Newport Association Football Club Ltd and others v Football Association of Wales Ltd

Last updated

Newport Association Football Club Ltd and others v Football Association of Wales Ltd
Royal Coat of Arms of the United Kingdom.svg
Court High Court of Justice
Full case nameNewport Association Football Club Ltd and others v Football Association of Wales Ltd [1995] 2 ALL ER 87
Decided11 April 1995
Citation(s)2 ALL ER 87
Court membership
Judge sitting William Blackburne
Case opinions
Preventing Welsh clubs that play in England from playing in Wales is an unlawful restraint of trade
Decision byMr Justice Blackburne

Newport Association Football Club Ltd and others v Football Association of Wales Ltd [1995] 2 ALL ER 87 is a High Court of Justice court case between Newport A.F.C. and the Football Association of Wales (FAW). The case resolved around the Football Association of Wales refusing to allow Newport A.F.C. to play their home games in Wales owing to them choosing to remain in the English football pyramid instead of joining the newly formed League of Wales. Newport appealed this as a restraint of trade. The court found in favour of Newport and issued an injunction preventing the FAW stopping Newport from playing in Wales.

Contents

Background

Newport County A.F.C. were originally founded in 1912 and were one of a number of football clubs in industrial South Wales invited to join the Southern Football League. At the end of the 1919–20 season the majority of the Southern League became the new Third Division of the Football League. In 1989, having been automatically relegated out of the Football League the previous season, the club was liquidated with debts of £330,000. Fans created Newport A.F.C. as a phoenix club — however they were barred by Newport City Council from using their old Somerton Park ground as the council viewed the new company as a continuation of the old and asserted they owed back rent for the ground. [1] Whereas the FAW ruled they were a new club with no connection to Newport County. [2] The club's stated aim was to regain Football League status, and as such, they started in the Hellenic League, which as part of the English football league system allowed eventual promotion back to that level and as Wales had historically had no national league. [3] [4]

In 1992, the FAW created the League of Wales and invited Newport to join. The club declined and although the FAW had granted permission for them to continue to play in the English leagues, they banned them and any other Welsh club playing in the English leagues below the Football League from playing their scheduled matches at home in Wales. [5] The legal reasoning for being able to do this was not revealed though it was stated it was designed to promote the League of Wales, despite no contractual obligations between the FAW and Newport requiring member clubs to join existing. [6] [7] This resulted in Newport having to groundshare with Moreton Town F.C. in Gloucestershire. [8] [9] This decision also affected seven other Welsh clubs that played in the English football pyramid, Bangor City, Barry Town, Caernarfon Town, Colwyn Bay, Merthyr Tydfil, Newtown and Rhyl, whom began to be referred to by the Welsh press as the "Irate Eight". [10] [11] Subsequently, four of the affected clubs joined the League of Wales, but Merthyr Tydfil, Newport, Caernarfon Town and Colwyn Bay remained. The latter three appealed the FAW's decision but their appeal was rejected after a hearing. [12]

After a failed attempt at obtaining arbitration and due to the excessive costs of playing 80 miles away in England, Newport sued the FAW on the grounds of restraint of trade in what had been stated as the first occasion where an individual football club has taken its football association to court. [1] [13] They also cited inconsistencies in application as Merthyr Tydfil played in the Football Conference yet were allowed to play their home games in Wales and had permission to continue to play in Wales if they were relegated. [14] This was due to Merthyr Tidfil being successful in an independent FAW appeal. [15]

Case

The case was heard at the High Court in London before Mr Justice William Blackburne in April 1995. [16] The clubs requested an urgent injunction to allow them to play in Wales during the case and sought a declaratory judgement that the FAW's decision to ban them from playing in Wales was an unreasonable restraint of trade and requested £300,000 each in compensation for breach of contract. [12] [14] [17] The clubs stated they would not be able to continue to operate due to the expense of not playing at home. [12] [17] The FAW responded saying the court had no jurisdiction to grant an injunction without the declaratory judgement. [12] They also claimed that the ban was needed in order to protect Welsh clubs' representation in order to partake in UEFA run European competitions. [5] The court had previously ruled in August 1994 that it did have the power to issue such an injuction if it wished. [18]

