite-chitosan scaffold for tissue engineering". Reactive and Functional Polymers. 67 (9): 780–88. doi:10.1016/j.reactfunctpolym.2006.12.002.
21. US 5079201,Chu, Pochen&Garwood, William E.,"Zeolite-clay composition and uses thereof",published 7 January 1992 . (US Patent). Retrieved 20 October 2017.
22. Food and Drug Administration (17 April 2003). "Antidiarrheal Drug Products for Over-the-Counter Human Use; Final Monograph" (PDF). Federal Register. Vol. 68, no. 74. pp. 18869–81.
23. Walker, R. R. (April 1921). "Kaolin in the Treatment of Asiatic Cholera: Its Action and Uses". Proceedings of the Royal Society of Medicine. 14 (Ther_Pharmacol): 23–29. doi: 10.1177/003591572101402210 . ISSN   0035-9157. PMC   2152614 . PMID   19982160.
24. "Chelation Therapy: AHA recommendations". American Heart Association. Archived from the original on 19 April 2008.
25. Immunization Safety Review Committee, Board on Health Promotion and Disease Prevention, Institute of Medicine (2004). Immunization Safety Review: Vaccines and Autism. Washington, DC: The National Academies Press. ISBN   0-309-53275-2.
26. Thieu, Nguyen Quang; Ogle, Brian; Pettersson, Hans (2008). "Efficacy of bentonite clay in ameliorating aflatoxicosis in piglets fed aflatoxin contaminated diets". Tropical Animal Health and Production. 40 (8): 649–656. doi:10.1007/s11250-008-9144-3. PMID   18975130. S2CID   21846519.
27. "Kaolin". Medicinenet.com. Are there any interactions with medications?. Archived from the original on 28 July 2016.
28. "Attapulgite Tablet". Drugs.com. Archived from the original on 26 May 2016.
29. Adamis, Zoltán; Williams, Richard B. (2005). Bentonite, Kaolin, and Selected Minerals (PDF). Geneva: World Health Organization. ISBN   9241572310.
30. Bentonite Archived 2009-08-01 at the Wayback Machine from oregonstate.edu website
31. Calamine from www.drugs.com website
32. Maxim LD, Niebo R, McConnell EE (2016). "Bentonite toxicology and epidemiology - a review". Inhal Toxicol. 28 (13): 591–617. doi:10.1080/08958378.2016.1240727. PMID   27809675. S2CID   28266051.
33. Information from Drugs.com
34. FDA Final rule.
35. FDA "Kaopectate reformulation and upcoming labeling changes."
36. "Kaolin Information | Evidenced-Based Supplement Guide on MedicineNet.com - How does Kaolin work?". Medicinenet.com. Retrieved 2012-10-07.

Further reading

• Abehsera, Michel (1979). The Healing Clay: The Centuries-old Health & Beauty Elixir Rediscovered . Brooklyn, NY: Swan House. ISBN   0-918282-10-1. OCLC   12094673.
• Engel, Cindy (2003). Wild Health: Lessons In Natural Wellness From The Animal Kingdom. Houghton Mifflin Harcourt. ISBN   0-618-34068-8.
• Ferrell, RE (2008). "Medicinal clay and spiritual healing". Clays and Clay Minerals. 56 (6): 751–760. Bibcode:2008CCM....56..751F. doi:10.1346/CCMN.2008.0560613. S2CID   129110656.
• Johns, T; Duquette, M (Feb 1991). "Detoxification and mineral supplementation as functions of geophagy". Am J Clin Nutr. 53 (2): 448–56. doi: 10.1093/ajcn/53.2.448 . PMID   1989412.
• Knishinsky, Ran (1998). The Clay Cure – Natural Healing From the Earth. Healing Arts Press.
• Reinbacher, W. Rudolph (2002). Healing Earths: The Third Leg of Medicine : A History of Minerals in Medicine with Rare Illustrations from 300 to 1000 Years Ago. W. Rudolph Reinbacher.
• Retsas, S (2012). Medicinal Use of earths and minerals from Hippocrates to Sir Hans Sloane and beyond. Vol. XVIII. Vesalius. pp. 2, 93–98.
• Rodgers, Paul (27 October 2007). "French muck: Is this the new penicillin?". The Independent. UK.
• Root-Bernstein, Robert; Root-Bernstein, Michele (1997). Honey, Mud, Maggots and Other Medical Marvels . Houghton Mifflin. ISBN   9780395822982.
• Williams, LB; Haydel, SE; et al. (2009). "Bentonite, Bandaids, and Borborygmi". Elements. 5 (2): 99–104. doi:10.2113/gselements.5.2.99. PMC   2895274 . PMID   20607126.