Oakland County Child Killer

Oakland County Child Killer
Sketches of the suspect.
Other names	The Babysitter Killer The Babysitter The Snow Murderer
Details
Victims	4+
Span of crimes	February 15, 1976 –March 16, 1977 (Confirmed)
Country	United States
State(s)	Michigan

The Oakland County Child Killer (OCCK) is the name given to the perpetrator(s) responsible for the serial killings of at least four children in Oakland County, Michigan, United States, between 1976 and 1977. The victims were held captive before being killed, and forensic DNA testing has indirectly implicated two suspects, one of whom has since died, with the other serving life in prison for offenses against children. A DNA profile of the main perpetrator was created from samples taken from some of the victims' bodies, but does not match the DNA of anyone named in connection with the case; the perpetrator's identity is unknown. ^[1]

Background

Between February 15, 1976, and March 16, 1977, two boys and two girls aged between 10 and 12 went missing outside their homes, en route to or from another location, in Oakland County, Michigan, northwest of Detroit. Each child's body was discovered in a public area within nineteen days of his or her disappearance. The children were all either strangled or shot, with the two boys having been sexually abused. Once the victims were dead, the offender dispersed their bodies around Oakland County in places where they could be seen from roadways. The four deaths triggered a murder investigation which at the time was the largest in U.S. history, ^[2] with Detroit's two daily newspapers, as well as the area's numerous radio and television stations, covering the case. A presentation on WXYT radio, entitled Winter's Fear: The Children, the Killer, the Search, won the Peabody Award in 1977.

Victims

Confirmed

• Mark Douglas Stebbins, 12, of Ferndale, did not return home from an American Legion Hall on February 15, 1976. His body was found four days later, wearing the same clothes he was last seen in, lying on a pile of wood and dirt in the parking lot of a local office building in Southfield. He had been strangled and sexually abused with a foreign object, and had two lacerations to the left rear of his head. ^[3] Rope marks were evident on both his wrists and ankles, indicating he had been bound during his captivity. ^[4]
• Jill Robinson, 12, of Royal Oak, left her home on December 22, 1976, following an argument with her mother over dinner preparations. The following day, her bicycle was found behind a local hobby store, before her body was found alongside Interstate 75 in Troy, within view of Troy police station, on the morning of December 26. She had been shot in the face with a 12-gauge shotgun, and her body was fully clothed and wearing the backpack she had taken with her when she left home. ^[5] Autopsy reports revealed that Robinson had been fed and cared for at least three days before she was killed.
• Kristine Marie Mihelich, 10, of Berkley, was reported missing on January 2, 1977, after she failed to return home from a 7-Eleven store on 12 Mile Road at Oakshire. A mail carrier found her fully clothed body nineteen days later on the side of a rural road in Franklin Village. She had been smothered to death less than twenty-four hours earlier and her body lay within view of nearby homes. ^[4]
• Timothy John King, 11, left his home in Birmingham and went to a pharmacy on the evening of March 16, 1977. After he failed to return home, an intensive search covering the entire Detroit metropolitan area was conducted, before his body was found on the evening of March 22 by two teenagers in a shallow ditch alongside Gill Road in Livonia. He had been sexually assaulted with a foreign object and suffocated approximately six hours earlier. ^[4] Autopsy results revealed that King had eaten his favorite food-- Kentucky Fried Chicken-- shortly before his death, and that he was cleaned and groomed prior to his suffocation.

Suspected

• 17-year-old Donna Serra went missing after hitchhiking to a beach after school in Macomb County, Michigan on September 29, 1972. Serra's body was discovered face down in a shallow creek on October 20, 1972, in her hometown of Ray Township in Macomb County, close to 27 Mile Road. Before she was killed, Serra had been imprisoned and drugged for several days. Her death was due to strangulation. Her murder remains unsolved.
• 13-year-old Jane Louise “Janey” Allen went missing on August 8, 1976 and was last seen hitchhiking between Pontiac and Royal Oak in Oakland County, Michigan. Allen was found dead floating in a river in Miamisburg, Ohio, on August 11, 1976, four days later over 200 miles away from her Royal Oak home. Her wrists had been tied behind her back with torn strips of a T-shirt. Decomposition of the body left police unable to determine whether or not Allen had been sexually assaulted but they were able to ascertain that Allen had been dead before being dumped in the water. She had died from carbon monoxide poisoning. ^[6]
• Kimberly Alice "Kim" King, 12, disappeared from Warren on September 15, 1979. She had stayed over at a friend's house that night. When she called her sister at 11:00 p.m., she claimed to have snuck out of her friend's house and to be phoning from a nearby outdoor phone booth. Her sister instructed her to return inside. However, Kimberly never went back to her friend's house and has not been seen or heard from since. Authorities believe she was abducted and that her disappearance is connected to the unsolved killings. ^[7]