Mr Justice Blackburne considered the case based upon the case of Pharmaceutical Society of Great Britain v Dickson. He ruled on 11 April that the FAW's ruling had been a restraint of trade but considered whether this was a justified one. [12] He ruled that it was not as it was not necessary to protect recognition of the new League of Wales by UEFA and the FAW ruling was done specifically to get the clubs to play in the Welsh league system. [12] He also ruled that UEFA had never offered an opinion on the matter, the FAW had provided no evidence that UEFA would discriminate against Welsh clubs and the fact that the FAW had permitted the clubs to continue to play in the English leagues had not prevented UEFA recognising the league. [12] He also recognised that there was a genuine risk that the clubs could cease to exist, if they played another season away from home, due to the financial burdens. [17] Accordingly, he ruled that the FAW's ban on playing in Wales was an "unlawful and unreasonable restraint of trade" and granted judgment in favour of Newport and the other clubs, allowing them to play at home in Wales. [1] He also granted the injunction to prohibit the FAW from banning clubs playing in Wales if they played in the English league. [19] However, the breach of contract compensation claims were denied. [20]

Aftermath

Despite the judgment in favour of Newport, the world football governing body FIFA announced they would seek to ban the 3 clubs from playing as a punishment for suing the FAW. [5] 10 days after the ruling, FIFA informed The Football Association (The FA) that all three were banned from football indefinitely with the club officials behind the lawsuit all receiving two year bans. [21] However in December 1995, following a request from the FAW "in the interests of peace", [22] the bans were later rescinded in favour of a requirement that the clubs join the League of Wales by 1997, which never occurred. [23] In 1997, FIFA did not attempt to enforce the requirement. [24]

Though the clubs played in leagues governed by The FA, jurisdiction for disciplinary matters relating for the Welsh clubs in English leagues remained with the FAW. This situation continued until 2011 when it was revealed that Cardiff City could not be punished for breaching FA third-party ownership rules as the FAW had no such rules. [25] Following this revelation, The FA would assert disciplinary jurisdiction over Welsh clubs playing in the English Football League. [26] [27]

Newport would subsequently repurchase the trademark for their previous club's name and would compete as Newport County A.F.C., winning promotion to the Football League in 2013. [1] Caenarfon Town, however, would resign from the Northern Premier League after the 1994–95 season, opting to join the League of Wales despite the ruling. [28] Colwyn Bay would follow suit in 2019, leaving the Northern Premier League Division One West to join the FAW's Cymru North. [29]

Related Research Articles

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Newport County A.F.C.</span> Association football club in Newport, Wales

Newport County Association Football Club is a professional association football club in the city of Newport, South Wales. The team compete in EFL League Two, the fourth level of the English football league system. The club's usual home colours are amber shirts and black shorts.

The Cymru Premier, known as the JD Cymru Premier for sponsorship reasons, is the national football league of Wales. It has both professional and semi-professional status clubs and is at the top of the Welsh football league system. Prior to 2002, the league was known as the League of Wales (LoW), but changed its name as part of a sponsorship deal to the Welsh Premier League. The league was rebranded as the Cymru Premier for the 2019–20 season.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Football Association of Wales</span> Governing body of association football in Wales

The Football Association of Wales is the governing body of association football and futsal in Wales, and controls the Wales national football team, its corresponding women's team, as well as the Wales national futsal team. It is a member of FIFA, UEFA and the IFAB.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Barry Town United F.C.</span> Association football club in Wales

Barry Town United Football Club is a semi-professional association football team based in Barry, Wales. They are known for representing Wales in Europe as winners of the Cymru Premier and Welsh Cup during the 1990s and early 2000s and have also competed in England's Southern League and FA Cup. The team, which has contained more than 50 full internationals, is now run by supporters. They play at their traditional home of Jenner Park, Barry, which holds 3,500 spectators.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Welsh Cup</span> Association football competition in Wales

