Murder of Yoshie Sato

Last updated

Murder of Yoshie Sato
Yokosuka-Chuo2019.jpg
Yokosuka-Chuo station, near to where the incident took place
LocationYokosuka, Kanagawa, Japan
Date3 January 2006;19 years ago (2006-01-03)
c. 6:00 a.m. (JST)
Attack type
Beating, robbery
VictimYoshie Sato
PerpetratorWilliam Oliver Reese
Convictions Murder

On 3 January 2006, 56-year-old Yoshie Sato was murdered by 21-year-old William Oliver Reese in Yokosuka, Japan. Reese was a United States Navy sailor stationed on the USS Kitty Hawk (CV-63) at the time and confessed to the crime. Reese is currently serving life in prison in Japan. The killing led to public calls for a revision of the U.S.–Japan Status of Forces Agreement, [1] which had previously occurred following other incidents of killing and rape by U.S. military personnel. [2]

Contents

Background

Yoshie Sato (Japanese : 佐藤好恵; née Sanada, 真田) was born in Yokosuka on 28 February 1949, as the eldest of three children. Following her second divorce and the death of her parents, she entered a common-law relationship and bought an apartment together with her fiancé. She had three children and six grandchildren. Sato was employed as a bus cleaner and despite the three-day holiday season for Japanese New Year, Sato had been on her way to work at the time of her death. [3] [4] [5]

William Oliver Reese was born in Pittsgrove, New Jersey, United States, to an African-American family. He held the rank of seaman and had been stationed in Japan since 2004 on his first assigment. [6] [7] [8] [9]

Murder

On 3 January 2006, William Oliver Reese was near the Yokosuka-Chūō train station when he accosted 56-year-old Yoshie Sato, demanding money. Reese was intoxicated at the time. At first, he asked her for directions to the nearby naval base, and after she pointed it out to him, he attempted to take her purse. When Sato began yelling for help, Reese dragged her to a nearby stairwell and beat her for 11 minutes. Sato later died of a ruptured kidney. The initial robbery attempt was recorded on surveillance footage. [10] [11] [12]

He then removed 15,000 yen (equivalent to $131) [13] from her purse and left the scene. Some accounts claim that Reese was apprehended by US Navy sentries at the main gate to Yokosuka Naval Base, who became suspicious when they noticed Reese's bloodstained clothes. Other accounts state that he was caught aboard the Kitty Hawk as he attempted to return to work. Reese claimed that he had no idea why he killed her. [14] [15] [16]

International repercussions

Reese was indicted and made a full confession. He pled guilty, but claimed that he had not intended to kill Sato. Reese was convicted on 3 June 2006 and sentenced to life imprisonment. [1] [17] While judges called the murder "shocking" and "dreadful," they cited Reese's confession, among other factors, as their justification for sparing him from a possible death sentence. [18]

A U.S. Navy official issued an apology on behalf of the United States during Sato's funeral. Sato's brother Shuichi Sanada stated that they wished that the military educated its troops more to prevent "a serious social problem". Sato's youngest son Katsuki said that he was hoping for the death penalty for Reese, but otherwise held no ill will against the navy. [3]

On 6 January 2006, restrictions were enacted by the U.S. Navy upon its sailors stationed in Yokosuka. The CNFJ, which blamed the attack on unregulared alcohol abuse, issued a four-day "period of reflection" for American military personnel in Japan, which included a curfew and ban for personnel regarding city entry for personnel of Yokosuka Naval Base and Naval Air Facility Atsugi, as well as detailed "liberty plans," written statements of a sailor's exact whereabouts throughout the day. [19] [20] [21]

Sato's murder was considered the most severe of a number of highly-publicised violent crimes committed by U.S. servicemen, which included a hit-and-run that injured three elementary school students in Hachioji by another USS Kitty Hawk sailor, as well as an assault on a taxi driver in Yokohama by a drunk U.S. Navy petty officer. [22] [23]

In October 2006, the Sato family filed a civil lawsuit against the Japanese government, the U.S. Navy and William Reese for 200 million yen (equivalent to $1,700,000), citing a NATO status of forces provision for victim compensation. [24] In 2013, the Supreme Court of Japan ruled that Reese would pay the demanded sum, as only he could be held liable for the crime. Sato's husband, Masanori Yamazaki, criticised U.S. officials for framing the murder as "a chance to make the Japan-U.S. alliance even stronger". As Reese was unable to pay the compensation, the American government offered to pay 40% of the originally agreed sum to Yamazaki, which he refused on account of the settlement including a clause absolving the United States and Reese of further liability. In 2017, Yamazaki agreed to sign the document if the demand for immunity was dropped. As of 2020, no updates had been made regarding the settlement. [4]

See also

References

  1. 1 2 "Political Affairs Magazine - Japan: U.S. Kitty Hawk sailor kills Japanese woman in Yokosuka". www.politicalaffairs.net. Archived from the original on 11 July 2007.
  2. Wallace, Bruce (6 January 2006). "U.S. sailor a suspect in beating death of Japanese woman". Wilmington Star-News. Retrieved 16 May 2025.
  3. 1 2 Kusumoto, Hana (1 June 2006). "Brother recalls Yokosuka victim's willingness to fight back". Stars and Stripes.
  4. 1 2 "Husband of woman murdered by American sailor keeps up fight for Japan, US accountability". Mainichi Daily News. 5 June 2020.
  5. "山崎裁判が結審、秋の判決に向けて署名へのご協力をよびかけます". 神奈川労連 (in Japanese). 28 June 2011.
  6. "Japan jails US sailor for murder". BBC. 2 June 2006.
  7. Johnson, Tim (14 January 2006). "U.S. faces new ire after deadly beating in Japan". Inquirer.
  8. "U.S. sailor convicted of death in Japan". Tampa Bay Times. 3 June 2006.
  9. "US Navy hands over murder suspect". ABC News. 7 January 2006.
  10. "Archived Article". stripes.com.
  11. "NBC10.com - News - South Jersey Sailor Accused Of Killing Woman In Japan". www.nbc10.com. Archived from the original on 13 January 2006.
  12. "William Reese". usp.com.au.
  13. Brooke, James (23 January 2006). "Sailor's Case Reflects Shift in U.S. Image for Japanese". The New York Times. ISSN   0362-4331.
  14. "Page currently unavailable".
  15. "NBC10.com - News - South Jersey Sailor Accused Of Killing Woman In Japan". www.nbc10.com. Archived from the original on 13 January 2006.
  16. "Prisoner Images". usp.com.au.
  17. "U.S. Sailor Convicted in Robbery, Slaying". Los Angeles Times. 2 June 2006.
  18. "Kitty Hawk sailor gets life term for killing Japanese woman". Stars and Stripes. 4 June 2006.
  19. "Stars & Stripes". www.stripes.com. Archived from the original on 21 February 2006.
  20. "Archived Article". stripes.com.
  21. Batdorff, Allison (8 January 2006). "CNFJ calls for 'period of reflection' after fatal beating". Stars and Stripes.
  22. "米兵犯罪賠償、日本政府が6割負担 遺族「なぜ肩代わり」 | 社会". カナロコ by 神奈川新聞 (in Japanese). 18 November 2017.
  23. "Japan: U.S. Kitty Hawk sailor kills Japanese woman in Yokosuka". politicalaffairs.net. 15 January 2006.
  24. "Slain Yokosuka woman's family files $1.7M suit". Stars and Stripes. 10 October 2006.