Possible

• Patricia Ann Spencer and Pamela Sue Hobley, age 16 and 15 respectively, were last seen in Oscoda, Michigan on October 31, 1969, the day of their high school's homecoming football game. A passing driver stopped to pick them up and drove them to a gas station at River Road and US-23. They were last seen strolling together on River Road away from the school and toward the business district. Both disappeared and have not been seen since. A link to the Oakland County Child Killer has been explored by investigators, though this was deemed unlikely. ^{[8] [9]}
• Laura Wilson, 16, went to a Bi-Rite Market in Detroit, Michigan, in the evening of November 10, 1972. She arrived at the market, but went missing shortly afterward. On November 10, 1972, youngsters in Wayne County discovered her dead body in bushes not far from her home. She had been assaulted and raped. Her head had also been smashed in with a brick. Evidence in her case was ordered destroyed by police in the late-1970s after authorities reinvestigated her case for links to the Oakland County Child Killer. ^{[10] [11]}
• On February 2, 1977, 10-year-old Valerie Bishop was attacked, raped, and stabbed, close to an empty house a short distance from her family's home on the west side of Detroit. She had gone to a corner store to get milk as part of an errand for her mother. At the time, the Oakland County Child Killer task force was active, but they chose not to look into or investigate Valerie's murder. 30-year-old Moses Potter was charged with her murder but was released due to a lack of evidence. No one else was ever arrested and her case remains unsolved. ^[12]

Disproved

• 16-year-old Judy Ferro was found beaten and strangled on January 1, 1976, at Lola Valley Park in Redford, Michigan. She had vanished between midnight and 3 a.m. from the home where she had been babysitting. A Redford Township policeman discovered Ferro's body at 7 a.m., fully dressed. When it was learned that Gary Pervinkler, 19, had left his home the same evening with a gun and his father's automobile, he was identified as a prime suspect. On April 7, 1976, Pervinkler's body was discovered; he had shot himself in the head. The firearm found next to Pervinkler's body matched a bullet casing discovered in the house from where Ferro was abducted. Her case was closed.
• Cynthia Rae “Cindy” Cadieux, 16, of Roseville, was found bludgeoned to death on January 16, 1976, in Bloomfield Township. ^[13] Cynthia had been abducted while hitchhiking in the 11 Mile area of Roseville, between Gratiot and Grosbeck, on January 14, 1976. Her naked body was found shortly after; she had been tied up, raped, and then beaten to death. In 1979, Robert Anglin and Raymond Heinrich were both convicted of her murder. A third individual, who has not been named, was also involved, but he passed away before their arrest. Both men were sentenced to life in prison.
• Sheila Srock, 14, was raped and shot dead while babysitting in Birmingham, Michigan on January 20, 1976. While shoveling the snow off his roof, a neighbor had witnessed her killer, Oliver Rhodes Andrews, as he burglarized homes in the neighborhood. ^[14] Andrews was sentenced to life imprisonment. ^[15]

Investigation

After the discovery of Mihelich's body, authorities noticed similarities shared by her case and those of Stebbins and Robinson, and reports were released warning the public that a serial killer was possibly operating in the Oakland County area. The Michigan State Police led a group of law-enforcement officials from thirteen communities in the formation of a task force, devoted solely to the investigation into the killings of the three children.

After King disappeared, a woman told authorities that she had seen a boy with a skateboard (like King) talking to a man in the parking lot of the pharmacy that he visited on March 16, 1977. A composite drawing of the suspected kidnapper and his blue AMC Gremlin was released, and authorities questioned every Gremlin owner in Oakland County. Investigators created a profile based on witnesses' descriptions of the man seen talking to King—a white male aged between 25 and 35 with a dark complexion, shaggy hair and sideburns, who had a job that gave him freedom of movement and made him appear trustworthy to children, was familiar with the area and could keep children captive for long periods of time without rousing neighbors' suspicions.

