National Insurance (Australia)

*National Health and Pensions Insurance Act 1938*^[11]
National Health and Pensions Insurance Act 1938
Parliament of Australia
	Long title An Act to provide for Insurance against certain Contingencies affecting Employees, and the Wives, Children, Widows, and Orphans of Employees, and for other purposes. ;
Assented to	5 July 1938
Repealed	1 July 1947
Introduced by	Lyons government
	Status: Repealed

Last updated June 26, 2024

A series of contemporary cartoons depicting (1) the Lyons government's initial adoption of the scheme, (2) contemporary criticisms of the scheme, (3) conflict within the government over the scheme, and (4) the scheme's ultimate abandonment.

National Insurance was a planned system of social security in Australia which would have provided medical, disability, unemployment and pension coverage to its contributors and their dependents. The scheme was passed into law by the Lyons government as the National Health and Pensions Insurance Act 1938, but was abandoned the following year in order to divert funds to defence.^[1]

Background

There were few serious proposals for a comprehensive social insurance scheme in Australia before World War I, as it was seen as unfeasible.^[2] In 1911, deputy opposition leader Joseph Cook told federal parliament that "the more I think of it the more convinced I am that we must come ultimately to a form of national insurance which will give every man–the millionaire as well as the poor man–who has subscribed to his own insurance fund the right to receive that insurance, without taint of pauperism or charity, in his old age".^[3]

Advocates of greater federal government involvement in healthcare were divided between those who supported centralised public health services providing universal healthcare and those who supported contributory insurance-based schemes.^[4]

Bruce–Page government

At the 1922 federal election, the Country Party's platform included plans for a national insurance scheme covering "sickness, unemployment, poverty and age". After the election the party's leader Earle Page, a trained surgeon and strong supporter of the scheme, entered into a coalition with the Nationalist Party under S. M. Bruce, who became prime minister.^[5] In 1923, the new government announced plans for a comprehensive social services system that would "remove altogether the taint of pauperism".^[6]It subsequently established the Royal Commission on National Insurance under the chairmanship of Nationalist senator John Millen,^[7] which ran from 7 September 1923 to 5 October 1927.^[8]

1928 bill

In September 1928, Page introduced the National Insurance Bill into the House of Representatives, which "provided for sickness, old age, disability and maternity benefits, mainly paid for by compulsory contributions by workers and employers, along with smaller payments to parents of children under 16 and to orphans".^[9] The legislation failed to pass before the 1928 federal election, although the government heavily promoted the scheme during the election campaign. The scheme was postponed indefinitely the following year, prior to the government's parliamentary defeat on a no-confidence motion and defeat at an early election.^[10]

1938 act

The Lyons government, a coalition between the United Australia Party and Australian Country Party, was re-elected at the 1937 federal election on a platform which included a national insurance scheme covering both old-age pensions and healthcare. The strongest advocates of national insurance within the UAP were treasurer Richard Casey and former minister Frederick Stewart, while Prime Minister Joseph Lyons was lukewarm towards the idea and many Country MPs were hostile.^[12]

Drafting and provisions

The government's legislation was largely modelled on its British equivalents and was drafted by British civil servants.^[12] However, unlike in the UK, administrative control over the scheme was to be vested in a National Insurance Commission. Its final form was largely due to financial considerations, with the legislation required the scheme to become self-financing as soon as possible.^[13] It ultimately included contributory schemes for sickness and disability, old-age pensions, payments for widows and orphans, and child endowment.^[14] Many specialist medical services were excluded from the scheme, including anaesthesia, pathology, x-rays, venereal diseases, abortions, miscarriages and stillbirths.^[15] The health and pension insurance components (known as the Kinnear scheme after their author) were to be enacted separately to the unemployment insurance component.^[12]

Although the Australian branches of the British Medical Association (BMA) were largely in favour of a contributory health insurance scheme, the medical profession ultimately came into conflict with the government over the scheme. The initial conflict was over the size of the capitation fees payable to doctors, with general practitioners claiming they would have to increase their workload in order to maintain their income.^[16]

One provision of the act excluded Indigenous Australian workers in remote areas from contribution requirements "where collecting contributions was deemed impracticable".^[17]

Enactment

The National Health and Pensions Insurance Bill was introduced to parliament on 4 May 1938. The government sought to insurance swift passage of the legislation, as it had suffered losses in the Senate at the previous election and wished to ensure passage before new opposition senators were seated on 1 July. Dissident Country MPs, led by Hubert Lawrence Anthony and Arthur Fadden, secured several concessions.^[18]

Aftermath

In 1944, Richard Casey wrote to General Archibald Wavell defending the substance of the scheme and stating that it was inevitable that it would be revived after the war. He stated "it will be my bill and my scheme – and no argument and no playing-of-politics can gainsay that".^[19] Casey told journalist Jack Hetherington in 1964 that the decision to abandon the scheme was made “largely at Mr Lyons’ instigation, by reason of his belief that [...] we could not finance it”. However, he wrote to Fred Daly in 1956 that “on my own personal initiative, I recommended to Cabinet the withdrawal of the legislation [...] for reasons that were connected with the quite obvious on-coming war”. Menzies recalled in later years that Casey had recommended to cabinet that the scheme be dropped to avoid political controversy.^[20]

