Palmer v Western Australia

Last updated
Palmer v Western Australia
Coat of Arms of Australia.svg
Court High Court of Australia
Full case namePalmer & Anor v. The State of Western Australia & Anor
Decided6 November 2020
Citation(s) [2021] HCA 5
Transcript(s)
Court membership
Judge(s) sitting Kiefel CJ, Gageler, Keane, Gordon, Edelman JJ
Case opinions
The Quarantine (Closing the Border) Directions comply with s 92 of the Constitution

Palmer v Western Australia was a case heard by the High Court of Australia during the COVID-19 pandemic, which held that the Quarantine (Closing the Border) Directions and the authorising legislation, the Emergency Management Act 2005, were not impermissibly infringing section 92 of the Constitution of Australia. [1]

Contents

Background

On 15 March 2020, the Minister for Emergency Services declared a State of Emergency in Western Australia, due to the COVID-19 pandemic. The following day, a Public Health State of Emergency was declared by the Minister for Health. [2] Following the declarations, the Quarantine (Closing the Border) Directions ('Directions') were given by the Commissioner of Police and State Emergency Coordinator, closing the Western Australian border to all non-essential travellers from 5 April 2020. [3] These directions were continually extended until the Western Australian border reopened on 3 March 2022. [4] [5]

In mid-May 2020, Clive Palmer was refused entry into Western Australia, under the Directions. On 25 May 2020, Palmer commenced proceedings against Western Australia in the High Court, [6] on the basis that the Directions and the authorising legislation impermissibly infringed section 92 of the Constitution. Section 92 concerns "trade, commerce, and intercourse among the States", which shall be "absolutely free". [7]

Decision

The High Court's decision was handed down on 6 November 2020, [8] [9] with its reasons published on 24 February 2021. [1] The court found that the sections of the authorising legislation for the Directions—sections 55 and 67 of the Emergency Management Act 2005—did not impermissibly infringe s 92 of the Constitution in "their application to an emergency constituted by the occurrence of a hazard in the nature of a plague or epidemic". [10] The judgment went on to state that "the exercise of power given by those provisions to make paras 4 and 5 of the Quarantine (Closing the Border) Directions (WA) does not raise a constitutional question", and that costs were to be paid by the plaintiffs. [10]

Consequences

As a result of the unsuccessful challenge to the hard border, the Directions and the hard border remained in effect. Border control measures were eased from 14 November, [11] [12] with some travellers from "very low risk" jurisdictions permitted to enter Western Australia without an exemption. [13]

Due to comments made by Premier Mark McGowan and Palmer towards each other over the border challenge, each sued the other, with $5,000 and $20,000 awarded to Palmer and McGowan respectively. [14] [15]

See also

Related Research Articles

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Mark McGowan</span> 30th Premier of Western Australia

Mark McGowan is an Australian former politician and naval officer who served as the 30th premier of Western Australia from 2017 until his retirement in 2023. He was the leader of the Western Australian branch of the Australian Labor Party (ALP) from 2012 to 2023 and a member of the Legislative Assembly (MLA) for the district of Rockingham from 1996 to 2023.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Clive Palmer</span> Australian businessman and politician (born 1954)

Clive Frederick Palmer is an Australian businessman and politician. He has iron ore, nickel, and coal holdings. Palmer owns many businesses such as Mineralogy, Waratah Coal, Queensland Nickel at Townsville, the Palmer Coolum Resort on the Sunshine Coast, Palmer Sea Reef Golf Course at Port Douglas, Palmer Colonial Golf Course at Robina, and the Palmer Gold Coast Golf Course, also at Robina. He owned Gold Coast United FC from 2008 to 2012. Palmer created the Palmer United Party in April 2013, winning the Sunshine Coast seat of Fairfax in the 2013 Australian federal election and sitting as an MP for one term.

Mineralogy is an Australian mining company owned by Clive Palmer. Mineralogy's mining projects are now producing and generating income.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">United Australia Party (2013)</span> Political party in Australia

The United Australia Party (UAP), formerly known as Clive Palmer's United Australia Party and the Palmer United Party (PUP), is an Australian political party formed by mining magnate Clive Palmer in April 2013. The party was deregistered by the Australian Electoral Commission in 2017, revived and re-registered in 2018, and voluntarily deregistered in 2022. The party fielded candidates in all 150 House of Representatives seats at the 2013 federal election. Palmer, the party's leader, was elected to the Division of Fairfax and it reached a peak of three senators following the rerun of the Western Australian senate election in 2014. When the party was revived under its original name in 2018, it was represented by ex-One Nation senator Brian Burston in the federal parliament.