The task force checked more than 18,000 tips, which resulted in about two dozen arrests on unrelated charges and the discovery of a multi-state child pornography ring operating on North Fox Island in Lake Michigan. ^[16] The task force was unable to make much headway in the investigation, disbanding in December 1978, with the investigation being turned over to the State Police.

Suspects and persons of interest

A few weeks after King's murder, a psychiatrist who worked with the task force received a letter, riddled with spelling errors, written by an anonymous author ("Allen") claiming to be a sadomasochist slave of the killer ("Frank"). ^[17] "Allen" wrote that they had both served in the Vietnam War, that "Frank" was traumatized by having killed children, and that "Frank" had taken revenge on more affluent citizens, such as the residents of Birmingham, for sending forces to Vietnam. ^[17] "Allen" expressed fear and remorse in his letter, saying he was losing his sanity and was endangered and suicidal, and admitted to having accompanied "Frank" as the latter sought boys to kill. ^[18] He instructed the psychiatrist to respond by printing the code words "weather bureau says trees to bloom in three weeks" in that Sunday's edition of the Detroit Free Press , ^[17] before offering to provide photographic evidence in exchange for immunity from prosecution. The psychiatrist arranged to meet "Allen" at a bar, but "Allen" did not show up and was never heard from again.

Archibald Edward Sloan, a child molester who victimized young boys in his neighborhood, ^[19] became a person of interest after hair samples found in his 1966 Pontiac Bonneville matched hair found on the bodies of King and Stebbins, but the hair was not from Sloan himself. ^[20] A witness claimed to have seen King being abducted by two men, one described as being in his late 20s and the other described as bearing a strong resemblance to serial killer John Wayne Gacy, who was allegedly in Michigan around the time of the killings. ^[21] Gacy's DNA did not match DNA found on the victims' bodies. ^[22]

Police in Parma Heights, Ohio arrested Ted Lamborgine, a retired auto worker involved in a 1970s sex ring that preyed on young boys in Detroit’s Cass Corridor. Out of the five men involved in the ring, Lamborgine was one of only two living members of that ring when they were charged in 2006. Lamborgine faced 19 counts of sexually assaulting children, while his partner in the ring, Richard Lawson, faced 28 similar charges. On March 27, 2007, investigators told Detroit television station WXYZ that Lamborgine was considered the top suspect in this case. Lamborgine pleaded guilty to fifteen sex-related counts involving young boys rather than accept a plea bargain that would have required him to take a polygraph test on the Oakland County killings. He also rejected an offer of a reduced sentence in exchange for a polygraph on the case. ^[23] In October 2007, the family of Mark Stebbins filed a wrongful death lawsuit against Lamborgine seeking $25,000. The lawsuit alleges Lamborgine, who lived in Metro Detroit in the late 1970s, abducted Stebbins and held him captive in a Royal Oak house for four days in February 1976 before smothering him to death during a sexual assault. Lamborgine has never been formally linked nor charged in the death of Stebbins. Attorney David A. Binkley has sought compensation, including funeral costs, for Stebbins' brother, Michael, but stressed that money is secondary. ^[23]

The case sparked new interest when King's father, Barry, and brother, Chris, tried to get the State Police to release information about Chris Busch, the son of General Motors executive Harold Lee Busch. Chris Busch had been in police custody shortly before King's abduction for suspected involvement in child pornography. He allegedly committed suicide in November 1978. There was no gunshot residue found on him, though, and no blood spatter; the entry wound was between his eyes. Furthermore, there were four shell casings found in Busch's room. He was also found wrapped neatly under his sheets.^{[ citation needed ]} Bloodstained ligatures were found in his apartment, as was a hand-drawn image of a boy closely resembling Stebbins screaming which was found pinned to the wall. ^[24] There had been no confirmed activity by the Oakland County Child Killer for nearly twenty months prior to Busch's death. ^[25] The State Police have since released 3,400 pages of investigative records to Barry King. ^[26]