Related Research Articles

Sir Earle Christmas Grafton Page was an Australian politician and surgeon who served as the 11th prime minister of Australia from 7 to 26 April 1939, holding office in a caretaker capacity following the death of Joseph Lyons. He was the leader of the Country Party from 1921 to 1939, and was the most influential figure in its later years.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Ben Chifley</span> Prime Minister of Australia from 1945 to 1949

Joseph Benedict Chifley was an Australian politician and train driver who served as the 16th prime minister of Australia from 1945 to 1949. He held office as the leader of the Australian Labor Party (ALP), having previously served as the treasurer of Australia under Prime Minister John Curtin and later himself from 1941 to 1949. He was notable for defining Australia's post-war reconstruction efforts.

Medicare is the publicly funded universal health care insurance scheme in Australia operated by the nation's social security agency, Services Australia. The scheme either partially or fully covers the cost of most health care, with services being delivered by state and territory governments or private enterprises. All Australian citizens and permanent residents are eligible to enrol in Medicare, as well as international visitors from 11 countries that have reciprocal agreements for medically necessary treatment.

Johan Nygaardsvold was a Norwegian politician from the Labour Party who served as the 21st prime minister of Norway from 1935 to 1945. From June 1940 until May 1945, he oversaw the Norwegian Government-in-exile from London as head of the Nygaardsvold cabinet during the occupation of Norway by Nazi Germany.

Welfare, or commonly social welfare, is a type of government support intended to ensure that members of a society can meet basic human needs such as food and shelter. Social security may either be synonymous with welfare, or refer specifically to social insurance programs which provide support only to those who have previously contributed, as opposed to social assistance programs which provide support on the basis of need alone. The International Labour Organization defines social security as covering support for those in old age, support for the maintenance of children, medical treatment, parental and sick leave, unemployment and disability benefits, and support for sufferers of occupational injury.

Workers' compensation or workers' comp is a form of insurance providing wage replacement and medical benefits to employees injured in the course of employment in exchange for mandatory relinquishment of the employee's right to sue his or her employer for the tort of negligence. The trade-off between assured, limited coverage and lack of recourse outside the worker compensation system is known as "the compensation bargain.” One of the problems that the compensation bargain solved is the problem of employers becoming insolvent as a result of high damage awards. The system of collective liability was created to prevent that and thus to ensure security of compensation to the workers.

The Fair Deal was a set of proposals put forward by U.S. President Harry S. Truman to Congress in 1945 and in his January 1949 State of the Union Address. More generally, the term characterizes the entire domestic agenda of the Truman administration, from 1945 to 1953. It offered new proposals to continue New Deal liberalism, but with a conservative coalition controlling Congress, only a few of its major initiatives became law and then only if they had considerable Republican Party support. As Richard Neustadt concludes, the most important proposals were aid to education, national health insurance, the Fair Employment Practices Commission, and repeal of the Taft–Hartley Act. They were all debated at length, then voted down. Nevertheless, enough smaller and less controversial items passed that liberals could claim some success.

The U.S. Railroad Retirement Board (RRB) is an independent agency in the executive branch of the United States government created in 1935 to administer a social insurance program providing retirement benefits to the country's railroad workers.

Clement Attlee was invited by King George VI to form the Attlee ministry in the United Kingdom in July 1945, succeeding Winston Churchill as Prime Minister of the United Kingdom. The Labour Party had won a landslide victory at the 1945 general election, and went on to enact policies of what became known as the post-war consensus, including the establishment of the welfare state and the nationalisation of some industries. The government's spell in office was marked by post-war austerity measures, the violent crushing of pro-independence and communist movements in Malaya, the grant of independence to India, the engagement in the Cold War against Soviet Communism as well as the creation of the country's National Health Service (NHS).

National health insurance (NHI), sometimes called statutory health insurance (SHI), is a system of health insurance that insures a national population against the costs of health care. It may be administered by the public sector, the private sector, or a combination of both. Funding mechanisms vary with the particular program and country. National or statutory health insurance does not equate to government-run or government-financed health care, but is usually established by national legislation. In some countries, such as Australia's Medicare system, the UK's National Health Service and South Korea's National Health Insurance Service, contributions to the system are made via general taxation and therefore are not optional even though use of the health system it finances is. In practice, most people paying for NHI will join it. Where an NHI involves a choice of multiple insurance funds, the rates of contributions may vary and the person has to choose which insurance fund to belong to.

Sir Frederick Harold Stewart was an Australian businessman, politician and government minister. His continuing political commitment was to the establishment of a national insurance scheme and the shortening of working hours to improve social conditions during the Great Depression, despite the opposition of his own party.