Reece Raymond Whitby is an Australian politician. He has been a Labor member of the Western Australian Legislative Assembly since the 2017 state election, representing Baldivis. Shortly after the 2017 election, Whitby was appointed by Premier of Western Australia Mark McGowan as Parliamentary Secretary to the Treasurer and Minister for Energy and Finance, and as Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister for Environment and Disability Services. Whitby was successfully re-elected to the seat of Baldivis in the 2021 state election, and he was appointed to the Second McGowan Ministry, becoming the Minister of Emergency Services; Racing and Gaming, Small Business and Volunteering.

Zak Richard Francis Kirkup is an Australian former politician. He was a member of the Western Australian Liberal Party, and served as a member for the Western Australian Legislative Assembly for the electoral district of Dawesville from 2017 to 2021.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">2021 Western Australian state election</span> State general election for Western Australia, held on 13 March 2021

The 2021 Western Australian state election was conducted on Saturday 13 March 2021 to elect members to the Parliament of Western Australia, where all 59 seats in the Legislative Assembly and all 36 seats in the Legislative Council were up for election.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Chris Dawson (governor)</span> Governor of Western Australia

Christopher John Dawson is the 34th Governor of Western Australia and a former police officer who served as the Commissioner of the Western Australia Police Force from 2017 to 2022. He was sworn in as governor on 15 July 2022.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">COVID-19 pandemic in Australia</span> Ongoing COVID-19 viral pandemic in Australia

The COVID-19 pandemic in Australia was a part of the worldwide pandemic of the coronavirus disease 2019 caused by severe acute respiratory syndrome coronavirus 2. The first confirmed case in Australia was identified on 25 January 2020, in Victoria, when a man who had returned from Wuhan, Hubei Province, China, tested positive for the virus. As of 6 August 2022, Australia has reported over 11,350,000 cases, over 11,330,000 recoveries, and 19,265 deaths. Victoria's second wave having the highest fatality rate per case.

<i>Biosecurity Act 2015</i> Australian law

The Biosecurity Act 2015 is an Act of the Parliament of Australia which manages biosecurity risks in Australia. It was enacted on 16 June 2015, after the Bill was passed with bipartisan support on 14 May 2015. It covers both agricultural and human medical biosecurity risks, including epidemics and pandemics, and is designed to contain and/or deal with any "diseases and pests that may cause harm to human, animal or plant health or the environment" in Australia.

Andrew Miller is an Australian anaesthetist who was the president of the Australian Medical Association (WA).

The COVID-19 pandemic in Queensland, Australia is part of the ongoing worldwide pandemic of the coronavirus disease 2019 caused by severe acute respiratory syndrome coronavirus 2.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">COVID-19 pandemic in Western Australia</span> Ongoing COVID-19 viral pandemic in Western Australia

The COVID-19 pandemic in Western Australia is part of the ongoing worldwide pandemic caused by severe acute respiratory syndrome coronavirus 2. Western Australia (WA) confirmed its first case of COVID-19 on 21 February 2020, and its first death on 1 March. On 15 March, premier Mark McGowan declared a state of emergency. On 24 March, Western Australia closed its borders to the rest of Australia, and on 1 April, the state implemented borders between regions in the state. By mid-April 2020, the state had eliminated community transmission of COVID-19, becoming one of the few places in the world to do so. There were only a handful of cases of community transmission in the state after mid-April, until late December 2021 when a tourist caused an outbreak that led to the cancelling of some New Year's Eve events, and the re-imposing of mask wearing rules in Perth and the Peel region.

The COVID-19 pandemic in South Australia is part of the ongoing worldwide pandemic of the coronavirus disease 2019 caused by severe acute respiratory syndrome coronavirus 2.

The COVID-19 pandemic in Tasmania is part of the ongoing worldwide pandemic of the coronavirus disease 2019 caused by severe acute respiratory syndrome coronavirus 2.