Resumed investigation and new evidence

Investigation reports released to family of the victims

Police reports obtained by Barry King included new revelations, including DNA testing of new suspects and the bloodstained ligature and sketch from Busch's apartment. ^[27] Catherine Broad, King's sister, compiled an archive of investigation material as the case grew. ^[28]

Upon researching the case records, the King family produced a documentary entitled Decades of Deceit, which condemns the police and prosecutors for alleged shoddy investigations and uncooperative communication, and, in particular, of disregarding leads the family discovered in 2006. Funds generated from the sale of the documentary were donated to the Tim King fund, designated to help abused children and support activities for Birmingham children. ^[29]

DNA tests of hair

Forensic DNA tests conducted in 2012 showed that hair found on the seat of Sloan's car and on the bodies of Stebbins and King were a match and came from the same unknown man. The hair DNA does not match Sloan, but implicates someone he knew or lent his car to. ^{[30] [31]}

Later developments/2012 case reopening

In 2013, an anonymous informant reported a blue AMC Gremlin buried in a farm field now being developed in Grand Blanc. Police are investigating the Gremlin for ties to the crime as King was last seen in a blue Gremlin. ^[32]

"Jeff Gannon"

In 2005, an unidentified man, who would later emerge to become a common figure in the case and has been referred to by the alias of "Jeff", was reminded of a relationship he had in 1977 with an acquaintance. In an interview given to Oakland County investigators in 2010, Jeff informed them of atypical observations and actions while driving and conversing with the acquaintance, such as taking him to buildings where satanic rituals were allegedly performed. The acquaintance navigated through lesser-known routes associated with the case with ease. The acquaintance also spoke of details written in "Allen's" letter (see above). ^[33] Jeff requested information about the "Allen" letter to help confirm his suspicions, but was denied. ^[33]

In 2010, Jeff gave a recorded interview to Oakland County investigators and Prosecutor Jessica Cooper to present evidence pertaining to the investigation. ^[33] Jeff claimed to have tried to approach Cooper with his findings and to convince her to place the case under the jurisdiction of the Department of Justice. The department was already involved through the FBI and through resources such as the ViCAP database. ^[34] Cooper dismissed his suggestions and, as there was no new evidence presented, his request to inspect the "Allen" letter was denied. Cooper described the interview as "a rambling statement outlining a theory that the Oakland County Child Killer abductions and murders were related to pagan holidays, the lunar calendar, and Wiccan rituals". ^[35]

Jeff proceeded to correspond with Deborah Jarvis, mother of victim Kristine Mihelich, and investigative journalists such as ^[34] Bill Proctor and Heather Catallo in 2010. He claimed that he was among a team of a dozen investigators involved with the case and could identify the perpetrator of the crimes, but refused to indicate which law enforcement division he worked for. ^{[36] [37]} Jeff claimed to have invested 10,000 hours into the investigation over several years, but was reluctant to release his results as he doubted the competence of Wayne and Oakland County investigators. In a press release email, Jeff indicated possible meddling by Cooper and other reasons as to why he had not made his investigation public. ^{[38] [39] [40]} According to Paul Hughes, an attorney representing Jarvis, Jeff's investigation discovered the murderer. However, according to Hughes, Jeff refused to identify the culprit unless the authorities divulged crucial information which Jeff requested during the initial interviews in 2010. Jeff wanted to positively confirm the identity of his suspect using the police evidence before proceeding further. ^[41]

In 2012, Jeff presented his findings to a select group of Detroit journalists on Hughes' cell phone. To preserve his anonymity he insisted that his phone interview with Hughes not be recorded. He theorized that the killers were conducting Wiccan human sacrifice rituals coinciding with pagan celebrations or the lunar calendar.^{[ citation needed ]} According to Jeff, there was a total of approximately 11–16 victims, significantly more than the four officially confirmed victims. ^[37] He claimed his team found a number of similarities among the cases that were highly unlikely to be purely coincidental.^{[ citation needed ]}

Based on this information, Hughes attempted a lawsuit against the Oakland County authorities for $100 million, citing mishandling of the investigation and demanding Cooper's resignation. The lawsuit alleged a cover-up conspiracy and obstruction. ^[34] Hughes' website solicited donations, and offered a copy of Jeff's report for a donation of $1,500. The families of the victims, as well as Cooper, claimed that Hughes and Jeff were attempting to profit on their distress. The case was dismissed in March 2012 for lack of evidence.^{[ citation needed ]}