The FAW Welsh Cup, currently known as the JD Welsh Cup for sponsorship reasons, is a knock-out football competition contested annually by teams in the Welsh football league system. It is considered the most prestigious of the cup competitions in domestic Welsh association football.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Wrexham A.F.C.</span> Association football club in Wrexham, Wales

Wrexham Association Football Club is a professional association football club based in Wrexham, Wales. Formed in 1864, it is the oldest club in Wales and the third-oldest professional association football team in the world. They compete in EFL League Two, the fourth level of the English football league system.

The FAW Premier Cup was a Welsh football cup competition, organised annually by the Football Association of Wales from 1997 to 2008. Since the FAW excluded clubs playing in English leagues from playing in the Welsh Cup from 1996 onwards, the FAW needed another competition where the best Welsh teams could compete.

The Welsh football league system is a series of football leagues with regular promotion and relegation between them.

Association football is organised on a separate basis in each of the four constituent countries that make up the United Kingdom (UK), with each having a national football association responsible for the overall management of football within their respective country. There is no United Kingdom national football team. Football has been the most popular sport in the UK since the 1860s. Rugby union, rugby league and cricket are other popular sports.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Merthyr Town F.C.</span> Association football club in Merthyr Tydfil, Wales

Merthyr Town Football Club is a Welsh semi-professional football club based in Merthyr Tydfil, currently playing in the Southern League Premier Division South, in the seventh tier of the English football league system.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Colwyn Bay F.C.</span> Association football club in Wales

Colwyn Bay Football Club is a professional football club based in Old Colwyn in north Wales. They are currently members of the Cymru Premier. Nicknamed the Seagulls, but also known as 'The Bay', their home ground is Llanelian Road in Old Colwyn.

Association football is one of the most popular sports in Wales, along with rugby union. Wales has produced club teams of varying fortunes since the early birth of football during the Victorian period, and in 1876 a Wales national football team played their first international match. Football has always had a close rivalry with the country's de facto national sport rugby union, and it is much discussed as to which is Wales' more popular game. The Football Association of Wales (FAW), was established in 1876 to oversee the Wales national team and govern the sport in Wales, later creating and running the Welsh football league system.

The 1992–93 League of Wales was the inaugural season of the League of Wales, the top division of Welsh football. The League was made up of 20 member clubs that joined from leagues within both the English football league system and Welsh football league system.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Danny Holmes</span> English footballer

Daniel Holmes is an English football manager and former player who is currently managing Northern Premier League club Vauxhall Motors. He is a product of Tranmere Rovers' youth system.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">2011–12 Welsh Cup</span> Football tournament season

The 2011–12 FAW Welsh Cup was the 125th season of the annual knockout tournament for competitive football teams in Wales. The 2011–12 tournament commenced on 13 August 2011, and ran until the final in May 2012. The winner of the Cup qualified to the first qualifying round of the 2012–13 UEFA Europa League.

Women's football in Wales is overseen by the Football Association of Wales and is affiliated with both the world (FIFA) and European (UEFA) football governing bodies. As such the national team are eligible to compete in the World Cup and the European Championship. The winners of the top tier league is invited to join the qualifying stage of the Champions League.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">2021–22 Welsh Cup</span> Football tournament season

The 2021–22 FAW Welsh Cup was the 134rd season of the annual knockout tournament for competitive football teams in Wales. The New Saints were the competition's winners, the eighth time they had triumphed.

