| Ed. | Year | Champion | Score | Runner-up | Venue / city | MVP | Ref. |
|---|
| 1 | 1996 | Evansville (1) | 5–0 | Creighton | Black Beauty Field • Evansville, IN | Sally Meek, Evansville | |
| 2 | 1997 | Evansville(2) | 2–2 (5–4 p) | Eastern Illinois | Cooper Park • Springfield, MO | Laura Poland, Evansville | |
| 3 | 1998 | Evansville(3) | 2–1 | Illinois State | Black Beauty Field • Evansville, IN | Kari Sunderhaus, Evansville | |
| 4 | 1999 | Evansville(4) | 3–2 ( a.e.t. ) | Missouri State | Cooper Complex • Springfield, MO | Tina Allwardt, Evansville | |
| 5 | 2000 | Missouri State(1) | 1–0 | Evansville | SportPort • Maryland Heights, MO | Jennifer Grocki, Missouri State | |
| 6 | 2001 | Evansville(5) | 2–1 | Missouri State | Jessica Schwartz, Evansville | |
| 7 | 2002 | Creighton(1) | 1–0 ( a.e.t. ) | Illinois State | Kelan Brill, Creighton | |
| 8 | 2003 | Illinois State(1) | 0–0 (5–4 p) | Creighton | Chrystal Johnston, Illinois State | |
| 9 | 2004 | Creighton(2) | 3–1 | Drake | Cownie Complex • Des Moines, IA | Katie Brennan, Creighton | |
| 10 | 2005 | Creighton(3) | 1–0 | Drake | Morrison Stadium • Omaha, NE | Marcy Gans, Creighton | |
| 11 | 2006 | Drake(1) | 1–0 ( a.e.t. ) | Evansville | Melissa Nelson, Drake | [2] |
| 12 | 2007 | Creighton(4) | 0–0 (5–4 p) | Illinois State | Black Beauty Field • Evansville, IN | Marcy Gans, Creighton | [3] |
| 13 | 2008 | Evansville(6) | 2–0 | Indiana State | Morrison Stadium • Omaha, NE | Kayla Lambert, Evansville | [4] |
| 14 | 2009 | Illinois State(2) | 1–0 | Creighton | Jessica Carlson, Illinois State | [5] |
| 15 | 2010 | Creighton(5) | 2–1 ( a.e.t. ) | Missouri State | Lauren Cingoranelli, Creighton | [6] |
| 16 | 2011 | Illinois State(3) | 5–0 | Missouri State | Cooper Field • Springfield, MI | Kyla Cross, Illinois State | [7] |
| 17 | 2012 | Illinois State (4) | 5–1 | Indiana State | Morrison Stadium • Omaha, NE | Rachel Tejada, Illinois State | [8] |
| 18 | 2013 | Illinois State(5) | 5–0 | Indiana State | McCutchan Stadium • Evansville, IN | Hannah Leinert, Illinois State | [9] |
| 19 | 2014 | Illinois State(6) | 2–1 | Evansville | Adelaide Street Field • Normal, IL | Rachel Tejada, Illinois State | [10] |
| 20 | 2015 | Evansville(7) | 0–0 (5–3 p) | Loyola Chicago | McCutchan Stadium • Evansville, IN | Whitney Biggs, Evansville | [11] |
| 21 | 2016 | Illinois State(7) | 2–1 | Evansville | Adelaide Street Field • Normal, IL | Lauren Koehl, Illinois State | [12] |
| 22 | 2017 | Missouri State(2) | 1–0 | Northern Iowa | Allison South Stadium • Springfield, MO | Brooke Zimmerman, Missouri State | [13] |
| 23 | 2018 | Loyola Chicago(1) | 3–2 | Drake | Loyola Soccer Park • Chicago, IL | Jenna Szczesny, Loyola Chicago | [14] |
| 24 | 2019 | Loyola Chicago(2) | 2–0 | Illinois State | Allison South Stadium • Springfield, MO | Sienna Cruz, Loyola Chicago | [15] |
| 25 | 2020 | Loyola Chicago(3) | 1–0 | Valparaiso | Loyola Soccer Park • Chicago, IL | Megan Nemec, Loyola Chicago | [16] |
| 26 | 2021 | Loyola Chicago(4) | 4–0 | Evansville | Amanda Cassidy, Loyola Chicago | [17] |
| 27 | 2022 | Missouri State(3) | 1–0 | Murray State | Brown Field • Valparaiso, IN | Kaeli Benedict, Missouri State | [18] |
| 28 | 2023 | Valparaiso(1) | 1–0 | Drake | Cownie Complex • Des Moines, IA | Nikki Coryell, Valparaiso | [19] [20] |
| 29 | 2024 | Missouri State(4) | 4–0 | Drake | Allison South Stadium • Springfield, MO | Grace O'Keefe, Missouri State | [21] [22] |
| 30 | 2025 | UIC Flames (1) | 0–0 (2–1 p) | Illinois State | Adelaide Street Field • Normal, IL | Hannah Gryzik, UIC | [23] |