This article documents the chronology and epidemiology of SARS-CoV-2, the virus which causes the coronavirus disease 2019 (COVID-19) and is responsible for the COVID-19 pandemic in Australia during 2020.

This article documents the chronology and epidemiology of SARS-CoV-2, the virus which causes the coronavirus disease 2019 (COVID-19) and is responsible for the COVID-19 pandemic in Australia during the first half of 2021.

The Western Australian Division of the Liberal Party of Australia held a leadership vote on 24 November 2020 to determine its leader. The election was conducted among Liberal Party members of the Parliament of Western Australia. It came after its previous leader, Liza Harvey, resigned following poor opinion polling. Deputy leader Bill Marmion also resigned on the same day. The main candidates touted ahead of the election were Dean Nalder, a member of parliament since 2013 and a minister in the Barnett Ministry, and Zak Kirkup, a member of parliament since 2017. Nalder declined to nominate for the leadership after it became clear he did not have the full support of the Liberal Party caucus. As a result, Kirkup won the leadership unopposed, becoming the state's leader of the opposition. Libby Mettam was elected unopposed as the deputy leader.

<i>Mineralogy v Western Australia</i> High Court challenge over compensation for previously denied mining rights

Mineralogy v Western Australia was a case heard by the High Court of Australia at the same time as Palmer v Western Australia in 2020 and 2021, which held that the Iron Ore Processing Agreement Amendment Act 2020 was not invalid or inoperative in its entirety.

<i>Vunilagi v. The Queen</i>

Vunilagi v The Queen is a significant decision of the High Court of Australia concerning the nature of the laws of the self-governing Territories.

References

  1. 1 2 "Judgment summary" (PDF). High Court. 24 February 2021.
  2. ↑ "COVID-19 coronavirus: State of Emergency Declarations". www.wa.gov.au. Retrieved 2022-08-10.
  3. ↑ "The nation's toughest border controls are being adopted in WA, locking even its own residents out". ABC News. 2020-04-02. Retrieved 2022-08-10.
  4. ↑ "WA's border opening from Thursday 3 March 2022". www.wa.gov.au. 2 August 2022. Retrieved 2022-08-10.
  5. ↑ Dawson, Chris (18 September 2022). "Quarantine (Closing the Border) Amendment Directions (No 6)" (PDF). Retrieved 10 July 2022.
  6. ↑ "Clive Palmer threatens High Court challenge to WA border closure after being denied entry". ABC News. 2020-05-22. Retrieved 2022-08-10.
  7. ↑ corporateName=Commonwealth Parliament; address=Parliament House, Canberra. "The Australian Constitution". www.aph.gov.au. Retrieved 2022-08-10.{{cite web}}: CS1 maint: multiple names: authors list (link)
  8. ↑ "Clive Palmer ordered to pay costs as High Court rules in favour of WA hard border closure". ABC News. 2020-11-05. Retrieved 2022-08-10.
  9. ↑ McNeill, Heather (2020-11-05). "Clive Palmer loses High Court fight over WA hard border". WAtoday. Retrieved 2022-08-10.
  10. 1 2 Kiefel, Susan (24 February 2021). "HCA 5" . Retrieved 10 July 2022.
  11. ↑ "WA will have to 'wake up' to the COVID threat now hard border is down, AMA warns". ABC News. 2020-10-30. Retrieved 2022-08-10.
  12. ↑ "WA drops its hard border from 14 November". Australian Aviation. Retrieved 2022-08-10.
  13. ↑ McGowan, Mark (30 October 2020). "Health-based cautious transition to WA's controlled interstate border". Archived from the original on 26 May 2022. Retrieved 10 July 2022.
  14. ↑ "Judge slams waste of time as he rules Clive Palmer, Mark McGowan defamed each other". ABC News. 2022-08-02. Retrieved 2022-08-10.
  15. ↑ "Mark McGowan defends actions after court rules he and Clive Palmer to pay defamation damages". www.9news.com.au. 2 August 2022. Retrieved 2022-08-10.
This page is based on this Wikipedia article
Text is available under the CC BY-SA 4.0 license; additional terms may apply.
Images, videos and audio are available under their respective licenses.