Arch Sloan

In February 2019, the Investigation Discovery channel aired a two-part, four-hour documentary about the killings. ^[42] At this same time, WXYZ-TV investigative reporter Heather Catallo announced that a key suspect, convicted child sex offender Arch Edward Sloan, had failed a polygraph test when he was interviewed by the Oakland County Child Killer Task Force in 2010 and 2012. ^[42] Back in 2012 new DNA technology found that Sloan's car contained hair with the same mitochondrial profile as evidence found on the victims; however, it is not Sloan's. ^[20]

See also

• List of homicides in Michigan
• List of fugitives from justice who disappeared
• List of serial killers in the United States

References

1. "DNA results revive 36-year-old Oakland County Child Killer case". mlive. July 18, 2012. Retrieved May 5, 2020.
2. Martindale, Mike (August 24, 2007). "New DNA evidence surfaces in Oakland child killings". The Detroit News. p. 00.
3. Keppell, Robert (1995). The Riverman: Ted Bundy and I Hunt for the Green River Killer. New York: Pocket Books. p.  143. ISBN   0-671-86763-6.
4. Barfknecht 1993, pp. 123–126
5. Keppell, Robert (1995). The Riverman: Ted Bundy and I Hunt for the Green River Killer. New York: Pocket Books. p.  144. ISBN   0-671-86763-6.
6. Keppel, Robert (1995). The Riverman: Ted Bundy and I Hunt for the Green River Killer. New York: Pocket Books. p.  152. ISBN   0-671-86763-6.
7. "Kimberly Alice King – The Charley Project" . Retrieved May 5, 2020.
8. "Pamela Hobley and Patricia Spencer: Teens missing since 1969". Missing Persons of America. Archived from the original on August 17, 2015. Retrieved September 9, 2015.
9. Hughes, Paul (October 16, 2012). "FBI Summary for Media" (PDF). Retrieved September 9, 2015.
10. "Laura Wilson". Delayed Justice. February 15, 2009. Retrieved June 11, 2022.
11. "Laura Wilson". IAPE - International Association for Property and Evidence, Inc. February 21, 2011. Retrieved June 11, 2022.
12. "03 Feb 1977, Page 1". Detroit Free Press. May 30, 1969. Retrieved June 2, 2022.
13. McIntyre 1988, p. 11
14. McIntyre 1988, p. 12
15. "Suspect". Ludington Daily News. March 4, 1976. Retrieved June 11, 2011.
16. "Secrets and Lies". True Crime Diary. June 14, 2011. Retrieved March 12, 2014.
17. "Oakland County child killer still a mystery despite letters to the police". Ludington Daily News. Vol. 28, no. 264. Associated Press. September 28, 1977. Retrieved December 2, 2013.
18. Tommy McIntyre (January 1, 1988). Great Lakes Books (ed.). Wolf in Sheep's Clothing: The Search for a Child Killer. Detroit: Wayne State University Press. pp. 173–174. ISBN   0-8143-1989-0 . Retrieved December 3, 2013.
19. Catallo, Heather (July 19, 2012). "Local man says he was assaulted by new Oakland County Child Killer person of interest Arch Sloan". WXZY 7 ABC. Archived from the original on December 25, 2013. Retrieved March 12, 2014.
20. Catallo, Heather (July 19, 2012). "Local man says he was assaulted by new Oakland County Child Killer person of interest Arch Sloan". WXYZ-TV . Retrieved October 25, 2019.
21. "Is the Oakland County Child Killer connected to John Wayne Gacy?". Archived from the original on June 15, 2013. Retrieved February 1, 2013.
22. Heather Catallo (June 6, 2013). "Gacy DNA test results in Oakland County Child Killer case". WXYZ.com. Archived from the original on November 4, 2013. Retrieved March 12, 2014.
23. Martindale, Mike (October 19, 2007). "Victim's family in Oakland child killings sues molester over death". The Detroit News. p. 1B.
24. "DNA Links New Suspect to 1970's Oakland County Child Killings". May 19, 2011. Retrieved August 21, 2017.