The National Insurance Act 1911 created National Insurance, originally a system of health insurance for industrial workers in Great Britain based on contributions from employers, the government, and the workers themselves. It was one of the foundations of the modern welfare state. It also provided unemployment insurance for designated cyclical industries. It formed part of the wider social welfare reforms of the Liberal Governments of 1906–1915, led by Henry Campbell-Bannerman and H. H. Asquith. David Lloyd George, the Liberal Chancellor of the Exchequer, was the prime moving force behind its design, negotiations with doctors and other interest groups, and final passage, assisted by Home Secretary Winston Churchill.

The Labour Party governed the United Kingdom from 1974 to 1979. During this period, Harold Wilson and James Callaghan were successively appointed as Prime Minister by Queen Elizabeth II. The end of the Callaghan ministry was presaged by the Winter of Discontent, a period of serious industrial discontent. This was followed by the election of Conservative leader Margaret Thatcher in 1979.

Social welfare has long been an important part of New Zealand society and a significant political issue. It is concerned with the provision by the state of benefits and services. Together with fiscal welfare and occupational welfare, it makes up the social policy of New Zealand. Social welfare is mostly funded through general taxation. Since the 1980s welfare has been provided on the basis of need; the exception is universal superannuation.

Social security, in Australia, refers to a system of social welfare payments provided by Australian Government to eligible Australian citizens, permanent residents, and limited international visitors. These payments are almost always administered by Centrelink, a program of Services Australia. In Australia, most payments are means tested.

Welfare in France includes all systems whose purpose is to protect people against the financial consequences of social risks.

The social security system in Spain is its principal system of social protection. The concept of social security first appeared in Spain in 1883 under the Committee for Social Reform, it was expanded several times during the twentieth century and finally the right to social security was enshrined in the Spanish Constitution of 1978 under Article 41 which states "that the public authorities shall maintain a public social security system for all citizens, guaranteeing sufficient support and social benefits in situations of need, especially in the event of unemployment, and that the support and additional benefits shall be free".

The Social Security Act 1938 is a New Zealand Act of Parliament concerning unemployment insurance which established New Zealand as a welfare state. This act is important in the history of social welfare, as it established the first ever social security system in the world.

The Lyons government was the federal executive government of Australia led by Prime Minister Joseph Lyons. It was made up of members of the United Australia Party in the Australian Parliament from January 1932 until the death of Joseph Lyons in 1939. Lyons negotiated a coalition with the Country Party after the 1934 Australian federal election. The Lyons government stewarded Australia's recovery from the Great Depression and established the Australian Broadcasting Corporation.

Invalidity Benefit was a benefit from the United Kingdom's National Insurance scheme that was introduced in 1971 by Edward Heath's government. It was paid to people who had been invalided out of their trade or occupation after sustaining an injury or developing a long-term illness. It was replaced by Incapacity Benefit in 1995.

References

↑ Thornton, Danielle; Bowman, Dina; Mallett, Shelley (2020). Safety net to poverty trap?: The twentieth-century origins of Australia's uneven social security system (PDF). Brotherhood of St Laurence. pp. 10–11.
↑ Gillespie 1991, p. 88.
↑ Arthur, Don (20 December 2021). "Myths of entitlement: a history of the Age Pension and the National Welfare Fund" (PDF). Research Paper Series, 2021-22. Australian Parliamentary Library. p. 8.
↑ Gillespie 1991, p. 33.
↑ Hawkins, John (2009). "Earle Page: an active treasurer" (PDF). Economic Roundup (4). Treasury: 57.
↑ Arthur 2021, p. 8.
↑ Bennett, Scott (2004). "Millen, John Dunlop (1877–1941)". The Biographical Dictionary of the Australian Senate. Vol. 2. Melbourne University Press.
↑ "Royal Commissions and Commissions of Inquiry". www.aph.gov.au. Parliament House, Canberra. Retrieved 2022-12-30.
↑ Wilks, Stephen (2020). 'Now is the Psychological Moment': Earle Page and the Imagining of Australia (PDF). ANU Press. p. 175. ISBN 9781760463687.
↑ Wilks 2020, p. 176.
↑ "National Health and Pensions Insurance Act 1938". Federal Register of Legislation. Retrieved 1 May 2022.
1 2 3 Gillespie 1991, p. 91.
↑ Gillespie 1991, p. 92.
↑ Gillespie 1991, p. 98.
↑ Gillespie 1991, p. 99.
↑ Gillespie 1991, pp. 93–95.
↑ Murphy, John (2013). "Conditional Inclusion: Aborigines and Welfare Rights in Australia, 1900–47". Australian Historical Studies. 44 (2): 211–212. doi:10.1080/1031461X.2013.791707.
↑ Gillespie 1991, pp. 98–99.
↑ Hudson 1986, p. 145.
↑ Hudson, William James (1986). Casey. Oxford University Press. p. 105. ISBN 0195547306.

Bibliography

Gillespie, James (1991). The Price of Health: Australian Governments and Medical Politics 1910-1960. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press. ISBN 9780521523226. OCLC 49638492.
National Insurance: A Summary of the Principles of the Australian National Health and Pensions Insurance Act 1938. National Insurance Commission. 1938.