References

  1. 1 2 3 4 "FA Cup: 'Newport v Man Utd not possible without my dad'". BBC News. 27 January 2024. Retrieved 31 January 2024.
  2. ↑ "The story of Newport County and how they became star of FA Cup". Wales Online. 16 February 2019. Retrieved 31 January 2024.
  3. ↑ James, Stuart (15 February 2019). "Newport County: The inside story of a club that rose from the dead". The Guardian. Retrieved 13 March 2024.
  4. ↑ "Cymru Premier celebrates 30-year anniversary". BBC Sport. Retrieved 31 January 2024.
  5. 1 2 3 "FAW loses court case". The Independent. 12 April 1995. Retrieved 31 January 2024.
  6. ↑ "Now FAW in MP probe" . Sport on Sunday. 19 July 1992. Retrieved 11 March 2024– via Newspapers.com.
  7. ↑ Fordham, Michael (2001). Judicial Review Handbook. Bloomsbury Academic. p. 1109. ISBN   9781841132389.
  8. ↑ "League Two club to mark 30th anniversary of groundshare". Gloucestershire Live. 5 July 2019. Retrieved 31 January 2024.
  9. ↑ "Newport County: 30 years since going bust". BBC Sport. Retrieved 31 January 2024.
  10. ↑ "Why a European Super League would destroy the domestic game in a way we've already seen in Wales". Football Times. 19 November 2018. Retrieved 31 January 2024.
  11. ↑ "Reddy: Irate Eight may go to court" . Wales on Sunday. 29 September 1991. Retrieved 31 January 2024– via Newspapers.com.
  12. 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 De La Rochefaucauld, Estelle. "Collection of Sports-related case law" (PDF). Sport and Law Commission: 55–56. Retrieved 31 January 2024.
  13. ↑ "A Sport Courting Disaster". New York Times. 3 August 1995. Retrieved 31 January 2024.
  14. 1 2 "Football: Welsh exiles to take legal action over home ban: Non-League". The Independent. 28 April 1994. Retrieved 31 January 2024.
  15. ↑ "League storm is still with us" . South Wales Echo. 27 August 1992. Retrieved 11 March 2024– via Newspapers.com.
  16. ↑ Williams, Aled (3 May 2013). "Conference play-off final: Newport's 25-year dream". BBC Sport. Retrieved 11 March 2024.
  17. 1 2 3 Greenfield, Steve (2001). Regulating Football: Commodification, Consumption and the Law. Pluto Press. p. 130. ISBN   9780745310268.
  18. ↑ "Law Report: Case Summaries". The Independent. 14 August 1994. Retrieved 31 January 2024.
  19. ↑ "Sport and the Law" (PDF). University of Glamorgan. Retrieved 31 January 2024.
  20. ↑ "Exiles win court case" . South Wales Echo. 12 April 1995. Retrieved 31 January 2024– via Newspapers.com.
  21. ↑ "Fifa hits Welsh clubs with ban". The Independent. 3 April 1995. Retrieved 31 January 2024.
  22. ↑ "Official ban lifted" . South Wales Echo. 14 December 1995. Retrieved 31 January 2024– via Newspapers.com.
  23. ↑ "Looking Back.....Season 1994/95". Southern Football League. Retrieved 31 January 2024.
  24. ↑ "No Surrender!" . Wales on Sunday. 17 August 1997. Retrieved 31 January 2024– via Newspapers.com.
  25. ↑ "Same division but different rules for Cardiff City". The Guardian. 5 May 2011. Retrieved 28 February 2024.
  26. ↑ "Football Association breaks Welsh jurisdiction over Cardiff and Swansea". The Guardian. 6 May 2011. Retrieved 28 February 2024.
  27. ↑ "Explained: Why Welsh teams play in the 'English' Premier League". Goal.com. 3 November 2019. Retrieved 28 February 2024.
  28. ↑ Duke, Vic (2014). Football, Nationality and the State (reprint ed.). Routledge. p. 22. ISBN   9781317886730.
  29. ↑ "End of an era for Welsh exiles Colwyn Bay". BBC Sport. 26 April 2019. Retrieved 31 January 2024.
This page is based on this Wikipedia article
Text is available under the CC BY-SA 4.0 license; additional terms may apply.
Images, videos and audio are available under their respective licenses.