25. Keenan, Marney Rich (October 26, 2009). "Finding Timmy's killer: Family seeks answers 32 years after son's death". The Detroit News. Retrieved November 2, 2009.
26. "Detroit ABC affiliate WXYZ, December 28, 2010"
27. "EXCLUSIVE: New Person Identified In Oakland County Child Killer Case". Clickondetroit.com. November 2, 2011. Archived from the original on October 14, 2013. Retrieved March 12, 2014.
28. Dave Phillips (April 13, 2013). "Woman blogs about losing a brother to the Oakland County Child Killer". Theoaklandpress.com. Retrieved March 12, 2014.
29. Heather Catallo (September 12, 2013). "Family of Oakland County Child Killer victim takes prosecutor, police to task for unsolved murders". WXYZ.com. Archived from the original on December 25, 2013. Retrieved March 12, 2014.
30. Dave Phillips (July 17, 2012). "Prosecutor: DNA presents first link in Oakland County Child Killer case; person of interest named". The News-Herald . Retrieved March 12, 2014.
31. "EXCLUSIVE: New Person Identified In Oakland County Child Killer Case". Clickondetroit.com. November 2, 2011. Archived from the original on November 27, 2013. Retrieved March 12, 2014.
32. Tammy Stables Battaglia (August 20, 2013). "Cops comb blue Gremlin near Grand Blanc for ties to Oakland child killer". Detroit Free Press. Retrieved March 12, 2014.
33. Ashenfelter, David (May 15, 2012). "With audio: In Oakland county child killings shadowy figure offers his theories". Detroit Free Press . Retrieved December 1, 2013.
34. Catallo, Heather. 'Detroit lawyer files suit alleging cover-up in Oakland County child killer case Archived December 3, 2013, at the Wayback Machine '. April 23, 2012. WXYZ ABC 7 Action news. retrieved December 1, 2013
35. Cooper, Jessica R. 'The Oakland County children Killings: What about Jeff'. Retrieved December 1, 2013
36. Ashenfelter, David. 'Anonymous tipster Jeff has become part of the mystery of Oakland Child Killer case'. June 17, 2012. Detroit Free Press. retrieved November 29, 2013
37. Ashenfelter, David. 'Informant says he can connect Oakland County child killings to other deaths'. May 14, 2012. Detroit Free Press. retrieved December 1, 2013
38. 'Jeff'.'Press release from 'Jeff'.'October 16, 2013. Detroit Free Press. December 1, 2013
39. Ashenfelter, David. 'In Oakland county child killing case, man named Jeff makes many claims'. May 12, 2013. Detroit Free Press. retrieved December 1, 2013
40. Burns, Gus. 'Anonymous 'Jeff' releases secret Oakland country child killer details to select media.' October 16, 2012. Mlive. retrieved November 30, 2013
41. Catallo, Heather.'Source behind $100 Million Child killer is anonymous to even lawyer, family Archived November 25, 2013, at the Wayback Machine '. April 24, 2012. WXYZ ABC 7 action news. retrieved December 1, 2013
42. Catallo, Heather (February 19, 2019). "Investigation reveals Oakland Co. Child Killer suspect failed polygraph test about murders". WXYZ-TV . Retrieved October 25, 2019.

Bibliography

• Barfknecht, Gary (1993). Unexplained Michigan Mysteries: Strange but True Tales from the Michigan Unknown . Davison: Friede Publications. ISBN   0-923756-05-1. OCLC   29187818.
• Keppel, Robert; Birnes, William (1995). The Riverman. Arrow Books. ISBN   0-0992-3311-8.
• McIntyre, Tommy (1988). Wolf in Sheep's Clothing: The Search for a Child Killer. Detroit: Wayne State University Press. ISBN   0-8143-1966-1. OCLC   17731672.
• Appelman, J. Reuben (2018). The Kill Jar: Obsession, Descent, and a Hunt for Detroit's Most Notorious Serial Killer. Gallery Books. ISBN   978-1507204023. OCLC   1005098024.

External links

• Detectives Revive Infamous Case (2005 Michigan State Police Press Release)
• Don't Talk to Strangers (podcast series on the OCCK)